Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

OT - HVAC advice needed

Posts

OT - HVAC advice needed

#1

JL

OT - HVAC advice needed

JL

When they ducted the auditorium of the playhouse, they put the "registers" or vents in the suspended ceiling. While this is fine for warmer weather, it doesn't work too well in colder weather - it is a LONG way down to the audience.

We can't really put in new ducting - the auditorium seats are on concrete "terraces". The hot air rises and collects near the roof - the lighting catwalk is quite warm with the rising air and the heat from the lights.

Would it be reasonable to put some fans or squirrel cage motors up in the upper area to help the warmer air get down to the audience? Would I even need ducts?

It might be possible to put ducting on the auditorium right side on the other side of the wall - but I don't know if that would be enough circulation.

Here is the main floor plan.



I could use the closet on the right or the triangular shaped piece

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

#2

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Suggest ceiling fans directed up toward the ceiling. That will destratify the airmass and circulate the air without blowing on your audience as the warm air will be forced down along the walls. You wind up with a unified temperature. Reverse them for cooling season. You'll want them at about 2/3's of the total height (1/3 down) so look for units with a remote control module to switch directions with playing with ladders, etc.

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

#3

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

Gary Smyth

Sound. Sound. Sound. This is a theater first.

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

#4

Big A$$ Fans *LINK*

Tom Dunlap

One summer I went to see the Gourds play. They concert was supposed to be on the patio but a thunderstorm was forecast so they moved inside. while I was waiting for the show to start I looked up and saw a cool looking ceiling fan. The fan had an aeronautical look. Then I saw the name plate :)


Very clever company name

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

#5

JL

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

JL

The suspended ceiling grid could adequately support a number of the medium sized (56" diameter) fans. Probably about four or so. Maybe 4' or so down rods.

Thanks for the suggestion. It would be reasonably inexpensive (under $1000) for four ceiling fans - and we could add some light fixtures.

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

#6

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

I would not hang fans from a suspended ceiling. I would prefer to extend a REAL pipe to the actual building ceiling. The constant vibration is going to sooner or later break something. I saw the aftermath of an improperly hung fan. Well over $2500 damage in a living room, this was 25 years ago.

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

#7

The Only Thing

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

you hang from a suspended ceiling frame is a fly catcher glue-strip!

Ceiling cans MUST be secured to joists.

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

#8

Hire an engineer

Pat Evans

First contact the engineer that did the original design and have him analyze the problem. It may be a balance problem or problem with the HVAC unit. It might be as simple as increasing the fan speed. If it turns out to be a design problem, you may have to involve another engineer and maybe lawyer.

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

#9

I agree with Pat....

Mike in NC

If this is not an older building that has been altered beyond the original design, it is a design issue. Where are the returns? If they are in the ceiling the system is "short cycling". If the returns were near the floor, they would suck the air down from the supply grills in the ceiling and thus circulating it.

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

#10

Re: I agree with Pat....

Barry Irby

I took design classes in college back when we had to out run Dinosaurs to get to class. Auditoriums are interesting as you have discovered. You and "lay" air conditioning on the floor and because the colder air is heavy it will stay there and you only have to cool the bottom eight or ten feet or so. Heat is a different topic as you have found.

An Engineer who does this day could tell you pretty quickly if you have a design problem. You either have to put he heat in down low and pull it out near the top or put the heat in up high and pull it down with the returns. Another way to do it is to use radiant heat and warm the audience and not the air so much.

As an Aside, the crowd provides a lot of its own heat. Each person at rest puts out about 400 BTU an hour. The room is cold and everybody that gets in early gripes about the cold and may demand "they" turn the heat up. The crowd assembles ad the room warms up. Somebody comments, "I'm glad they adjusting the thermostat." , and yet no one adjusted anything, its just body heat. Maybe you just need a crowd to come in ahead of the real crowd to warm the place up for them. :)

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

#11

Crowd heat

Tom Dunlap

Many years ago I read about a greenhouse operator who was looking into alternate heat sources. He did the calculations and found that the cheapest heat source was to buy field corn and bunny rabbits. Corn=fuel, bunnies=furnaces. The corn was efficiently converted into heat and a little waste. The waste just composted and he didn't have any chimneys or open flames so it was super simple.

Since he used pesticides in the greenhouse he couldn't eat the bunnies after their heat producing days ended.

Tom

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

#12

Ducted fan

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

They make a fan for high ceilings that has an axial flow fan and a canvas sock that runs down to the floor from the fan which is mounted near the ceiling. I've seen these in gyms and industrial buildings with high ceilings.When operating the fan pulls warm air off the ceiling and releases it at ground level. This destratifies the air. You could probably make your own with any axial flow fan and pvc duct work. You'll want a fan with a high flow and low noise level.

Lee

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

#13

JL

Early 1980s

JL

The engineering firm isn't around anymore.

The ducts are in the suspended ceiling (four of them). The returns are up near the stage (they come down the two shafts on either side of the proscenium opening). There are two HVAC systems (auditorium right and auditorium left) and two separate returns.

We are a 501 c3 organization operating on a shoestring budget. We really don't have the money for a HVAC redesign and rework.

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

#14

JL

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

JL

I'll have to see if I can get up to the underside of the roof. Probably not that possible due to the seats and terraces.


I know I can probably get up to the catwalk and suspend something from the underside of it.

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

#15

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

Larry in NW Ohio

JL Before you start doing to much renavating to someone elses building, make sure you have permission to do it and make very sure they have personal insurance. Just to be on the safe side. Larry

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

#16

Did it ever work?

Pat Evans

Presumably the system worked when originally installed. I would be looking for what has changed. Perhaps you could find an HVAC contractor who might volunteer enough time to at least investigate the current operating condition of your system. If I were involved, I would rather see the system operate as designed rather than jury-rigged add-ons.

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

#17

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

Galen Vetterick

How long has it been since anyone cleaned the system? I've seen blower fins so packed with dust they no longer effectively moved air. Suspended grills that the top side looked like a cat shed its hair. When the ducts get coated with dust and dirt it also makes a big reduction in air flow as the friction lose becomes much higher than smooth new sheet metal. I've even seen where a thermostate was so dirty it did not respond as it should. They added security covers to our thermostates at work and removed them when they did not respond correctly. Anything change around the thermostate? I assume the ducts are not insulated and a good share of the heat goes for heating the area above the false ceiling and insulation can be added, but is a big cost.

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

#18

Re: Early 1980s

George Koch

Since you mentioned the returns are down low, my first thought would be to make sure they are drawing properly thereby drawing the heated air down to them. Check the filters, which are in the return air sides of the systems. George

Re: OT - HVAC advice needed

#19

JL

Re: Did it ever work?

JL

Only in summer and fall.

The woman who contracted for the building died before it was occupied. A local community theater group took it over - but had no money to really pursue anything or to get the building up and running properly.

Now a new group has taken over the facility and is trying to "make it right" and functioning up to capacity.