Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Looking for recommendations for random

Posts

Looking for recommendations for random

#1

Looking for recommendations for random

roger lance

orbit palm sanders in 5" or 6" size...PSA or hook & loop....with ability to hook to dust collector. I know Festool is the top of the rock. But, at nearly $350 to $400 per sander, I could have 3 sanders with 100, 150, & 220 grit discs and simply move thru each sander without changing discs...which is a nice way to sand. Currently using PorterCable 332s with PSA discs with no holes over a shop made downdraft table that works well but direct dust collection would be better. Lookin for that knowledge based on experience thing. Thanks in advance. My aging PCs were made before Black & Decker got a hold of PC....enough said.

Re: Looking for recommendations for random

#2

Anyone have experience with Bosch sanders?


Re: Looking for recommendations for random

#3

Re: Anyone have experience with Bosch sanders?

John McGaw

Yes, I've had two of them for years. The oldest one is a cheaper 5" and the slightly-newer one is a 6" which they called a sander/grinder. That one is able to remove material with the best of them when power-driven orbit is engaged rather than the 'floating' orbit that the little one uses exclusively. Dust collection is excellent using a Fein Turbo III vac although the little dust collector bag system is not terribly efficient. I've never had a glitch except for having to replace the pad on the 5" because I destroyed the H&L surface through my own stupidity (hint: make sure that abrasive is installed before starting to sand enthusiastically). Part was easily obtained and not very expensive.

Re: Looking for recommendations for random

#4

JL

Re: Looking for recommendations for random

JL

I've got a PC 390K. I've had it for a few years. I like the soft start and how quickly it turns off. It is an excellent sander.

It took some doing, but I found a Ridgid adapter which fits the inner dust port. I recommend it.

Re: Looking for recommendations for random

#5

Re: Looking for recommendations for random

Dave Paine

I have a Bosch 6in unit 327 or some such model. Only bag dust collection. Recently saw Bosch now sells a plastic adapter. This unit no longer being used, except for gathering dust.

I now use the PC 390K, as the other poster commented, this is a terrific sander. Fits in the hand easily, does not give me any issues with vibration in the hand. Quiet.

The dust collection is good, but somehow PC managed to make the hose connection a non standard size as in the SAME size as the normal shop vac hose. I ended up with a home made adapter from an old 1+in hose and a piece of 3/4in CPVC pipe which fits inside the PC.

I would buy the 390K again if this one broke.

Re: Looking for recommendations for random

#6

Re: Looking for recommendations for random

Jesse Cloud

If you are serious about the dust, step up to Festool. The 150/3 is on sale for $265. If you aren't that serious, look for a reconditioned PC if thats what you like.

The dust issue isn't just your health - though what can be more important than that... But with good dust control you spend time sanding the workpiece and not old dust. Sanding goes much faster and is more effective. The paper lasts way longer, too.

Most sanders seem to offer dc as an afterthought, so the hose connectors are awkward and making sanding even worse. If you do a lot of sanding, getting a good one is well worth the money.

Re: Looking for recommendations for random

#7

What about the Festool ETS 125 EQ ?

roger lance

5" pad....smaller/less weight....tighter sanding orbits....on sale for about $157....has same dust control....can you hook to a standard wet/dry vac??

Re: Looking for recommendations for random

#8

I used to buy Ryobi's

John in NM

Because you could get replacement stick on hook pads in a package of two or three for $5 or so, rather than replacing the whole pad at half the cost of the cheep sander. They also had a dust bag port which I could hook a shop vac up to - and that makes a huge difference to sand paper life.

Last one I bought was more expensive and trying to be like a PC sander, huge and top heavy I thought compared to the older ones that I used to get for $20-$30 at Home Depot. Still had the dust port though, and that was the main thing. Once I run out of hook pads (the hooks all wear off after a year or so of heavy use), I'll likely get the 5" Festool.

I understand that Festool sanders don't give you a numb hand after long use, if that is the case it will over ride my cheap gene :D . Like dust control, that is something I find important enough to pay for if they can deliver.

Re: Looking for recommendations for random

#9

I'll second the PC 390

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

It's dust port fits my Fein vac without any adapter and it is virtually vibration-free (can't say that about my older PC 333 and 330).

Re: Looking for recommendations for random

#10

Re: Anyone have experience with Bosch sanders?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have three Bosch 5" and one older PC - 2 of the Bosch have the variable speed - although I can't remember the last time I slowed one down. They are functional, though do vibrate quite a bit. IMHO the dust canister system works pretty well -if you clean it out with an air gun after about 10 - 15 minutes of sanding. I may go to a Festool as my next sander - the only reason I haven't is that they don't appear to use the standard 5" ~ 8 hole disks. I have changed the pads on my H&L Bosch units a couple times - last me just a few months with moderate use.

Re: Looking for recommendations for random

#11

Re: Ammendum

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I forgot you were asking about connection to a vacuum system. The Bosch I purchased did come with case and an adapter to hook to a vacuum. I haven't tried it as I did jury rig a vacuum to one a couple of years ago, it did eliminate the dust but seemed quite awkward to use - couldn't seem to keep the pad level and even on the surface so quit using it.

Re: Looking for recommendations for random

#12

Re: What about the Festool ETS 125 EQ ?

Jesse Cloud

I don't have the 125 personally, but I've heard good things about it. I like the 6 inch pad myself (almost twice the sanding area, so you finish faster).

Yes, a regular vac works ok. May have to buy an adapter to fit the tool end. A smaller vac is fine, too much suction actually slows things down.

Re: Looking for recommendations for random

#13

Re: Addendum

Barry Irby

I have two of the Porter Cable 5" sanders. They have a round dust port about an inch in diameter. I found a small Shop Vac hose at Lowes and the wand on it can be force fit to the port on the sander. I hook it to my DC and use the wand as a handle on the sander. I "fly" the sander over the surface holding the wand. Works great on large flat surfaces.

Re: Looking for recommendations for random

#14

Re: Anyone have experience with Bosch sanders?

Hal

I have two 5" Bosch RO's. You can get a hose from Bosch with an adapter on one end that fits the exhaust port. Other end to a shop vac. Have had both RO' for several years and like them. I am partial to Bosch tools, I guess just because I've had good experience. And yes, be sure you have a sanding disc on before you start sanding. Been there, done that. Hal