Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Selling my contractor's saw

Posts

Selling my contractor's saw

#1

Selling my contractor's saw

Allen Bryant - Bumpass, VA

I have some side work coming up this weekend and after getting paid for it, I will finally have the money saved up for a new or used still not sure which, cabinet saw. Before I can get the saw I need to get rid of my current one. There just isn't enough room in my little shop to put both saws even temporarily.

Some years ago I updated my contractor saw to a 52" rip fence along with a custom made mobile base and cabinet system underneath of it. This base will not work under a cabinet saw no matter what one I end up getting, so I can't re-use it. In addition there are some features I like about it and some I don't so I plan on making a new one to go underneath the cabinet saw.

I have a couple of options here.

1. I can strip the contractor saw back down to the factory stand and fence and sell it that way. This will allow me to save a little bit of money as I can purchase the saw with a standard fence and move the 52" fence over to the cabinet saw.

2. I can sell the outfit as is complete with the mobile cabinet / base. This would be easier in some respects as the fence and extension table are built as part of the cabinet base, plus far less work. I would still give the new owner all the factory parts. Also the base has a hole cut for my router plate and router setup that will not be going with the saw.

Any thoughts? Would it even be worth trying to list with the custom base / cabinet. I doubt I could reuse any of the parts except maybe the door hinges and drawer slides. The cost to replace them would be minimal.

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#2

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

Ralph Lipeles

With the economy the way it is, there are a lot of saws out there and they are not bringing great money. Whatever you can take of to reduce costs in the new saw will save you more then it would bring in left to sell with the old saw.

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#3

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

Allen Bryant - Bumpass, VA

Good point, hadn't thought about that.

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#4

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

Brian in SLO

I sold my contractor saw last year and found the best way to do it was to strip it down to the basic saw. No extras included. I took what parts I could and used them on my new (used) cabinet saw.

I transferred the link belt and saved the cost of buying it again, although I needed more going from one long belt to three shorter ones.

Took my mobile base to the welding shop to have it refitted to fit the new saw

I have a cast iron router table extension, transferred it.

Nobody wanted to pay what I wanted for the saw with the extras. But once I took off the extras and lowered the price accordingly I actually made more money in the long run by saving the cost of replacing the extras.

I ended up happy and so did the guy who bought the saw, and he knew that I had removed the extras!

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#5

Re: Keeping my contractor's saw

Charlie Lenz

What is it that you do that you think that you need a stationary industrial table saw such as a cabinet saw in your shop ? Whoever it was that convinced woodworkers that they have to have a cabinet saw in their hobby shops must of been one heck of a salesman to sell it to some of the cheapest people on the planet, the same goes for pleated cartridge filters.

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#6

Re: Before you all go ballistic on me

Charlie Lenz

If you allready own a cabinet saw, well I'm cheaper then you are, and probably allways will be.

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#7

Cost/benefit tradeoffs don't always apply

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I think for a lot of folks, the pleasure of using a thoroughbred tool is worth the dollars.

Then there are those, and you're not alone, Charlie, who look at cost vs. benefit and "good enough tools" and go with lower cost approaches, either because they have to or because it makes more sense to them.

For me, it's a little like the folks who would never buy an old hand plane, even for rough work; or who buy an old hand plane and spend hours redoing the japanning, refinishing the handles, etc., so it'll be pretty, even though much of what they do affects the actual function not at all.

Different strokes for different folks; horses for courses; your mileage may vary; whatever works for you. I've probably made my attitude clear, but I respect those whose decisions differ.

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#8

Re: Cost/benefit tradeoffs ( Bill )

Charlie Lenz

Bill, I agree, and you put it nicely. I just get really tired of hearing about Cabinet saws, SawStops, Festool, pleated Cartridge Filters, etc. I don't know who these people are, if they are salesmen or woodworkers, my guess is that there are a few salesmen in the bunch of every forum.

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#9

Bought mine used...

