Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Torsion box design

Posts

Torsion box design

#1

Torsion box design

nickb

It's looking like my house is going to be the "home" location for my son's First Lego League team, and I need to build a table that is lighter than the 90+ lb MDF monster the team currently has (FLL is an organization that promotes engineering/sciences through an annual competition that, in part, involves building Lego robots to perform a set of missions on a 4'x8' field). The kids want to play/experiment with the robot in the "off-season" (FLL normally runs Sept-Dec), so I'm looking to build something that is relatively portable (or at least more easily moved than the MDF monster) while still able to stand up to 11 yr. old boys.

The typical FLL table is a sheet of 3/4" MDF or plywood with 2x4's stood up on edge to form a rim - the table is set on saw horses. I'm thinking a torsion box (with folding banquet table legs in place of the saw horses) made with a 1x4 (jointed straight and ripped down to 3") grid and door skin to cover. Does this sound reasonable and any advice on how dense to make the grid?

Re: Torsion box design

#2

Re: Torsion box design

Joseph Mulherin

Nick, I would suggest you make the taqble like this: torsion boxes on each end with drawers on each side of the table 8" x 24" long. Make the boxes fold up underneath the top and then install casters on the rear side for transport easily. A good view of what I am saying would be like Norm Abram's router table...www.newyankee.com... four drawer on each leg, and four on the back side too.

Make a drawing of this and see if it works for you.

Re: Torsion box design

#3

Re: Torsion box design

Bill Earl

This doesn't answer your torsion box question. But having coached an FLL team for 3 years now, I can offer you the following advice on building a table:

In spite of any craftsman-like instincts you may have, resist the urge to make the table too perfect. The tables at the competitions tend to be fairly roughly put together (by my standards) and most have never seen sandpaper or a paintbrush. Many teams get to the competition and wonder why their robot doesn't perform like it did in practice. It is better for them to design a robot that can tolerate a less-than-ideal playing field.

This year, we tested by taping irregular surfaces to the smooth walls of our table. For next-year, I am considering just rebuilding the whole table to minimum standards.

Please don't take this as criticism of FLL or the organizers of the tournaments. Putting together a regional or state-level competition is a monumental task and the very next day all the tables go back into storage. All of the tables we have seen have been built to spec with standard-grade construction lumber. No more, no less.

Good luck to your team!

Re: Torsion box design

#4

Re: Torsion box design

Yonak

Nick, if you use 1/2" Ultralight MDF with a few more (1X4..or 3 ?) braces instead of 3/4" regular it will reduce the weight by about half. 3/4" Ultralight will reduce the weight by 1/3.

Re: Torsion box design

#5

Re: Torsion box design

Larry in NW OHIO

Nick This is going to sound pretty dumb. Could you make the table out of the flat no panel doors. Get a couple close to the 2foot and hinge two together, and maybe do the same on the ends. Would that work. Also the best of luck to your team. Larry

Re: Torsion box design

#6

Re: Torsion box design

Steve Schoene

cheap flush doors are only 6'8" high a challenge to stretch to 8 ft.

Re: Torsion box design

#7

Re: Torsion box design

Barry Irby

I would use sheets of what Lowe's sells for underlayment these days. It's 5 millimeter birch plywood and is about $12 a sheet. They have some other stuff that is a little thicker and may be what passes for 1/4", but its about twice the money. For ribs I would use half inch stock about 3" wide. I'd put the ribs on about 8" centers and glue it up with yellow glue. I can also buy 1/8" plywood locally for about $10 but it is little more than sturdy cardboard. Might work but might be a little tender if your guys decide to climb on the table and walk around.

Re: Torsion box design

#8

Re: Torsion box design

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Two options that should work fine:

1. A 4' X 8' sheet of 2" rigid foam available at most building supply centers (not big box stores), surfaced top AND bottom with 3/16' tempered hardboard.

