Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

Posts

Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#1

Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

Bill Tindall

It was reported below that 2/3 of table saw injuries involve kick back.

Mounting soap box yet again......

Use a thin kerf 7 1/2 or 8" 40T combination blade on the 10" saw (the CMT and Freud 7/12" blades are a good choice but there are others). It is virtually impossible to get a kick back with these small thin blades and they will accomplish nearly all the table saw cuts I need to make while making furniture. Once you get used to this small blade the occasions where a 10" blade is required will seem so scary by comparison (no kidding) that the additional caution could further reduce the risk of the 10" blade cuts.

In spite of the fact that some of the main furniture builders in our club have gravitated to these small blades others stubbornly refuse to try this radical concept.

BTW, it's not my idea. I picked it up from the person that demos the Mesa Vista Grip-Tite devises ( an exceptionally handy table saw aid I might add that can prevent other table saw injuries).

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#2

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29

Hal

Sounds like an excellent idea, and I plan to try it even though I have "yellow wheels" mounted mounted on my Bies fence which prevent kickback. I will keep them because they also do a good job of holding the workpiece against the fence and tight against the saw table.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#3

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29

Bill Howatt

There may be something to this but just what is the principle behind the claim?

Lots of people use thin-kerf blades and that doesn't prevent kickback, after all, a tooth that catches the wood enough at the rear kerf will want to throw it back.

Smaller diameter does mean less ft per minute of teeth going through the wood.

The part I don't like is that with a smaller blade there is more chance for the top teeth to be in the wood and those teeth are the ones with the biggest "throw it back to the operator" direction.

Bill

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#4

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29

Bill Tindall

Were you to try the blade described you would observe that the cutting force is vastly less than with any sort of 10" blade. Less force, smaller teeth, less force to throw stuff. At least that is my theory to explain the result.

As far as teeth in the work, blades are designed to operate with about 2/3 the teeth in the work at top center. This is also the safest configuration. Persons operating blades much higher than the work is thick invite amputations.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#5

Bart Goldberg

Kickback Physics

Bart Goldberg

Just to add to the question - doesn't a smaller diameter blade result in more downward force that forward force? I'm thinking that it might, thereby giving you less change of kickback.

Bart

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#6

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29

Bill Howatt

I can see where a diminished force would be better. I don't think blades are made to run with 2/3 of the teeth in the wood to reduce kickback but to give a better/less tearout cut.

It may be safer for amputations but not for kickback, IMO. The further down the blade you go with the cut (blade higher) the smaller the component of force directed towards the operator. I also referred to using a guard because of that increased risk although I always use a guard anyway.

Regardless, it is an interesting idea and I agree that the vast majority of cuts can be made with a smaller blade.

Bill

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#7

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29

gary peterson

for years I've used the dewalt 7 1/2 yellow 24tooth blade, very thin kerf, small carbide profile for some uses. These sell $12 at big box. At work now, so can't provide any info other than that. They cut all wood smoothly. If cutting thick, and stock is square, i cut halfway in, turn over and cut the other cut. Usually I have on the ww2 blade...does seem like overkill at times. Little force is needed with this blade, at times thought to keep using just this one blade, but perhaps the forces ww2 prestige keeps me from doing so.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#8

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29

Jesse Cloud

I don't know about this. I figure if it has enough force to slice through wood, it probably has enough to toss the wood toward my noggin... ;)

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#9

me too

Bill Tindall

I use the blade you refer to for utility cutting. But the 40TPI, more expensive and presumably higher quality, blades do indeed deliver a smoother cut in hardwood. I believe they are sharper and better balanced.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#10

What is the hook angle?

John in NM

I suspect that could have more to do with it's behavior than diameter.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#11

Re: Kickback Physics

TomD

- They also just don't get much of a grip on the wood. If the wood gets into position to go, the teeth are quite likely to slip, because the kerf is fine.

- Also the board gets thrown at radial speed, in theory. Though my worst was as a jam to the fence. BUt anyway, radial on a small blade is less than on a large blade. Not if one adjusted to surface speed, but presumably people aren't bothering with that.

- Where jams to the fence are concerned, the blade is very lat flexible, so it gives a little.

- Also, you can adjust down on HP since you need only half the power. That is huge on kickback.

I have been using these blades for like 30 years. They were originally a big deal being sold in Jap. catalogs like Jap. Woodworker, but later we just used the 7.5 circ blades. Main reason was to reduce kerf, but did notice they were pretty easy to use. MY earliest ones were full diameter, in my case 9", but they were still easy.

