Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

Posts

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Yes, folks, it's time again to register your opinions on yet another topic of importance to woodworkers. Six times a year, we post these "Ides" surveys and publish the results in our "News & Views" column in Woodworker West magazine.

This month's topic is a timely one. As most of you know, there is a major deliberation taking place at the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) regarding mandating the use of flesh-sensing technology on tablesaws sold in the US. The issue is now coming to a head, as the deadline for public comment is December 12, 2011. The full story can be found in the Federal Register.

We've had numerous discussions on this matter over the years, the most recent being this one back in October. Whether or not you participated in that discussion, I look forward to hearing your thoughts. Do you think that the government should mandate flesh-sensing technology on tablesaws? Would such a ruling be an unwelcome intrusion on woodworkers' freedom of choice, or would it be a justifiable regulation in the public interest, similar in scope and effect to mandatory seat belts and air bags in new vehicles in this country? Does the fact that Saw Stop owns the only patents on this technology as applied to tablesaws enter into the equation? What other pros and cons enter the equation?

If you'd like to register a formal comment to the CPSC, go to http://www.regulations.gov/#!submitComment;D=CPSC-2011-0074-0001 .

Thanks for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host


Comment to the CPSC

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#2

JL

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

JL

Do you think that the government should mandate flesh-sensing technology on tablesaws?

I believe the government should mandate safety devices - not necessarily flesh sensing technology.

Would such a ruling be an unwelcome intrusion on woodworkers' freedom of choice, or would it be a justifiable regulation in the public interest, similar in scope and effect to mandatory seat belts and air bags in new vehicles in this country?

Good question - you don't have to have a table saw. There are other saws (band saws, circular saws, etc.) out there. But where do you draw the line? Modern woodworking deals with inherently dangerous tools (as does hand tool woodworking). Can you protect against all of them? I've cut myself on drawknives, chisels, gouges, etc. Are the regulations going to cover all tools? Just power tools? Just dangerous power tools?? I believe it is somewhat an unwelcome intrusion. I can see where it might be justified in learning environments or "public" environments.

Does the fact that Saw Stop owns the only patents on this technology as applied to tablesaws enter into the equation?

Absolutely. I'm all for safety - I just would prefer alternatives. A decent riving knife and a decent blade guard. Kickback happens - so I am against anti-kickback pawls.

What other pros and cons enter the equation?

You should ideally have a choice. You should be able to say - I would like the following safety features .... Let the market drive the development.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#3

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My impression has been that the injuries from table saw use have come mainly from unguarded saws, coupled with poor work practices. Regulation can do nothing about poor work practices, nor can it cause people not to remove guards.

Your reference to automotive safety devices is quite apt: if riving knives and blade guards are seatbelts - excellent safety devices that require intelligent action by the user to be safe - then the SawStop technology is an air bag - a device that protects even the lazy user.

I actively dislike air bags (although I've never had one go off in my face, so it may be an irrational dislike); but I was raised to put on my seat belt every time, so I see air bags as less necessary for me (and my family and passengers; I won't leave the parking place until everyone's belted in).

I would prefer not to see the air bag philosophy extended to tablesaws.

Presumably, if the CPSC mandates a performance standard, other inventors will come up with alternatives to the SawStop in time, thus diffusing this apparent unfair advantage to one company; but, for the moment, it will make that company king in the tablesaw field, controlling every other manufacturer's choices.

My son makes the point, from his observations, that Volvo drivers are often significantly less safe in their driving habits, because they believe they're driving safe cars that will protect them. One of my concerns about the SawStop is that it will foster unsafe use practices because the consequences of poor practices will be minimized.

And everything fails: who will lose the lawsuit when the SawStop (or similar) module fries unnoticed, and the user, having done something stupid, pays the price for stupidity?

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Moses Yoder

Do you think that the government should mandate flesh-sensing technology on tablesaws?

I do not believe the govenment should be in charge of the safety of the people. To mandate flesh sensing technology on table saws would mean the govenment should also outlaw soda and mandate cars that drive themselves so no on gets hurt. Then they would also have to shut down all fast food places and mandate how many calories of what food group we eat each day. I have used a table saw about 30 years now, normally with standard guards in place, and have never cut myself on a table saw. I have cut myself with a knife though, maybe they should outlaw knives. I have a Powermatic 66 table saw, with no flesh sensing technology, that I expect will last me the rest of my life.

Would such a ruling be an unwelcome intrusion on woodworkers' freedom of choice, or would it be a justifiable regulation in the public interest, similar in scope and effect to mandatory seat belts and air bags in new vehicles in this country?

