Re: This shows that SawStop tech will be effective
TomD
" "Most of the accidents don't happen in schools, the workplace or on job sites. Most of them happen to hobbyists 50 years of age and up, using high end cabinet and contractor's saws."
it's hard to argue that flesh sensing technology isn't going to make a significant positive impact on the damage done by table saw injuries to hobbyist woodworkers if it's implemented across the board."
Not really. The saw can have it disengaged, which will probably be necessary in certain cases. Or preferable. And then it will not be reconnected. I run my band saw without adjusting guard height, just leave it high. Normally I am standing in a area that looks like a large rack of rakes toppled. Keeps me sharp.
There is the issue of people using more dangerous tools to get around the costs, be they various alternatives, like the hideous bandsaw, or just old saw off craigs, that miss even the basic guards.
Then there is the issue of people being more daredevil in general, because at last they feel safe.
Plus you get people who will feel cool for using the old gear. The demographic will change to the people using saws being all about the resistance to government will, they will ride saws across parking lots ballanced on the spinning blade etc...
Accidents could rise if people are put off the tablesaw scene, go as suggested above, while the initial penetration of the good tech remains a small part of the market
"Whether that's a good idea or not is another issue, of course. But this data shows that objections on the basis of the technology not being effective really don't hold water."
I don't believe data for a second, it is all coming from self-interested parties. There is a huge gap between what the various sides are saying. I think we had a dust up on Handtools over whether to trust data. Well here is the poster boy case. One says 70 accidents a year, and some of it is tripping into tools, while the other says 3000 amputations. That may not be the exact case, but I have a hard time resisting telling the optimist "I told you so"
"For the record, I look at this issue as a public health matter. Even if the majority of injuries occur to people over 50, a significant portion of those people are still working, productive members of society. A table saw injury leads to costs related to the medical care delivered and the loss in productivity."
I think you are right. It isn't for those of us on the peak of the pinnacle, but for the broad Jerketariat, they are getting hurt by a product with a long history of mainming people. WHat is more. TSs are somewhat stupid there are a lot of better solutions. We live in a world of CNC.
"And even if the government wasn't going to mandate this, you can bet the insurance companies are going to be interested in pushing a similar action through because it will save them a lot of money."
Maybe. Insurance companies make money by selecting sets that minimize risk, and maximize premiums. Warren Buffet is the genius on their many artful aspects. Geiko was the original company to discover that one could easily charge teachers more than their risk indicated. The other side of the deal is to insure high risk people, but not pay out to them. Neither of these actually involves eliminating the risk. I have certainly never been asked what is in my shop by my agent, and if he only knew...