Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

Posts

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#26

Who's pushing this agenda?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

To me, that's the key question.

I think that if you take a slight trip back on the WABAC machine, you'll find that it's the insurance companies. In the celebrated case where a worker was awarded a million+ settlement against (I think) Ryobi, he wasn't the one who appealed the case and pushed for the award. It was the insurance carrier. The worker had admitted he screwed up and that it wasn't the saw's fault.

My ex-BIL has a cabinet shop. Years ago he was told by his city inspector he needed to have a fire door between his shop and the adjacent business sharing his building. He put off the inspector for several years. Finally the inspector had enough and called my BIL's insurance company. The agent made one call to my BIL and told him if a door wasn't installed that week his insurance was canceled. He got the door put in that day.

I need a new tablesaw, and my next one will be a SawStop contractor saw. For a couple health reasons, a saw accident for me would be catastrophic. If that one piece of technology will provide an additional level of protection, then it makes the difference for me. And, as an aside, I've been using a tablesaw without incident for 50 years.

My choice and only mine. I don't like ANYONE telling me what to do any more than anyone else.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#27

Moses Yoder

Re: I think the data is baloney( or another "B" wo

Moses Yoder

Those numbers do sound high, sounds like maybe Saw Stop had a Washington bean counter on the payroll. On the other hand, I clearly remember the guy we had running a saw who decided the blade was not that close to the edge of the guard and he could safely put his thumb underneath the guard. When the smoke cleared, the tip of his thumb was wedged in the front of the guard. We took a picture of it, but that was years ago so I don't have the pic to post or I would. Some people really are that stupid, hard to believe I know but I got witnesses. So I could kind of agree with making the Saw Stop mandatory for commercial wood shops. 2 of the 3 shops that build cabinets for us use Saw Stop saws and between the two shops they have kicked off 5 brakes this year so far. Hard to say how much money that saved their church; these shops are Amish, so no workmans comp, anyway that's how I understand it. The church pays their hospital bills.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#28

Moses Yoder

Re: Keeping it in perspective

Moses Yoder

So I should stop voting, just because I only have one vote?

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#29

Re: Are most saw accidents blade cuts?

Bob Lang

I've written a bunch about this topic on the Popular Woodworking Editor's Blog. A search on "Table Saw Safety" will lead you to them.

Kickback injuries that don't involve blade contact are about one-third of reported injuries. Kickback that takes the hand into the blade is about another third. The remainder are instances where the operator loses track of where his/her hand is, either through lack of attention or some other distraction and moves it into the spinning saw blade. In about 30% of reported injuries, the guard is in place.

The statistics and data are available from the CPSC website, under the FOIA library, and make for some interesting reading.

Most of the accidents don't happen in schools, the workplace or on job sites. Most of them happen to hobbyists 50 years of age and up, using high end cabinet and contractor's saws.

Bob Lang

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#30

Re: It's a done deal (but we don't know it)

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Interesting points Gary,and I would have to agree to that your probably right. A person can't argue with good, clean logic.

Ray

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#31

Re: I think the data is baloney( or another "B" wo

TomD

I have had the chance to teach some guys who work in cabinet shops. They turned out to learn more which was impressive, but often their work had not prepared them for much, and since they came at it from a 9-5 perspective of the jobsite will provide the answers, they didn't have much information to grow on. I think what these shops need is very different than what a home enthusiast shop needs. The person who is just a weekend warrior and buys the 100 dollar saws, may really be ignorant. Unfortunately, there seems to be some question whether the cheap saw can make the jump to this technology.

But yeah, if I ran a shop, I would maybe be interested in this tech. In the guitar realm, my preference would be to have a workstation for every single step, and the saws would only make one kind of cut, and the blade would not be anywhere accessible.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#32

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

TomD

After reading through some of the regulatory stuff, I have to admit that this move does not seem that out of whack. Basically there is a common product, that is really highly unsafe when used by average users, and even as commonly used by high end users. There is a safe way of using this tool, but it just doesn't happen to be the way the tool is actually used. And the users prefer a professional model that is very loose on education or other requirements to set up a business, or use these tools. There is a fairly significant new technology available to lesson some of the exposure. In most fields this would be a regulatory no-brainer. Just glad I already have my 2 Beavers, and one Inca.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#34

This shows that SawStop tech will be effective

wilbur

"Kickback injuries that don't involve blade contact are about one-third of reported injuries. Kickback that takes the hand into the blade is about another third. The remainder are instances where the operator loses track of where his/her hand is, either through lack of attention or some other distraction and moves it into the spinning saw blade."

If this is the case, then flesh sensing technology will reduce 2/3 of all table saw accidents to very small lacerations, as opposed to amputations. And given this:

"Most of the accidents don't happen in schools, the workplace or on job sites. Most of them happen to hobbyists 50 years of age and up, using high end cabinet and contractor's saws."

it's hard to argue that flesh sensing technology isn't going to make a significant positive impact on the damage done by table saw injuries to hobbyist woodworkers if it's implemented across the board.

