Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

White and Gray?

Posts

White and Gray?

#1

White and Gray?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I am being "commissioned" to build my first crib (grandchild due in May). Mom-to-be has asked for some white and gray hardwoods to be incorporated into the design. Holly can, however, get rather expensive, so I'm looking for alternatives. I know I can bleach out something like poplar, but I'm trying to avoid colorants or chemicals that may have a residue unfriendly to teething toddlers.

Suggestions anyone? Sources?

TIA

Re: White and Gray?

#2

Re: White and Gray?

Dick Coers

Some ash sapwood can be close to white, and hard maple sapwood of course. American elm can be on the gray side, and the grain pattern is course like ash. Hackberry heartwood is pretty dark, maybe gray. Something to think about anyway.

Re: White and Gray?

#3

Re: White and Gray?

paul in AZ

How about hickory? The sapwood I see in a local yard is pretty light.

You might have to look at a diluted black dye wash for the gray. The gray will make any adjacent light wood look paler so that is a plus.

There's always paint.

Re: White and Gray?

#4

JL

Re: White and Gray?

JL

Some wood bleach (part A + part B type) consists of hydrogen peroxide and sodium hydroxide as the active ingredients. The hydrogen peroxide (which is the real active ingredient and bleaching agent) effectively turns into water. The sodium hydroxide is water soluble and can easily be rinsed off.

The only thing you really end up with is raised grain - no real residues to speak about. So you have to sand when you are done - but you'd be doing that anyway :b.

I like ash sapwood. I also like white oak sapwood for a nice white color. You aren't going to get wide pieces in either case.

Re: White and Gray?

#5

Re: White and Gray?

Philip Duffy

Hi Mark, I have some holly planks, 6/4 for sale and for you, a special price discount. Send me a pm with quantity needed. Phil

Re: White and Gray?

#6

Re: White and Gray?

JMOHNIKE

Prior to getting any wood find out how toxic it is. Children will stand up in a crib and mouth the rails and everything else. Birch is not the color you want but safe. I have seen some maples almost white. Almost any wood you use is going to oxidize and change color so why not look at safety issues first? Just my 2 cents worth.

Re: White and Gray?

#7

Re: White and Gray?

Larry in NW OHIO

Congratulations Mark, when GOD blest me with this event the kids told me the design they wanted and left me to the rest, But everyone to their own. There are plastic covers for the rails so the little one can`t get to the wood. May GOD bless you as he did our family. Larry

Re: White and Gray?

#8

Re: White and Gray?

R Payne

Most "black" dyes that I'm familiar with (mostly from leather work) aren't truly black. They are really dark concentrations of green or blue or purple or brown or even red. Diluting these won't produce grey. Charcoal (or pencil lead) tends to be more grey than black and may be an option to turn something light into a grey.

As for white, I'd go with light as true white is hard to find unless paint or bleach is an option and a few good light choices have been mentioned. I believe hydrogen peroxide by itself should lighten woods some.

ron

Re: White and Gray?

#9

Thanks, Larry

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

The excitement is beginning to build.

I already have the rail-topper/teething caps "in-stock" so whatever design they settle on I'm covered in that department.

SOP on this is they're shopping and then throwing pix at me with "can you do this?" as the caption. Haven't stumped me yet, but I'm waiting for accessory items (chest, changing table, etc) to creep into the mix.

peace

Re: White and Gray?

#11

Re: Thanks, Larry

Larry in NW OHIO

Mark I have built 3 beds, if there is anything I might help with, just mail me. I`m very courious as to what they have in mind for a design. Could you post a pic if you would have one. Good Luck. Larry

Re: White and Gray?

#12

David Barnett

From a woodworker who's actually done it *LINK*

David Barnett

Well, not for the two-tone effect, exactly, but I adore bleached and pale pastel dyed woods.

Maple responds beautifully to two-part wood bleach. Bill Luce, a woodturner, has a picture on his website of a bleached maple bowl:

http://www.billluce.com/curly_ne_maple.html

Lite-N-Up from WoodKote - http://www.woodkote.com/products/WoodBleach/Lite-N-Up.pdf - is a popular brand, and you can find it at paint stores, usually cheaper than online, but if you need an online source:

http://www.woodworkingshop.com/product/ln80040/

Another two-part brand, very strong and somewhat less expensive is Hoodbleach-190:

http://www.hoodfinishing.com/Wood_Toners_Bleaches.html

Ron Payne's right. You want to stay away from diluting black dye. The trick to getting a good pale (or darker) grey is to first bleach your wood to white. Very white. The idea is to remove any yellow tones that will show through the grey. After bleaching, then use a good grey dye. I prefer Moser's Silver Grey W1620. This allows dilutions to the palest true grey while not going cold or blue. Not as warm as a dove grey, but certainly not cold.

