Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

OT: Back Up Generator Advice

Posts

OT: Back Up Generator Advice

#1

Bart Goldberg

OT: Back Up Generator Advice

Bart Goldberg

Given the recent set of weather issues that have created massive power outages in the North East, I'm considering having a dedicated power back up system installed for my house. Both my wife and I work from home, so when the electric goes out, neither of us can work. I am interested to hear if anyone has first hand experience in this area. I'm currently looking at systems made by Kohler, Generac and GE. All three look decent, but I am lacking any sort of reliable comparison to make a decision. If you have any knowledge in this area, please share.

Thanks

Bart

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

#2

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

Dave Paine

I live in Eastern PA and at the far end of the PP&L Utility companies northwest boundary. I am intimately familiar with power outages. Can be due to weather or a driver taking out a power pole.

Back in 2005 a loss of power pole resulted in a several hour outage. Was predicted to be up to 12+ hours. After this incident I purchased a portable generator and manual transfer switch.

We lost power after the hurricane for 3 days. The generator kept the food cold, fish tanks operating, water pump and some outlets.

My unit happens to be a Generac 7100 Watts with a Briggs and Stratton engine.

A co-worker who lives in the Pocono's is presently getting quotes on a stationary unit.

The most common portable units use gasoline. Seems they go up to 10,000 Watts.

The most common stationary units use either propane or natural gas. I have neither of these fuels and prefer to avoid installing a propane tank.

The stationary units can be sized to back-up a 200 Amp service. The quotes my co-worker is getting for 20,000 Watt unit range from $6,500 without the tank to $8,000 with propane tank and initial fill. The units are the brands you mention.

The co-worker is also having a difficult time deciding the pro's and con's of Generac, Kohler, Briggs and Stratton.

My portable Generac has always started easily. In the hurricane outage it was consuming about 5 gallons of gasoline per day. This will be dependant on the loads being run.

The challenge with portable units is they are not sufficient for electrical powered heat - whether heat pump or direct heat. If you have oil, they can easily power the blower.

In my case, I use heat pump with coal supplement in the coldest months. The unit can power my stoker motor and blower.

Portable units will cost $1,000 - $1,500. I highly recommend a transfer switch which will cost around $150, but may need to be installed by an electrician.

The alternate is back-feeding the breaker box. Not recommended, but can be done IF you disconnect the main breaker. Works but then you have to watch for the neigbours power to come back on.

I have 6 circuit manual transfer switch. The 220V for the water pump takes two circuits. I may add another switch to get more circuits. More lights would be useful.

The portable units are noisier than stationary, but the stationary and not exactly quiet.

In the RV world, it seems Kohler is preferred over Generac based on the number of RV's which seem to use Kohler.

I would buy the Generac again, but I would pay more for a unit which is quieter. So if I upgrade the capacity I may look for less noise.

I hope this helps your decision.

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

#3

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I can't comment on the reliability of the brands, but I believe that the type of fuel used is far more important. Gasoline is probably the cheapest - but the least dependable, as the ethanol blends do become "stale" much faster than the old blends. It is also harder to obtain when a major power outage occurs due to ice storms, hurricanes etc. as the gas stations are also down. My oldest son purchased a very large diesel whole house system last year and has had problems with it from day one. The fuel selector valve system appears to be the problem - and it takes a diesel mechanic to replace the part and time the system. As of right now it is not running. If you have propane heat, I would opt for a propane powered system, if not natural gas. Most, if not all the whole house systems have a timer that automatically starts and runs the system on a periodic basis (sons is monthly). This keeps the lubrication circulated and starting battery charged. The propane /NG systems do produce somewhat less power for the same motor size than gasoline, but are IMHO far more trouble free.

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

#4

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

Howard Norman

I would say that considering a back up generator is a good idea.

I have a 5KW electric start, gasoline powered Honda unit myself. It is not wired with a transfer switch so hooking it up when needed requires extension cords which is not the best but will work. If you decide on a portable unit like I have I strongly suggest an electric start unit. When the weather is miserable you don't want to be outside trying to start a unit with a rope starter.

I consider the stationary units superior but certainly more expensive than my setup. Around here the Generac brand is the most popular. That may be because of dealers more than anything else. Natural gas is not available here so all of the stationary units that I am aware of are propane powered.

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

#5

Hi Neighbor

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

We have a 6Kw WINCO generator that's about 10 years old. When the power goes, I disconnect from the street and then back-feed the whole house. Originally it would run the lights, keep the furnace going along with the well pump, plus the food cold, my office computers and printers and fax operating. However, since we redid our kitchen, the new appliances, especially the microwave, are too much draw. The other problem is balancing the load.

Ours went down this time and I had to hump it up to a guy in NE Pa for repair. There are few places around that will touch the generator portion.

SWMBO stated she wants a whole-house automatic units which means 20-30Kw working off our propane tank. I've gotten a quote for a 25Kw Briggs, however it's not a power-lubed engine and I don't care for Briggs engines in that class. Kohler are well rec'd as are Onan units. Unfortunately, the waiting list for them is about 3 months long.

A 25Kw Generac with a liquid-cooled engine will run you about $8,300 plus shipping, ATS, and the install.

A 20 Kw Kohler is about $5,200 +,+.

That's an very expensive 5Kw, but the liquid-cooled engine is in a better class than the air-cooled Kohler.

