Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Wood Movement issue

Posts

Wood Movement issue

#1

Alan Young

Wood Movement issue

Alan Young

I am finishing up work on a large memorial cross


The circle is made from Sapele and is currently screwed to the back side of the large maple sections.


I am concerned that in the warmer more humid months the maple sections will expand causing the sapele pieces to crack-or perhaps the sapele will stay firm but cause the maple to crack--in either case it seems I need a method to allow the sapele circle pieces to float with respect to the maple. I suspect an elongated hole for the mounting screws is the most conventional way however I am open to other ideas-perhaps some sort of clip?

Any other ideas???

-Alan



Re: Wood Movement issue

#2

Re: Wood Movement issue

doug f, san clemente, ca

Alan - since your fasteners will not show to the observer, I would think that elongating all the screw holes of the circular piece would be the most straightforward answer. Simple is usually better.

Douf

Re: Wood Movement issue

#3

Re: Wood Movement issue

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Hi Alan,

From your photo it seems you have a complex issue because the two woods in question will not be "moving" in the same direction, but rather at about 45° to each other across each of 8 joints. Given that complexity I'd first research which one will move the most, as that may be controlling. The smaller the grain width the less total movement you get, so I'm betting there will be more movement in the maple. Assuming that, but still allowing for some dance in the sapele, I'd hazard a guess that enlarged holes and a washer under the screw heads fixing the circular segments may be enough. You will, however, have to consider maintaining the alignment of the circle segments. Thus you might consider "fixing" one end of each arc while letting the other one float.

You might also consider making your arcs out of stable ply and veneering them to eliminate one vector of the movement.

Good question. Please post your answer for the rest of us.

m

Re: Wood Movement issue

#4

That's the solution......

Howard Acheson

..... I would use too.

Re: Wood Movement issue

#5

Alternatives

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

1. Instead of attaching the arcs to the maple, attach "bridges" [complete the circle] across the gaps and then secure the circle at/to the center points of the main cross frame members. Than way the circle and the wedges will move independently of each other and you'll have 4 fixing points for the circle that won't move at all.

2. Cut your complete circle out of 1/2 ply. pack it out to make contact with the back of the maple elements. Now cut veneer section and apply to the circle in truncated wedge shapes oriented to the center of the dove on the face. Suggest you look at Bernini's Cathedra Petri and Gloria in the Apse of St. Peter's Basilica.

Re: Wood Movement issue

#6

Me, too...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I screwed drawer supports to 24" wide butternut panels, used elongated holes with pan head screws and haven't had a problem in 20 years. Same result with an ash table 36" wide screwed to a trestle base.

Re: Wood Movement issue

#7

Alan Young

Re: Wood Movement issue

Alan Young

Hi Mark-You have diagnosed my concerns-The sapele is 2" in width as it was cut by swinging 12" and 14" diameters.

I have been considering "Fixing" one point of each sapele hemi circle (or what ever 1/4 circle is called) Specifically at the very top points and the bottom points but keeping the outer points "loosely" attached and let them pivot off some fixed blocks----


Still thinking on this....

-Alan

Re: Wood Movement issue

#8

Alan Young

Re: Alternatives

Alan Young

OK-Really Like this idea-Too late for this project as the design was meticulously arranged with the client's desires-but very helpful for a future rendition

-Alan

Re: Wood Movement issue

#9

Don't Forget

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You've got two other pieces of maple that will be moving at 90° to the first two you have noted in your graphic. BSOM how you allow for movement along all 3 vectors in each quarter.

The "bridge suggestion would only need 1/4" stock since the circle element is not structural. As it appears this will be wall-mounted, the 1/4" extra material on the back should not make any difference and will solve ( I think) all your problems.

Re: Wood Movement issue

#10

Alan Young

I think this is it.

Alan Young

Mark- I played around with the bridge idea tonight-I think this is the solution. Made some bridge pieces from 1/4 ply. It's gluing now. Pictures in a day or so.

Thanks!

-Alan

Re: Wood Movement issue

#11

Re: I think this is it.

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Glad to brainstorm with someone of your skill. Makes me dig deeper on a question. ;)

Re: Wood Movement issue

#12

Alan Young

Here's the Fix

Alan Young

I removed the walnut back cross sections which were only screwed to the maple. They will get glued on in the final steps. I cut 4 pieces of 1/4"ply and glued them to the sapele sections. I decided to place the ply between the sapele and the maple.The sapele/ply bridges are not yet glued or fastened to the maple -just clamped in place and glued to each other.


I placed pencil marks around each glued section so I can align the ring when I make the final assembly.




Here is the glued ring. It will then get fastened at the center points of each plywood bridge. The sapele should float freely now.


The Walnut back cross pieces will get placed over the plywood bridges. I'll need to cut a channel in the sections of the walnut that "bridge the bridges" but I feel that this is a great solution.-Thanks Mark!

-Alan

Re: Wood Movement issue

#13

Should Work

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You're very welcome. Now don't forget to post a pic when it's installed!

:D

m

Re: Wood Movement issue

#14

Re: Here's the Fix

larry in nw ohio

Alan You sure do outstanding work with crosses. Do you just make most of them for yourself and give them to various people or are they all contracted work. Again Great Job. Larry

Re: Wood Movement issue

#15

Alan Young

Re: Here's the Fix

Alan Young

Larry -A bit of "all of the above" this current piece is a commission. It will be mounted in a large open area of a school.

-Alan