Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

Posts

Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#1

Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

Craig Daymon

I can't really comment on Tommy Mac's woodworking ability as I've yet to see a show that gives much of a glimpse of it. Too bad, I really need a show to fill the NYW void.

Watched last weekend's show and he casually went to the jointer to face joint his 10" wide board (because all of us have that 12" jointer). Then he later went to the tablesaw to cut a 7/8" dado. Well, the JET cabinet saw I had struggled holding a 3/4" dado, let alone a 7/8". David Marks would do similar stunts, but he was building decidedly more high-end projects.

Also watched him turn a lamp the week before and he didn't even come close to using a real cutting technique (scraping with carbon tipped tools) doing his spindle turning. Again, disappointed.

Maybe if they stretched the show to an hour he could raise the level of the show. At this point, I'm not a fan.

And yes, I'm well aware that NYW wasn't ranked as fine woodworking, but the quality of his projects and the amount of useful information given in a program was well above what you get from Rough Cuts.

-Craig

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#2

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

David Dircksen

I agree

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#3

Couldn't disagree more!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

For starters take a look at his home page and you'll see his work, which is of superb quality.

However that's not what I like about the show. I like the fact that he assumes you know something about woodworking and doesn't try to show every little detail or procedure. I got SO tired of that on NYW.

He is letting us in on his ideas, which is far more important.

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#4

Re: Couldn't disagree more!

john lucas

I agree with Craig. I enjoyed Norm. Perhaps is was just his personality. Can't get into the new woodworking shows at all. Maybe I'm just finally burned out on them.

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#5

Re: Couldn't disagree more!

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon John,

I liked Norm. Also liked Scott Phillips, Dave Marks and also Roy Underhill as a comic relief, albeit a skilled one. The others don't inspite me at all. Maybe it is a matter of personality, but the show chemistry of the more current offerings leaves me cold.

George

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#6

But Norm is not Tommy Mac either....

roger lance

Don't get me wrong, I love Norm....he was my woodworking teacher/mentor for 20 years and I keyed in on him from his first appearance on This Old House (my dad was a carpenter)....but Norm was not a "furniture maker" and he went out of his way to remind everyone of this fact by wearing without fail a carpenter's leather tool belt on each and every project (the message being I'm a carpenter building furniture).....plus Norm had Russel Morash as his show's director/producer and Norm had years of on camera experience before starting NYW....there just is/was no better produced woodworking show period.....but, for fun, do a search on Thomas J. MacDonald....WOW....this guy is a first class, classically trained furniture maker.....he is no Norm on camera and he does not have the level of TV production Norm had, but with the influences of The North Bennett Street School there is the potential of learning some interesting techniques in furniture construction.

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#7

Re: But Norm is not Tommy Mac either....

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

Maybe one of the issues is that our skill level has progressed to a point where Norm and Tommy are sort of superfluous. I know Norm got me into the shop as a rank beginner, didn't know a tenon from a screwdriver. I credit Norm for getting a lot of folks into or, back into, the shop. But, after twenty plus years of working wood I don't learn that much from woodwroking shows. I do get entertainment value from them though and, especially like Tommy's road trips that take us to historical places and see great works. Just like Norm use to do. I find them very inspiring. I am sure all the shows fill a need for someone or, they would have been cancelled. Back in the NYW days, I'd be downstairs watching Norm and yell at my wife, "He's cheating again!" She'd yell back down, "What tool does he have that you don't?" I guess she knows me too well. Darn!

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#8

Re: But Norm is not Tommy Mac either....

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

But I like them both. Norm did get me started and Tommy has more unique projects. Tommy just needs a little more polish, that'll come with experience in front of the camera.

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#9

Other considerations...

Tony - Memphis

Don't forge that this show is sponsered by Woodcraft. I have no clue what their intent is, but I would assume they are trying to attract new blood and keep us "old timers" interested. I have a feeling they have a whole lot of say in the show content.

I have been watching Tommy for quite a while via his web page videos. Great for lunch time viewing at work. He is definitely a top notch woodworker with better than average talent. It has been funny to watch his shows cleaned up for PBS! One thing I really appreciated about his videos was that he showed all of his mistakes, miscalcualtions, unseen issues, etc. I learn from those as much as anything. I really think they have dumbed down his projects for the show.

Anyway, I enjoy the show better than most other stuff on tv. We don't have any cable, so my options are limited.

Tony

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#10

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

Jesse Cloud

All I can say is that nobody that good looking should be smart, too.

It just ain't fair! ;)

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#11

Re: But Norm is not Tommy Mac either....

roger lance

Doug....You've made some good points....I just watched a NYW episode on the NYW website (look for NewYankee.com)....they are showing a different NYW show for a week starting on Mondays....this week it is the Tiger Maple Washstand #904....in it Norm builds a replica of a 1830s nightstand and goes to a lot of effort to replicate the piece with tiger maple but then builds a drawer with a tiger maple front and plywood sides (3/4" plywood at that)....I don't recall my reaction to that all those years ago when the show first aired but there were a number of questionable choices made on NYW other than the use of a nail gun to attach moldings....but it is the number of years of working wood and learning from other sources that give an insight into realizing that plywood is not the appropriate choice on a drawer when trying to replicate an antique.

