Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

Posts

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#26

Re: Kickback Physics - Here it Is

Steven P. Bellner

One way to quantify the difference is to look at the rotational energy for the two different blade configurations. Rotational energy is equal to Iw^2/2, where I is the moment of inertia of the spinning object, w is the angular velocity. The moment of inertia for a flat disk is mr^2/2, where m is the mass of the object, and r is the radius.

Let's assume we're using a typical 60 hz induction motor, with a no-load speed of 3450 rpm. A 10" blade weighs about 1.8 lb, whereas a 7-1/2" blade weighs about 1 lb. I assumed a 3/32" plate thickness with a mass density of 500 lb/ft^3.

Do the math, and you will find a 10" spinning blade provides 316 ft-lb of rotational energy. Our 7-1/2" blade only provides 99 ft-lb. So the smaller blade delivers a little less than 1/3 the energy than the 10" blade.

Now, in the real world, resistance of the blade while cutting creates the torque against which the motor turns while trying to maintain the no-load speed. Obviously that torque is limited by the motor horsepower, and in my simple example, the actual speed of the blade will be somewhat slower because of the resistance, but you probably get the general idea. The energy available for work is reduced by both the blade diameter and its mass.

All this math won't disprove the possibility of a kickback, but it should demonstrate that if one were to occur, it would be about 1/3 as forceful. There has to be a certain amount of energy required to generate the kickback. If all the rotational energy is converted into linear velocity (unlikely, as this would require the blade to come to a complete stop, but there's still plenty of energy available to propel the board), the speed of the board flying back toward your head can also be calculated. It would be the square root of 2 times the rotational energy just calculated divided by the mass of the board, (2E/m)^1/2.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#27

Difference is even bigger

Bill Tindall

Thanks for the insightful analysis.

I weighed my 10" blade at 784 grams and the 7 1/2 thin kerf at 237 grams.

But I think the friction between the blade and the wood is as important as the energy that is available from the spinning blade. In the case of the smaller blade it is substantially less so there is less grab for the blade energy to be translated to the object to be thrown.

Bottom line- less tendency to grab the wood and if it is grabbed less energy to throw it. Result is less kick back tendency all for the price of $29 (for the best quality blade)

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#28

PS

Bill Tindall

Is only 1/6th the energy for the smaller blade the correct value for the actual blade weights? I was unsure what ^2/2 means.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#29

Re: That's Shorthand for "Squared"

Steven P. Bellner

It's a little confusing looking at it without the aid of superscripts, but for example, the energy equation, Iw^2/2, could be written E = (I x w x w)/2. Same goes for the moment of inertia.

By the way, the last equation, (2E/m)^1/2, is intended to represent the square root of (2 x E / m).

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#30

I believe there is an error

John in NM

"Iw^2/2, could be written E = (I x w x w)/2"

I don't think that is correct, it seems to me to be mis-applying a distributive notation of the exponent - applying both exponential operations to one variable but only one operation to both. If this is indeed correct, mathematical semantics sure has gotten sloppy since I was in college.

The way I remember it, neither exponent should be applied to "I" without a change in the parentheses. The term "Iw^2/2" is quite meaningless, being the same as "Iw"

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#31

Re: I believe there is an error

Steven P. Bellner

The order of operations is to first exponentiate, then multiply or divide, then add or subtract. So the first equation would go like this: w squared times I then divide by 2. If you take the first equation and make the character combination ^2 equal to the superscript 2, it would look more straightforward. You could write it as (I/2)*w^2. The parentheses would be redundant, but do offer some clarity. The important thing is w is the only variable squared in the equation.

If I were programming this, it would look like E = I*w**2/2, which is the same as E=I/2*w**2.

By the way, w is the angular velocity, which is usually represented by the lower-case Greek letter Omega. But I substituted w because if I couldn't figure out how to superscript something, I had my doubts I could insert Greek letters into the post!

But let's try it: ω.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#32

Placing symbols, etc.

Sgian Dubh

Σ δ β Ω Δ π γ

Steve, place your symbols in a Word document, then highlight them, copy them, (Control C), put your cursor in the place where you want to insert the symbol in the forum's reply box and paste, (Control V).

Superscript can sometimes be done the same way, ie via highlighting the superscripted text or figure in a Word document and pasting it into the forum reply box. It doesn't seem to work in this forum but it does in others. Slainte.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#33

Must be a computer thing...

John in NM

Never heard of that kind of logic in ordering operations, but then before the 1990's there would have been no need for it in a school setting (I never used this stuff professionally), paper and pencil being the method by which it was done. I can tell you though, the hand written equivalent of x^2/2 would have earned a heavy sigh and shake of the head from the instructor. Though I can see why a computer would like that kind of shortcut, my human brain still sees it as sloppy - the reason being that there is an extra, specific, and logically un-necessary rule that must be known in order to follow the operation.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#34

Re: Must be a computer thing... *LINK*

Steven P. Bellner

John, the way I did it was the way I learned to do it back in the '70s before a commoner had access to computers (I did have a slide-rule, however).

I do agree the slash can be a source of confusion (as was the carat symbol to designate exponentiation), but I believe my original form was technically correct.


The Standard Order of Operations

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#35

I should have been more clear

John in NM

I did follow your second equation in your second post, because that equation uses correct notation. The point is you're making an error with the shorthand used in the initial post, leading to some confusion - it wasn't the carat symbol, it was the 2/2.

The reason I say this is you're making no clear distinction between:

x^2/2 --> the square root of x squared -- it is after all fairly standard notation to use x^1/2 for the square root of x.

and:

x^2/2 --> x squared divided by 2

This is sloppy notation, though of course the confusion would never arise in a handwritten equation. The correct use of parentheses would distinguish between the above possibilities and are therefore not redundant but required, along the lines of (Iw^2)/2. There are several correct ways to express it, but Iw^2/2 is not among them.

I'll avoid the risk of further pedantry by leaving it at that.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#36

Final Comment (I Promise)

Steven P. Bellner

John, I understand your point (in fact I made the exact error you were talking about in the kinetic energy equation a few lines down. Thanks to Sgian Dubh's tip and the old Windows Character map, I can come up with this (which this board seems to support):

ER = ½Iω²

where I = ½mr²

v = √(2ER/m)

Not forgetting the original theme of this thread, if one actually does the math (in the right order, of course) they will find out that a 10" blade has a tip speed of 102 mph, and contains enough energy to fling a one-pound cutoff 97 mph. I would not enjoy being struck by a piece of wood traveling close to 100 mph.

Thanks for the constructive criticism. It's boards like this one where people can discuss a topic in a civil manner that make portions of the internet actually enjoyable to use.

At this point, I believe we've beat this topic to death.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#37

97 mph!   WOW

Bill Tindall

No wonder people get broken bones from kick backs. If I did the calculation right the blade I use only has enough energy to throw this piece a safer speed of 16 mph.

Delightful discussion. I have asked the editor to get it captured in the Articles section.