Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

shop light converson question Rant

Posts

shop light converson question Rant

#1

shop light converson question Rant

Rick Snyder

Hi All,

Read an article in the paper today about the replacement (via the GOV.) of T-12 to T-8 bulbs. I'm going to guess that the T-8 BULBS DO NOT/CAN NOT fit the T-12 fixtures!.... I have 22 4ft lights in my shop and it now sounds like I'm going to have to use a different bulb and buy different LIGHT FIXTURES($$$$). Maybe I'll go out and buy every T-12 bulb I can find and ease my pain for awhile until I can buy new fixtures. Any other ideas out there?

Thanks, Rick

Re: shop light converson question Rant

#2

details, rant continued

Bill Tindall

The phase out of t12 began some time ago with the ruling that no new t12 fixtures were to be made. I thought the lamps were to be phased out sooner but I see they are still for sale.

The T8 will fit the T12 pins but you will need a T8 ballast. I have been replacing T12 ballasts with T8 as the T12's need replacing. Also I have been stocking up on T12 ballasts in case I need some. BTW, incandescent lamps are next on the list for extinction. I can't have an incandescent lamp but the mall looks like high noon with all their lighting. I can't see the milky way anymore for all the yard lights uselessly lighting the sky.

Will the public ever get tired of this endless government intrusion into every detail of our lives and vote out the intruders?

Re: shop light converson question Rant

#3

Rick L

Re: It's not as bad as it seems...

Rick L

You can use the same fixtures but you have to modify them with new ballasts and receptacles. We found a deal with the power company and they paid for a good chunk of it and we had many more fixtures than you did.

Re: shop light converson question Rant

#4

receptacles?

Bill Tindall

what receptacles were changed? Only the ballast needs to be changed. The pins are identical.

BTW of the several I have changed two wipe out Channel 5 TV when the light is on.

Re: shop light converson question Rant

#5

Re: receptacles?

Bill White

Wonder what Las Vegas is gonna do?

I put in T8s when I built the new home/shop (or is that shop/home).

Just more gov. crap.

Bill

Re: shop light converson question Rant

#6

Not sure I understand the kerfluffle

Neal in San Jose

The smaller the diameter a fluorescent lamp is, the more efficient it is. (BTW, the number of the lamp is that lamp's diameter in 1/8ths, thus a T-8 is one inch in diameter) A T-8 is up to 40% more energy efficient than a T-12 for the same amount of light. Industry and large offfices are already moving to T-5 lamps, which are even more efficient and can be made dimmable, but that doesn't matter to us.

When I made the decision to convert my gar...woops, I mean shop... to T-8 lamps, I figured the pay-back was less than a year if I bought all the ballasts and lamps and did it all at once. I took the path of least resistance and slowly converted the ballasts and lamps as the old T-12 lamps wore out. Industry chose to make the fixtures adaptable just for this reason - it is cheaper to change out a ballast and lamps and leave the rest of the fixture in place. Sticking with T-12 bulbs will guarantee that you are paying a premium for light, but you may have reasons for doing this like difficulty in getting to the fixture to replace the ballast. I'd rather spend my money on premium wood that I can turn into firewood!

Believe it or not, sometimes government does do something that actually makes sense. Besides the T-12 to T-8 switch, you will slowly have to change out most of your incandescent light bulbs to more energy efficient CFL or LED as they are phased out (I've already converted to take advantage of reduced energy costs), but specials, like appliance bulbs will continue to be available.

Re: shop light converson question Rant

#7

TN economics not so favorable; light economics

Bill Tindall

Situation( my shop is extravagantly illuminated with the bench area 200 ft candles)

24 lamps, operating 2 hours per day 365 days per year. T12's are Phillips #818282 40 watt with output of 3300 lumens

Alternative GE T8 32 watt #4788371 with output of 2800 lumens.

My cost to operate the T12's at my current rate of $0.095 per KWH is $67/year.

The T8 would cost $62/year for equivalent light intensity.

The electricity savings from a switch to T8 would be $5 per year.

I can move these numbers around +/-$5 depending on the details of exactly what lamps I am comparing. Some T12 lamps produce more light, others less, ditto for the T8's. But in any case there is no economic reason for me to retire T12 fixtures. Indeed, it is only because of the unfavorable economics that the government required the switch.

The situation is in fact even less favorable. I have to heat my shop in the winter months. I use electric heat. Hence, it costs me nothing to illuminate the shop in the winter for I am just trading 100% efficient heat from lights for heat from the heat pump.

Re: shop light converson question Rant

#8

Similarly...

John in NM

Some of us are cheap. Really cheap (that one is me :D )

T12 fixtures and bulbs are cheaper than T8. Incandescent bulbs are cheaper than CFL's and vastly cheaper than LED. The cost difference in electricity, as Bill has illustrated, is trivial - less than the cost difference of a single fixture for his shop. Why on earth would anyone who can perform simple arithmetic would support such policies is beyond me.

Re: shop light converson question Rant

#9

Re: 100% agree

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

If the cost savings is so great, let the free market prevail. For those applications where the light is on a great deal of the time it might (Note I said might) save the consumer money. In those cases it won't take long for those people to purchase the bulbs. However I have MANY applications where the light is on maybe 1/2 hour a year (storage areas, closets etc.), normally I used 100 or 150 watt incandescent bulbs that cost $.50 or less - now I have to purchase a $9 to $15 Chinese built fluorescent bulb. IMHO many of the lumen ratings are completely false - at least to my eye. I have tried replacing some 100 watt with "comparable" lumen fluorescent bulbs, finding there was inadequate lighting. I guess their ratings compare to my 3 1/2 HP router and my 7 hp compressor. I would guess there were several politicians who received large contributions to their funds or great vacations to advance this cause.

Re: shop light converson question Rant

#10

Re: TN economics not so favorable; light economics

gary camp Bend, Oregon

In my case, at work I went from 90 watts per fixture to 18w on about 200 fixtures and went from a lamp rated for 750 hrs at about $7.00 to CFL's rated at about 10,000 hrs at a cost of about $2.00 ea. (two per fixture) operating between 1,500 and 2,500 hrs per year. That said, I detest the consumer grade "spring shaped" lamps with the built in ballast. They cost a lot more, don't last anywhere near the rated life and you have to throw away (or recycle) the lamp and ballast. The commercial grade fixtures I used at work have a separate ballast that should last about 50,000 hours. I do switch from t-12's to t-8's when I need to change bad ballasts, althought the last time I bought t-12's they were significantly more expensive than t-8's. I am not much of a fan of being told I have to do it though.

glc

Re: shop light converson question Rant

#11

Chuck Jones - West TN

Maybe I misread something, but

Chuck Jones - West TN

I'm pretty sure I recently saw an article on the AP wire stating that the whole government driven plan had been put on hold.

Politics aside (and that's where I normally put politics) less than a year ago I replaced metal halide lights in my shop with T5's. I'm happier than a pig in the mud. I have 12' ceilings with 8 T5 four-tube fixtures mounted near the ceiling and the most I usually have on is 6. It is like daylight, figuratively and literally. The light is rated 5100 kelvin. I didn't do it because of the gummit. I did it because I despised the metal halide lights.