We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I'm in a finishing "rut". I have been hand applying finish for years. Nothing wrong with it but it does come with some pitfalls. One is time consumption...longer to apply and longer to dry etc.
Spraying is not without challenges but I wonder if I can get better results in less time? Perhaps spraying laquer would be an idea?
So what say the WC community?? I welcome ALL feedback...pro or con.
Go for it. Get a good gun and put a dryer in your air line. I used to spray and quit for a long time (20 years) and have started again. I am trying to find and old school Binks or Devilbis gun. I probably need to find a better gun, but I am of touch. Can't stand the idea of paying $2500. I am using a borrowed Craftsman gun from a friend and its working well enough.
First, some anecdotal info. I've been looking at the health side of finishing lately. I'm 59 and have been woodworking for 40 years. I sprayed lacquer in the early years by raising the garage door and spraying in front of a box fan. Always had a charcoal mask on while spraying, but now I'm thinking the off gassing surely has done it's work. In those days it was a convential gun, and you couldn't see across the room when spraying a big piece. Next came a professional business, and I switched to conversion varnish. In the winter I had no make up air, so shut the fan off too soon to keep the shop up to temp. That really wasn't good for me.
All that said, I would definitely suggest spraying. Much faster, much less work on the finish after the gun. It does come with issues in IL. Mainly temp and humidity, but those are issues no matter what the application. You will need some really good air filters, dessicate filters in the summer to keep moisture out of the lines. Look at water based, but I still find fault with the look of it. Good luck.
I am a hobby woodworker and rank amateur sprayer. But, I say go for it. I have been using various Target Coatings (water borne) products and believe that I consistently get better results than by hand finishing. I am also more willing to try new things because they don't require the learning curve or time investment that hand finishing does. Water borne is easy to clean up and doesn't need the significant investment for explosion proof fans and lighting that solvent products do. Good luck with your decision.
I agree with the above on the waterborne. I also use Target finish. I use oil based stains, then a coat of SealCoat shellac, then several coats of waterborne. Since I spray out of my garage, I figure I cannot take a chance on the fire hazard of spraying non-waterborne finishes.
I also vote "go for it". I took the jump several years ago. There is a learnng curve...I almost gave up spraying because fixing my mistakes took more time than simply hand-applying a finish. You'll also need to experiment until you find a finishing schedule that works for you.
The advantages:
1. Can take much less time than a hand applied finish,
2. Dyes and toning open up a new decorative avenue,
3. Gloss/satin/matte/flat options are easily accomplished,
4. Some spray finishes are much tougher than hand applied options.
The disadvantages:
1. There's more need to plan ahead with finishing in mind (eg. finish the inside of the cabinet before assembly),
2. More space is needed to spray pieces and store pieces while drying.
3. A spray booth of some type is required. If you choose to use solvent based finishes, fire and explosion risks must be mitigated.
4. For small projects it can be a pain to spend an hours setting up to spray, spray for 15 seconds, wait 30 minutes, spray 15 seconds, wait 30 minutes, spray 15 seconds, then spend an hour tearing down and cleaning up. If you have a dedicated finishing room that might be OK, but without a dedicated room, your shop might be out of commission for a while.
Overall I'm glad I took the leap to spray finishing. I like to apply toned shellac to get the colour I want, then topcoat with gloss Target lacquer to build the finish up, sand to remove imperfections and/or fill grain, then apply one or two coats of satin Target laquer to give a beautiful, non-shiny, silky smooth to the touch finish.
Hi Thomas, I have sprayed finishes for years - I use either wipe on or spray - never could brush anything that looked good. I spray a lot of lacquer using a conventional Binks spray gun. I have also sprayed Shellac with good results. Spray is also good for "toning" using stain prior to final finish, after practice you can successfully apply stain to some woods that are really hard to get an even color. I use Behlen Qualalacq Lacquer, thin it a lot and apply multiple coats - its pretty hard to screw it up that way. It dries in just a few minutes so I can apply 4 or 5 coats in an afternoon. Pick you up a used gun (I like Binks but most any gun will work pretty well with the thin finishes), put an air dryer cartridge in your air line and using scrap cardboard spray some water or cheap shellac or lacquer until you learn to adjust the gun and apply an even coat. I open the garage door of my shop and spray right outside the shop. (does limit me to decent weather and temperature for finishing).
Spent 10+ years learning to hand-apply finishes, from shellac to oil to poly to lacquer. Spent a great deal of time "building-building-leveling-leveling" then compounding out to lovely deep surfaces that begged to be touched. This also afforded me the perceived high ground to look down upon all those quick and dirty spray finishers, even though they built and finished 3 pieces in the time it took me just to put the finish on one. I also cussed loudly and long about all the reactive oil finish I threw away when it gelled in the cans.
Then the waterbornes hit the market and I tried a friend's early-adopted turbine HVLP gun. Who-o-oa, Nelly!! Finishing can be fun? Seriously?
I have since laid in a set of good HVLP guns (a CA Tech Jr. and Walcom Geo on a pressure pot) and have not looked back. Less finish, equal results, less cost (amortizing out the price of the guns). I can take a piece from raw to finished in 4 hours over 3 days and have a finish that would have taken 24 hours over 3 weeks to achieve.