John in NM

Had an 8" contractors saw before that. If there had been a used heavy contractors saw available I would have bought it instead if it were cheaper. At the time and place it was buy new or grab what came up when you had the money. Couldn't have bought a new contractors saw for the cost of the cabinet saw, so it was an easy decision.

Festool stuff is a whole different ball of wax. Most people won't actually "need" such things, but they are an absolute pleasure to use and those that I've used did a far better job than other versions of the same tool. Was it 2x or 3x better to go with the price tag? No, probably not. But then is driving a luxury car 3x or 10x a better experience than my crummy economy cars? Definitely not. The curve of price vs. quality is never linear. Some find the luxury stuff worth paying for, some do not. I'm grateful that some do like luxury stuff - it means I occasionally sell some woodwork :D

Why sweat it anyway?

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#10

Re: Bought mine used...

Charlie Lenz

John, I had bought my Contractor's saw new in 1995 and it cost me about $950 with a good fence and mobile base. I was offered a Cabinet saw a few years ago where the guy was claiming that he'd give me a good deal, I was so not interested that I didn't even ask the brand, model number, or the price. Then as you probably know I sunk a bunch of time into dust collection and a couple other addons to my saw to upgrade it. Well I thought that others would appreciate haveing a good dust hood and maybe a paddle switch on thrir saws, it's been a extremely up hill battle with it since 2007. I'm really about wore out, lost my passion for woodworking because I couldn't make it there, now I'm loseing interest in being inventive, or atleast shareing it. Then ofcourse theres some other things in my life that I'm really haveing a hard time with, plus how people and things have changed for the worse in this country, it just isn't like it use to be. I know things could be worse, but I'm tired of worrying about it all and geting no where.

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#11

Re: Keeping my contractor's saw

Allen Bryant - Bumpass, VA

Charlie, you are correct I don't need a cabinet saw, I want one. I'm not trying to put you down or make fun of you or go ballistic. I know that having a cabinet saw will not make me a better woodworker, only skills and patience will do that. I have seen some wonderful work come from people using bench top saws and I'm quite proud of the work that has come out my saw. The decision was not one I took lightly and I wouldn't recommend anybody take lightly the decision to put that much money into a tool. I've been saving up for almost 4 years to purchase one and have had plenty of time to reflect and research on what I wanted. I also have intentionally not named the type of cabinet saw that I'm getting ready to get because I didn't want to start a big discussion on brands and why I choose the brand that I did. Suffice to say I did my research and picked out the saw that worked for me.

My contractor's saw was purchased in 1997 and has served me very well. Over the years there are a few features about it I just don't like. For instance the saw I'm looking at even when I move the 52" fence over has a smaller footprint than the contractors saw. In my shop space is at a premium and with the new shop being delayed yet again for 4 to 5 years, having a saw with a smaller foot print will be nicer. Not having the motor hanging out the back means I can push the saw another 12 to 14 inches closer to the wall and free up some floor space when I need it. The shop shares space with the vehicles and I can actually do quite a bit while having the vehicles in the garage, which makes dust collection an issue. I've tried for years to come up with some effective way of collecting dust from the current saw and I'm just tired of trying. The other problem I've been having is that to save weight the manufacturer used an open mesh cast iron extension wings, which are a pain for several reasons, they are difficult to keep clean and waxed, I'm constantly dropping stuff through them or having small parts fall through and while I thought at first that it would make a good clamping because of the open mesh, it actually hasn't. All these decisions went through my mind when I started looking. I also considered hybrid saws, but didn't really see one I thought was worth it. In addition the blade guard and riving knife that come with the one I'm getting is leaps and bounds better than what came with the contractors saw.

Notice that I didn't mention horsepower of the saw. I have rarely bogged down my contractor's saw even with 8/4 oak. The fact that the saw is a 3 horsepower is a bonus.

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#12

Re: Bought mine used...

John in NM

Hard to know what to say Charlie, other than I'm genuinely sorry to hear of your troubles. There are often no easy answers.