Someone asked for a contemporary full-size goban in pale grey. The effect with inlaid oxidized sterling silver lines worked beautifully. (The next was a very pale salmon pink over birdseye maple with the same line treatment.)

Worried about toxicity. I'm not. Although I'm fairly sure no one chewed or licked the gobans, the data sheet at woodworker.com should allay any fears you might have.



"INGESTION: A SMALL AMOUNT WOULD NOT BE TOXIC IF SWALLOWED."
And this refers to the undiluted dye powder. You'll have to access it from the website's dye section, though. There's no direct link.

Obviously, the bleach in its active liquid form has safety issues, but you can search and find if toddler ingestion of the spent, dried, and neutralized bleach in wood could present any problems. I'd think not, but I'm no expert.

http://www.woodkote.com/msds/WoodBleach/WB801.pdf part A

http://www.woodkote.com/msds/WoodBleach/WB802.pdf part B

Your real task is to find and test a water-clear, non-amber, non-yellowing topcoat. I don't know what's available to you or where your tastes run (I abhor gloss, personally), so an acrylic knocked down to matte might be the thing. You're obviously going to want something sturdier than RenWax over super-platinum shellac, but toddler-proofing isn't really my thing, so ...

Whatever you do, test test test on scrap. I've had no problems, but your mileage may vary.


Moser water-soluble aniline dye powders

Re: White and Gray?

#13

Thanks!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Good info and leads. I'm running down MSDS and other information by direct contact with mfg's.

The gray will be the primary issue since the design calls for several gray boards to be included in glue-up panels with other woods. As bleach and/or dye don't penetrate very deeply, the panels would not tolerate much abrasion after the glue-up, and I don't even want to think about bleaching and coloring sections of an already glued panel.

I may have to try to talk them out of the gray sections :\

Re: White and Gray?

#14

David Barnett

You bet.

David Barnett

"The gray will be the primary issue since the design calls for several gray boards to be included in glue-up panels with other woods."

Now that I have not done, nor would I want to take it on. Such is often the nature of 'commissions', especially where family is involved, heh, but it'll all be worth if it makes 'em happy.

I just have a thing for bleaching, I suppose. I recently made some 'rusticated' cabinet hardware that captures the look of fossil bone. Really fun, very striking.

Re: White and Gray?

#15

Re: Thanks!

R Payne

I've never done it but I've read that if you bleach everything then put shellac down where you what the white to stay and dye the rest grey the shellac may prevent the dye from taking where it has been put. If you use an alcohol based dye you may need a different resist.

ron

Re: White and Gray?

#16

Resistance

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Won't be an issue because if they choose the white stripe look, the white will go in as holly. Only the gray section would need to be bleached and then dyed, which is what poses the construction problem. Most likely I'll attempt to talk them out of the gray in favor of another light wood like poplar or beech. Slightly curious, however, as to how the manufacturer did the gray sections.

They did call today to tell me that the mattress has been ordered and it seems they've decided on M&T joints for square spindles. I hope I can get a set of springs to match the mattress, otherwise this baby will have its first platform bed.

There's a style being pushed for open sides cut from sheets of 1" bamboo ply with the spindle spaces routed into the ply. I don't care for the look, personally, so I'm glad they're not going there.

Re: White and Gray?

#17

David Barnett

A simpler path

David Barnett

I didn't mean to suggest you can't get a satisfying grey without bleaching, just that it produces an optimal and more pure effect if the ground has no yellows. It depends on the wood you're dying and how dark you want the grey to be; palest, harewood color, a medium felt grey, or a steel grey. So I'd suggest getting a grey dye and experimenting before bleaching. If you don't like the results, then bleach and see how that goes. Personally, I prefer bleaching, then dying, but I'm also aiming for the palest dye washes.

Resists can work but I find them iffy. You'd want to do some testing. I've used encaustic (beeswax and damar resin) as a resist for dyed wood features, but never removed the encaustic as it was part of the piece (unpigmented encaustic was then applied over the dyed wood sections). Long ago, I tried a shellac resist to keep padauk from bleeding onto adjacent aspen. Didn't work. For me, anyway.

Re: White and Gray?

#18

Simpler Still

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

is to "86" the gray pieces in the panels. :\ Woossie way out, I know, but getting into masking and resists, in whatever formulations or combinations is simply not worth the effort. Plus, they've been pulling stuff off the internet, so I've suggested they find things in-person to get the true value of both color and scale. If they decide that the gray is required, I'll draw the check rather than the plans.

I may, however, contact the outfit that makes the crib my kids saw, and simply ask them how they got the gray without buggering up the woods next to them.

Re: White and Gray?

#19

Re: Simpler Still

Yonak

Mark, is there a picture of the crib the outfit makes on the internet ? Maybe it can be brainstormed. At least, if would be fun to see what they have in mind.