Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Problem with chest of drawers...need help

Posts

Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#1

Problem with chest of drawers...need help

Bill Tindall


The picture shows the top right of the chest. The forward facing profile is a bull nose as shown in Picture 2. The "top" in this picture is the test piece I made to test the top profile and overhang. It looks awful, see Picture 2.


When I design something I always make a drawing and from the drawing I can get proportions right, etc. When it comes to curved feature a drawing can fail, as this case shows. In the drawing the front view showing the bull nosed overhanging top looks fine, and it would be fine if the front facing edges were flat like they show up on paper.

But a look at the cross section of the situation shows the problem. The transition from the top drawer blade bull nose to the top is just all wrong and looks awful.

A half round profile on the top looks better, even acceptable. But diddling around with profile alternatives has not revealed a entirely attractive top profile to sit on the bull nosed top drawer blade.

Help....any suggestions?

PS this shiny finish will be rubbed out

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#2

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

del schisler

how about the top made with a 1/2 round with profile on top ? and a 1/2" x 1/2" square spacer or filler set back on the top and in on the sides back say 1/4" This would be like a square on top of the top. Now when you make the top piece it would set down on the square filler and over hange the square filler say 1/2" ?? Kind of hard to explane with out drawing . Now the filler or spacer would go all the way to the back of dresser. I know their are lot's of idea'a . I know 2 bull nose doesn't look right I belive if you space the bull nose of a 1/2" round with profile it will look better good luck

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#3

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

gary peterson

from the picture my impression is it doesn't need a top...you could always inlay a top

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#4

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

James Watriss

That was my thought, too.

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#5

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

James Watriss

A pic of the whole piece might provide more food for thought.

This does reveal one of the benefits of scale models. They're time consuming, but even if they're not incredibly detailed, they can highlight trouble spots before you get going.

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#6

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

Paul Leuba

I would want to test any option on scrap to check its appearance before applying it to the finished top.

There are two options I would try:

1. Cut the top edge at ninety degrees to the surface, and apply an odd number of beads to the edge, either three or five depending on the bead size selected.

or,

2. Cut a 3/8" radius, or so, cove on the bottom edge of the top and apply a couple beads to the flat edge above the cove. I would size the overhang such that the cove terminates smoothly at the drawer blade.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#7

too late

Bill Tindall

I has a false top of poplar dovetailed in with utilitarian dovetails. Not at all clear how I would cover it up. But I agree, if I had planned on no overhanging top all would have been well.

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#8

creative

Bill Tindall

I will try a test piece tomorrow. thanks

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#9

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

paul in AZ

Could you trench a dado into the round edged piece and drop in a panel that would be flush with the top of whats already there?

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#10

Re: too late

GolfSteve in Calgary

Try increasing the overhang to say 1 or 1-1/2" on the front and sides. That should reduce the visual impact and visibility of the transition.

Stick with about 1/2" overhang at the back where the case is against the wall.

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#11

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

Biil - I think your drawing already shows it. I would try a partial bullnose (maybe it is called a fingernail) as you show, like this:


I think it wuld match the details you already have. The sample has too much of a rounded edge. A fingernail edge made with a bigger bit would look better.

Nice looking piece, by the way.

Robby Wright

San Marcos, Ca

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#12

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

Pat Evans

Do you need the top blade? Could you remove it and substitute the top? Wouldn't that condition be similar to the base condition?

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#13

More data.....veneer question

Bill Tindall




Indeed as some have suggested this piece would look fine with no applied top. As it stands it has a false top as shown in picture two. I could plane this surface smooth and perhaps apply veneer to it. The question is how would I apply pressure to set the veneer glue?

Hammer veneering with hot hide would be the ticket but I don't know how to do that and this is not a place I want to learn on. Would liquid hide work with the force of a a few hundred pounds of stuff applied to the top while it dried. Suggestions?

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#14

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

Larry in nw ohio

Bill If this is the same as what Paul said just ignore this. What if you would put say a 1/2" in between the case and the top and cove the edges or something else the would break it up a little. Larry

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#15

Re: More data.....veneer question

paul in AZ

This will likely get shot down as heresy but... contact cement.

Many years ago I built and veneered a harpsichord -visualize the size and shape of a concert grand piano. The biggest veneer sheet was for the lid and around 6 feet long by close to 4 feet wide. Veneer for the sides was ~7 feet long by over a foot. Real wood veneer, not the paper crap sold today. Contact cement, lots of wax paper, a veneer roller and considerable nervous sweating got it done.

Its over 30 years now and still adhering with no problems.

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#16

Re: More data.....veneer question

Keith Newton

Bill, My first impression was the same as Del. I think a small reveal, maybe 1/4 or 3/16, set back 1/4 painted black or finished darker, will float the top above enough to read better.

As for veneering, I would think you should be able to use a thick platen, along with some sprung cauls to get some pressure to the middle, especially of your veneer is flat.

Of course I would use epoxy, which doesn't need any more clamp pressure, than needed to bring the two parts together for full contact.