Mandating safety through the government is a violation of our personal freedom, plus it ruins natural selection. In Michigan, the goverment has ruled that all motorcycle drivers wear helmets. In natural selection, the stupid people would not wear helmets and thus would die if an accident occured. This would prevent them from breeding. By forcing everyone to wear helmets, the government prevents the stupid people from dying off, enabling them to breed further stupid generations.

Does the fact that Saw Stop owns the only patents on this technology as applied to tablesaws enter into the equation?

The patents do enter into the equation, because the goverment is essentially creating a monopoly if it mandates that technology.

What other pros and cons enter the equation?

Government mandated safety measures mean I no longer have to take care of myself, the government is responsible for doing so.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#5

Re:mandating the use of flesh-sensing technology

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Do you think that the government should mandate flesh-sensing technology on tablesaws?

Mandate?, no! I truly believe we have more important things to worry about in this country.

Would such a ruling be an unwelcome intrusion on woodworkers' freedom of choice, or would it be a justifiable regulation in the public interest, similar in scope and effect to mandatory seat belts and air bags in new vehicles in this country?

Absolutely! Tablesaws, drills, even a simple screwdriver can't inflict an injure. Driving a car is one thing, operating a tablesaw in my home is another. People have been driving cars for 100+ yrs., tablesaws date back to the 16th -17th century. Cars have gotten a lot faster but the tablesaw remains relatively the same. So where's the logic? Blade gaurds, riving knives, sharp blades, and knowing how to use any power tool properly is the answer. Even then, accidents happen. Where do we draw the line?!

Does the fact that Saw Stop owns the only patents on this technology as applied to tablesaws enter into the equation? What other pros and cons enter the equation?

Absolutely! I think the Saw Stop feature is fantastic, but, as someone else said, I think it would lead to a false sense of security, somewhat. Now, if Saw Stop wanted to sell that technology or offer an aftermarket type product, then I would welcome that option from any manufacturer. I still can't justify a product and it's cost when good ole' common sense and learning how to operate things properly seems more logical. Most, if not all power tools, and hand tools, come with warnings and such. Sorry, the user must take responsibilty and know the risks. What about the risks of saw dust inhalation? What about the risk of wood chips flying into a persons eyes? What next, a US inspector coming into my home any making sure I'm using my Phillips screwdriver properly?! If I want to use it as an ice pick, then it's my choice and my risk. Right? :D

Good topic, I look forward to other posts and seeing what happens with the Consumer Product Safety Commission.

My 2 cents worth,

Ray

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#6

It's a done deal (but we don't know it)

Gary Smyth

Mandate or no mandate, the guy has a better mousetrap. He tried to go through the manufacturers and they collectively tossed his butt out. What to do? First he built the saw on his own. Secondly the government got wind.

I see little difference in legislating safety concerning flesh sensing than that enacted concerning cigarettes, drivers licenses, prescriptions, automatic weapons, armor piercing rounds, air bags and hundreds of other “safety” items. As with these, you don’t have to like it, but flesh sensing legislation will happen. If the TOTAL community of woodworkers is balanced against the 10% of the health industry, wives, mothers, and any other “safety conscious” group. The answer is a forgone loss for those without flesh sensing technology.

The patent for Saw Stop will eventually expire and I’ll bet one whole dollar to one of you naysayers that when it does, a new saw without “flesh sensing” from any manufacturer will not exist. The liability for not doing it will be too high. Remember the Lamello biscuit joiner, The Fein Multitool, Ansco photo film, Buick’s Dynaflow automatic transmissions, Xerox's Graphical User Interface? Manufacturers are not stupid. They know a better product, they just don’t want to pay the inventor. Remember, invention is the mother of thievery.

So like it or not, it will happen and all of the bitchen and moanin won’t affect a thing in the final outcome. The only concern we all have is how long will we have before what most of us have becomes either obsolete or outlawed. The investment you have made for a table saw that is not a Saw Stop has an end date.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#7

Amen.


Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#8

Moses Yoder

Re: 13th amendment

Moses Yoder

AMENDMENT XIII

Passed by Congress January 31, 1865. Ratified December 6, 1865.

Note: A portion of Article IV, section 2, of the Constitution was superseded by the 13th amendment.

Section 1.

Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.


I was just reading the bill of rights and noticed it would be illegal to force people to only use table saws guarded with flesh sensing technology because it would in effect make them a slave of the state. Slavery was abolished in 1865.

