Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

Posts

On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#1

On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

Bill Tindall

In the recent Popular Woodworking the editor made his case for project cut lists. While cuts lists can be advantageous for some kinds of projects they are not the approach I take when precision is required. Well into my woodworking experience I was shown another way, described below, which delivers the precision necessary for fine furniture joinery and it reduces errors.

Let us take the case of building a chest of drawers. I certainly don't disagree with the editor that planning is important. I fix the design and joinery with a scale drawing of the project. From this information I know the size cuttings I need to make the panels for the top, bottom and sides. I select this lumber from the lumber stash and proceed to assemble the case. If the case winds up slightly different dimensions than designed it is immaterial.

Here is where I differ from the cut list approach. Where ever possible I transcribe measurements off the case to the pieces to be cut with a marking knife. For example, the rough cut pieces for drawer blades will be held to the case and the cut length scribed onto the piece to be cut. Ditto for drawer parts and molding pieces. Where ever possible I avoid using a ruler to make and transfer measurements which reduces the possibility of measuring as well as transcribing errors.

A real life example of the efficacy of this approach was demonstrated by a good friend who is an exceptionally talented and experienced woodworker. Never-the-less he transcribed a ruler measurement and made drawers 1” too long for the case. Fortunately the error was caught in the dry fit stage and corrected with some inconvenience. Had the rough cut drawer side been held to the case and an appropriate length marked the drawer side would have been correct with no possibility for error. I will not spend the next several pages describing my similar screw ups before I adapted this more reliable method of cutting to fit.

For best precision I found that cutting alone didn’t deliver the precision needed for fine furniture. For the most precise fits the pieces are cut slightly larger and planed to fit . Planing enables one to shave off thousandths of an inch increments to achieve a perfect fit.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#2

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measureme

Carol Reed

Oh, amen, Brother Bill, AMEN!

When I was teaching, I always one or two who wanted to get a jump start and would cut all their wood acording to a cut list, and then wind up buying more wood and recutting later on. The downside was, I had already taught them how to choose wood for color and grain. The hodgepodge of wood their project wound up with always diminished the end result.

Best advice I ever got was 'let the project measure itself.' Cut lists are good for estimating the amount of wood to purchase - plus the waste factor which incrementally rose with the lack of experience. All that is needed is the intended height, width, and depth. The rest works itself out.

I work as you do. Thanks for your perspective.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#3

I will 3rd that  make it your way and it fits


Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#4

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measureme

Barry Irby

Apparently I use cut lists differently. I only use them for hacking the rough lumber to length initially for the stock prep phase. Where possible, I like to leave the pieces several inches too long to allow for snip and other such disagreeable events when dressing the lumber. I don't trim off the ragged Split, Chainsawed ends at first, I let them be the cushion for the snipe. I use the list to economically cut between the knots or other defects. When the lumber is flat and straight, I leave the pieces double or triple length, again to minimize the impact of snipe. (I just realized I spend a lot of effort avoiding snipe, there must be a snipe monster hiding in my shop.) I have a stash of cherry and walnut and poplar. I wish I had painted the ends of the logs with different colors indicating which tree they came out of. It would make grain and color matching easier, but its not much of a problem and I usually dress out enough stock to give me a good selection to choose from.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#5

...and story sticks

Alex Grigoriev

I mark the sizes from ruler to a story stick with a knife, and then use the stick and a knife to transfer it to the boards. Makes the sizes much more repeatable, than marking multiple times from a ruler.

A 1/4" square poplar rod from big box store makes an excellent cheap story stick. If you're really cheap, you can use its 4 sides for 4 projects.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#6

Re: ...and story sticks

John Pappas

I'm a hugh fan of story sticks. Standard procedure for me. Prevents many of the common mistakes woodworkers make.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#7

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measureme

Carol Reed

I don't cut a piece until I need it. Or if I need matched pairs, then I will cut them together. This whole thing is really a type of woodworking philosophy, isn't it? It is fascinating to learn how others think and do things.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#8

Re: ...and story sticks

Carol Reed

Interesting about story sticks. I have not found a need for them unless I am making built-ins. Tell us more about how YOU use them. This is fun stuff.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#9

I have not used them routinely

Bill Tindall

I see the utility of the stick for doing replicates but I am not understanding their utility for a one of. If I am making 6 of something the same length I set a stop on the saw.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#10

Re: I have not used them routinely

Jesse Cloud

Unfortunately, my shop isn't large enough to host much of a "stash" of lumber, so I use a cut list plus a few key templates when I go to the lumber yard. The templates show the shape of parts that need special grain or figure, say a curve for a chair leg. I find a piece with the appropriate figure, mark it with chalk and consider, from the cut list, how I might use the rest of the board. Without a cut list, I would almost certainly forget to provide for the little, uninteresting pieces and have to come back later to correct that.

