Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

Posts

Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#1

Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

Charles Jackson III

I am going to build me a 12x18 shed on a slab on grade foundation. I am wondering what next tool buys should be. I have a 10'' Unisaw, 9'' DeWalt Radial Arm Saw, 13'' Delta Benchtop Planer, Steel City Benchtop Mortiser, and a Jet DC1100 Dust Collector. I am looking at adding a 6'' Jointer, 14'' Bandsaw, and a 15'' Floor Model Drill Press. I am wondering are these good choices.

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#2

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I take it your question is related to what tools would be good next steps in building up your shop toolkit, not what you need to build the shed.

The classic answer, and worth weighing, is what's frustrating you right now with your existing tools? That is, what processes do you find yourself not being able to do well that can be ascribed to limitations in your tools?

I've never much used a jointer, but I have hand planes for that purpose. On the other hand, I'm ever so glad that I bought a bandsaw some years back; the number of uses seems endless.

And I'm right glad I have a drill press.

So if I were restocking my shop, those would be my priorities.

But your needs are your own; not necessarily mine.

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#3

JL

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have

JL

The answer is - it depends.

If you are working with rough lumber a lot, I would consider an 8" jointer rather than a 6" - but I would say the jointer would be a valuable tool for your "arsenal".

I use a band saw a lot. Good for cutting curves, good for resawing, good for general sawing. If you were to get something like the 14" Rikon - you would have decent resaw capabilities.

Drill press is a valuable tool - I use mine for "precision" drilling. I can set angles on my angle board and get the correct angles for a lot of things.

Your choice of tool depends on what you really need. I would agree with Bill that a decent band saw with a good resaw capability might be the best choice. But I still would think about a jointer.

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#4

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have

Charles Jackson III

Yes its related to building up my shop toolkit. I have the tools to build the new shop. I really dont like hand jointing even thou I have hand planes. I guess the reason I need a jointer is because I buy my lumber rough.

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#5

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have

Charles Jackson III

Since I hang out at OWWM I dont got hook on Old Woodworking Machines :)

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#6

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

Is this 12x18 shed going to be your shop? Are you expecting to fit all of these tools in that space and be able to work? Or is the shed just a project that will use the tools to create? I'm spoiled from having a big barn for a shop, but I remember being in a one-car garage and there was never enough space.

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#7

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have

Charlie Lenz

A drill press is a must in my shop, not only for drilling, but I often have used it for drum sanding for curves, and a wire wheel to remove rust on some parts such as bolts, etc. I have a Bandsaw that gets used occasionally, but not much. I've had a couple of Jointers, 4" and 6" that I never used, so I sold them, and have no plans of ever buying another. But as Bill says, buy what YOU will use, only you will know that.

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#8

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have

Charles Jackson III

Its going to be my new shop.

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#9

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have

Howard Norman

I would say an 8" jointer would be my first purchase if I were in your shoes. Followed by a bandsaw and a drill press. But as others have said this is very personal and your needs my not follow any of the rest of us.

12x18' is not a large area for a wood working shop so I would recommend that most of the larger pieces of equipment be put on mobile platforms so that they can be moved around easily.

howard

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#10

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have

Barry Irby

Charles, My shop is 14 by 22' I think. Its small enough to be a curse but large enough I can't bring myself to enlarge it. Its a hobby shop and I do everything in there from building small boxes like jewelry boxes to parts for decks. If you have the space and money I would strongly recommend you make your shop bigger. Not sure it would add that much cost but it would sure make life more pleasant. In my shop there is a garage door at one end and the TS sits about five feet inside the door. That leaves enough room to bring in a 16' board and rip it with the door open. For most furniture projects I don't have to open the door as a five foot rip is usually enough. The width of the shop is a constraint as well. It is difficult to break down plywood in the shop. I have a TS, RAS, 6" jointer, Floor model DP, lathe, 14" BS small shaper, Chop saw. and a 12" planer. If I got one more tool I would not be able to get myself into the shop.

The planer is on wheels and its good, but a PITA. Difficult to keep it parking place clear. The thinking becomes very three dimensional. The top of the planer is the same height as the BS table and the outfeed table feeds under the wing on the TS so longer stock can go under the storage bench and then out under the TS.

My DC is in a shed behind the shop and that's a wonderful thing. Any dust it collects is GONE and I don't have to worry about the quality of the filter and the noise is out there. A slight PITS keeping up with the fullness of the bag but the benefits outweigh the downside.

About the tools. A big yes on the jointer. Get one with a long bed. Wider is better. Spiral cutter head is even better.

Drill press is also a yes but does not get as much use in my shop as it might, but OTOH, I use it for mortising, drum sanding and drilling and I like the floor model because I occasionally drill into the end of something long. I would look hard at the table and I think one with a tilt able table and the rake and pinion gears for raising and lowering the table would be better.