Amendment IV

The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.


The 4th amendment, on the Bill of Rights, would prevent the government from searching my house without probable cause. So if they then end up outlawing saws without this type of guard, as someone else suggested, they would not have the right to search my house and take my saw without "probable cause".

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#9

I Reckon You Are Right


Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#10

Re: It's a done deal (but we don't know it)

Charlie Lenz

Yeah, if your looking for a way to kill off woodworking for alot of folks, and for the makeing the SawStop technology mandatory would be the way to do it. Most folks don't have that kind of money to spend on a table saw, I know I sure don't. I also think it would also trickle into lost sales for the retailers and even stores closeing with less woodworkers being around. A few years ago the manufacturers started puting guards on wood lathes, and it drove the prices for them way up. I would guess that wood lathe sales droped sharply after that because you don't see new wood lathes with guards on them anymore. Also if SawStop got their way, where would it end ? If SawStop wins it won't be because the people want it, it will be because someone knows someone in Washington.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#11

I think the data is baloney( or another "B" word)

Bill Tindall

The inventor of Saw Stop, who I previously had no ill will toward, has a missive in the recent Woodshop news. In it he claims that the government claims that there are 40,000 emergency room trips each year resulting from table saw accidents at an average cost of $50,000 per accident. Thus, the total yearly cost of table saw accidents is $2 billion dollars! I just don't believe these numbers.

But if this is the kind of baloney the government is basing their ever increasing intrusions on it is no wonder we got to where we are. Just today I learned of this boondoggle, plus the quest by the government to control what my children eat for lunch and a proposed ban of children operating tractors on a farm, obviously proposed by someone that never lived on a farm, or hell, may never have been out of Washington.

For you city dwellers that think this tractor thing is a fine idea I drove a tractor by age 10, maybe before. The first tractor job was driving in a straight line across a level field at 1 MPH while my father loaded hay on the trailing wagon. It involved holding the steering wheel steady and pushing on the clutch when I got to the end of the row. As I got older and more experienced my tractor driving got more complex. My progress was controlled by my father as it should be, not some Washington desk jockey with the philosophy that the government is a more responsible parent. Oh, and the driver ed teacher loved to get farm kids for students. Much less stress! Learning to drive an automatic took a few minutes to get used to but the rest was easier than the two ton farm truck.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#12

Are most saw accidents blade cuts?

Bill Tindall

In my limited experience the injuries my acquaintances have had were from kick back incidents, something the blade stopping feature does not prevent.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#13

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

TomD

I'm against making the SS feature mandatory. Government is not made up of woodworkers, and they are unlikely to consult with an unbiased segment in developing regulations. At most they should mandate disclosure, and leave the determination of safety features up to individuals.

Sticking your fingers in the saw blade is about as sensible as being run over by your own car. The real risk factors for US table saw use are the poor guards, poor splinters, and the fact that while the domestic market has moved away from making everything out of panel products, the standard saw continues to be designed for that purpose, and too deep to safely access. This latter problem is worsened by the addition of bulky fence systems to saws not designed to carry them. Kludgy US saws are the bigger problem.

Another US/amateur thing, is to use tablesaws far more broadly that safe practices allow. The saw for everything crowd pushes the saw into things it may not be designed to do. Since I have an uncounted number of saws in my shop, I never have to use a saw for something it is not safely able to handle. I feel the saw represents zero risk to me. Perhaps people who want to push their saws should consider something like SS, but that should be a choice, not some generalization.

The US is all about the quick technology fix. This product area is developing like bike helmets back in the 70s, where one manufacturer lobbied for mandatory adoption of bike helmets, even though the helmets adopted were woefully inadequate. I noticed that there are now some TS users who think that TSs are completely unsafe unless used with an SS, as though there was ever any reason to get one's hands in the blade in the first place. This also parallels the bike example, where generations of users now grow up thinking that riding a bike at jogging speeds is suicidal without a helmet.

The woodworking industry not bought and paid for by SS should consider the helmet example. While you will never get any agreement on this subject, I think it is true that helmets: A) led to more accidents in many jurisdictions, and; B) led to many people shying away from cycling, in large percentages. The explanation behind these paradoxical effects is that people wearing helmets and drivers near them, both feel more confident in their safety, leading to other accidents. Also, while helmets are certainly capable of reducing the effects of accidents, and making cycling safer, many participants took the need to wear them as evidence that cycling was an unreasonably dangerous activity. There are parallels in woodworking.

