Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice
Dave Paine
I live in Eastern PA and at the far end of the PP&L Utility companies northwest boundary. I am intimately familiar with power outages. Can be due to weather or a driver taking out a power pole.
Back in 2005 a loss of power pole resulted in a several hour outage. Was predicted to be up to 12+ hours. After this incident I purchased a portable generator and manual transfer switch.
We lost power after the hurricane for 3 days. The generator kept the food cold, fish tanks operating, water pump and some outlets.
My unit happens to be a Generac 7100 Watts with a Briggs and Stratton engine.
A co-worker who lives in the Pocono's is presently getting quotes on a stationary unit.
The most common portable units use gasoline. Seems they go up to 10,000 Watts.
The most common stationary units use either propane or natural gas. I have neither of these fuels and prefer to avoid installing a propane tank.
The stationary units can be sized to back-up a 200 Amp service. The quotes my co-worker is getting for 20,000 Watt unit range from $6,500 without the tank to $8,000 with propane tank and initial fill. The units are the brands you mention.
The co-worker is also having a difficult time deciding the pro's and con's of Generac, Kohler, Briggs and Stratton.
My portable Generac has always started easily. In the hurricane outage it was consuming about 5 gallons of gasoline per day. This will be dependant on the loads being run.
The challenge with portable units is they are not sufficient for electrical powered heat - whether heat pump or direct heat. If you have oil, they can easily power the blower.
In my case, I use heat pump with coal supplement in the coldest months. The unit can power my stoker motor and blower.
Portable units will cost $1,000 - $1,500. I highly recommend a transfer switch which will cost around $150, but may need to be installed by an electrician.
The alternate is back-feeding the breaker box. Not recommended, but can be done IF you disconnect the main breaker. Works but then you have to watch for the neigbours power to come back on.
I have 6 circuit manual transfer switch. The 220V for the water pump takes two circuits. I may add another switch to get more circuits. More lights would be useful.
The portable units are noisier than stationary, but the stationary and not exactly quiet.
In the RV world, it seems Kohler is preferred over Generac based on the number of RV's which seem to use Kohler.
I would buy the Generac again, but I would pay more for a unit which is quieter. So if I upgrade the capacity I may look for less noise.
I hope this helps your decision.