Whether that's a good idea or not is another issue, of course. But this data shows that objections on the basis of the technology not being effective really don't hold water.

For the record, I look at this issue as a public health matter. Even if the majority of injuries occur to people over 50, a significant portion of those people are still working, productive members of society. A table saw injury leads to costs related to the medical care delivered and the loss in productivity. And even if the government wasn't going to mandate this, you can bet the insurance companies are going to be interested in pushing a similar action through because it will save them a lot of money.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#35

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Dave Paine

A topic which many people have strong feelings, one way or another. A topic more than capable of starting a fight in a bar.

I personally feel the ruling would be an unwelcome and expensive intrusion in this case. I could still injure myself on my mitre saw, portable saw, band saw or even a hand saw, all of which I also own. I am happy that I purchased my new table saw last year. I could have purchased a Saw Stop. I chose another brand. We should be left to make our own choices.

Two of my own injuries which come to mind involved a screwdriver slipping off a screw and creating a deep cut in the other hand and a drill bit (stationary at the time) which I managed to impale in my other hand.

How many people have injured themselves with kitchen knives, sometimes seriously.

We cannot always protect ourselves from every operation. The operator has to also be part of a sage operation.

I would expect a table saw related accident to be caused by myself rather than others.

If this law is passed, it is only a matter of time until the technology does not work for whatever reason, and then another interesting lawsuit may happen.

I think the flesh sensing technology is interesting, but it deserves to find its own place in the market and not forced on users by law.

I believe in some safety related laws, such as the mentioned car seat belts and air bags, since many accidents are caused by others.

I am not fond of some safety related laws meant to protect people from themselves. I purchased a snow blower and find some of the safety related interlocks more than a hassle in operating the machine.

I purchased some replacement garage door openers which required the light beams to be installed and "seeing" each other. These would have protruded at the floor level and been a significant tripping hazard for my garage. I ended up installing the beam a few inches apart on the roof, well away from any tripping hazard. In my case I do not have children and do not use the garage for cars, so I am always at the switch and aware of the location of my dog.

I think of the safety design for pill containers, and how these become so difficult for seniors to open. It is not easy to have one design which works for everyone.

I have not read the details of the proposed legislation, so I am not sure if it has to be flesh sensing at the blade, or proximity detection like the Whirlwind other technology which is built into a guard. I like the latter not destroying the blade, and working will any blade.

If I recall the Saw Stop technology can be turned off e.g., for wet wood.

I expect some users would end up turning this off and so would be an expensive "feature" which they may not use.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#36

It used to not bother me...

John in NM

But more and more the blithe acceptance of intrusive regulation all in the name of safety as perceived by people with little or no experience in the field to which they intrude is irritating. Put in the context with so many other things that I do not consider to be within any government's purview, as you have done, makes it much more clear to me.

I accept the reality of the situation, the do gooding that I find so foolish is inevitable, but I do reserve the right to say that it is wrong

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#37

I agree...

John in NM

It is highly unlikely that a CPSC ruling will ever carry effective weight in the ownership or sale of secondhand machines. Our government will simply never have the efficiency to succeed in organizing a retro active enforcement over something like this. Even pro shops I've worked in managed to stay under the OSHA radar by simply having few enough accidents to pass un-noticed.

Should they mandate the technology for new saw sales, pre-mandate saws will increase in desirability and to some degree value (relative to current values).

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#38

Re: This shows that SawStop tech will be effective

TomD

" "Most of the accidents don't happen in schools, the workplace or on job sites. Most of them happen to hobbyists 50 years of age and up, using high end cabinet and contractor's saws."

it's hard to argue that flesh sensing technology isn't going to make a significant positive impact on the damage done by table saw injuries to hobbyist woodworkers if it's implemented across the board."

Not really. The saw can have it disengaged, which will probably be necessary in certain cases. Or preferable. And then it will not be reconnected. I run my band saw without adjusting guard height, just leave it high. Normally I am standing in a area that looks like a large rack of rakes toppled. Keeps me sharp.

There is the issue of people using more dangerous tools to get around the costs, be they various alternatives, like the hideous bandsaw, or just old saw off craigs, that miss even the basic guards.

Then there is the issue of people being more daredevil in general, because at last they feel safe.

Plus you get people who will feel cool for using the old gear. The demographic will change to the people using saws being all about the resistance to government will, they will ride saws across parking lots ballanced on the spinning blade etc...

Accidents could rise if people are put off the tablesaw scene, go as suggested above, while the initial penetration of the good tech remains a small part of the market

"Whether that's a good idea or not is another issue, of course. But this data shows that objections on the basis of the technology not being effective really don't hold water."