I personal follow a more euro approach to my TS use, and feel that is a better model than the US mousetrap one. Hand injuries can be devastating at a number of levels, and I do not take that risk lightly. But I just think the table saw budget should be divided up among solutions for better saws, and safety gear, other than SS. I know I don't need one, and I wonder whether those who use a power feed in a factory setting need them. etc...

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#14

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

TomD

"The patents do enter into the equation, because the goverment is essentially creating a monopoly if it mandates that technology."

That could be solved but dating the legislation to the patent expiry date, or more sensibly just ensuring it is licensed.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#15

Re: It's a done deal (but we don't know it)

TomD

"The only concern we all have is how long will we have before what most of us have becomes either obsolete or outlawed. The investment you have made for a table saw that is not a Saw Stop has an end date.

CPSC won't affect the use of old saws. Not sure what it would mean for US second hand sales.

I can see your point on adoption by other makers. You could well be right, though... Far better safety gear has been available for tables saws for decades, and far better saw designs. Yet US manufacturers have avoided all that stuff, so why they would jump in with both feet for something that triggers a 200 dollar repair bill... Not sure.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#16

Re: "Now is wood twixt gut and bladder interposed"

TomD

+1

I also find that a heck of a lot more terrifying. You can live without a hand a lot more easily that with a 2x4 through the belly button.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#17

Re: It's a done deal ( I don't think so )

Charlie Lenz

I also feel that it's disgusting that a company here in the USA that doesn't want to support American manufacturing jobs ( the trades ), but wants to force it down the American trades throats, and everyone else in this country. The saws are made in Taiwan. If I was to spend that kind of money on a table saw, it would be an American made Delta Unisaw.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#18

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Do you think that the government should mandate flesh-sensing technology on tablesaws?

In my opinion we would be far better off if the government did just what it was designed to do in the constitution. That is ONLY maintain a military for protection and set rules for interstate commerce. I do not know where the idea came from that the federal government should make decisions for our safety anywhere or anytime. As my father explained to me about 60 or so years ago, we have (had) the freedom to swing our fists as far as we want as long as we don't harm anyone else. NO - the government should not mandate flesh-sensing technology.

Would such a ruling be an unwelcome intrusion on woodworkers' freedom of choice, or would it be a justifiable regulation in the public interest, similar in scope and effect to mandatory seat belts and air bags in new vehicles in this country?

As to seat belts and air bags - the only reason Indiana has a seat belt law is that the Automobile manufactures were threatened by the Federal government several years ago that they would be forced to install an automatic restraint or air bags on all new vehicles if a certain number of states did not pass a mandatory seat belt law. The manufactures then threatened Indiana and several other states that did business with them to pass the law or loose the business. The only person that is harmed if I don't wear a seat belt is me - therefore where is the justification to force me to wear one?

Does the fact that Saw Stop owns the only patents on this technology as applied to tablesaws enter into the equation?

Yes and no, I don't believe the government should have the power to force any safeguards on a person purchasing a saw, even if it added no cost to the saw. The fact that Saw Stop is the sole provider only makes it worse as they are influencing the decision for a huge profit.

What other pros and cons enter the equation?

I think it is up to us as woodworkers to determine what safety features we want and or use. Manufactures will provide anything we want if we are willing to pay for it. The flesh sensing technology is available to anyone today if they want it and are willing to pay for it, leave the rest of us alone.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#19

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Merle

Much of this has already been stated better by others, but I feel the need to add my voice to those opposed to more governmental control of my life.

1. You can't fix stupid and to me that is what the government is attempting with this.

2. I believe in the free market system. Wasn't that one of the basic premises of this country? Therefore, let the buyers decide what has value to them and that they are willing to purchase.

3. I see the SS as similar to having a safety on a handgun. Some guns have them and others don't. Do we want the government to decide that all guns must have a safety? I don't because I believe every gun's safety is located between the ears of the user. (see #1 above)

4. We all know that people drown in water every year. Will the mandatory use of PFD's be required for all people entering the water? In my bath tub in case I feint???

5. "That government is best which governs least." has been attributed to Thomas Jefferson, Henry David Thoreau or John Adams. It seems that nobody knows for sure, but it was most certainly a very wise person.

6. "A government big enough to give you everything you want, is big enough to take away everything you have." Thomas Jefferson I think we all want safety, but at what price?

Sorry for the rant and I hope that I was not too political.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#20

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

AZ in Colorado Springs

Hello Ellis and everyone

As I understand it (I do not own a sawstop and have never used one but I have seen it demonstrated a few times) the sawstop technology does not detect flesh. It senses changes in voltage and or conductance. Hence, the misfires due to wet wood. It can imply the presence of flesh and prevent amputations if flesh is in fact present, and that is a good thing.

