Re: Alone in the Wilderness
Gary Smyth
I would never take anything away from the work of building or shooting that documentary. However, in the movie “Broadcast News” there is a scene where Holly Hunter is confronted with the fact that Wm.Hurt, on a single camera shoot, is shown in a cutaway, crying. On a single camera news shoot, journalistically it is impossible to do that without some editing and, in the case of the movie, shows that it was a set up, staged for the news (which at that time, USED to be expressly forbidden).
With Dick Proenneke it is difficult to believe the story as presented. In a former life I used the film to teach critical points of documentaries. We always discussed how much more difficult it would be to be rushed by weather and the season to both build a cabin and do the hundreds of time consuming setups with 16mm film and film speed, the camera and lenses of that time, lights and tripod. Where did he stay when building the cabin? That is a LOT of film to shoot, store, and get processed. Not only that, shooting that way was very expensive. He would have to set it up, start the camera, move into and out of frame, go back and then turn off the camera,--all the while burning film. We used to budget 50 cents for each second of 16mm going through the camera—used or not in the final cut. Not impossible for a man to do on his own, but difficult. Another example, in the 1960’s how do you pan a scene with you in it if there is only one camera and you are alone?
As I said, take nothing away from the guy when he did it. Blame it on the production company for re-editing (and reshooting) if you have to. But watch closely the filming technique as you are seduced with his skill.
This from Wikipedia: (Underlines are mine)
In May 21, 1968, Proenneke arrived at his new place of retirement at Twin Lakes. Before arriving at the lakes, he made arrangements to use a cabin on the upper lake of Twin Lakes owned by a retired Navy captain, Spike Carrithers, and his wife Hope from Kodiak, (in whose care he had left his camper). This cabin was well situated on the lake and close to the site which Proenneke chose for the construction of his own cabin. Proenneke's bush pilot friend, Babe Alsworth, returned occasionally to bring food and orders that Proenneke placed through him to Sears.
Proenneke remained at Twin Lakes for the next 16 months, when he left to go home for a time to visit relatives and secure more supplies. He returned to the lakes in the following spring and remained there for most of the next 30 years, going to the lower 48 only occasionally to be with his family. He made a film record of his solitary life, which was later recut and made into a documentary, entitled Alone in the Wilderness. It has aired on PBS numerous times. In 2011, a sequel was produced after it was revealed Proenneke had shot enough footage for at least two more programs. Alone in the Wilderness: Part 2 premiered for the first time on December 2, 2011. A premiere date for Part 3 has yet to be announced