2. Two sheets of 3/16" tempered hardboard and an internal grid system (6" X 6" to 8" X 8" cells) of the same material glued using yellow glue. If you make a simple jig it is easy to cut the grid pieces so they interlock which simplifies assembly.

I made an 8' X 18" X 2.5" table/scaffold using method #2. It was strong enough to hold over 350 pounds of bricks with only 1/2" of sag at mid-span. It weighed less than 30 pounds.



I would make your table in two parts- easier to transport and store.

Re: Torsion box design

#9

Re: Torsion box design

Thomas Norton

Alan,

What material and glue did you use? I just made a TB door that had to be veneered for a job. I used 3/4" ply for ribs and 1/8" ply for the skins. I had a max thickness because of the Euro hinges I was using. BTW the door was 24"x 80". Dead Flat.

Re: Torsion box design

#10

Re: Torsion box design

Larry in NW OHIO

I guess I wasn`t real clear, they could hinge a piece on the ends to make it 8foot long or whatever they need. But the idea to put thin sheets of ply on 2" styrofoam is a good idea. Larry

Re: Torsion box design

#11

Very impressive, Alan.

Yonak

You could probably get by with fewer lateral cross pieces as the length is where the stress is. Nice engineering and result.

Re: Torsion box design

#12

Re: Torsion box design

nickinmass

Yeah - 2011 was the first year for this team and we definitely experienced the difference in tables at our qualifying tournament (three runs within 10 pts of each other on 1 table, then over 30 pts. lower on a different table). I have talked myself out of doing anything but plain old 2x4 for the rims, but I really want to make this light enough to be moved by one person.

Good luck to you and your team too!

Re: Torsion box design

#13

Re: Torsion box design

nickinmass

I love the XPS foam idea. I'll need to cut it back a little to add wood edging (both for protection and to give a little meat to attach the rim, but this should work great, be light, and eliminate the need to mess around with cutting a zillion half-lap joints. Thanks for the great idea!

Re: Torsion box design

#14

Re: Torsion box design

Bill Earl

Is that "nickinmass" as in "Nick in MA"? Which qualifier were you at? We went to the BU Academy qualifier in Boston.

Re: Torsion box design

#15

Re: Torsion box design

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

I used either 3/6" (or 1/8"?) tempered hardboard skins and plain old yellow titebond. The web was made from the same material until I ran out and had to supplement it with 1/4" pegboard.

If you do some research on torsion boxes (I did before writing the article for American Woodworker two years ago) you'll see the web can be very thin - have you ever seen airplane wing (a torsion box) ribs? Many hollow core Birch and Luan doors use a web made from cardboard! The web's main purpose is to keep the skins apart. One of the few reasons to use thicker web material is to provide a better gluing surface since the web must be firmly attached to the skins, and to a much lesser degree if the torsion box will be subjected to surface loads. That is more easily addressed by decreasing the web spacing and/or making the skins a little thicker- none of that is usually needed in a door. As you can see, edge gluing the thin web material worked just fine for me. Many folks overbuild their torsion boxes and suffer a significant weight penalty- one of the main reasons to build a torsion box in the first place. Another common mistake and a lot of needless extra work is cutting dadoes in the skin for the web pieces.

Re: Torsion box design

#16

Re: Very impressive, Alan.

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Thanks! You are probably correct. One issue I was trying to avoid is having the web pieces bend or distort which is less likely with this spacing. I built that torsion box as example for the engineering part of an article I wrote for American Woodworker.

The spacing was based on no special formula, just gut feeling and a little experimentation. When I did research for my article, I couldn't find a useable formula nor rule of thumb. The available torsion box formulas were quite complex and required too much materials data or other info which just wasn't available or not useable- remember we are working with wood or wood products and glue- there are a lot of variables. One engineered materials association website, said in fact, they only use the formulas as starting point then build and do extensive testing and often make changes to each design.



Re: Torsion box design

#17

Re: Torsion box design

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

You may need to experiment with adhesives to attach the skin if you go with a foam web. Also, to get a flat table you need a flat construction platform.