I use story sticks to help visualize how a board will look as a leg, apron, etc. In a leg, for instance, I can see where the apron will intersect, where the band will be inset, how the taper will run, where the stringing will begin and end. I spend a lot of time looking at freshly milled stock with a story stick to decide on orientation, e.g., which leg would work best as the right front leg, which face is the show face, and which should point inward.

Bill is absolutely right - story sticks are not saw stops, they serve a much different function.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#11

Re: I have not used them routinely

Carol Reed

Thanks, Jesse. I use cut lists at the lumber yard along with a piece of chalk as well. I used SketchUp as you use the story stick. I have an old laptop in shop for this purpose.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#12

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measureme

Sgian Dubh

Bill, I haven't seen the article you referred to, so I can't comment on that. However, one of the primary purposes of a cutting list is to price work. I'm sure you see the value of this whether you are in business or an amateur. The next function of the cutting list is to guide the initial selection and processing of the primary materials for the job. For example, if you're making a cabinet it helps you get the external dimensions for the basic carcase right, in conjunction with the orthographic projections, which may be supplemented by additional guides, such as rods, or as you Americans seem to call them, story sticks.

Beyond that, I tend to agree with you that measurements taken directly from the main carcase (of the example cabinet above) are far more useful than anything taken from a cutting list, eg, for sizing and fitting drawer parts. Incidentally, rods (story sticks) are a truly efficient way of making sure things are made just as they meant to be made. I don't have time here to go through their use, but I employ them frequently, even for one-offs. Slainte.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#13

Living Under A Rock

David Yoho

Bill, I agree with your assessment of the use of cut lists. Depending on the project, a cut list is all that's needed. However, sooner or later there will be a need to abandon the list and measure as you go for accuracy.

I sometimes feel like I live under a rock when it comes to woodworking. What I mean is that all these years I've been at it I have pretty much been on my own to figure things out. No woodworking club locally, no neighbors or anyone I know close by into WW at my level, and, since I'm a visual type, reading about it only goes so far. The few times I've been able to share some face time with others in the know, I've learned a lot. All this is to say that most of the time many things I read about here or elsewhere that woodworkers find useful, I've figured out on my own one way or another. I guess it's called using common sense.

Years ago I built my first real fine chest of drawers. Even though I was using two different plans to inspire my project, I needed my own plan and cut list. It soon became evident that I could not determine the exact drawer openings to size the drawers on paper. They were inset drawers and I was determined to only have a small gap around the closed drawer. So, I built the case and then measured each opening for each drawer and cut from that. Worked like a charm!

That was a real departure for me after only working from a set plan I'd put on paper. However, I found it easy to get comfortable with this concept and began using it all the time. The result was my accuracy improved greatly. Then I see tips like this somewhere and realize - "Hey, I've been doing that already on my own". All the time I'm thinking I came up with a solution or technique that was simple for me but must not be as technical as the way the "big boys" do it. Turns out I'm usually not that far off from the "big boys" and the so called "isolation" under the rock really causes me to be better at problem solving and independent thinking. It also makes me feel like there are times when all I really did was "reinvent the wheel".

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#14

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measureme

Barry Irby

When I am prepping stock, if my lumber is straight and flat, I plane it in full length pieces. If it is warped and crooked, I cut it down to near the size I need to minimized the curvature and allow for the flattening on the pointer without removing too much material.

Its funny, Not cutting the ragged and split ends off until last was an "insight" for me. My neatness gene was screaming to clean that up and get it out of the shop and out of sight, but it makes more sense to leave it on the piece to absorb the snipe and the dinged corners if they get dropped.

I do have to be careful not to cut the end piece too short and to allow plenty for cutting the cracks and checks off the ends, sometimes they run further than they appear.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#15

All my BEST ideas were stolen by the Ancients...

Barry Irby

I too am self taught and I don't work at your level but there have been times when I had a flash of insight and was sure I had invented something, either a technique or a tool, only to learn somebody was using the idea a thousand years (Or maybe a hundred) ago. Sometimes I feel a little deflated but at other times I feel like I really did invent it because I had no knowledge of the other.

