Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Routing a flat on a cylinder

Posts

Routing a flat on a cylinder

#1

Routing a flat on a cylinder

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hello.

I am in the process of making a couple candle stands.

I was trying to route a flat on the post as shown below. As you can see in the pictures, the flat looks a tad off center on the left side - there is a slight ridge.

Without being too wordy here, I think the pics show what I am trying to do. I put the post onto the lathe this morning quickly to get these images with my cell phone, so the post is not centered perfectly on the lathe when the image was taken.

My lathe (Jet mini) doesn't have a lock on it. I marked the 120 degree marks on the post using a compass. Then locked it into place with the screw you see in the end of the jig.

I thought everything lined up perfectly. Not sure where I screwed up.

I think once I get the legs set into the DT's I can use a little sand paper and chisel work so hide my problem. I hope...

What can I do differently so the next one doesn't turn out this way?

They make this stuff look so easy in magazine and on t.v..... :\

Thanks.

#1


#2


Re: Routing a flat on a cylinder

#2

Re: Routing a flat on a cylinder

Ralph Lipeles

What if you put a faceplate on the arbor with a plywood dick attached to the faceplate. The plywood would give you something that you could locate holes in and screw it to the fixture.

Ralph Lipeles

Re: Routing a flat on a cylinder

#3

Re: Routing a flat on a cylinder

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've done what you're trying, and don't feel bad -- it is difficult. However, it's a lot easier if you have an indexing head on your lathe. The torque provided by the router bit can move the object ever so slightly, but that's enough to make a difference.

I recently routed a fluted exterior on a corian dish using a round-nose bit. I used essentially the same jig as you have, but it took maybe a half-dozen tries before I got a set-up rigid enough to withstand that torque, and I wasn't routing a groove more than 3/32" deep.

On your next go-around, try it out on a scrap piece first to work out the bugs. And clamp the daylights out of the jig. Maybe even find a way to clamp the side of the jig against the side of your workpiece so it can't rotate even a little.

Re: Routing a flat on a cylinder

#4

Re: Routing a flat on a cylinder

Bruce, a MN Galoot

The other thing to look at is how well centered your router bit is on the work piece. It needs to be dead on. That's by far the easiest to fix.

Re: Routing a flat on a cylinder

#5

Re: Routing a flat on a cylinder

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

also double check that the router bit is centered in the base of the router. It is pretty common for the base to not be perfectly centered to the bit.

Robin

Re: Routing a flat on a cylinder

#6

Re: Routing a flat on a cylinder

Barry Irby

I have done this. My lathe does have an indexing head on it. I used a setup similar to yours but instead of trying to index off the base of the router, I used a guide bushing. (I often index off the base for many operations and find it works well.) Never had any problem with it being off center but I do try to not spin the router it self during the operation.)

I have made a bunch of small tables and candle stands sing this technique with several variations. I cut the dovetail in the leg. Then I cut the flat. I used a bit large enough to cut the flat all the way across in one stroke. I lowered the bit until the width of the flat was nearly identical to the thickness of the leg at the top. I then cleaned up the little radius shoulders left at the top of the flat with a chisel. (This was very easy, but I am not into hand work and it made me feel almost competent.) Than I cut the dovetails on the legs using my router table. The legs were "square" on the end so that they had a flat top edge to mate under the ring left on your turning.

The second way I did it was to route the "flat" deeper into the leg using a router bit that matched the thickness of the leg. The dovetail remains the same or slightly deeper. Then dovetail the legs and have a radius profile on the top of the leg so that it slides right into the recess and fills it. The recess only has to be about a 1/16 or 1/8 deep. This looks really nice as it changes the "viewing angle" of the slots and makes them harder to see into. If you use the first method the DT's have to match perfectly to pull the two flat surfaces tightly together. On the second method, Epoxy is your friend and if you miss by a hundredth, you can't see it.

As far as indexing the head, If you have two routers, you can do both operation in each leg at the same time and if you are of by a degree or two, it won't show. Just clamp the leg tightly to prevent rotation and also be sure your guide box is sturdy front to back, mine was too flimsy. You needed another router anyway, didn't you? Christmas is coming.

Re: Routing a flat on a cylinder

#7

Re: Routing a flat on a cylinder

TomD

I always index the router bit the same way, because even using a different segment of the base can cause it to be off center.

Re: Routing a flat on a cylinder

#8

Re: Routing a flat on a cylinder

TomD

Another option if you aren't in production is to do it by hand or half by hand. As you have found out, doing it with a lot of jigs and gear has left you with an imperfect result, that you will have to compensate with hand work. So if you are up to that, why not start with the hand work?

By hand you would:

- probably nail getting it central, though you could end up slightly to one side of your lines depending on skill, but overall I think it is easier.

- Since you are still in get er done mode, you can use some power where it makes sense like drilling relief holes or setting a flat bottom.

- The hand work of making the cuts right is easier than the corrective hand work you are currently facing

- There would be a lot less dust

- It would probably have been faster, unless you are making tons of these.

- The hand cut is more traditional looking and gives more bearing/strength, and the geometry is whatever you think it needs to be, not whatever the bits says it has to be.

Partially by hand:

- You can approach this in a number of ways, so if you roughed out very quickly by hand, you would still be able to do the accuracy stuff by router, if that was your preference. But taking the big chunks out by hand means less side loading on the router, therefore easier to be accurate; less wear on router and bit, and less dust and noise.

- Another approach would be to cut the joint essentially by hand but use power where it works better, like surfacing the main area in the bottom of the slot, or drilling relief cuts, or maybe cutting the tails on the legs.