Yes, put good edging on the torsion box! I do that with all my assembly tables. I had no need for an edge on the test torsion box, so just left it off.

Don't be put off by the need to cut "a zillion" halved joints in the web pieces, which is much easier and quicker by the way than the method David Marks and the Wood Whisperer used! A simple miter gauge indexing jig makes quick work of cutting a perfectly spaced and fitted web. An indexing peg is just visible below my left index finger in the photo below.

I cut the halved joints in all web pieces for a 4' X 7' torsion box table in less than 5 min.!


Re: Torsion box design

#18

Re : glue

Yonak

You can use any water-based glue you think will hold. Polystyrene is dissolved by oil-based chemicals, such as mineral spirits, acetone, toluene, oil-based paint, etc.

Re: Torsion box design

#19

Re: Re : glue

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

When I was building a foam-fiberglass composite experimental class two-place airplane years ago, it was standard procedure to use two-part epoxy resin for layups since polyester resin would eat the foam.

And by the way, that brings up another EXTREMELY light, but potentially more expensive, way to make a torsion box. I built the aircraft fueselage, bulkheads, and wings from fiberglass-foam-fiberglass sandwiches of different thicknesses. When people questioned my sanity to fly in a craft built like that I would set the ends of a 3' long by 1' wide by only 3/8" thick scrap piece of bulkhead that weighed just a few ounces on cinder blocks then stand on and even gently bounce in the middle of it without it breaking! It was incredibly strong. A piece of foam alone would snap immediately, the fiberglass alone wouldn't break but would flex to the floor, but the torsion box sandwich of both was strong and rigid.

Re: Torsion box design

#20

Re: Torsion box design

John McGaw

The foam core method is most appealing to me although, if I could afford it, I'd go for the rigid PVC foam that is used in yacht construction. There it is often used as the major strength element in the hull and a 1" layer of PVC foam between even the thinnest layers of fiberglass/resin provides stiffness that must be experienced to be believed. The thing that would worry me most about constructing a large table would be ensuring a proper bond between the skins and the core. A 4X8 structure is not exactly conducive to clamping, a vacuum bag big enough to handle it would cost a fortune, and getting the entire thing flat would be a nightmare in a regular shop environment.

Re: Torsion box design

#21

Re: Torsion box design

nickb

We were at the BU Academy too (the Electrons). First year team - all boys (1 4th grader and 5 5th graders). The boys were very happy with their performance (and I was impressed too, given how much time we spent spinning our wheels figuring out the programming and robot). About half of our team is coming back next year and are excited enough to want to work on programming and the robot during the off-season (and they've already found replacements for the kids that aren't coming back), so that's good to see.

Re: Torsion box design

#22

Re: Torsion box design

nickb

Point taken, but happily I don't have to worry about absolute flatness (the typical table is a sheet of AC plywood with big box store warped/twisted 2x4s screwed to the edges), and penetrations through the skins are not a problem. I'll probably do the glue up on my basement floor (which is fairly flat - more than flat enough for glue down flooring whenever I get to finishing out the part of the basement that is not my shop) with a combination of brads into the edging plus weight (I have about 2000 lbs of bagged rubber mulch awaiting deployment).

Re: Torsion box design

#23

Re: Torsion box design

Bill Earl

I know the Electrons! Will you be at the Library with the team this Saturday? I work with Team Lightning. We started out at Hillside 3 years ago. Now we have members from Hillside, High Rock and Pollard.

Re: Torsion box design

#24

Re: Torsion box design

NickinMass

We'll be there, although I just realized that my son is double booked and we'll have to leave at 1:20 or 1:25. See you then.

Re: Torsion box design

#25

Re: Torsion box design

Bill Earl

My son is double-booked as well and won't make it until 2, but I will be there early to set up. The Brainstorms will be bringing their portable table made from foam sheets. I am interested to see that in action. See you there!