TN economics not so favorable; light economics
Bill Tindall
Situation( my shop is extravagantly illuminated with the bench area 200 ft candles)
24 lamps, operating 2 hours per day 365 days per year. T12's are Phillips #818282 40 watt with output of 3300 lumens
Alternative GE T8 32 watt #4788371 with output of 2800 lumens.
My cost to operate the T12's at my current rate of $0.095 per KWH is $67/year.
The T8 would cost $62/year for equivalent light intensity.
The electricity savings from a switch to T8 would be $5 per year.
I can move these numbers around +/-$5 depending on the details of exactly what lamps I am comparing. Some T12 lamps produce more light, others less, ditto for the T8's. But in any case there is no economic reason for me to retire T12 fixtures. Indeed, it is only because of the unfavorable economics that the government required the switch.
The situation is in fact even less favorable. I have to heat my shop in the winter months. I use electric heat. Hence, it costs me nothing to illuminate the shop in the winter for I am just trading 100% efficient heat from lights for heat from the heat pump.