On cut lists, calculating and making measurements
Bill Tindall
In the recent Popular Woodworking the editor made his case for project cut lists. While cuts lists can be advantageous for some kinds of projects they are not the approach I take when precision is required. Well into my woodworking experience I was shown another way, described below, which delivers the precision necessary for fine furniture joinery and it reduces errors.
Let us take the case of building a chest of drawers. I certainly don't disagree with the editor that planning is important. I fix the design and joinery with a scale drawing of the project. From this information I know the size cuttings I need to make the panels for the top, bottom and sides. I select this lumber from the lumber stash and proceed to assemble the case. If the case winds up slightly different dimensions than designed it is immaterial.
Here is where I differ from the cut list approach. Where ever possible I transcribe measurements off the case to the pieces to be cut with a marking knife. For example, the rough cut pieces for drawer blades will be held to the case and the cut length scribed onto the piece to be cut. Ditto for drawer parts and molding pieces. Where ever possible I avoid using a ruler to make and transfer measurements which reduces the possibility of measuring as well as transcribing errors.
A real life example of the efficacy of this approach was demonstrated by a good friend who is an exceptionally talented and experienced woodworker. Never-the-less he transcribed a ruler measurement and made drawers 1” too long for the case. Fortunately the error was caught in the dry fit stage and corrected with some inconvenience. Had the rough cut drawer side been held to the case and an appropriate length marked the drawer side would have been correct with no possibility for error. I will not spend the next several pages describing my similar screw ups before I adapted this more reliable method of cutting to fit.
For best precision I found that cutting alone didn’t deliver the precision needed for fine furniture. For the most precise fits the pieces are cut slightly larger and planed to fit . Planing enables one to shave off thousandths of an inch increments to achieve a perfect fit.













