Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Incra Miter gauges

Posts

Incra Miter gauges

#1

Incra Miter gauges

Bill P.

I'm looking at the Incra 3000se and the 5000 miter gauges. I'm not sure if one would be better than the other. Has anyone bought the 3000 and later wish they would have gotten the 5000 or vice versa. I'll be "gauging" (sorry) your responces closely.

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#2

Re: Incra Miter gauges

Jason Waters

Bill,

What are you going to be doing?

I have an Incra 3000, and it's fine for what I do. I've got a short and long fence for it, with the stop system. I've never done anything tougher than an octagon shape. I also have the Cheaper Incra miter guage only (V27 maybe) that I use too when I need something a little more than the Delta, and I don't want to remove the fence off the 3000. I bought mine mostly for the fence system, which I love.

It looks like the Incra 5000 adds a sled to the 3000 system, with the same precision. I guess it depends.

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#3

Re: Incra Miter gauges

Archie

I've got the 3000 and really like it, and I have no reason to buy a more complicated or sophisticated jig. But that's largely the result of doing more handtool work as opposed to powered...

For accuracy, though, I like the Incra!

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#4

Re: Incra Miter gauges

John M in Mid Mich

Bill: I bought the 5000 several years ago and love it. The ease of exact repeatability was a revelation that continues. There is just one caution, however: it is big, and it is awkward to put on and off the saw. I would never give it up, but as a matter of fact, I just recently added a 1000HD for the tasks that don't need or benefit from the sled. I have not used their Miter Express, but it looks like a slick solution to my problem: a sled that you can easily dock the gauge to. And I think it is smaller than the 5000.

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#5

Re: Incra Miter gauges

Grant Wilkinson

I was looking at the 5000, but after talking with Incra, went with the 3000SE and the Express. With this setup, I get the benefits of the sled like the 5000, but I can take the 3000 off the sled and use it on another saw, router table, etc.

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#6

Re: I guess that I don't get it

Charlie Lenz

I use my table saw mostly for ripping. If I have a board thats too wide for the miter saw I might use a sled on the table saw, or a straight edge and a circular saw, depends on how long and awkward the board is. The Incra's look nice, but thats not reason enough for me to buy one, or any other fancy looking miter gauge. They just aren't practical in my shop, I get better results with a miter saw.

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#7

Re: Incra Miter gauges

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I was fortunate in that I ran into a "deal" at the Indianapolis WW show a few years ago and purchased the 5000 for about the same price as the 3000 normal price. I really like the fact I can use it quickly then remove it to do other work on my Unisaw. The settings remain accurate and the sled quickly locks into the miter slot. I don't use it a lot but it is very accurate when needed. I can't compare it to the 3000 since I went directly to this unit. I have found though, that when I have tried to save a few bucks by not buying the top of the line, I always kind of regret it and wonder "what if I had the better unit". I have never regretted holding out and buying the best. When you figure out the cost divided out during the time you will be using the tool - normally it adds up to less than the cost of your coffee or cola.

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#8

Re: I guess that I don't get it

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Charlie, I guess it depends on your methods of work. I have used my Incra for cutting the shoulders on tenons - my CMS won't do that, and the Incra is repeatable to within .005" - could do the straight pieces using my sled and a stop block, but the Incra is much faster and easier to set up and will do longer pieces than my sled - also you can do accurate angled cuts very quickly and I do get less tearout on my table saw using my WW2 than I get on my CMS (with a Forest 12" blade).

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#9

Different suggestion

Bill Tindall

I think the Accu-miter from JDS company. It is robust, can be set and holds a setting to great accuracy and it is especially handy for repetitive cuts to length.

That said, once I built a sled for my table saw I use this miter much less for precise cross cuts.

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#10

Re: I guess that I don't get it

Grant Wilkinson

I think it's just a matter of what we are doing with our saws. I do picture framing and I've found that I can get more accurate repeatable angles with the Incra on my table saw than I could with my mitre saw. I've found the same thing doing small segments for segmented vessels. When the segments are only 1/4" x 1/2" x 1", they were flying off the mitre saw, never to be seen again. With a 7 1/2" blade on my table saw and the Incra 3000SE/Express combo, they are cut accurately and fall easily to the side of the sled.

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#11

Re: Different suggestion

Larry in nw ohio

I have the 3000 I bought a few years ago it worked very well, but I just do not use it as much as I thought. If you would be interested I`d sell it. You can email me if youd like Larry

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#12

Re: Well I know one thing...

Charlie Lenz

On the jobsites of new home construction, you don't see finish carpenters useing the table saw for miter cuts. I also noticed that Larry had to mention that he owns a Unisaw, as a hobbyist I don't need a stationary industrial table saw in my shop. If I was rich I supose I could afford all sorts of toys to brag about, but unfortunatly I'm not, so I have to live with what gets the job done the best at a reasonable price. I may not have alot, but I'm proud of what I do have. If you table saw produces better miters then your miter saw, then maybe it's time for a different miter saw.

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#13

Re: Well I know one thing...

Grant Wilkinson

Charlie: You seem to have taken offense to what I said. Looking back on my post, I don't see what I said to offend you or anyone else. My miter saw works well for what it's made for, thank you. I don't need a new or better one. I don't go out on job sites, either. So, it's like I said. I guess the best saw for our purposes depends on our purposes. I cut very small segments for bowls. Doing that on a miter saw - no matter how good the saw - has the small pieces flying all over the place. With a small blade on a table saw and a sled, I don't have that problem.

I did not brag about having anything. I worked hard, too, for what I do have. I'm a hobbyist and I use a contractor's style table saw a lot. That's not a brag. I use my miter saw a lot, too. That's not a brag, either.

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#14

Re: Grant

Charlie Lenz

I wasn't pointing a finger at you, unless your name is Larry. But if your haveing a problem with loseing small pieces of wood while useing a miter saw, a backer board should solve that problem.

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#15

Re: Well I know one thing...

John M in Mid Mich

If we equate the quality of what I have seen in finish carpentry with furniture making, we're in trouble right off. No doubt there are some good finish carpenters but the majority are just getting the job done.

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#16

Re: Well I know one thing...

Charlie Lenz

I've worked with some good finish carpenters over the years. Here is a recent pic of a handrail done by one. Most of the homes that I've worked in are not just run of the mill homes.


img

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#17

Re: Well I know one thing...

Charlie Lenz

Another picture of some work done in another home, tell me these guys couldn't make furniture if they wanted.


img

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#18

Re: Well I know one thing...

John M in Mid Mich

Great looking stuff, but would it prove anything if I posted pictures of crappy finish carpentry?

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#19

Re: John, the funny thing is ...

Charlie Lenz

that the finish carpenter is only supplied with a $250 - $300 Craftsman 10" benchtop table saw, and a Craftsman miter saw that are supplied by his boss. One day I seen the guy take a slice off the wide side of a 4 ft long 2" X 4" that you couldn't of done better with a bandsaw. It's not allways about what you have for tools, but what you can do with what you have.

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#20

Re: I guess that I don't get it

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Charlie - I sure didn't think I was bragging, I was merely trying to describe the tools I use - my CMS is a DeWalt 705, not one of the best but a decent saw. I really didn't think having a Unisaw was a great accomplishment. I know many that have the same saw or more expensive General or Powermatic. I saved for about a year to purchase mine a few years ago. The Incra gage does lock into the Unisaw slot well and the 10" blade runs smoother than my 12" CMS - that's why I described the saws. Sorry if I ruffled your feathers - you must have a pretty thin skin!

Re: Incra Miter gauges

#21

Re: Yeah, it's my fault like allways. Thanks