Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

multiple identical spindle tirning tool

Posts

multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#1

multiple identical spindle tirning tool

Joseph Mulherin

I once saw where the guy ground into the edge of an angle iron the design for the spindles he was turning for a stairway....all identical when finished. The idea was to have the angle mounted on the tail end of the lathe and descend down cutting the material by gravity only until finished. Does anyone know of this idea, maybe have some plans or knowledge of how to do it? I am making those chairs which have 14 turnings to be done on each one, seven of each design x 2, and it would be a lot better if I had this tool for identical turnings. Thanks

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#2

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

John in NM

I would bet there would be huge amounts of chatter and general difficulties with that much cut length.

Even the copy lathes I've seen use a regular tool insert and some sort of mechanism to ride against a master form. Many turners find it only takes a little practice to get them to come out close enough by eye and a few measured points. Open end wrenches make good quickie calipers for small diameters. Larger diameters I will sometimes make a fixed caliper out of 1/4" plywood.

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#3

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

Joseph Mulherin

I understand, John, but I am not an experienced turner...just do what is needed for the project i am working on at the present time. But, with that many turnings for 6 chairs x 14 turnings, I just thought it would be nice to have this tool. I saw it done by Tom Silva on This Old House many yrs ago when he was working on a stairway.

Anyway, I am going to buy a piece of 3/16"x1 1/2" x 36" angle and use my diamond cutoff blade and bench grinder. Aim to make the individual designs on it, and make sure it is the correct length for the turnings without having bumping problems when it descends. I still have the duplicator on the Shopsmith, but this is a new idea I had. The duplicator works fine, but at times it also causes problems....have to make sure the speed of the lathe is correct. They say to use "C" for rough turning, "H" for medium, and "N" for final burnishing.

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#4

Re: multiple identical spindle turning tool

Joseph Mulherin

John, the "master form" is what I am thinking is the angle iron design I am speaking of.

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#5

Turning multiples

Bill Tindall

I was taught this tip and found that it works. One's eye is not sensitive to small differences in the diameter of the elements in a spindle, but their spacing must be precise. I make a story stick with a hook on one end to hook over the end of the spindle to be. The story stick has notches to locate the various elements-cove, bead, etc.). Hook stick over end of spindle and then mark off the beads coves etc. So long as they are spaced right it doesn't matter if say a bead on one part is slightly larger diameter than one on another part. This approach is so simple that duplicating devices are not necessary, or even an advantage.

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#6

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool *LINK*

John Lucas

Joseph Unless it's a very thick piece of wood I would think that you would get huge amounts of chatter and very rough finish.

If you get one of the new carbide lathe tools you can turn spindles quite easily with little skill. The Easywoodtools are great for spindles. The easyrougher and the easy detailer would do what you need to do for spindles and don't take any skill to use. Just a little care and attention to detail and you should be able to use them to make duplicates.


http://www.easywoodtools.com/

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#7

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

Joseph Mulherin

Thank you, John, but I do have a couple sets of lathe tools already. I was just thinking if I could have this aqngle iron design to descend down the dowel it would cut at only one point and go on to finish the design I am hoping for for my chairs. 7 different designs, 14 turnings per chair and i am thinking about maqking 6 chairs before Xmas for presents for the family members. I am not inexperienced with lathe turnings; have the Shopsmith duplicator too, and can make my first turning and then use it for the model for the rewst of the turnings. But having the angle iron tool would make it easier for me to make many spindles with little trouble and not a lot of time on each. 14 x 6 =84 turnings. I have the first spindles made for my first chair, and have to just glue them into their sockets.

Oh, well, I guess I shall just continue with the duplicator and forget the other tool I mentioned...maybe later will be made.

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#8

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

What you are describing is called a back knife lathe. They are a heavy duty specialized pieces of equipment with very powerful motors. You might want to do some google searches and check out how they work before grinding on some angle iron.

Robin

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#9

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

del schisler

I use bead cutters of different size's. They all come out the same size. I know you know . The one's i have are richard sorby brand. Of course these are not automatic cutting but will work. I have all the size's.

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#10

Experience

wilbur

"I understand, John, but I am not an experienced turner...just do what is needed for the project i am working on at the present time. But, with that many turnings for 6 chairs x 14 turnings, I just thought it would be nice to have this tool."

