Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

plane geometry question

Posts

plane geometry question

#1

plane geometry question

Jerry Gibbs

can I layout a circle into thirds (120 deg) with just a compass?

Re: plane geometry question

#2

Used like a divider ??...probably


Re: plane geometry question

#3

Re: plane geometry question

John in NM

Not as far as I know, trisecting with just a compass is pretty well impossible except by iterative guesstimating.

Why not use a protractor?

Re: plane geometry question

#4

yes

Bill Tindall

If I recall correctly the way to inscribe a hexagon inside a circle is to walk off the radius of the circle around the circumference with the compass. This operation would divide the circle, 360 degrees, into 6 equal parts of 60 degrees each.

Re: plane geometry question

#5

Re: plane geometry question

Barry Irby

I think Bill Almost answered your question or maybe I miss understood it.

Draw a circle with a compass. Without changing the setting, sett eh point on the circle and make a tick mar on the circle in each direction. Put he point in the ticks and step again, and again. You will divide the circle into six equal parts. Choosing alternate tick marks will give you thirds. If you draw a radius for the center to every other mark, you will have thirds in that sense also. if you connect the alternating ticks, you will have an equilateral triangle and if you do both sets, you will have a star of David. If you connect each to the next one you will get a hexagon.

Re: plane geometry question

#6

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: plane geometry question

#7

Try it and see

Bob Lang

The circumference is along the arc, using the compass set to the radius bridges the arc, a shorter distance, going as the crow flies if you will. Stepping off as mentioned will work.

Bob Lang

Re: plane geometry question

#8

Except...

John in NM

The error will be proportional to the radius - bigger circle, bigger error - because as the radius increases the length of arc becomes closer to the chord length between the two points defining the arc.

Good enough for eyeballing? Certainly. True trisection? No, I wouldn't say so.

Re: plane geometry question

#9

Re: Almost, but not quite!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The divider method makes six chords (straight lines from one point on the circumference of the circle to another). It also makes six equilateral triangles, with two radii the center of the circle and one chord, all the same length. Since:

1. The interior (inside) angles at the corners of any polygon add up to ([number of sides on the polygon]-2) times 180 degrees. Triangles having three sides, the total of the angles is 1 times 180 degrees, or 180 degrees, and

2. The interior angles at the corners of an equilateral triangle are each the same, or 1/3 of 180 degrees, or 60 degrees, and

3. 60 degrees is 1/6th of the 360 degrees in a circle,

The divider method, done accurately, will divide a circle evenly into sixths; and marking from alternate points on these sixths, as Barry suggests, will give you a circle divided into thirds.

Bill, NOT a mathematician, but my junior high math teacher would have been proud of me just now.

I just think it's cool that the math works out this way. I have yet to understand how to divide a circle into fifths, though.

Re: plane geometry question

#10

Joe Bradshaw

Re: Almost, but not quite!

Joe Bradshaw

You don't have to mark the circle into six parts. Set the point of your compass on the circle and swing it both ways. You will have two tic marks. Draw a line from each tic mark through the center point and you will have divided the circle into thirds.

Re: plane geometry question

#11

Thank you sir!

Bob Lang

I knew the math was in there somewhere, and I know that the method works. My junior high math teacher wouldn't be so proud, he'd be saying "I told that kid this stuff would be important some day"

Bob Lang

Re: plane geometry question

#12

Re: Almost, but not quite!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've always (well, as long as I've known you) thought that you were probably very good at what you DID do for a living, but I think you missed a bet when you didn't become a teacher, Bill.

Re: plane geometry question

#13

I did and it does

Lee Schierer McKean, PA


As you can see from the Autocad drawing above using the radius to swing arcs starting anywhere on the circle will divide the circle into six parts. You can select three to get the 120 degrees desired.

Lee

Re: plane geometry question

#14

thanks all


Re: plane geometry question

#15

Bill:  To divide a circle into fifths:

PaulSV

A little research discloses that you can, apparently, divide a circle into 5 equal segments, using just a compass and a straight edge:

1. Draw a circle, with the center point being labeled O.

2. Draw a straight line horizontally through the center of the circle. Label the points where this diameter intersects the circle X and Y. (You now have a circle with a diameter drawn from X to Y, intersecting the center of the circle, which is O.)

3. Draw a line perpendicular to the X-Y diameter from O, and label the point where it intersects the circumference of the circle as Z. (You now have a circle that is divided in half horizontally by diameter X-Y, and the top half of the circle is divided in half by radius O-Z, which is perpendicular to diameter X-Y.)

4. Bisect line X-O. Label that point A.

5. Set your compass to the distance between points A and Z, and with the point of the compass on point A, strike an arc which intersects the diameter X-Y. Label the intersection point B.

6. The distance between points Z and B is the length of the cord that will divide the circle into 5 points.

Re: plane geometry question

#16

That Is Exactly How I Designed My Family


Re: plane geometry question

#17

Are you saying...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

...you applied the principle of divide and multiply?

Re: plane geometry question

#18

Well explained Bill...

John in NM

I now see my mistake, I reversed the chord and arc :D

Re: plane geometry question

#19

Another way to do it

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Swinging arcs whose radius is equal to the radius of the circle replicates the arc the dividers will go through as you step off the sixths of the circle.

Re: plane geometry question

#20

Re: Almost, but not quite!

eliotandmax

Well, I AM a mathematician, and the compass method will definitely work EXACTLY -- not approximately -- right( assuming only that you can accurately place the point of the compass at the mark). Just use the radius, move it around six times, and choose every other point. Using a protractor is the way to get only an approximate angle depending on how well the protractor is made and how well you can see and make marks, etc.

Re: plane geometry question

#21

I stand corrected

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

I stand corrected- didn't understand the question when he said "lay out". My slow brain visualized a laying out a string equal to the circumference and attempting to divide it using dividers set to the radius.

Chords drawn with a radius will indeed create 6 equilateral triangles and divide a circle into six arc segments and six wedges.