"Just do it".
Caveat: Spray finishing with a cheap gun, etc. will be a learning experience and will carry frustration. Borrow one and work with it in a number of different finishes from solvent to waterborne so you'll appreciate a truly good piece of equipment when you invest in it. My Walcom rig was $800 (I had the compressor already), but it'll put down waterborne finishes like glass. I haven't actually rubbed out a gloss piece since I bought it. The finish is that good, "right off the gun."
One of the things that prompted all this was my experience last night. To any newbies reading this....beware of canned finished from your woodworking stores. Check the "born on" date. I do. But even though I bought the fresher can on the shelf it was already past prime when I opened it. Pet peeve....Woodworking stores (yes the 2 best known included) that do not rotate stock and remove old stock.
That "brand new" wipe-on poly I applied last night ought to be cured....in a week!
He recently sold me a very nice gravity feed HVLP 'touch-up' setup, which is a gun kit with 5 oz. cup, and three needle/jet setups. A little pricey at about $225, but, in retrospect, worth every penney.
He also recommended the General Finishes Enduro® line of waterborne finishes. I've used the WB lacquer, and also the Pre-cat so far, and both are great - easy to use (and clean up after) and both lay down a really nice finish.
I've also used waterbornes from M.L. Campbell and Target Coatings, both of which are also very good.
Lacquer is easy to learn to spray. Why this is so? It is formulated with a mix of solvents, fast and slow drying. The lacquer viscosity increases with about the 4th power of concentration, such that a small amount of drying increases viscosity to prevent runs. Slower drying solvent enables leveling.
From your post I take it Jeff sold you a C-A Tech Jr. That little jewel is my go-to gun for shellac, toning, and finishing small items like turnings. If he didn't give you an on-the-gun regulator, get one as it will give you much better control.
Speed of lacquer solvent prevents moisture from the air to be trapped in the finish as the solvent flashes off. Trapped moisture is called blushing and will show as a white hazing in the finish. Slow solvents slow the flash off and blushing is eliminated. Slow solvents will also let the finish level out better in high heat situations. Some water based finishes will just plain tell you to not spray in high humidity situations.
What kind of drying times are "fast vs slow"? The fast solvent is usually acetone and it does its drying in seconds . The slower drying solvents will be a ketone and/or ester, and toluene. These take minutes to dry to the touch and hours to fully harden.
What affect does humidity play with laquer and drying times? No effect on drying time but high humidity requires a retarder solvent ( slow evaporating solvent). When the acetone evaporates the surface cools and it may reach the dew point at high humidity and condense water upon the surface. 5% retarder solvent eliminates this problem but it may take more time to harden the finish to be able to move the piece.
Are similar principles found in water based finishes? I have yet to see a water based finish that has the brightness of lacquer or shellac. I don't use them. These finishes contain tens of percent coalescing solvent so it is a myth that they are "less toxic". The solvent isn't the issue anyway. It is the aerosol finish particles entering the lungs that will result in long term effects. Unless you wear a respirator filling the gas tank it won't be necessary to worry about the vapors.
Water based finishes are less flammable but I spray out doors so flammability is not an issue for me.
I used to shoot a lot a lacquer, but that was back when I worked at a shop that had dedicated spray booth. With my small shop it is faster to apply hand finishes if I factor in cleaning the shop to a point that it would be clean enough to spray without raising a dust cloud. I don't have an outside area that is clean enough and it is often too windy late in the day when I am usually ready to finish work.
Since I started with my highbred finish shcedule of waterboune poly over wet oil I have had great results that require less rubbing out. To recap I use General's HP poly over a blend of varnish, tung oil, turp and japan drier. (It is necessray to do a trial with the waterbourne you choose and the oil finish you choose but the oil gives the great depth and seals the wood so the waterbourne doesn't raise the grain.) The waterboune is durable and gives a deep gloss with a silky feel. My work is not cheap and the finish I choose is not to save a few pennies it is to get the best results and keep me from having call backs. This schedule works! I wipe the oil on and put those supplies away and lay out the rags to dry and then imidiately start brushing on the waterbourne. I apply 2=3 coats then use a dull but not knickked cabinet scraper to scrape the larrge areas and 22 paper on the curves and hart to reach areas and then follow with one more coat and rub out with steep wool and top with paste wax. I use a 1 1/2" raphael artist brush and it lays on the finish with little to no brush marks.
Spraying can get great results once you get the gun dialed in with the finish and get used to how it works in different temps and humidity. but when it dosent work it dosent work in a big way. Also with guns you ususaly get what you pay for. Even HVLP guns eat a lot of CFM and without the appropriate CFM you will get a lot of runs, make sure your compressor can handle the gun you get or spring for a turbine set up.
Yep, that's the one! Terrific little gun, and the kit does include a regulator. It also includes 1.0, 1.2 (my general 'go to') and 1.5 mm tips and needles, along with a cleaning kit and a Mil guage.
Target 6000 and Enduro W-B lacquer both go thru this gun beautifully, right out of the can.
I'd been using a Harbor Freight "touch-up" (more like "screw-up!!!") gun, and this little jewel is orders of magnitude superior to that!