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#13

Re: Cost/benefit tradeoffs ( Bill )

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I really think your attitude stinks. Woodworking is my hobby - period! I don't try or have to justify the costs of my tools. I purchased them because I like them as do many on this site. I personally feel good for the woodworkers that are excited and happy to get a cabinet saw, new or used or any other equipment they want. I worked for everything I have. NO one gave me anything and I worked 2 and 3 jobs most of my working life before I retired and raised 6 children. I don't drive (and haven't since 1963) a new or even late model car. I don't have a big fishing boat, or play golf or gamble. I don't cut those down that do enjoy those things, and am happy if they enjoy them. I am not jealous of those who have better cars, boats, houses or equipment than I do - more power to them. I do enjoy woodworking and shooting (and collecting guns) and enjoy corresponding with others of similar ilk. To me it sounds like you are mad at anyone who has more than you or doesn't agree with your thinking. Shame on you!

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#14

Re: Keeping my contractor's saw ( Allen )

Charlie Lenz

Allen, we also park our vehicles in the garage/shop. I just remove the motor at the end of the day to scoot it up against the wall, takes about a minute to do. The motor hanging out the back isn't an issue for me, I have a removable outfeed table that I almost allways use since most of what I do with the saw is ripping. Dust collection I have solved in a very user friendly and efficient manner. You know what you want and what you can afford. My biggest grip is when people say that one of the reasons for going to a Hybrid saw or a cabinet saw is dust collection, so I buckled down and spent alot of time figureing out how I could improve it, since there appeared to be a market for it. Well after all these years I've come to the conclusion that dust collection is just another excuse, like more power, and the trunions is. I've never had to realign my saw. I just recently bought a older Delta 12" 2 hp thickness planer with a extra set of new Freud blades, it's quite a chunk of iron and made in the USA, but I sometimes wonder why I bought it, the deal is that I got it for less then what I'd have to pay for an imported DeWalt 735. I'm still on the fence thinking about weather I should keep it or not since I don't do much woodworking anymore. The old Ryobi that I bought new many years ago is still pluging along, but I worry about how how much more life is left in it.

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#15

Re: Cost/benefit tradeoffs ( Larry )

Charlie Lenz

Yeah Larry, theres a big difference in attitude when your retired. I'm not retired and not everyone else is either. I'm not jealous, I just tell it the way I see it, my experience with it all in 30 years as mostly a hobbyist. I've had some nice machinery that people I'm sure would like to have, a 2 hp Cyclone DC, a Oliver 159MW lathe, etc. sold them all because they weren't a neccessity in my shop. I don't have alot of money and I have to make the best use of what I have. Sure it would be nice to have a dedicated shop full of industrial woodworking equipment and the best in tools, that I could just walk into and start working, and at the end of the day do a little minor cleaning and walk out the door. For me, I have to have an income, it took me awhile to finally figure out that woodworking isn't it, and for the majority of people they aren't able to make a respectable income from it either. It's a retired persons hobby, someone that can take all day doing something that most people aren't willing to pay much for. Yeah I may be bitter, especially when someone tries to blow dust up my port.

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#16

Demand...

John in NM

It seems like there would be demand there, with two primary problems to solve. First is the vast array of saws available. One would have to come up with either something that would work with many or an individual design for each, and both of those require access to a lot of saws.

Second is that the potential market is a subset of contractor saw owners - those who either have ineffective dust collection or have none and are serious about buying it. There is little point in trying to reach saw owners who are content to put up with the dust (yes... guilty as charged :D ).

Of course, you've been through all this and probably know the subject better than do I. But I do think you should keep at it, if not with this with something else. It can be hard to do, but don't worry about the time spent on it. Even if you invent a bunch of stuff that never sells, it is still time better spent than sitting around watching game shows :D

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#17

Ask the CPSC to make your products mandatory


Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#18

Re: Demand...

Charlie Lenz

The biggest problem with dust collection on Contractor's style table saws is what the industry has provided, the generic plastic shallow trayed dust hood under the saw, it's very inefficient. I know that alot of people worry about the backside of the saw being open, but with a good dust hood and dust collector you'd be suprised what little bit of dust actually makes it's way out of the cabinet. Here is a guy that built my dust hood out of wood and demonstrates how well it works. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MkzY0F-5YlI

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#19

Re: LOL AZ

Charlie Lenz

I'd rather people like the hood, not hate it.

