Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

Posts

Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

#1

Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

Robby Wright - San Marcos, CA

I am having a dispute with an electrical contractor that did some work for my company. When he wired up our new distribution panel and UPS in the computer room, he did not run a separate ground from the main panel to the ground bus on the sub-panel. I remember from my electrical contractor days that you always ran a separate ground to the sub-panel. He says the conduit is enough, although he didn't put any bonding bushings on it.

Does anyone know the NEC section that covers this? Barry - Any chance you know this?

Thanks in advance.

Robby Wright

San Marcos, CA

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

#2

JL

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

JL

I am not an electrician - but I did have to be a project manager on our recent electrical work at the playhouse. From what I remember - it was NEC 250.

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

#3

My experience

Joe W

Where I work, we generally pull a separate ground when installing a new panel. But I believe he is correct in saying he can use the conduit for the ground (we have done that too). We generally only use bonding bushing when using concentric knockouts on the panel, and without a ground wire, they would serve no use. As usual, the correct answer can have a lot of depends and vary on individual circumstances.

If you are installing a UPS, it sounds like you electronic equipment to protect, a separate ground wire would be prudent.

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

#4

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

John McGaw

Whether or not it is 'required' it is almost certainly permitted -- at worst it would offer a redundant ground path. Since you (or your company at least) is paying the bill then he should put in the little bit of extra work and materials to do it and make you happy and if (s)he has any future in business then it should be done with a smile.

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

#5

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

Robby Wright - San Marcos, CA

The issue I am having is I remember sub-panels as requiring a separate ground wire to the ground bus, which is isolated in the sub-panel. He is saying that it isn't needed and wants more money to do it. I am hoping that someone knows the relevant NEC section that backs me up. The latest NEC version I have is 1984, so if I can't get it here, I am going to have to spend some time in the library.

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

#6

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

Larry in nw ohio

Robby Since this is for your company, I would think that you should be able to google it, and it might be faster. Larry

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

#7

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

Robby Wright - San Marcos, CA

Larry - I did and got a bunch of answers talking about not bonding the neutral bus to ground on a sub-panel, but not the part I was looking for.

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

#8

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

Keith Weber

If using metal conduit, he's right -- it isn't required. But that doesn't mean that it's not good practice. I always run a ground wire to sub panels and through every inch of conduit for that matter. If you do, and the conduit becomes separated behind a wall, then you have ground protection.

As for the bonding issue. You bond the neutral bus in a main panel, but not in a sub panel.

Keith

For full disclosure, I am not a licensed electrician, but I've met some that have known less than me about electricity.

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

#9

Look at 250.2 and 250.118

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

In 250.118, they list the acceptable ground path conductors. Metallic conduit is fine. Although a good idea, a separate ground conductor run to that panel is not required by code. The thing about sub-panels is that you are not allowed to bond the grounded conductor bus (neutral bus) to the ground bus or the panel chassis. This is to prevent neutral current flow on the conduit parts. You are, however, allowed to ground the neutral at that subpanel for a separately derived system, such as a generator, ss long as there's a transfer switch. I don't believe this applies to your situation.

For what it's worth, there is absolutely no mention of the term "subpanel" in the NEC.

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

#10

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

That it's not required doesn't mean it's not a darned good idea. I personally don't think it's possible to pay too much attention to grounding.

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

#11

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

Jason Waters

I think he may be right, I know you can do it for circuits, but I DON'T. It seems pretty easy to add the 4th wire and have the extra security. I agree with you it's a good idea and should do it. I hope you can work it out with your contractor.

I just wanted to post so you know there are "others" out there like you......

Just because it meets the requirements of the code, doesn't mean you can't do better. We could get into stud spacing and a bunch of other issues too. Just look at dryer cords. It took forever to go the 4 wire cords for houses, but we did because it's better.

I think the other poster nailed it, try and work it out, and reason with them on why it would be prudent to do it that way, and the importance of the grounding in those applications, and potential future work. Maybe the owner would be best to talk to. Then he can explain to future clients why it's better to do it that way. And maybe he'll do it gratis.

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

#12

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

Larry in nw ohio

This may really sound dumb but would it do any good to try and get him to sign a paper saying he didn`t hook a ground to where ever it is suppose to be and if something happens to the equipment, that he would be responsible for it. Just a thought. I told you it would sound dumb. Larry

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

#13

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I agree. If you don't provide a path for that energy, it will find its own, and you can bet it won't be one that you want.

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

#14

Re: Grounding Requirements for Sub-Panel

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

Thanks all for your input. The contractor refuses to put the wire in unless I come up with part of the NEC that says I am right or we pay for it, which is going to be a pain since it is already connected. I'll check out those sections you all recommended.

Thanks again.