Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Which Router???

Posts

Which Router???

#1

Which Router???

Dale Penkala

Hello Everyone!

Well I'm looking for all you guys that are more experienced in routers. I'm building a router table/cabinet for my shop basicaly to replace the Craftsman setup that I have. (1 3/4hp) The Craftsman has done a good job but I'm getting into some more things that I need more accuracy and control not to mention the bits that I would like to run are 1/2 shank. I've pretty much narrowed down the routers to 2 models.

The first one is the Dewalt DW618 2-1/4hp 12amps $154 @ online Home Depot.

The second one is the Bosch MR23 EVSK 2.3hp 15amps. $229 @ Menards

Honestly I really like Dewalt as have 2 other machines that are Dewalt, But I'm leaning towards the Bosch because I'm thinking that it will have more "guts" so to speak because of the 15amp rating.

Either one of these will do better than what I have now. Both should pretty much do everything I would want to do at this point and more with the added power.

Any thoughts as to which one of these you would go with??? Just another note, The base means nothing to me in fact I'd probably try to sell the base. I have 3 other routers with bases.

Thanks in advance!

Dale

Mid-Michigan

Re: Which Router???

#2

Re: Which Router???

Dave Paine

I have used Bosch routers for many years. I have a 1613 hand held and I installed a 1617 in a table.

The 1617 may "only" be 12 amps but it has been able to perform with whatever operation I wanted. I think this has been in router table service for over 6 years.

I do consider the volume of a cut and am happy to make several passes, altering the fence with each pass. This will assist in the smoothness of the final pass.

The MR23 looks like a nice machine. I think the 1617 at less money will do you good service in a table. The base mounted switch is not adding any functionality in a table mounted unit.

Consider a router lift to allow easy and repeatable height adjustments from the top of the table. Some routers have then built-in via a large allen key via the base.

Re: Which Router???

#3

Re: Which Router???

Jason Waters

I have a Hitachi M12, about 12 years old. I love it. I used it in a basic table I made with a homemade adjustment knob under the table until I bought a Jessem Lift.

I have used a Bosch router, it was fine. My DeWalt Plunge (like 2 hp) is the best plunge handheld I have ever used.

That being said, why not get a 3+ Hp for raised panels?

Re: Which Router???

#4

Re: Which Router???

Daale

Thanks for the input Dave!

Re: Which Router???

#5

Re: Which Router???

Daale

Hello Jason

Thanks for the input! Budget really. I'm trying to put more cash towards a good lift & fence. I have looked at the Hitachi models as well, but don't really no much about them.

Thanks!

Dale

Re: Which Router???

#6

Re: Which Router???

del schisler

go to this web site for all router stuff. I have been around routers for 30 yrs or so. This web site is the best and has the most info on routers and bit's ect. I have been a member for 7 yrs or so nice people and info.

http://www.routerforums.com/

Re: Which Router???

#7

Re: Which Router???

del schisler

Deside on what you will be doing ? And the bits you will be using. I have a couple PC 690's and bosch 1617 in my router work shop table and a couple ryobi's which are mounted in their own table for my dovetales and pin's so i don't have to change back and forth. Any of those you mention will do a good job. I belive the HD are closing out the bosch 1617's at $129.00 and maybe less ? You mite check it out. That is a good buy if you can get at that price.

Re: Which Router???

#8

Bart Goldberg

Re: Which Router???

Bart Goldberg

I think both routers would serve you well. Both Dewalt and Bosch make great routers. I would however, suggest that you get a 3hp router for dedicated table use. You don't need a lot of fancy features for a table mounter router, but variable speed is a must since you will be using various sized router bits. As was suggested, a router lift is also something to consider. You can always add one later. FYI - I purchased a Freud 3HP router many years ago for dedicated table use for just over a $100.00 and has worked well for me.

Regards

Bart

Re: Which Router???

#9

Re: Which Router???

Dale

Thanks Del will do when I get home from work!

Re: Which Router???

#10

Re: Which Router???

Dale Penkala

Hello Bart

Thanks for the input! I'm definetly planing on getting a good lift & fence! If I could get me a good 3hp unit for $200 - $225 I'd definatly consider it, but I've not seen anything for under 299.00.

Re: Which Router???

#11

Re: Which Router???

Earl

Dale I have the 618 just luv it. BUT with lite use the motor did not last very long. I think it was about 2 years (lite use). I did have it rebuilt and am still using it and luv all the adjustments and the power. I have seen on different forums where the motor still seems to be a problem. I am going to run until it quits again but if I am not satisfied with how long it lasts I will be done with it. I only use it for hand held work.

Earl

Re: Which Router???

#12

Re: Which Router???

Larry in NW Ohio

Dale, I see no one has said anything about the Milwaukee, I have 2-3 1/2hp and a 1 1/2hp and love all of them. I also have Porter cable and hate it, I rattles something fearce and is just plan bad. The Milwaukees run so smooth if routers weren`t so noisey in the first place you would not know it was running. I know someone is going to come along and want to cram their Milwaukee someplace where the sun never shines, but I like them. Larry

Re: Which Router???

#13

Re: Which Router???

Dale Penkala

Thank you for the info Earl!

Much appreciated!