With 84 turnings to do, you could just start turning them using a story stick to help you keep the transitions consistent. At the end of that 84, you'll have more than enough experience, and it will be a skill that you'll use again and again.

And so what if you wind up messing up a few? If you're really worried, do dry runs on scrap wood.

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#11

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

Joseph Mulherin

OK, guys/gals, I have decided to discard my previous turnings and make some new ones from a previous project I made about 8 yrs ago. Shall copy the design, turn it on the lathe, then use that for the model to make all of the new turnings. The lengths will have to be different, but that will be easy enough....just make them longer and then form each length to the desired dowel usage on the chairs. Am going to be buying some hardwood dowels from a source and then turn them as needed.

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#12

JL

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

JL

I've made a few legs, center stretchers and side stretchers of various designs.

I have story sticks for each pattern that I typically use. If I haven't turned in a while, I start with stretchers as they are easier. By the time I get to the legs I'm in production mode.

After I get in practice, I can turn a leg in less than hour from billet to final sanding.

One of my mentor's does his in less than 15 minutes.

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#13

dowels are expensive

Dick Coers

For lathe work, if you want round stock, take a piece of square stock and make 4 passes on the router table with a round over bit. It won't be dead round, but really close and you will be turning it anyway. If the spindles get very small in dia., check into a spindle steady to limit vibration as you turn.

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#14

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

Joseph Mulherin

Have decided to redo the turnings with another turning I did about 10yrs ago.

Made the copy, ran it thru the lathe, used that first one as the model for the rest.

I am having the luck of being able to use the previous turnings to make the next ones.

Have two seats ready; arms and rockers made...just need to redo the leg and arm turnings.

Redid 10 turnings today....more tomorrow. Then drill holes for spreaders and glue up everything.

Found another back design for the next two chairs.

Still not able to send out pictures of the works...mainly because the Kodak EasyShare program is screwing up on my computer, so have decided to trash it and reinstall from the CD they sent when I bought the camera.

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#15

Re: dowels are expensive

Joseph Mulherin

Yesw, Dick, that is what I have been doing. Bought some 1"x4"x8ft spruce from HD, cut it to lengths needed for individual spindles, glued two boards together to get 2"x4", divided them on the bandsaw to 1 15/16" each so now I have two sets from one glueing. Have seven different turnings x 2 to make for each chair. I found out the first turniung did not meet my satisfaction, so I selected another turning I made about 10yrs ago and made a model to use for the next turnings. They will be almost identical on each chair.

Redir 10 turnings today and more tomorrow. Two chairs....28 turnings.

Have decided to just keep on using my Shopsmith duplicator when turning. Shall try to make that back knife tool later.

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#16

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

Joseph Mulherin

Ran out of material, so will stop until next month on doing the new spindles.

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#17

Spindle dancer was a term I recalled

DizD

and I did a quick Bing search. There was a link to an article in Popular Woodworking and it shows a photo of the device. Its a jig used to establish the diameters for reproducing turnings. Thought it might be of interest.

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#18

Re: Spindle dancer was a term I recalled

Joseph Mulherin

Thanks, shall try to find and view.

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#19

Re: Spindle dancer was a term I recalled

Joseph Mulherin

Could not find the spindle dancer at all. So, I have decided to just use my spruce for the spindle turnings using the Shopsmith lathe duplicator for the3 entire 84 turnings I have to do for the 6 chairs.

Others have said that the equipment is for a large motor...5hp... and it would not work for the home lathe.

I shall just finish my chairs for this year for Xmas gifts and forgo the back kinife idea.

Bought the new Nikon camera last Xmas, used it today for pictures of another project I got myself into, so will put the chairs I have already cut parts for...assemble dry again, take a few pics and try to send them to WC .

Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#20

Here is photo I found on link

DizD

From Popular Woodworking Feb 2006


Re: multiple identical spindle tirning tool

#21

Re: Here is photo I found on link

Joseph Mulherin

Diz, that is not what I had in mind. Think about the design being ground into the angle-iron, mounted on a swivel bolt on the tail end, and it descends slowly cutting the spindles in one pass. Others have said that this process is called a back-knife and needs to have say a 5hp motor to work. I have the Shopsmith 5-in-1 tool with variable speed adjustment, so I think it would not be a problem that way.

I saqw Tom Silva do some stairway spindles on the Old House program a few yrs ago this way and it did work for him.