Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Finishing problem

Posts

Finishing problem

#1

Finishing problem

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I did it again. I completed a project then started the drudgery of applying a finish. I've said it here before - I hate finishing.

The product is Behlen Rock hard table top finish. Although, I have this problem with any varnish I use.

The piece is a small cherry round table top.

What I did:

  • Brushed on several coats using a quality badger brush
  • After the last coat cured a few days I leveled the surface with 400 grit paper. The surface looked good i.e. a nice consistent dull surface, no gloss left.
  • Then I used 600 grit paper lubricated with soapy water. Still looked good although still has the sheen as if I just sanded with 400 grit paper.
  • Then I used pumice lubricated with soapy water rubbing with a paper towel (Viva). Still looked good, but still really dull.
  • Then I used rotten stone with soapy water and paper towel. Still has the sheen of having just been sanded with the 400 grit paper!

  • I've ended up with a super dull, but nice, flat, and smooth surface. The last thing I tried was some paste wax applied with 0000 liberon steel wool. No change in the look but I've never had luck with wax.

    I wanted a smooth silky feeling semi-gloss surface.

    I think tonight I will try to wipe on one last thinned coat and hope for the best and just leave it at that (meaning hopefully end up with a surface that has no nibs or anything in it).

    That's my plan unless somebody has a suggestion on how I might polish up what is currently there.

    Edit: this is a Christmas gift I am trying to get done.

    Thanks.

    Joe in a Cleveland suburb (about to move onto another hobby!)

Re: Finishing problem

#2

Re: Finishing problem

paul in AZ

Unless you know of hard data that says Behlen is the hardest toughest finish for your application how about cleaning off the wax and putting on a satin or semi-gloss poly?

I use General Arm-R-seal, thinned a bit. Wear has never been a problem.

Re: Finishing problem

#3

Re: Finishing problem

JMOHNIKE

After the 600 grit use #0000 steel wool. Rub and keep checking the patina. Do not rub fast enough to develop heat which might soften the finish and create other problems. You should have a semigloss look. When satisfied with the apply paste wax and buff and if you want you can go over that with a spraywax, ( I use Pledge the non streking version). I have used this method on well over a 100 projects and it works for me. As a foot note I was told by an old timer to the craft, that pumace and rotten stone will not work on the newer finishes as the poly finishes we use today are harder than either the pumace or rottenstone and are mostly a waste of time.

Re: Finishing problem

#4

Bart Goldberg

Re: Finishing problem

Bart Goldberg

Given that the rottenstone had no effect on the sheen, I would agree that it is too soft to effect the surface, but the approach was correct, just the wrong abrasive to achieve your goal. My suggestion is this: before you start adding additional layers of finish that may lengthen the time to complete this project, try using even finer grits of sandpaper. Given that this is a small table, I'd try using micro mesh abrasives, which I use all the time for turning, and should work for you application as well. They will allow you the ability to tweak the sheen you are looking to achieve simply by increasing the grit you use till you get the level of gloss you are looking for.

Let us know what finally works

Bart

Re: Finishing problem

#5

not correct

Bill Tindall

No finish is harder than rock. I have many pieces finished with urethane and then rubbed out. The only time a finish can not be rubbed out is when it is too soft.

Re: Finishing problem

#6

I suspect the varnish is the porblem

Bill Tindall

The only way to fail to rub out a finish is when the finish is too soft. I suspect either this finish is inherently too soft or you have not allowed sufficient time for it to harden, a process that can take days at cool temperatures.

I have never rubbed out with water so I don't know if this variable is affecting results. I use mineral oil and a wad of soft cotton. Rotten stone will yield a bright gloss finish with a hard varnish. 4/0 wool and wax will yield a medium rub.

Having used wax you face peril trying to re-varnish.

Mounting soap box..........Never employ an untried finishing schedule on the final product. (write this on the shop blackboard 100 times) In the beginning select a piece of similar material and save it to test the proposed finishing schedule. This testing can be done while the piece is under construction such that a reliable finish schedule is ready when the piece is ready for finish.

Buying the equipment and learning to spray makes finishing more pleasurable and near instant gratification when using lacquer(which is easy to rub out).

Re: Finishing problem

#7

Re: Finishing problem

Howard Acheson

Behlen Rockhard produces a very gloss if it is allowed to fully cure and if the proper abrasives are used.

First the finish must be built to sufficient thickness to allow some fairly aggressive abrading. Next, the finish must be fully cured. Like all oil based varnishes, Rockhard needs 3-4 weeks to cure to the point where rubbing out is best. Curing should be done where the temperature stays above 65-70 in the finishing room for the 3-4 weeks.

Once cured, flat sand with 400 paper mounted on a felt faced sanding block. Vacuum the dust and then sand with 600 grit using water as the lubricant. Finally, move up to 1200 grit and wet sand. Now use a polishing compound. I've used a couple over the years. Currently Maguiares Polishing Compound (not rubbing compound) is my choice. It works best if applied with a power polisher but this takes some learning to use most effectively. You can apply it by hand. Finally, apply a Maguiares swirl remover. These steps will give you a mirror gloss.

Avoid wax. It adds nothing to the process or the finish.

Re: Finishing problem

#8

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Finishing problem

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Perfect reply, Howard - particularly the part about letting it cure for several WEEKS before trying the sand/rubout.

Re: Finishing problem

#9

Fallen Vitim To....

David Yoho

Joe, as others have pointed out, it sounds like your varnish has not fully "cured" and it's not hard enough yet. You've fallen victim to a deadline that can't be met, given your choice of finish.

Now, all the advice on rub-out methods and materials is all good and worth remembering for the next time you need it. However, it seems you're really looking for a way to still pull this thing out of the fire and be ready by your deadline.