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

#6

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

John Veerkamp

My brother is a quadrapelegic (sp) . He built his ideal home two years ago and after much research, had a Gererac Natural gas automatic whole house back up. He has needed it a couple of times since then and it has worked flawlessly. When the grid goes down, this starts itself and he never knows the difference. It is fairly quiet running. As i recall it cost about 16K installed.

Be cautious using portable generators to power newer furnaces. If your power is not conditioned you will blow your circuit boards. This is an expensive repair. Ditto for other delicate electronics, including some high end refrigerators.

Based on my brothers experience, I recommend the Generac.

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

#7

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

Bill Howatt

I have a 5.5KW portable "cheapie". I keep about 12 gal of gas available for it because if you have no power the local gas station won't either. We are on a well so no electricity means no water too!

I hate to tempt the electricity gods but our power is extremely reliable. If it wasn't, I'd get an electric start generator and since we do have natural gas, I'd get a natural gas unit to avoid fooling with the gasoline.

I put Sta-bil in the gas and rotate it through my car about 2-3 times per year.

I don't recommend feeding your electric panel with the main breaker disconnected. It is dangerous should you forget the turn off the breaker. A transfer switch is best but I use a souped-up extension cord method. The advice about upsetting electronic control boards on furnaces is correct - I also wouldn't power my expensive TV etc with generator power either.

Bill

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

#8

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

Larry in nw ohio

I`ve heard about htis conditioning. What is it and how is it done and can a person do it themselves on a personal unit at home. Also where can a person get one and how much do they cost. Thank You Larry

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

#9

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

John Veerkamp

I'm sure there are add on devices that regulate the power output, but this capacity is built into better generators. I'll let some of out electronic experts chime in on the after market equipment.

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

#10

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

Don Orr

Bart,

We have a 16KW Generac automatic generator fueled by a 1000 gal propane tank in the ground. We are very pleased with it. It has a 2 cyl Subaru engine and tests itself once a week. It has come in handy several times. Not as quiet as we were hoping since it is located next to the bedroom wall. We bought the tank separately and had it installed while doing some other construction. No natural gas in our rural area. Generator and tranfer switch installed was around $3500 complete. It powers most of the house-well pump, furnace, hot water, refrigrator, lights, etc. No 220volt circuits though. Don't remember what the tank was. We get a better price on propane because we own the tank and buy a good volume. We have only filled it twice in over 5 years-once at install and once since. We don't heat or cook with it-just some gas logs, stoves and heat for my shop. When the power goes out it takes about 20-30 seconds to switch over.

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

#11

Bart Goldberg

Some additional details

Bart Goldberg

I am looking for a fixed / permanent solution for my house. I have 200amp service and I have Natural Gas for my house. So, I will of course be getting a Natural Gas generator. I had the first contractor come by on Friday and quote me two options 1) A 14KW Generac system for $7,850 installed that would cover most of my house, but not the 2 AC units, or 2) A 20KW Generac system that would cover my entire house, including the 2 AC units for $11,750 installed.

Part of the cost for the install includes digging a 60 foot long trench to bury the the gas line from the meter to the location where I'd have the generator installed. Based on some of the prices I see including in the replies to my original posting, this guy's prices seem a bit high. I am waiting on a callback from a contractor for Home Depot to quote the GE system and another callback from the local Kohler installer.

Regards

Bart

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

#12

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

Bill Howatt

Some UPS units provide power conditioning and surge protection but you have to make sure you get one that does. The common, cheaper ones may only monitor the line voltage and then switch over to battery/inverter operation when the line voltage fails.

Some generators, seems to be the lower power ones 3KW or so, provide their output by an inverter. The generator provides DC and the DC is turned into 60Hz power by an electronic inverter circuit. Inverter supplied power is seen as much cleaner than that provided by typical home generators.

I have a power-bar with surge protection that I use for running my cheaper satellite receiver, cheap TV, etc from the generator. It may not do much but makes me feel better.

About all I know about the subject.

Bill

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

#13

Caveat

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Bart,

If you're running NG instead of propane, you must figure in the de-rating factor. A 20Kw generator running on natural gas gets stepped down to 18 Kw. You need to figure that in as you decide on capacity and size. You should know that while the transfer switch may be fore a 200 amp service, you'll only have 75 amps to work with from that 18Km unit. Consider that whole house A/C units are usually breakered for 40 amps, and an electric oven can pull 50-60. One of those loads won't leave much for lights, refrigerators, well pumps and other appliances; running 2-zone A/C units at the same time could get you into trouble.

BTW, Northern Tools sells a 20KW 30hp Kohler for $5200 including transfer switch, plus shipping. You'd have to g-c your own install.

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

#14

Bart Goldberg

Re: Caveat

Bart Goldberg

Thanks Neighbor!

How ya doing - long time no see.

Bart

Re: OT: Back Up Generator Advice

#15

Not Bad

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

For an older type dude. :D

SWMBO was PO'd when the little (6Kw) genset poo'd the bed in the middle of the last outage. But the street power's back on now and she about choked when I laid the $12K bill for a whole house (30Kw) unit on here.

If you have zoned central, new appliances, work out of your house like I do, and don't want to hear complaints about "all the stuff I can't do" 'til the street power gets live again, you'd best be thinking about more juice than a 20K will give you. Wish I had NG. :(