OTHER STUFF:

- Saw power is way out of whack. I sold my 3HP, and use 3/4 - 1.5. I like a saw that I can win a fight with during kick-back.

- I like a small but high quality saw, that I can really dominate the playing space on. This is great for most solid wood stuff. Obviously if one is breaking sheets for kitchen cabinets that isn't going to work. If I did a lot of that, I might consider a wall saw. As it is, I get the sheets broken at HD.

- Learn the geometry, it is a lot more than spliters. Study the european approach, I think it is a) better ; b) more slated to small shops and solid wood (they still have apprenticeships in much of mainland euro; c) if nothing else, it's another approach.

None of this is really going to save fingers for the extreme newbies, and extreme lunchbucket crowds. They won't be able to get their minds around this stuff, and they either won't pop for the gear, or want to use it. There actually is a product safety issue here, and it would make sense to do something about it. Not my vibe, but for those whose job it is to make sure heart valves are sterile, it's a no-brainer.

I'm not a product safety nut, no bike helmets for me. But, if one has the job of drawing a line and representing the thousands hurt, it makes perfect sense to jump on this with both feet.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#12

Re: What is the hook angle?

eliot d

All this makes good sense. but I'm of the opinion-- based on some nasty mishaps-- that the most important devise for reducing the chance of kickback is the splitter. What can happen without it -- no matter what size or thickness blade -- is this: imagine a board about four or five inches wide and a couple of feet long. Suppose you are feeding it through the blade, without a splitter, and using a thin push stick pushing close to the fence. Now, what can happen is that near the end of the cut, the board begins to ROTATE away from the fence , because there is no splitter, and the back of the blade grabs the board and hurls it at tremendous speed! USE YOUR SPLITTER AND A FINGER BOARD!

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#13

Re: What is the hook angle?

TomD

In the ones I have had it ran from normal for a TS blade, to really hooked for a nail cuttiin', knot bustin', deck building machine. Little difference either way, because in clean wood it was so thin it encountered no resistance.

Think of it this way. Ever see those big T-handle drills that can rip your shoulder off if the bit hangs? They may flip you when you jam a 3/4" auger in there. But what do you think happens with a 1/8" drill, nothing right. You can easily overpower that. The difference is that when you need 3/4" hole you need to use a big bit. Everything else equal, the board is just as cut in half with a 1/16" kerf as a 1/8" size one. The only downside would be if grooving. Mostly upside.

Sorta like this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Ey2DwMI2BM

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#14

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

Interesting idea. Do you happen to know what the maximum cut depth would be on a 10-inch saw with a 7.5 inch blade? Seems like my contractor saw will max out at about 3 inches (I think) with the 10 inch blade but I seldom cut things bigger than an inch or so.

Interesting,

Mike

Cutting thick stuff on the bandsaw in Apex, NC

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#15

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29

TomD

+1 for the bandsaw. Never want to get hit again.

You would loose 1.25" off your depth of cut. Sometimes you can make up a little by looking at whether there is a way of getting the blade up higher, though in most cases that might also apply to the 10", but at least you have the option of going for it. Stuff like stabilizers might be removed, and it could turn out that the full depth of the 10" wasn't used. Plus there are 9", and 8" blades.

As I say, I have used thin cut larger diameter blades, and they are also nicer, so diameter is not the whole story.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#16

about 2" depth of cut

Bill Tindall

I measured the CMT blade on a 10" Deltal Unisaw of 1970 vintage.

Bandsaw: Indeed before I retired a perfectly good Unisaw for a Saw Stop to gain safety I would consider spending part of the price and buying a band saw with a large table and rip on it. I got a Delta 20' for $500 plus another $150 for new tires and bearings. Love its big table. Why ever do they put such dinky tables on many band saws?

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#17

Right-on for all points made

Bill Tindall

Why people are buying home shop saws with 3 or even 5 HP motors remains a mystery. I have shoved thousands of bd ft of hardwood lumber through my 1.5 HP Delta and never had any urge to want for a more powerful motor. Production ripping would be another another matter.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#18

Please report

Bill Tindall

So far in this exchange there has been one person willing to try it (you) and several thinking hard as to why it can't be effective. If you try such a blade please report your experiences. If there are flaws in the approach I have not discovered I would like to know and I'll I quit advocating these blades. On the other hand if you find the blades useful other might be encouraged to try them.