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#12

Re: Couldn't disagree more!

Art Silva

Colonel! At our age you and I should not be thinking of being cold. Semper Fi, Art

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#13

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

John McGaw

I find him irritating and, whatever else he might have to offer, I don't enjoy the show at all. A combination of mannerisms, forced speech, and the stooges he sometimes trots out as our representative everyman just irk me. Sorry. I'll do without and this is one show that has been removed from the DVR schedule.

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#14

Ok Guys, Ok Guys it's like Different Ok Guys ??

Mark

Ok guys Ok Guys Ok Guys......For me the issue is learning...sure after several seasons with Norm I can't say I was learning much, but the first three...the three that got me totally hooked and inspired and passionate about making furniture ..WOW

Tommy Mac ....he builds stuff ....you see some interesting things ...but he does not Teach in my opinion...Norm albeit, after several tenons ...you were sick of it, and you wondered how much it was going to cost you to get all those tools ..Norm taught hundreds of WWs...Tommy Mac ( are you a rapper ? ) ...may entertain lots of them but there is little from what I have seen that you can record as I did with Norm, and then take into the shop and execute .....one taught and entertained ...one sometimes entertains.

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#15

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

AZ in Colorado Springs

I've seen Tommy Mac only once -- at the woodworking show in Denver last fall. He's a nice guy. Don't know about his show.

Several posts have compared NYW/Norm and Tommy Mac and discussed who is more of a teacher. As I said above, I've not seen Rough Cut, but two thoughts strike me -- the two shows were established at different times and maybe to speak to different generations. And, if one 'grew up' watching NYW it'd difficult to go back and 'see' Rough Cut as a new woodworker would see it.

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#16

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)

The difference between Norm and Tommy is that NYW is more instructional whereas Rough Cuts is more entertaining. Tommy Mac is having fun! I enjoy watching someone so enthusiastic about woodworking. And you really gotta laugh when he demonstrates a technique that would take about a week to complete and says "before you know it, you're done!".

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#17

Kneale Brownson

A Cold Cut, Eh, George?


Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#18

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

Bill White

Hey! FWIW, he's on tv, and we're not. Gotta believe that there is somethin' that the sponsers like.

You don't want to see me spend a week doin' a project with my dino tooling and techniques. (But I sure do have fun.)

I even use brushes and wiping finishes, a '50s bandsaw and DP, and a contractor's TS.

I do have an 18v Makita driver/drill. Does that make my a modern WWer?

Chuckle!!!!!

Bill

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#19

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

Craig Daymon

I did check out Mac's site and his "real" work, but that's not what the show offers. In my opinion, even the camera work is weak, failing to give clear shots of what is being shown.

Keep in mind that this show is NOT directed at professionals. Why would a pro waste time watching what they can do themselves? He's not showing the level of work that was shown by David Marks on his show.

Also, and this was the key point of my post, what about his use of a 7/8" dado stack on his saw and the 12" (maybe 16") jointer? I'm not aware of a 10" tablesaw that will take that dado stack and the vast majority of woodworkers don't, no matter how much they want one, have a 12" jointer in their shops. Correct me if I'm wrong, but those tools aren't what makes Mac a good woodworker.

Does Woodcraft even sell a saw that takes a 7/8" dado stack?

Again, no reflection on his abilities. His site certainly shows he can create quality work, but the show really isn't letting him do it.

Too bad. I think Woodcraft's magazine has WWJ beat easy. Still more toys than I like, but overall pretty good and not as heavily laden with product promotions. I'd like to see them do a better job with the show as well.

-Craig

P.S. I think the humor is pretty weak too. Most of the joking sounds like it should have a rim shot included.

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#20

Re: 7/8" dado stack

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

I've noticed that Tommy uses a SawStop.

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#21

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

Walter

I'll watch Tommy, but I'm not sure they are taking enough time to show methods like Roy Underhill (my favorite) and Norm.

I'd like to do a video series starting with an empty building and teaching all the different options on how to set up a shop based on 3 levels. Apprentice, Journeyman and then Master.

Anyone want to fund me?

I have the building.

Re: Rough cuts is definitely not Norm

#22

Re: 7/8" dado stack

Craig Daymon

That being the case, by putting a 7/8" stack on the saw he is exceeding the specified max for the saw. I just went to the SawStop site and their industrial cabinet saw takes a maximum dado width of 13/16", an 8th over 3/4" and an 8th under 7/8". Hmmm...using the saw that claims to be the safest on the market in an unsafe manner. Oh well, so much for safety features.