I don't believe data for a second, it is all coming from self-interested parties. There is a huge gap between what the various sides are saying. I think we had a dust up on Handtools over whether to trust data. Well here is the poster boy case. One says 70 accidents a year, and some of it is tripping into tools, while the other says 3000 amputations. That may not be the exact case, but I have a hard time resisting telling the optimist "I told you so"

"For the record, I look at this issue as a public health matter. Even if the majority of injuries occur to people over 50, a significant portion of those people are still working, productive members of society. A table saw injury leads to costs related to the medical care delivered and the loss in productivity."

I think you are right. It isn't for those of us on the peak of the pinnacle, but for the broad Jerketariat, they are getting hurt by a product with a long history of mainming people. WHat is more. TSs are somewhat stupid there are a lot of better solutions. We live in a world of CNC.

"And even if the government wasn't going to mandate this, you can bet the insurance companies are going to be interested in pushing a similar action through because it will save them a lot of money."

Maybe. Insurance companies make money by selecting sets that minimize risk, and maximize premiums. Warren Buffet is the genius on their many artful aspects. Geiko was the original company to discover that one could easily charge teachers more than their risk indicated. The other side of the deal is to insure high risk people, but not pay out to them. Neither of these actually involves eliminating the risk. I have certainly never been asked what is in my shop by my agent, and if he only knew...

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#39

Re: This shows that SawStop tech will be effective

wilbur

"I don't believe data for a second, it is all coming from self-interested parties."

In this case, the accident data is coming from the National Electronic Injury Surveillance System. I don't see how this is a self-interested party.

As far as whether this technology will be effective, even if you include the people who disengage the sensor and forget to reengage it, the OWMM crowd, and the ones who are being daredevils, cheap, or stupid, I have a really hard time believing that will cover the 67% of table saw accidents that involve some form of blade contact.

Full disclosure: I have a 1940's era bandsaw that I think is cool. I also use the blade guard all the time (and I even spent time to fix it up as it was broken when I got the bandsaw) and I keep the area around my bandsaw clean and tidy.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#40

Re: Keith - the difference between me and you

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

is that I don't care if you want and use a Sawstop. However you feel you must make me use one even if I don't agree-- Why do you feel this is right? I may decide to use a manual push mower as they are MUCH safer than a power mower- but do I have the right to make you use one? This is a fundamental difference in our thinking.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#41

No Larry, I hope nobody thinks they can pry

Keith Newton

Your saw or mine from our hands. There are many millions of saws out there for those like us who feel we are bullet proof, or impervious to all injuries relative to normal sawing accidents.

However, there are more out there in this day in time, who use these saws, that have no idea what they are doing, and maybe this is their first job, and they really need this job to feed their kids. They may be afraid of loosing this job, even though it doesn't pay enough to meet their expenses, they really have to work long and hard at long repetition, until BAM, their life has changed."

I don't know about you my friend, but as a self employed woodworker, I have always been in the highest insurance bracket, never qualifying for a group policy. Typically expecting a rate hike of 20 ~ 30% per year, because there are a lot of accidents with these tools.

I have to change policies on a fairly regular basis, but because I have had few claims, I can still get coverage, but the deductions go higher, and so do the primeums even if I never use it. Last time I changed it was $1250 per month for just me, with hardly any claims for years.

If someone who has never used a TS before looses a hand, it affects my rate whether they have insurance or not. The hospitals get their money, either way. We the insured, or we the tax-payer pay one way or the other. Why wouldn't you want those poor people trying to eek out an exsistance to have this protection? It will cost you more in the long run, when there are disability claims that can be prevented by this simple device.

Nobody is going to take away YOUR saw and make you use this, anymore than they are going to take away your guns, no matter what the NRA, or your favorite TV distortation station tells you.

Eventually, there will be a insurance premium advantage to having one of these saws, which will pay for the difference in a few years, and those of us from the old world, will wish we had been given the option when we bought our trusty saws.

I may be wrong, and it wouldn't be the first time, but my crystal ball tells me.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#42

Well, it does sound reasonable...

John in NM

Until you remember that insurance premiums never go down :D

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#43

Re:  Justification???

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

In the first place I doubt the insurance premium would go down - Do they currently give discounts based on the machines you have? Since all the old machines will still be in use they would certainly not do what you wish until all those are no longer in use (maybe pass another law outlawing them?), definitely not in your lifetime - probably never. The justification you use for wanting the government to regulate the saws could be used in many ways. For instance maybe they should pass a law that says no one can paint their house pink - since it devalues the property next door. Or sell fast foods since they contribute to obesity causing my life insurance to be more costly. Also outlaw all driving except for necessary tasks. That would certainly save me money as both gasoline and car insurance would be reduced - right? The list could (and probably will) go on and on as long as people believe they have the right to tell others how to live. It is very easy for a few or group of people to want to regulate one thing - that they don't like, until the next regulation affects their life in a way they don't like. As I said I am against all government interference in our lives. I still stand by my previous statements.