Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

Posts

Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#1

Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

Barry Irby

I am building a vanity for the rental house I am working on. I have never used Euro style hinges and thought I might just to learn how. At Lowe's they were about $7 a hinge (I need four), but at Home Depot they (Liberty Brand) were about $7 a pair. Both places and Old style hinges for about $1.20 each.

Interestingly, Lowe's bins were marked as being Blum Brand, but the actual hinges were Richelieu (SP?). I would have been more comfortable buying Blum. Their packaging on the brand X (to Me) hinges was printed in three languages but said nothing. No indication of the bit size, no info on whether they were adjustable.

So the question is, What do I get from using Euro style hinges? Why would I pay $7 a pair (let alone $14 a pair) rather than $2.50?

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#2

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

David Yoho

Most Euro hinges have one nice feature I like - they allow a bit of adjustment in and out, up and down, and left to right. You generally need either a 35mm or 40mm forstner bit for installation.

They're nice when you don't want to see the hinge hardware on the show side. I have several hole drilling jigs that help with placement. Actually, I like them and I generally use Blum brand.

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them????? *LINK*

Moses Yoder

The Blum concealed hinge is nice when you want a concealed hinge. You can now get them with integrated soft close for a variety of applications. With the integrated soft close I think we are paying about $3-$4 per hinge, and if you are really interested in those I could get you some I think. Amazon has the ones without soft close for $1.07 for Blum hinges, about the same as we pay from wholesale distibutors. You should look at the Blum hinge catalog, downloadable from their website, before purchasing. See link below for Blum at Amazon.


Blum at Amazon

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#4

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

Mark Nowicki

Barry, I have been in the rental business for the past 35 years and I have learned that Euro trash hinges and frameless cabinets do not belong in rental units.

There are three grades of construction; residential, commercial, and tenant proof.

Mark

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

Moses Yoder

I don't recall anything being mentioned about frameless cabinetry. And now you are calling the #1 hinge in the cabinet industry a trash hinge, without even the courtesy of offering an alternative. Plus, there is no such thing as a tenant proof cabinet. If there is, please share the construction and finishing details. Patent them first, because you will be making millions off of it.

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#6

I agree

Bill Howatt

I will temper it slightly with the fact the Euro hinges are adjustable so it is possible with very rough treatment to cause the adjustment to slip.

I wouldn't make a kitchen/vanity type cabinet without using Euro style hinges.

Bill

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#7

Re: I agree

Jesse Cloud

Agree with Bill, not putting Euro hinges down, but my philosophy is that anything

that can be adjusted will have to be adjusted sooner or later (or both).

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#8

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

Mark Nowicki

Box made from 5/8" water resistant Baltic birch plywood, screwed and doweled together. All joints and corners caulked.

Face frames at least 7/8' thick screwed to the box with trim screws.

Bathroom vanities raised off the floor.

Doors are flat with small edge treatment, made from ply, painted.

Hinges: the cheapest you can find attached with the longest screws possible.

We keep boxes of those in stock, since they are cheaper to change than to clean.

http://www.leevalley.com/en/hardware/page.aspx?p=52879&cat=3,41241

This is not patented as of yet, so if you feel this will help you make a million bucks, knock yourself out.

You don't have to thank me.

Mark

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#9

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

Bob Lang

I think most woodworkers, especially professional cabinetmakers have been conditioned/convinced that hanging a door on butt hinges is an impossible task.

First of all, you have to make a square opening, then you have to make a square door, just the right size. Then to connect the two, you have to put the hinges in the right position. You'd have to be superman to do something like that. Or a cabinetmaker that knows what he's doing.

Euro hinges make sense in a production situation, where you have the machine to bore and press them in. People make a big deal about the adjustability, then use that as an excuse for sloppy work. If the doors and cabinets aren't the right size and shape to begin with, it won't look good, no matter how much adjustment you have. Despite their widespread use, Euro hinges get sloppy over time and there's a lot of leverage when the door is open that can cause them to fail, especially when people expect a door to open beyond 120 degrees.

Bob Lang

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#10

i don't like them, and why

Bill Tindall

First, I have noticed that Lowes and the like charge much more for cabinet hardware than what I can get it for from cabinet supply shops.

I find opening a door and having that much hardware staring me in the face is offensive. I don't like it on kitchen cabinets and it is vastly more offensive on "furniture" kinds of cabinetry. There is a gallery associated with the tony Grove Park Inn, Asheville, NC and it is not uncommon to see these hinges upon opening furniture doors there. It just looks out of place in an otherwise nice cherry cabinet. I wonder if these makers don't know how to install a butt hinge on a well fit door, or they for some reason choose not to.

In addition to looks, to me it signals that the maker didn't choose to take the time to do a better looking hinge, or was unable.