There's a guy in the Turning club that makes hand cut dovetails. He thinks they are easy. The ones I saw were as nearly perfect as any I have ever seen. Jaw dropping for me. I don't do hand cut ones, unless you count the Leigh jig. Something to be learned there. And there is a guy that makes Windsor chairs. Something to be learned there too. you should come to a meeting or two. Maybe we could go visit Charles Neal for a day, if he takes guests. He's in VA.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#16

More on rods/story sticks

Bill Tindall

It would be useful for someone to start a separate thread on story sticks and how they are used. Obviously they are of more utility than I had considered them. The only employment of a story stick I ever saw in an amateur or professional shop was to use them to store a record of basic furniture dimensions to be used some time in the future to replicate a piece of furniture. It is still not clear to me how they are used in the building stage of a "one of a kind" piece of furniture, presuming one is working off a scaled and dimensioned drawing or sketch.

I do see how carrying a stick to the lumber yard could be a useful alternative to a drawing and ruler.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#17

Re: All my BEST ideas were stolen by the Ancients.

David Yoho

I've been to Charles Neil's shop in New Market several times. He's always busy but unless he's fighting a deadline he has always taken time to visit and share his talents. I can probably set something up if you want but it would probably need to be on a Saturday.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#18

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measureme

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

If that Editor knew how I worked he would freak. Some doodles on a sketch pad followed by some hand guestures to visualize size and proportion. A couple of notes for reminders and I'm off to the races.

I rarely precut wood because so often I am assessing boards for color and figure to see how they work in the design. Adnmittedly, sometimes that results in a wasteful cut now and again but if the figure you need is in the middle of a board...so be it!

T.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#19

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measureme

Jesse Cloud

"I rarely precut wood because so often I am assessing boards for color and figure to see how they work in the design. Adnmittedly, sometimes that results in a wasteful cut now and again but if the figure you need is in the middle of a board...so be it! "

Tommy nailed it! The best you can do is to try to find a use for the other ends, and a cutlist can be helpful (lets see, I have 15 inches left, which parts are that short).

The notion that you can just add up the board feet from the cutlist and go to the lumberyard for that many feet is just silly.

And yes, in practice, ignore the precise dimensions on the cutlist and "Cut To Fit". For instance, I'm making a little desk now, with two small drawers in the front apron. I'll cut the nicely figured piece I selected into three strips, cut out the drawer fronts from the middle strip and glue it back together. Hard to predict the exact width and length that will result. But whatever results, I will just use that to determine the length of the back and the width of the other aprons. The exact dimension doesn't really matter, just that the front matches the back, etc.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#20

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measureme

Carol Reed

Now that I don't teach anymore, I work like you, Tommy. I begin with exteror dimensions and work inward or with the dimensions of what is to fit inside and then work outward. Yes, I use SketchUp to get a scale of over all proportions, but it doesn't 'drive' my cutting.

Along with the custom pieces in the shop, I am working on a cabinet to fit under the right end of the tablesaw. That design is driven by the space that is available and by what I want to store in the drawers. It doesn't need to be a work of art but it does need to be functional and of the best craftsmanship I can bring to the project. Shop furniture is the best place to practice fine craftsmanship.

Thus the first thing I do is make a list of necessary information: space available, item storage, portability, etc.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#21

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measureme

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

In thinking about it, I suppose we enjoy the advantage of experience. I can see where some beginners might really need a cutlist for guidance.

I was a rebel from the start. I have never worked from a plan in my life. But that's how I roll. Full disclosure....first few projects were not photo-worthy! ;-)

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#22

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measureme

Carol Reed

I never have used plans either. I may have been inspired by them but always found something lacking in them. And my first projects and a camera thankfully never graced the same space at the same time either. :)

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#23

Re: More on rods/story sticks

Sgian Dubh

Bill, here are nine JPEGs of an article of mine on rods and their use. They may be a little difficult to read because of their resolution and size, but hopefully you can get the general idea. I'd forgotten I'd got these images scanned out of the British magazine Furniture & Cabinetmaking, and digitally saved out there in cyberspace. Slainte.

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#24

Re: I have not used them routinely

Alex Grigoriev

Wish I had a (space for a) table saw.

Re: On cut lists, calculating and making measurements

#25

Thanks

Bill Tindall

It was not difficult to read the text. I have never done built in furniture and cabinetry away from my shop so the use of the rod in this kind of construction was enlightening. I have used a rod/story stick for replicating turnings, for example posts or legs. And I can see that using a rod to transfer measurements from a full sized model would be efficacious. But I don't encounter many people that work off full scale models, the Krenov school being the only place I have ever encountered the practice.

For myself, working off a sketch or scaled drawing, the story stick does not appear to be of any practical use. Or at least no beneficial use has revealed itself other than the historical use as a means of storing measurement for the future.