Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

JET Bandsaw Burned Out...electrical question

Posts

Re: JET Bandsaw Burned Out...electrical question

#26

Re: JET Bandsaw Burned Out...electrical question

Bill White

Sure makes me wanna buy a JET. NOT!!!! :D

Re: JET Bandsaw Burned Out...electrical question

#27

Re: JET Bandsaw Burned Out...electrical question

Ed in NY

I don't know Bill, the bandsaw was bought in 1999 and had performed well, my 6" jointer is rock solid and my 22/44 drum sander is top of the line. I have no real complaints with any of my JET purchases.

Re: JET Bandsaw Burned Out...electrical question

#28

Re: JET Bandsaw Burned Out...electrical question

Ed Wozniak-Buffalo, NY

Larry,

There is nothing incorrect about what you said, but the difference between using 120 VAC or 240 VAC is a little more dramatic than what you indicated. 12 AWG wire has .001588 Ohms/ft of resistance. A 50 foot run has a total of 100 feet of wire so the total resistance is .1588 Ohms. Assuming an 8 Amp load at 120 Volts the voltage drop across the wiring will be .1588 Ohms X 8 Amps or 1.27 Volts which is about 1% of the 120 VAC line voltage. Assuming a 4 Amp load 240 Volts the voltage drop across the wiring will be .1588 Ohms X 4 Amps or .635 Volts which is only .26% of the 240 VAC line voltage. The per cent of full line voltage that is lost across the wiring at 120 VAC will be roughly 4 times higher than the per cent of full line voltage that is lost across the wiring at 240 VAC.

I have to admit that if the motor drew 8 Amps max and the wire run was 50 feet there would not likely be any noticeable difference in performance. But if the motor bogs down even slightly the current draw will increase and may become large enough to make a difference. From my own experience I got a noticeable improvement in performance when I changed by Craftsman table saw 1 HP motor from 120 to 240 VAC operation. My wiring was 12 AWG and less than 50 feet. But who knows, your mileage may vary.

Re: JET Bandsaw Burned Out...electrical question

#29

Re: JET Bandsaw Burned Out...electrical question

Kurt

I'd recommend a new motor but not from Jet necessarily. 1.5 -2 h.p. work well. The nearest Tractor Supply looks like it's in New Milford, CT. but I bought a 1.5 h.p. G.E. at Tractor Supply to replace a Grizzly .75 h.p. motor. HUGE difference and it cost $189 at the time.

Re: JET Bandsaw Burned Out...electrical question

#30

Re: JET Bandsaw Burned Out...electrical question

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Well your figures are correct for a 100 foot run - however most runs are not that long. And the industry standard for motor and equipment design is normally that their rated output is at 115 Volt AC + or - 10%. IE: The equipment should function properly from 104.5 Volt to 126.5 Volt. Now the power companies standard is at the transformers is 120 Volt +/- 5% or 114 to 126 Volt.

Therefore you will most likely have 4 to 5 times as much variation in your in-coming line voltage than the variation in using 120 volt or 240 to run your motor.

"North American Voltage Ranges

In the US and Canada, 220 volts, 230 volts, and 240 volts are used interchangeably to describe one voltage range that is used to power larger appliances. Similarly, 110 volts, 115 volts, and 120 volts all refer to the one voltage range that is available through the common electrical outlet. The sources of these seemingly different numbers are as follows:

The 220 volt and 110 volt designations are older and familiar terminology, but are no longer used in either product design or by electric utilities in the US and Canada.

The 230 volt and 115 volt terminology comes from equipment design standards. Equipment is commonly designed to operate at 230 or 115 volts plus or minus 10%.

Electric utilities typically deliver electricity, under standard conditions, at 240 volts and 120 volts plus or minus 5% at the transformer.

When one takes into account that equipment is designed to accept voltage variations of 10% at a minimum and that the electric utility regularly delivers electricity within 5% of their standard, there is a good match between the voltage the electric utility delivers and the voltage equipment was designed to use."

Re: JET Bandsaw Burned Out...electrical question

#31

Re: JET Bandsaw Burned Out...electrical question

Ed Wozniak-Buffalo, NY

i believe my figures are correct for a 50 foot run. A 50 foot run has 100 feet of wire in the circuit.

Re: JET Bandsaw Burned Out...electrical question

#32

Re: JET Bandsaw Burned Out...electrical question

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

You are correct - however it doesn't change the basic premise that a couple of volts difference would have any appreciable effect on the measurable horsepower of a motor. It is quite likely that you would see more difference of voltage measured in a circuit between peak and low usage hours than you would due to the 240 and 120 Volt voltage drop. I have hooked up a (laboratory standard) recording volt meter to the circuit in my home many years ago to prove to the local utility that they had an undersized transformer feeding several houses in the area. (They did change it after I proved the voltage dropped below allowable specification at peak hours). I was an Engineer at a manufacturing facility that produced automotive switches and appliance controls and timers and had access to better instruments than the utility owned.