I would speculate that these things were invented for European style cabinetry, which I don't like the looks of, adding to my prejudice of this hardware. It was discovered that this kind of hinge was easy to install in a mass produced situation so the hardware was adapted to other door styles. The association with mass produced cabinetry furthers my prejudice.

Bottom line... I don't like the looks and I associate them with quality that I try to surpass. None of my discussion is relevant to kitchen cabinets in a rental apartment. But I have been wanting to rail against these things since my last visit to Asheville and this was the opportunity. Oh, and ditto for metal drawer hardware in furniture.

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#12

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

Keith Newton

Barry, I have been using them for over 30 years, and have not had any problems, other than my local distributors keep changing brands, leaving me with a lot of odds and ends, but durability has not been a problem.

I don't think most people even notice the hinge on the back side of the door. It is all so close in the corner in a space space which couldn't be used anyway.

As for why,,,,,,, Back in the mid eighties, I made a set of templates which are the same size as the base and upper cabinet sides, which are drilled with 18mm tapered holes, which I use a plunge router with a 5mm, and 18mm guide bushing,to drill all the hardware holes for hinges, and slides, and shelf adjustment pins.

I can drill 1.5 holes per second, or 90 per minute, then screw on the hardware while the cabinet side is laying on the bench, before I even assemble the box. My back and neck really never liked stooping and reaching back into the depths of a base cabinet, trying to hole my head back to see through my bifocals to hit a screw hole.

By standardizing door sizes, I can drill the holes 2.5" from each end of the doors, which eliminates the need for keeping up with right or left swing doors.

And the list goes on and on. Time is $

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#13

Moses Yoder

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

Moses Yoder

What you are saying is that hanging a door with a Blum cup hinge takes the same amount of time as hanging a door with a morticed butt hinge. I can hang a full inset door with an even 3/32" gap all the way around the opening with Blum cup hinges in about 3 minutes. How long does it take you to hang a door with morticed butt hinges?

Another thing you are saying is that the customer has nothing to do with the choice of hardware, which is also not true. If a gas station down the street sells gass for $3.48 and yours sells gas for $3.50, you are going to be out of business soon. It is the same way in the cabinet industry. Blum warrants there products for the lifetime of the customer. Why pay 10 times as much to open a door when the less expensive method hinge is warranted for life?

Third, how do you hold the door shut with a morticed butt hinge? Some type of unsightly hardware, or maybe Krenov's hand made latches, or magnets hidden in the door and frame? Another time & expense.

Do you really think today's IKEA generation is going to pay me $10,000 more for the same kitchen as the guy down the street , and I can tell them "Yes my price is higher, but I am using the same hinge as the Romans were when they built cabinets?

I can understand using a morticed butt hinge in a piece of nice furniture, and I used them on my entry door, nice stainless steel ones too, morticed into quartersawn white oak door jamb. But I don't see using them on a vanity that is going to be replaced in 20 years when the room is remodeled again.

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#14

different worlds

Bill Tindall

European hinges are essential for some styles and could be essential for some competitive situations. But most of us are not in either situation. What about the case where a variety of hinge styles will do and we are amateur woodworkers who may never have installed a European hinge? Are they still quicker than alternatives? What is involved in learning to install them? Do they offer any advantage than labor cost in a production situation? Are there door styles where they don't work (yes)? I think these are the questions Barry is really asking that users could answer. Personally I thought installation looked intimidating to learn for a one time door installation.

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#15

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

Jim Smith

Dang Barry you sure stirred a hornest nest,*NM*

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#16

Re: different worlds

John McGaw

As for the learning curve I can say that I've never messed up a door using the cup hinges. My first one worked fine after drilling one 35mm hole in a piece of scrap to make sure that I understood the back spacing properly. Of course I've never totally screwed up a butt hinge or a piano hinge beyond recovery either, the major problem being snapping off tiny brass screws with the attendant mess. As for speed, I can do a much better job with the Euro hinge in three minutes than I can I can with the best quality Brusso hinge in an hour since I invested in a simple mechanical jig to position the cup and mounting holes. Without the jig it might take me twice as long but I'd still be far more productive that I'd be with conventional hinges. Just a matter of what you get used to I guess...

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#17

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

Barry Irby

I really did stir up a hornets nest.

Did not mean to. I guess I got the answers. Once you are set up, they are fast and easy and adjustable. And they are hidden form view so you don't have to coordinate them with the rest of the metal on the piece or in the room. I wonder abut the durability. Simplicity is a good design feature and these are definitely more complex that simple actual hinges.

