Re: Kickback Physics - Here it Is
Steven P. Bellner
One way to quantify the difference is to look at the rotational energy for the two different blade configurations. Rotational energy is equal to Iw^2/2, where I is the moment of inertia of the spinning object, w is the angular velocity. The moment of inertia for a flat disk is mr^2/2, where m is the mass of the object, and r is the radius.
Let's assume we're using a typical 60 hz induction motor, with a no-load speed of 3450 rpm. A 10" blade weighs about 1.8 lb, whereas a 7-1/2" blade weighs about 1 lb. I assumed a 3/32" plate thickness with a mass density of 500 lb/ft^3.
Do the math, and you will find a 10" spinning blade provides 316 ft-lb of rotational energy. Our 7-1/2" blade only provides 99 ft-lb. So the smaller blade delivers a little less than 1/3 the energy than the 10" blade.
Now, in the real world, resistance of the blade while cutting creates the torque against which the motor turns while trying to maintain the no-load speed. Obviously that torque is limited by the motor horsepower, and in my simple example, the actual speed of the blade will be somewhat slower because of the resistance, but you probably get the general idea. The energy available for work is reduced by both the blade diameter and its mass.
All this math won't disprove the possibility of a kickback, but it should demonstrate that if one were to occur, it would be about 1/3 as forceful. There has to be a certain amount of energy required to generate the kickback. If all the rotational energy is converted into linear velocity (unlikely, as this would require the blade to come to a complete stop, but there's still plenty of energy available to propel the board), the speed of the board flying back toward your head can also be calculated. It would be the square root of 2 times the rotational energy just calculated divided by the mass of the board, (2E/m)^1/2.