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#20

Re: Demand...

Bill White

I'll just jump in and say that my trusty Grizz 0444Z has been a very good saw. Sure, there are more sophisticated beasties out the, but this feller has done all I ever asked. But then............

Bill

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#21

Re: But then what ? ( Bill )


Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#22

Re: Keeping my contractor's saw

J. Waters

Charlie,

I have BOTH!!! OK, so we are not alike like I said last week. I had a 9" Rockwell saw, and it used it for many years (about 4-5). But then I realized I could use a more powerful motor. I didn't worry about, and thought something would come along. And it did!! I went to the Tampa Woodworking show about 10-12 years ago, and I went after work on Friday (it was really near my office), and there was a Dealer selling Unisaws with a 52" Bisemeyer Fence (I liked both), and tableboard (Platinum Edition-but I could have cared less) for a good price. I can't remember, But I think it was $1100 (maybe $1200 but I think that was the before price!) after rebate, plus sales tax. I wasn't sure about the price, and came home and checked out the deals online. It was indeed a good price!!! I went back the next morning over an hour before the show opened, and waited. I made a bee line for the saw, and bought within 5 minutes of opening. We went out back, they adjusted their liftgate truck to my tailgate height and we slid it in. That was some of the best money I ever spent. It is a joy to use. Of course, I have never seen that deal again. They had 4 to sell, I was #2. I could have gotten the same deal on a 30" Unifence saw but why? A contractor saw was about $750-850 at the time with the same fence setup, and offered little more inprovement from what I had.

Would I pay what Delta wants today? Not sure. But it's a different saw too.

As to the cartridge filters, IF you know what you are doing, you can build a cyclone, and buy cartridge filters pretty reasonable off Eb@y, but you have to look at specs, etc. That's what I do, but it's not for everyone.

Yes, I could have done everything without what I have and using my old equipment, but I have done a lot of home improvement work, furniture, and probably have at least broken even on most equipment, and I have exactly what I want in my house.

Making money at woodworking would be hard to do with a lot of people wanting to go to big box furniture stores every 3 years and redo their living room. I see it all the time, it's their choice, just not for me, just like the saw and pleated filter...........

I truly like discussions like these here, I think people get a lot of insight on wants and needs.

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#23

Re: Keeping my contractor's saw ( J. Waters )

Charlie Lenz

I guess that I feel this way, if you can afford a Cabinet saw and have enough power in your shop, or can afford to upgrade the power then thats great. For me I'd rather spend the extra money on other machines, like a 12" disc sander, mortising machine, a good router table, dovetail jig that I can also do box joints with, thickness planer, etc. you know the story, it never ends. Things that make my shop more versatile.

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#24

Re: Before you all go ballistic on me

TomD

I bought a good grade old iron cabinet saw +++ it has cast iron base!!, for 60 bucks. Kinda deal that needs a fence upgrade, but I'm thinking more Inca out of scrap than an aftermarket, even though I already own one.

Speaking of Inca, I bought one of those with a mortiser, and it was under 500.

So I don't see any reason to buy some saw that is specifically designed to do something other than what I do, on the basis of cost.

Re: Selling my contractor's saw

#25

Re: The 87th problem...

TomD

"Could be worse"

There's a story about a farmer who visited the Buddha. The man wanted to know how to solve all the problems he struggled with. He sat down with the Buddha and listed everything that made him miserable. The Buddha listened, nodded, and said, "I'm sorry, but I cannot help you with any of those problems. There are 86 problems and we all have one or another of them at any time"

"What?" the farmer cried. "What kind of wise man are you that you can't help me with any of my problems?"

"I am the wise man who can help you with the 87th problem," the Buddha said.

"The 87th problem? What problem is that?" the farmer demanded.

"The problem of not wanting to have any problems," the Buddha said.