Lawyers, for the most part, argue others' cases and take a share of the profit or damages, depending on the case they are arguing. The irony here is that the lawyer actually produced a new product, but failed at marketing and is pursuing government regulation to serve his cause.

I do not agree that the CPSC should mandate a flesh-sensing standard of performance for table saws, for several reasons:

- unlike seat belts, they would (I believe) raise the cost of saws by a substantial proportion

- there are currently safeguards such as blade guards and riving knives available in the market place, produced for a reasonable cost

- I've not seen evidence that table saw injuries which could be prevented by flesh-sensing technologies are of epidemic proportions; subjecting the entire population of woodworkers to the added costs of saw-stop-type tables, and the additional cost for blades and cartridges in the case of misfires, because of a guy like Mr Osorio, is unjustified.

- transportation by automobiles is a very common experience and the costs of development, and scale of economy in manufacturing seat belts andair bags is spread over a larger cutomer base

- the hazards which seat belts and air bags defend against are unsafe drivers on the road; operating a table saw, on the other hand, is a more solitary experience

Would such a rule infringe on freedom of choice? Sure -- while Gass's technology is patented in the US, there likely will be poorly performing knock-offs manufactured overseas and made available to hobbyist woodworkers at costs they can afford, but providing machines they cannot live with.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#21

Keeping it in perspective

Gary Smyth

This is not a solution based on personal freedoms. It has nothing to do with that. If you think so you are completely missing the way politics and legislation works.

A quick story and a life lesson

Several several, years ago when I worked at a college, Senior nuns from all over the world converged at that location for an international conference on the state of the future of sisters in the Catholic Church. For four days they met in all manner of forums and discussed all manner of problems, situations, desires, and politics within their orders and the church as a whole. At the end they voted and made a list of decisions they made and headed back to their respective locations where the intention was to present the list to someone high in the Vatican -- Bishop or Cardinal.

When they got back to their parishes, the church made it their business to have some of the newest, lowest ranking priests reject thier proposals. None of the decisions the high ranking sisters agreed on made a bit of difference. You see, what they forgot was that they had little leverage. In the hierarchy of the Catholic church of that time, any priest in the church could overrule any sister.

Life lesson: Don’t assume that because a group has a collective opinion within that group that it will mean anything in the grand scheme of a separate but more powerful agenda.

So it is with woodworkers and the flesh sensing question. We can spit and spew and tell people what we want and how we won’t stand for the infringement on our trade, or hobby and personal choices. It’s all for naught. We don’t have the numbers for leverage. Even the lowest (or highest)

ranking Congressman or woman is not going to fight a battle for woodworkers if Congressional polls indicate a greater number of people with differing opinions want something else. Just saying.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#22

I'm not sure I've ever seen this...

John in NM

Usually the forum owners/admin discourage such discussions :D :D :D

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#23

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

TomD

"The only person that is harmed if I don't wear a seat belt is me - therefore where is the justification to force me to wear one"

I think the justification is that seat belts help the driver remain in control of the car, which is an issue that affects third parties and possible children in the car. They also stop injuries caused by ballistic bodies. However in my home jurisdiction they just passed the laws on a big brother basis, and did not bother to make an argument that was more restricted in nature.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#24

Re: Keeping it in perspective

TomD

That's politics 101, but in fact the number of woodworkers in the US seems huge. Who is pushing this agenda in a convincing way? One guy with a paycheck at stake? Do the HMOs, and hospitals actually want to reduce the amount of surgery they do, so long as it is in the calculation somehow. No answers from me. But simply stating that the weak tend to give way to the strong, doesn't get us very far without some knowledge of the players.

This could be interesting some time. As it stands woodworkers are mostly untouched by politics. No NRA to represent us. Could get interesting.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#25

I'd like to see a show of mangled hands.

Keith Newton

After forty years, I still have all ten, but I still remember younger times holding my hands up in front of my face, so I could see if they were still there. I have to admit that I have been lucky.

I have taken a coworker to the emergency room, and have several other friends who have lost parts to the beast. I would imagine, if you could put what it cost them on a scale against the cost of this tool, it would seem cheaper to just buy the tool, not to mention the pain and inconvienence.

I am all for new saws being required to have it. I have no worries about the government coming to take away any of the three that I currently own. It is unrealistic to expect a novice to know how to avoid all possible ways for a TS to get them.