If you wanted to go wild and try vacuum bagging, you could snag plastic bag from a furniture store from a mattress, and use your shop-vac. A couple years ago I cut two one foot squares with my bath scales between, and was surprised to see 200 # per sq ft. Of course that might work out to 2000 # on the front and back, so on second thought,,,,,,, just saying.

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#17

Let me be the first to congratulate you.

Keith Newton

If you are absolutely sure there have not been any problems. If there haven't been any problems yet, it is likely that it has never seen any swings in relative humidity.

I can't tell you how many times I've been ask to fix projects done by others who used contact.

A couple of years ago, a woodworking friend of mine ask me to help him with a project. When we were meeting with his longtime friend and customer, he proposed using contact, the customer and i were both already shaking my head side to side before he finished saying it.

He said, hell, I've used it for years with no problems.

The customer and another friend / customer who was over here visiting both informed him that each of them had bought pieces from him that had failed. Or as he put it, the veneer fell off.

I suspect you have a more stable climate than we have here in AR, or Bill has in E TN.

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#18

Re: Let me be the first to congratulate you.

paul in AZ

Maybe I got lucky but stable climate is not a factor.

I built it in NYC, moved to Boston, then N. of Seattle where it now lives. It saw summer humidity, winter drying and changing climate in spades.

As I said, I expected getting shot down but can only relate my experience with this one large piece.

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#19

Re: More data.....veneer question

Barry Irby

Git U some Cherwy Formyker and some contact cement and one of them big steel rollers they use on floors. Run a router roun da edge and you's done. What the H? If she coems apart you can jist stick her agin.

One a more serious note, I have no experience with contact cement and veneer, but lots of it with plastic laminate on counter tops. I've seen a lot of it fail after ten or twenty years. I have also seen veneer fail that was glued with whatever.

On a different note, Are you not concerned the the dovetail joint between Cherry and Poplar? Not enough differential expansion to worry about? I just don't know. And, I have seen dovetails photograph through veneer in these circumstances.

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#20

Re: creative

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

I had nearly the same thought regarding Option Two as did Paul. Maybe make a full size mock up in poplar. It'll all work out and you will be pleased at the outcome, I have no doubt.

George

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#21

Youse Tawk Funny, Barry


Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#22

Re: More data.....veneer question

Sgian Dubh

Veneering over the top as is is almost certainly a complete waste of time, whatever thickness of veneer is used or whichever glue is employed Bill. All it will take is a little differential shrinkage between the top board and the end grain of the side panels for every dovetail to telegraph through the veneer.

In lesser quality old and antique furniture I've worked on it's common to see the veneer lifted right off at the ends of the top where there's been moisture cycling over many decades in the veneer and the through or lap dovetails.

As to your transition why not consider letting the ~3/4" thick top overhang by about 2" or 3" at either end, and perhaps an inch or so at the front edge. Then work a low angle bevel on the underside, perhaps a 20 or 30º rise, and leave a slim vertical edge all round, perhaps 3/8" deep. You never know: it might work. Slainte.


Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#23

The decision has been made....

Bill Tindall

First, let me thank all for their thoughtful suggestions. I have tried all of them and here are the results......

Best would have been to design it for no added top but it's too late for that option.

Veneer- too risky. Sigian's warning was the nail in the coffin of this idea. He has too much experience to dismiss. BTW, I have used contact cement for veneering and I don't know why it has a bad reputation. However, it leaves a more obvious glue line and this dark glue line could have been blazing obvious at the front edge.

Other profiles- To my surprise a flatter curve made the transition look worse and it didn't go with the rest of the curves in the piece. Again to my surprise the extreme, a half round looked best, better than any of the alternative profiles. And more to my surprise any sort of cove, or a step, at the transition looked even worse.

Overhang- On every piece I make wife says the overhang is too little. In this case I listened, to her and you all. With a larger overhang and the half round edge profile the transition disappears and the top drawer blade profile appears to flatten unless you are on your knees (this is a 3/4 scale chest and only 4' high. )

The decision (and not the one I expected)- Half round profile and more overhang. This mock-up looks equivalently attractive to no added top and this is an easy solution to implement. Thankfully, I made the top (which I had already roughed out) long enough to accommodate the larger overhang on the ends and I can add a strip to the back to fill out the required width. All's well that ends.

Lesson learned- Scale drawing on paper is sufficient to test design for flat rectilinear projects. For curved stuff a model is a safer path.

Again, thanks to all that contributed their creative energy and experience.

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#24

Re: More data.....veneer question

Alex Grigoriev

That's very weak vacuum you've had. Normal atmospheric pressure is about 1 kg/cm2, which is 929 kg/sqft which is about 2000 lb/sqft. If you only measured 200, you've had only 0.1 atm of vacuum.

Re: Problem with chest of drawers...need help

#25

Alex you are correct. I normally pull 28 Hg

Keith Newton

But it would be crazy to put a whole cabinet in a bag at that level. Ten tons would probably crush the broad front and back.

You might look again, that I stated, epoxy does not require a lot of clamp pressure.