Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

circles with the bandsaw

Posts

circles with the bandsaw

#1

circles with the bandsaw

Adrian

I tried to cut circles on my band saw using a crude circle cutting setup. I tapped a short nail into a scrap and positioned the nail about 3 inches to the right of the blade. I fit a 6.5" square into the nail slightly off center so the edge of the scrap was right up against the blade. Blade is 1/2" which is supposed to be able to cut a 3" radius circle.

When I fire up the saw and start cutting, I systematically found that the cut would tend to spiral in, forming a spiral. When I got around back to the beginning and the "circle" could release I would see the bandsaw blade spring back to the left. I tried various things like positioning the nail in line with the gullets either along the direction perpendicular to my saw's lead line or just perpendicular to the blade. (The lead is about 3/8".) And the best I got was a circle where I only spiraled in 1/8" when I got all the way around. Again the blade was pulled off center by 1/8" by the jig setup.

What is the explanation for this spiraling behavior? How can I get an actual circle?

Re: circles with the bandsaw

#2

Re: circles with the bandsaw

Larry in NW Ohio

Adrian I think the main thing is to have the blade guides and your blade backup bearing just about against the blade, about a paper thickness away. Also the pivot of the circle has to be right in line with the front edge og your blade, not a little in front nor not a little in the back. These are the main problems I found out that can really mess it up. Just a few days ago we had a post on circle cutting and I posted that there is a circle cutting attachment you can make, I think it is in the new issue of Woodworkers Journal if you have it or may be able to find it.. If not let me know and I maybe able to send it to you. Good luck. Larry

Re: circles with the bandsaw

#3

Re: circles with the bandsaw

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

Spirals are a sign that your pivot is too far in front of or behind the cutting point of the teeth. Ideally the pivot should be exactly in line with the tips of the teeth; however, you may need to adjust this one way or the other to get a perfect cut due to the actual tracking of the blade due to tooth set or wear. I would also suggest a thinner blade. a 3" radius is pretty tight for a 1/2" blade. You may also want to round over the back edge of the blade with a hard sharpening stone so it can turn more easily.

Lee

Re: circles with the bandsaw

#4

Re: circles with the bandsaw

Clementine

I started a post on this a couple of weeks ago. Got some good advice. Also looked at some videos on YouTube. I chose to try my luck with a bandsaw. I thought the table saw required a death wish and the router required a jig that I didn't want to buy for just a few circles. Attach a slide in the miter channel to a piece of plywood, then cut about one-half the way across the plywood. Clamp the plywood tight to the bandsaw table and then mark a 90 degree line using the cut in the plywood and the tip of the blade. I marked one inch increments down the line and drilled a 1/4" hole at each inch. I used a 1/4" dowel for the pivot. An adjustable pivot would be very much better, but I was only experimenting. I used this jig to cut a 16" round top for a Craftsman tambouret. As the others have said, the tip of the blade is the critical element. Get off on that and you'll have an interesting design, but you won't have a circle. BTW, the journal article mentioned is American Woodworker, but they'll take points off your score if you mention that publication around here.

Re: circles with the bandsaw

#5

Re: circles with the bandsaw

Adrian

So to address the point about 3" being too tight, it's towards the small size, but it should be OK. The books claim a 2.5 inch radius can be cut with a 1/2" blade and when the cut starts, the cut proceeds smoothly, without binding in the kerf. It does sometimes bog down and start burning as it gets half way around, but I think having the blade deflected 1/4 inch to the right is going to create a lot of friction even if I cut straight! My actual intention is to get a 5" radius circle, but I was testing smaller so I could use smaller test pieces. Since I've wasted 8 so far I think this was a wise choice.

If the problem is due to the alignment of the pin...then I know exactly where it is supposed to be. I tried aligning the pin to be right at the teeth tip or right at the gullet base relative to the lead line for the saw. In other words, I have the lead line drawn on the table and I set a square on that line and lined it up on the pin and blade. I also tried lining the pin straight out perpendicular to the blade. Nothing seemed to work. How precise does this alignment need to be for this to work? And which alignment method is in fact the right one?

If setup is this finicky for this type of jig then it doesn't seem very practical.

Re: circles with the bandsaw

#6

Re: circles with the bandsaw

Adrian

Some contemplation indicates that if the pin is placed too far back then the workpiece will rotate in a direction that pushes the blade left. Similarly if the pin is too far forward than the workpiece will rotate in such a way as to push the blade to the right. A quick test on the saw confirms that this indeed happens: I can see the blade being bent in the predicted direction. I suppose this supplies guidance for adjusting the setup. But I'd rather not have to cut 3 circle test pieces before I can cut the actual circle I want. It seems like the correct position for the pin is on a line perpendicular to the lead line. But what part of the blade should it line up with?

Note that if the pin needs to be on a line perpendicular to the lead line then it's not clear how a device that makes use of the miter slot can work properly, unless it has a swivel adjustment built in somehow. (I've never seen anybody propose a design like that.) The only design I've seen for a circle cutter that accounts for blade lead is a T-shaped design that you can clamp on the saw at an angle.

Re: circles with the bandsaw

#7

Re: circles with the bandsaw

Ken Krawford

I had exactly the same problem a couple of weeks ago. In my case, the problem was a dull blade. I put on a new blade and the circles cut perfectly.

Re: circles with the bandsaw

#8

Re: circles with the bandsaw

Adrian

It looks like the problem was saw setup after all.

I was getting ready to do more test cuts when I noticed that the guide assembly was shifting on the shaft. I tightened it up and tried again and the behavior was much better. The blade no longer deflects to the side. Instead the saw jams up and the wood starts burning. :) That's what happens when the pivot point is misplaced.

I tried placing the pivot point in line with the teeth tips and also in line with the gullets (relative to the saws lead line) and it seemed like in line with the gullets worked a bit better than in line with the teeth.

Now I just need to figure out how to secure my board with a nail through it to the saw without getting in the way of the ten inch circle I want to cut. I realized that the simple clamp isn't going to do it. Or maybe I have to make a real jig.

Re: circles with the bandsaw

#9

Re: circles with the bandsaw

Larry in NW Ohio

Adrian I`m happy to hear that your coming along with your circles. Now to clamp your circle table jig could be clamped down by making it longer and going passed the blade to the other side of the BS table and clamping it there out of the way of the circle you are cutting. That should do it. If not or if you have any more questions just ring the WC number. Good Luck. Larry

Re: circles with the bandsaw

#10

Re: circles with the bandsaw

Adrian

Your suggestion was helpful because I was trying to think of a way to secure the jig staying on the right side of the blade, so it helped me think in a different direction. I cut a notch for the blade out of a larger scrap of plywood and set a nail in place and got a decent 9.75" diameter circle.

Re: circles with the bandsaw

#11

Re: circles with the bandsaw

Larry in NW Ohio

I`m glad you replied and let us know that the circle cutting is coming along better. If for some reason the bandsaw doesn`t work good enough for what you want to use them for and you have a belt sander, then make a simular jig for your sander. Use a board and attach it to the table and put the center pin at the distance where you need it and sand away, of if you only have a hand belt sander you`ll need to fasten it down to a table and do it a little different. Good Luck. Larry

Re: circles with the bandsaw

#12

Re: circles with the bandsaw

Adrian

No belt sander here. In fact, I don't have any sanders at all. I cleaned up my circle with a spokeshave and I'm happy with the result.

I did borrow a buddy's oscillating spindle sander at one point and it didn't inspire me to want to get more into sanding or buy one of my own.