We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
We have a little Friday club, where four single adults take turns to cook dinner friday night. Since Thanksgiving is just around the corner, and it's my turn on Friday, I thought I'd make roast turkey followed by pumpkin pie.
The turkey and trimmimgs are no problems, but I need some advice of the Pumpkin pie. So what are your favorite recipes?
We can buy Hokkaido pumpkins here and also the kind used for carving at Halloween.
I have made this recipe and it is quite tasty. I've always made mine using prepared (tinned) pumpkin puree. I understand that the old way of making your own involved baking the seeded squash and then scraping the flesh from the inside with a spoon although I've never tried it. The stuff from can has a very smooth texture so I guess you could run the scraped flesh through your food processor.
Buy a can of pumpkin pie filling. However, if you must make your own use a pumpkin suited for cooking, or in fact, a butternut squash makes the best pie in my opinion. A problem to be solved is to get the pumpkin or squash paste smooth. If you don't have some device to puree the material it can, and usually is, grainy and while it tastes good the mouth feel is objectionable.
I think that canned pumpkin may be a major stumbling block in Denmark. Our standard Thanksgiving desert is seen as an oddity in much of the world as in "you make pies out of what?" It really does seem odd that one would make a custard pie (what the dairy products and eggs and sugar really turn into), common enough all over the world I guess, but make it with mashed gourd in it. I love it myself but when describing it to friends in the UK and Italy I was under the distinct impression that they thought my tastes a bit weird. Of course in Afghanistan and Pakistan they make soup out of pumpkins which always seemed a bit weird to me.
BTW, there is a major difference between pumpkin pie filling and pumpkin puree and never the twain shall meet.
My wife is a very talented baker and has several specialties and among those is pumpkin pie. I really don't think it is hyperbole to say that her pumpkin pie is the best I have ever had.
The two things that make the biggest difference to flavor are the choice of pumpkin and the way it is cooked. While sugar pie pumpkins make a good pie the best pies are made with rue de provance pumpkins (sometimes known as Cinderella pumpkins. These pumpkins have flesh that can be over 2" thick and they are very dense to the point of being difficult to cut.
To get the best flavor out of the pumpkin cut it in half and discard the seeds. Cut into as many pieces as necessary to fit single layer on in a baking dish or cookie sheet with 1" of water. Cook at 300*F until tender all the way through (For a large rue de provance pumpkin it can take nearly 2 hours to properly roast). Cooking at a low temperature for a relatively long time will caramelize the sugars and give the pumpkin a richer flavor that cannot be had from canned pumpkin.
Scoop out the flesh and puree then let stand for several hours or overnight in a colander lined with cheese cloth or a dishtowel to drain all the excess water. This is a very important step as your pie will have way too much moisture and not set properly if you skip draining. Even with draining my wife always adds a packet of Knox gelatin to insure a firm center.
My wife uses the standard mix of pumpkin pie spices but goes very light on the clove at my request as well as a bit light on the sugar. But other than that her recipe is pretty standard (Can’t give out all of her secrets).
Canned pumpkin is easier, yes, but also normally has preservatives in it and doesn't taste as good. On the other hand, we had bought a pumpkin to make pie then figured out we would not have time to make the pie so we just bought some. Now we have 4 pies for tomorrow.
The taste comes from the spices. The texture comes from the squash/pumpkin. So any hard squash-like fruit will do for the mush, again I prefer butternut, but be diligent about making the mush smooth by some means.
The spices will be personal. If you need a specific recommendation email me and I will have one of the excellent cooks that are about to arrive within the hour and make just such a pie provide the spice recommendation and any other details needed.
When you set out to do something for the first time, things can go awry.......
all the ingredients for the pie measured out, dough kneeded and left to cool, now the recipe says: Roll out to a thin sheet with a ROLLING PIN??? Who has a rolling pin? Not me, and no time to turn one..............
Well, if a J-rolller and a sheet of visqueen works with fibreglass and epoxy, it might also work with piecrust dough.
It does.
Relief, Pie's in the oven.
Now on to the turkey - it's old hat.......I think.
Oppps, that would require a mixer. Hummm, what could be mounted in the drill....
I recall a dinner party where tooth picks where required in the preparation of some dish. The husband of the host and I retired to the shop and rived some from a piece of maple. Others thought us strange.