The blades I recommended are thin kerf combination blades, not cross cut blades for skill saws or chop saws.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#19

Blade recommendation

Bill Tindall

The blade I am recommending is a combination blade designed for use on a table saw. It is not a similar sized blade for a skill saw or chop saw, blades which have different hook angle specific for cross cutting.

One has to look with some diligence to find the correct blade. It will be a combination blade, 40T, and a kerf of about 1/16". I have bought them from CMT, Freud, Stihle, and Tenryu(poorest cut of the lot). They can be resharpened for about $10.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#20

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29

Barry Irby

Bill, I am wondering abut this. Is it the diameter o the blade or the thinness that reduces the kick back.

I need a good rip blade. I know you are advocating a combo blade but would the same thinking apply to a thin kerf rip blade?

What about horse power? Does an 8" blade inherently require more or less horse power? Perhaps the very thin kerf is only available on smaller blades and that would save a few horses?

Do any of the blades you are advocating provide a flat bottom cut? I have an ancient blade that cuts a flat bottom cut and I switch to it when I do splines on the corners of boxes, so it would be handy if the combo blade did that.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#21

answers

Bill Tindall

Is it the diameter o the blade or the thinness that reduces the kick back.......Both, see Tom D's post above. And I would say virtually eliminates not just reduces.

I need a good rip blade. I know you are advocating a combo blade but would the same thinking apply to a thin kerf rip blade? No experience with buying a similar blade for ripping. I rip all my 4/4 stuff on these combo blades, effortlessly. The person demoing the Grip-Tite rips miles of 4/4 stuff on these blades in his demos.

What about horse power? Does an 8" blade inherently require more or less horse power?....... You could run this blade with two squirrels. There is no detectable cutting resistance, which in itself promotes safety in cutting.

Do any of the blades you are advocating provide a flat bottom cut? Someone in the club makes splined boxes and he found a thin kerf flat bottomed blade, but I do not recall the brand. However, you could send any blade to a saw shop and have it flat ground for your needs.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#22

Physical differences, blade diameters

Gary Evans

I'm not a physicist, but what strikes me about the change to a smaller diameter blade is that tooth speed is going to be reduced proportionally. The teeth on a 7.5" blade would be traveling about 2/3's the speed of the teeth on the 10" blade for the same RPM. If the teeth are also proportionally smaller, then there would be less metal brushing the sides of the kerf at any particular instant. I would imagine less friction combined with slower speed would have something to do with the reduction in kickback.

Gary

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#23

your hypothesis supports my experience

Bill Tindall

There is imperceptible cutting force with these small thin blades. What ever the reason, they just don't throw pieces like a larger blade with big teeth. You can see it more dramatically when cutting small stuff. I have had small pieces shatter under the force of a normal 10" blade. Ripping off 1/8" strips with these blades, no problem. Cross cutting 1/8" thick stock, no problem.

In fact I first bought a small blade to only cut small stuff. But one day it was on the saw and I needed to cut bigger stuff. It did so effortlessly. So I just left it on the saw, where it, or one like it, has been for about 6 years. There blades have built numerous pieces of furniture, produced house trim, cut up plywood and what ever else came up. I do switch to a full sized blade for ripping 8/4 stock. The best of them, the CMT "Industrial" does not produce as smooth a cross cut as my best 10" cross cut blade. But rarely is a smooth cut important for much of my woodworking.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#24

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29

Grant Wilkinson

I've used a 6 1/2" x 24 tooth Freud Diablo for cutting pen blanks for a couple of years. I got it for its thin kerf, smaller even than 1/16", so that I could get more than one slim pen out of a standard blank. As others here have done, when I've had it on the saw, and had something else to cut, I simply left it one an did the cut. On my Ridgid table saw, there is no resistance at all. Now, with only 6 1/2", I'm limited to about 1 1/2" of cut, but that's much of my normal cutting anyway.

Re: Eliminating 2/3 of table saw injuries, for $29`

#25

Demonstration of the reduced kick back propesity

Bill Tindall


As they say on Mythbuster and Time Warp....don't try this at home.

After sawing part way through this piece I simply let it go. It sat in this position for five minutes not moving a bit. Then I turned the saw off and took the picture of the result. Had it been a ten inch blade the picture would have been this piece of wood shattering against the wall behind the saw. Actually I would have been reluctant to rip something this wide and short with a larger blade. A friend who refuses to try these small blades broke his hand ripping something this sized when it kicked back.