BandSaw. Now there's a love/hate relationship. I have a 14" one with a riser block. I use it for resawing and preparing bowl blanks for the all the. Those are pretty much at the opposite ends of the bandsaw spectrum. Resaw requires an excellent blade and careful setup of the accuracy. The other requires a coarse blade that will hack through wet green wood and cut curves. Its PITA to change form one to the other. Might take 45 minutes. The temptation is to use the resaw blade to quickly hake up a bowl blank. That's the end of that blade for resawing. These are really two different jobs and I should have two band saws, but I don'to have the money or the room. Also, I find something like $700 for the saw and another $100 for the riser. Then was the kit to release the tension on the blade, $150 and the upgraded guides, $100, and Adding dust collection. Now I am considering a larger motor, but that leads to larger circuit and a larger switch. Buy the time you add it all up I would have been better off Paying $1400 for a larger saw with all those features on it already.

So, As others have said, think about what you plan to do and equip yourself for that. I sympathise. Lately I have thought about posting a question along the lines of "What am I missing?". Like you, working alone, I wonder what I might add to my shop that would improve it. The planer was a major improvement for me. So was the band saw. Would doubling the size of my shop really increase my enjoyment?

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#11

Moses Yoder

Re: Double the size of your shop

Moses Yoder

If you double the size of your shop, you don't have more room. You have more stuff in your shop.

I was reading through the responses, thinking how fortunate we are in America today. 18,500 children starve to death every year because they don't have enough food, and here we are telling a guy his 12' x 18' shop isn't big enough and that he needs an 8" jointer versus the 6" model.

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#12

tool choice depends on what you intend to do

Bill Tindall

If you are going to be working hardwood then a planer and jointer are essential. Of all the things you mentioned only the radial arm saw is not essential for general furniture making.

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#13

Re: tool choice depends on what you intend to do

Charles Jackson III

I mostly, build cabinets, some funiture in the mission and shaker style. But I would like get off into building simple 18th century funiture.

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#14

"I would like to build simple 18th  furniture"

Bill Tindall

Jointer, planer and table saw would be considered essential by many for your furniture building goals.....and a bench with a good vise(s), which you haven't mentioned. Quality furniture requires fitting parts and that is best done with hand tools. So, additionally plan on acquiring a hand plane(s) and a good set of chisels and the means to sharpen them. I use a drill press a lot.

For fine furniture you needs the capability to make these parts: assemble glued up panels and cut them to finished sizes, make mortise and tenon and dovetail joints and make moldings. These four operations will make the parts for a lot of kinds of furniture. Finally, you need the capability to fit these things together.

I think it best to buy stuff when you encounter a need, at least for the tools beyond the bare essentials.

Final advice: take a skill building class for hand tools. Something that will teach you how to sharpen plane and chisles as well as use them.

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#15

Re: "I would like to build simple 18th  furniture"

Charles Jackson III

I have a benchtop mortiser, and PC Dovetail Jig. Also have a No 4, 5, and No 8 Stanley Bench Planes and some Footprints Beech Handle Chisel 1'', 3/4'' 1/2'', and 1/4''

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#16

The rule is: Stuff expands to fill available space


Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#17

Three lessons I've learned

Jim in N. Va

Over the years, I've learned that (for me at least) there are several lessons to be learned about buying tools and equipment.

(1) Plan where the tool will go in the shop before you buy it. I prefer to avoid having to move tools and so I consider placement carefully. I once had a shop in a 12' x 12' shed. I had a table saw, radial arm saw, workbench, portable planer, and and a bunch of hand tools. It all worked because of how the tools were placed in relation to each other and to windows and doors that I could open to work on longer boards.

(2) For whatever size shop (12' x 12' or 20' x 40') it is important to assign "value" to "space" You need space to assemble furniture, store the carcass while you make the drawers, stack the drawers as you make the molding, etc. I'm a very slow learner when it comes to this lesson. I find as I move into larger and larger shops to gain "space" that it's easy to fall to temptation to add more tools and then suddenly the space vanishes. Sometimes, less is more.

(3) There are no universal "needs" as the tools you need all come down to how you want to work. I think Rob Millard builds some of the most beautiful Federal style furniture I've ever seen. Very high end. Rob does this in a shop the size of a one car garage. He has a small table saw, but no jointer or planer (he uses a hand held power planer). It works for him. I'm beginning to appreciate his approach. That said, I have a lot of stationary power tools. For example, I have a 3-phase 20 inch bandsaw that I love. It is very accurate and I often use it in place of my table saw as for many tasks it is much safer. Much of what I do on the band saw would be hard to accomplish on the typical 14" bandsaw and so I think it would use a 14" bandsaw a lot less if I had one instead of my 20". (Some days I think it would be awesome to have TWO bandsaws...one set up for ripping, cutting tenons, etc. and the other set up with a thinner blade to cut curves. I dream of this until I remember lesson #2. I really am a slow learner.)

Good luck with your decisions. If you adopt the attitude that a shop is never finished then you'll be fine. You can always add equipment later or sell things you buy but then find you are not using much.

Best,

Jim

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#18

You are right on about band saws.