Dale

Re: Which Router???

#14

Re: Which Router???

Dale Penkala

Thanks Larry! I'm glad you mentioned them. I had looked at them but really never considered it. Most of the routers I seem to have heard most of is the Dewalts, Bosch, Porter Cable & I see some Hitatchis occasionally. Glad to here they're a quality router!

Thanks!

Dale

Re: Which Router???

#15

Re: Which Router???

Jason Waters

The Hitachi I previously mentioned is about the price range you talked about. I used mine for several years without a lift, with a homemade crank knob under the table.

$201

http://www.amazon.com/gp/offer-listing/B004BG2JJO/ref=sr_1_1_olp?ie=UTF8&qid=1328150621&sr=8-1&condition=new

Amazon has good prices on all the big boys too. You can buy a crank knob for like $30 with a star wheel, but I made mine with a metric coupling nut, a piece of pipe or conduit, a piece of wood for the crank, and a spinner handle, and it's nicer.

I really think you will be more pleased with a 3+ hp router for raising panels and such. It's more important to buy the better router I think than the lift, but it would be best if you did both at once (you wouldn't have to buy or make some interim thing) as you wouldn't have to come up with an interim table.

Of course, I build my first table out of a scrap of melamine coated particle board, and 2x4's, and it didn't have inserts or a drop in plate to start. I used it like that for a year or so! Until I was working outside, and the bottom dropped out of the sky, and when I got everything in, it was too late.......the top bubbled up around the edges. That was when I only had the PC 690 kit.

I always wanted the Porter Cable big boy, but bought the Hitachi when it hit $179 in year 2000!!!! (it was still in the Amazon purchase list, and PC's were over $300 back then). Mine is the older one, so don't know if the new one is as good, but been plenty pleased.

Also, consider a recon (though not all of these are recon, some are new) from CPO:

http://www.cpohitachitools.com/hitachi-routers/hitachi-routers,default,sc.html

http://www.cpotools.com/bosch-routers/bosch-routers,default,sc.html

http://www.cpoworkshop.com/porter-cable-routers/porter-cable-routers,default,sc.html

http://www.cpopowertools.com/dewalt-routers/dewalt-routers,default,sc.html

OK, you get the picture. But it looks like little savings, except some of the palm routers look attractive from there.

I've bought a number of recons over the years (from CPO and elsewhere) and been happy. Have you tried craigslist for a used one??

Re: Which Router???

#16

I'll Seciond The Milwaukee's

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

I have a 2HP older Milwaukee, a new style 2 3/4 HP and a new style 3 1/2, the later in my router table. The two new style routers are great. They are smooth, powerful and a joy to use. For comparison, I also have a Makita, a Bosch and a 3 1/2 HP Porter Cable.

One reason I would recommend the Milwaukee's is that they come with bases that have lift style adjustments in them - you don't really need a lift. If I didn't already have a lift waiting, I would have just used the fixed base that came with the 3 1/2 HP unit. It even comes with a wrench that you can use above the table to set the height.

With the money you save on the lift, you can get a good 3 1/2 HP unit. One thing I was really happy with is the speed control. It automatically adjusts to the load and tries to keep the speed where you set it. Good collets and they come with centering devices to center the bottom plates on the base.

Re: Which Router???

#17

Re: Which Router???

Dale Penkala

Hello Jason

Thanks for all the info! Yes I have tryed Craigslist and haven't found anything of high quality there.

I'm going to try to do a good quality lift and router at the same time I've been looking on the used market but so far haven't been very successful.

Thanks!

Dale

Mid-Michigan

Re: Which Router???

#18

Re: I'll Seciond The Milwaukee's

Dale Penkala

Thanks for the input Robby!

I'm really planning on a good quality lift. I'm a tool and die maker and I guess I just have precision in my blood. I like control of adjustments that I make right down to the .001" in woodworking believe it or not.

I work in sub-microns at work so like I said its just habit for me.

I'm glad you commented about the milwaukee's though! I haven't heard much about them so I haven't even considered them.

Thanks!

Dale

Mid-Michigan

Re: Which Router???

#19

Re: I'll Seciond The Milwaukee's

Larry in NW Ohio

Dale I don`t understand why more people don`t get Milwaukee tools, even though they are owned by someone else now. The quality went down a little when that happened, but IMHO they are still the best in their price range. With all due respect to the Colonel, he has a high opinion of Porte cable, but IMO they went down when Black and Decker bought them, I really hated that. I hope I have it right. Larry

Re: Which Router???

#20

Re: I'll Seciond The Milwaukee's

Dale Penkala

I didn't know that Dewalt was owned by Black & Decker either. I just learned that one on a different forum.

Thanks for the input!

Dale

Re: Which Router???

#21

Re: I'll Seciond The Milwaukee's

Jason Waters

If the Milwaukee has the built in lift like has been stated, that's really not a bad option.

I have never used a Milwaukee router or their cordless tools, but generally regard their tools as good.

Drill, Sawzall, angle grinder, they are the best, and I own those, all older Made in USA ones too.

I used one of their circular saws, and it was one with the foot that went straight up and down, instead of pivoting, and I didn't like that. I think they got rid of that model for that. Otherwise, a fine saw.