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#18

Moses Yoder

Re: different worlds

Moses Yoder

You are not yet addressing the issue of how to hold the door shut with morticed butt hinges. A lot of people use this gigantic magnet on the back of the door which in my opinion is really unsightly, while a cup hinge looks like it is supposed to be there. Installing a nice looking detente to hold the door shut takes a lot of skill and effort too; just holding the door shut takes more effort and skill than installing a cup hinge. Those standard hinges Mr. Nowicki linked to from Lee Valley are so ugly I am not even going to address them. They might be okay if you are building an apartment for your mother-in-law.

It takes some time to install your first cup hinge. You have to study the catalog and get the right hinge, some of which need mounting plates, drill a correct depth 35mm hole the right distance from the edge of the door, and you are set to screw in the hinge. After that it's like riding a bike, you never forget how.

People say they work loose. We have gone back to the jobsite to adjust doors sometimes 6 months after installing the job, as the house and stuff settles, but so far as I know we have never gotten a call after that. Perhaps the homeowners are tightening them themselves, which I find doubtful. The clients we work for are not the kind of people who understand how to run a screwdriver. How do you adjust doors when the house moves and you have installed morticed butt hinges? This would be more critical in full inset applications with built in units. Do you plane the door edge and refinish it?

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#19

I don't

John in NM

Mostly because they are simply not my style and like many tasks, installing butt hinges is not hard once you've done a few.

Cost is a wash, since I don't usually buy the cheap butt hinges, Euro's are about on a par with the hinges I like to use.

Their main advantage is in a production format, where saving 10 minutes over and over does make a difference. I don't see any reason they would have much appeal for a hobbyist like you or me.

I have seen what I believe to be sag in use over maybe 5 years with a few Euro hinges. Might be limited to cheaply made Euro hinges, might be from improper installation, or it might be from wear of a fairly complicated mechanism. They can be adjusted to compensate for the sag, but that callback alone negates any time saved in installation as far as I'm concerned.

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#20

Yes, A Hornet's Nest, But Interesting

Bill Howatt

To be honest, I was surprised (perhaps naively) at the negative comments. I thought they were generally considered a good idea even if not for every application.

Bill

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#21

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I don't much like them for the amount of space they take up, but I do understand the logic of a hinge that can be adjusted quickly to fit the door in place and to take up later sag.

They offer all the aesthetic delight of a...well, there's just not a good comparison; if I ever get enough round tuits, oh yeah, and skill, to do really good work, I'll take the time to do butt or knife hinges. One of the Foine Workwooding design books some years back had a picture of a lovely cabinet with leaded glass doors and a very swoopy design, with Euro hinges showing through the glass. They might as well have had spotlights on them; ruined an otherwise stunning design.

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#22

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

Barry Irby

OK, So I went to Amazon and looked the Blum hinges. Information was scant so I went to the Blum site and tried to figure out the features of the hinge on Amazon. The Blum site is overwhelming. Could not find any way to relate the hinge on Amazon to one on Blum. Did not want to spend the morning deciphering a Fantastic site for info on a HINGE. Its a HINGE, not cybernetics.

So I decided to buy 6 hinges from Amazon at $1.09 ea. I clicked on the hinge and said Go to Cart. It listed 1 hinge with $4.99 shipping. Backed up and changed it to 6 hinges and it added $4.99 shipping EACH. Over $36 for 6 hinges. I can buy them cheaper locally. Still did not know whether they were soft close or self close or even if the screws came with them. Spent about ten minutes trying to figure out how to ask Amazon if they really charged six times the shipping for such small items. They clearly don't' want to hear form ME. Whole process made me feel like a Neanderthal. I'll just drive up the street and buy some with the coins I have saved from the previous Millenium.

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#23

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

Larry in NW Ohio

Barry you can call them @ 800-201-7575. Larry

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#24

Why don't you post a description here?

Keith Newton

You are right that the choices can be overwhelming for a newbi. Even lots of suppliers don't know their products all that well, and are not much help.

There are many choices that will get you the same look. You can start with a straight neck, which will give you a full over-lay, with a thin mounting plate, or half over-lay with the mid range plates, or even use it inset, with the high plates.

But you can get the cranked hinge neck of various sizes which can be used for the mid to inset with the thin plates.

And of course there are the degrees of opening variations in all, plus the different screw and bung options, plus soft close options.

You should just say "face-frame, or frameless" probably screw on, 120º, soft close for full overlay or whatever, plus the type of material.

If you are using something like melamine or mdf for the case, wood screws don't work well. You are better off getting euro screws which require a 5mm / 3/16" pre-drilled holes.

Re: Euro Style Hinges...Why use them?????

#25

Moses Yoder

Re:Amazon is usually pretty good

Moses Yoder

They should not have sharged you $4.99 each for shipping, that's just stupid. Obviously a glitch in the system, and I can see how it's a turn off. I think maybe when I retire I will become a Blum distributor; I have spent enough time studying their catalog that they owe me an honorary Master's degree in Blum Hardware.