Bill Tindall

I used a large machine in a class and sought to buy one (used) as soon as I could. One can find old Delta 20" machines for the price of a new 14". For what ever reason band saws often come with dinky tables which greatly limits their functionality. I kept my 14" and leave it set up with a narrow blade for narrow blade work and the big machine has a 3/4" blade installed for resawing, and general ripping.

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#19

Re: tool choice depends on what you intend to do

Joseph Mulherin

I built my own shop by myself about 14yrs ago, insulated it good because we live in the desert near Palm Springs. Tools used to include a radial arm saw, but I gave it away and purchased the Shopsmith Mark V...it is five tools in one that it only takes a few minutes or seconds to setup from one event to another. Also got the planer and their bandsaw... and many other hand tools. The most interesting tool you will need is the WORKBENCH...look around American Woodworker5 to get some ideas of which one you might like to build...the Roubo is a very good banch...and get two vises for the bench..one on the side and one on the end.

Check into EBay or Craiglist to see if there are some Shopsmiths listed for sale. You might be able to get one from a widowed lady, there again go to the Yahoo Shopsmith Users website and they often list machines for sale. And I would increase the shop size to 24x18.

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#20

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have

TomD

"I am going to build me a 12x18 shed on a slab on grade foundation. I am wondering what next tool buys should be. I have a 10'' Unisaw, 9'' DeWalt Radial Arm Saw, 13'' Delta Benchtop Planer, Steel City Benchtop Mortiser, and a Jet DC1100 Dust Collector. I am looking at adding a 6'' Jointer, 14'' Bandsaw, and a 15'' Floor Model Drill Press. I am wondering are these good choices."

Those are good choices. If it were me, I would go to an 18" bandsaw, 8" jointer, and I could live with a smaller drill press. But a floor mount is a good tool if you have room. YOu have at best 1/3rd my space, and I think you could start to run up against it.

It is really hard to recommend, because the issues are very complex. I would get cheap good stuff off craigs, so you can dump anything you don't like anyway. It isn't as though the Chinese stuff is better.

I have an 8" jointer. It will get 11 inch boards planed flat. The 6 inch ones just aren't big enough for face jointing decent wood. Wood comes in specific sizes, it isn't infinite, what you need is determined by the size that furniture is. MUltiples of 8" are more appropriate. It just works out the 8" is a better fit, and does not take up significantly more space. BUT. I could live without a jointer. It depends a lot on your wood, but despite being a jointing Nazi, I find I can put 90% of it through the planer from the get-go. And much of the stuff I can't put directly into the planer, only needs the high points knocked off with a hand plane, or will not joint down to a useable piece anyway. In my opinion 6" tools are not for cabinet shops. They are basically edge jointing tools. I prefer to edge joint by hand, but obviously the 8" works for that too. So If I couldn't have an 8 I wouldn't bother.

Bandsaw is different. The 14" is the key market, and there are some awesome tools out there in that category. I found I could work around a narrow saw. Unlike bill, I did not find the ability to remove a chip wider than 14" all that important. But I did find resaw work is critical for real woodworking, turning, and lumber processing. Your method of work will determine, but I do not find the 14" all that limiting. I gave mine to my dad. I use it happily when I am over there, and what is available in todays market is so much better than what I bought. A serious 14 is a good tool.

I could get by without the larger floor mounted drill press but they seem to take less space anyway. I resold my Taiwan one after over 20 years for about what I paid for it. I would only buy a serious old world one. I have a metal shop one, Buffalo Forge. I also have a 35 dollar, tiny I got off craigs. They are real useful, even where very small. A mortiser and a mill are way more cabinetguy, but I have never been without some kind of drill press. Drill presses for me are one of the tools in the shop that have a siren call for bad practices. Be careful.

Once you are in a ground level shop, time to toss the desk top planer and get one that will hog 250 thou. The desktop ones are amazing, but real time wasters beyond a certain point. I have had three, but I wish I had my old 16" Busy Bee, that was a smooth powerful Taiwan machine. My current General, is OK.

Of all the tools you have, production or hobby. I would only really need a planer and a bandsaw. I mean these days I would always have more, they are basically free. But those are the real tools.

Also, while all tools are a combination of precision, and power. Tablesaws, jointers, are the only two where I really insist on first world standards of quality. Which does affect price, since neither is really on my A-list. I would only buy good ones.

Re: Going to be building a new shed soon but have a?

#21

Re: Three lessons I've learned

TomD

Very well said Jim.

I have never followed those rules, certainly not the first two. And I have paid a huge price. I just can't.

The thing about millard is very much a production vs, hobby thing but with a twist. I normally identify production as having the heavy tool demands, and hobby as being the kind of thing where one could choose to make a fancy guitar with a pocket knife, as one well known builder claims to have done.

But there is the other side. The guy who makes a single high end product, like guitars, one instrument at a time. Or apparently Millard, vs, the guy who makes everything he has ever touched and needs a blizzard of tools as a result, even if it is just a hobby. It is easy to be organized neat and small, if you have zero ambition. :)