If so, here's what I would do. Start by thoroughly cleaning the wax from the surface with mineral spirits. Next, go back over the surfaces with the 400-grit paper just enough to give it a little "tooth". Wipe away any dust and apply a coat or two of General Finishes - Arm-R-Seal in semi-gloss. Let dry and you're done.

I used that Behlen's product once before and thought it was way too thick and tricky to work with for me. Now days when I want a varnish finish I either use Waterlox or Arm-R-Seal. Both have given me excellent results and they couldn't be easier to use.

Re: Finishing problem

#10

but are they compatible......

Bill Tindall

There is already one problem resulting from using an untried finishing schedule. There is certainly opportunity to go astray by adding a second untried(in this application) product over the first. If nothing else, the look of a "semi-gloss" achieved by adding a delusterant may not be what is desired. A delustered finish will not look like one rubbed out when viewed in some lighting conditions.

I have no experience with the varnish that was used but of the varnishes I have used none take 3 weeks to cure enough for rub out with 4/0 wool if cured in a warm environment.

The project is small and let us presume it lives in a cold climate where the heat is now on. Move it to a small room, say a bathroom, and fully open the heat source to this room and even add a small space heater, anything to get the temperature up to 80 degrees or so. I predict that after a couple of days under these conditions the finish will be hard enough to rub out. I would try 4/0 wool first as it will be most forgiving of a less than perfectly hard finish. The problem with pumice is that it will embed in a soft finish and deluster it. If 4/0 wool is not quite bright enough then add wax and this combination will take the gloss to between medium rub and gloss.

Re: Finishing problem

#11

I always fall victim to... [rant!]

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

woodworking magazines.

It seems every other issue has an article about the best ever, easiest to apply, wipe on, perfect, dummy proof finishing technique in the world. And, I always believe it, run off and try what I just read, and fall victim to it.

The articles seem to always leave out the nuances, caveats, and little details that are always pointed out here when asking a questions.

I've been a subscriber to FWW for years. Every year at renewal time I wonder why I do. But I pay it anyway. I even pay the extra premium for web content. Which is good once you get past the non-stop barrage of pop-ups, ads, horrible search engine, and horrible site layout - I pay extra for it.

I recently subscribed to PWW because I like how it has changed. Would you believe the day I dropped the payment into the mail was the exact day somebody here announced C. Schwartz was stepping down? He is the reason I finally decided to subscribe! Bah. I can't win...

Really, how many articles can you write about how to sharpen a plane iron. How to cut a mortise. Hot to make a box and so on. I know the authors are restricted by space and so on. But, it finally clicked in my head the number one goal of a magazine is to sell a product, to make a profit this quarter for the share holders, and that you learning something is second.

Sorry for the rant. I recently received an email from one of the magazines (I get daily nonstop spam from them trying to sell me stuff) declaring they are the best and their website is the best. I found it to be rather presumptuous and in bad taste. I pay a premium for that...

I tried to get a project done and fell victim to an article.

Phew. I got that off my chest. I feel better now. :)

Thanks for the help and replies.

I really do appreciate you people taking the time to respond and help.

WoodCentral is great for that.

Thanks Ellis for this site.

Happy Holidays.

:)

Re: Finishing problem

#12

Re: I always fall victim to... [rant!] *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

I really do appreciate you people taking the time to respond and help.

WoodCentral is great for that.

Joe, Rather than subscribe to a bunch of magazines I send an annual donation to help keep WC in place. There is more information, reviews (some are even unbiased) and help here than all the magazines combined.


Support WoodCentral

Re: Finishing problem

#13

The bottom line-finishing is technically complex

Bill Tindall

Finishing is the most technically complex part of most projects. There is a bewildering variety of chemistries used to create finishes and chemistries to cure these finishes. It can be expected that this chemistry will respond differently to the details of how the products are used . Details that might seem trivial may not be. Further complicating the situation, the manufacturers provide scant clue as to what is in the can, or even whether it was changed since the last time you used the product. For these reasons every finishing project is a chemistry experiment and should be approached as such. Every detail of the finishing operation must be tested on "scrap" before proceeding to the furniture.

Any time I fail to heed this advice I get screwed. For example, I was applying a water based product for the fist time to some wood. Nothing could be easier, I thought- no stain just finish on flat bare wood. I always tack the dust off before finishing and never gave it another thought for my solvent based finishes. The water based finish beaded up like water on a duck back, I suppose from the residue left from what ever variety of tack rag I happened to grab at the time. I could go on with numerous other screw ups resulting from making assumptions that finishing is not complex, but you get the picture.

Re: Finishing problem

#14

Re: The bottom line-finishing is technically compl

Steve Schoene

Remember that rottenstone is much finer than pumice so that it may take quite a bit more time. By the way, there is not any particular reason to use both in the same schedule. And, unless there are some major defects you might as well start the process with 600 grit. Then jump to the 1200 CAMI or 2000P grit taking care to remove the 600 grit scratches. (You will need good low angle light for this.) If you are going for gloss you can go directly from the paper to the polishing compound or the rottenstone.

As Howard points out, extra cure time for any oil based varnish will help the rubbing out process.

Re: Finishing problem

#15

Re: but are they compatible......

David Yoho

You ask a good question about compatibility. As you said, finishing involves chemistry and that can be a factor in this case.

The problem seems to be more about time, or lack of it at this point. The choices would seem to be either wait another day with the item in a heated space to cure more and try rubbing out again but risk another failure, or wait longer for a proper cure and then finish it and give it late, or try going over it with a semi-gloss varnish that should be ready to handle by Christmas day.