Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Epoxy set time question.

Posts

Epoxy set time question.

#1

Epoxy set time question.

Barry Irby

I have a broken board of spalted maple. Its 12" wide and about 6' long except its shattered into three pieces. I took some Epoxy I had and died it black with some dye I had and glued one of the pieces back onto the main piece. My thinking was that I am trying to mimic the splat lines and disguise the glue lines. How long does it take 5 minute epoxy to actually "set" In other words, when can I take the clamps off and do the other piece?

Check out this provenance...My Ex-wife's former step son worked for Burgess Joule (sp?) and installed the flooring in Oprah Winfrey's house in Chicago. He scavenged this piece from the job and left it at my X's house and she gave it to me. Wood is wood, right?

Re: Epoxy set time question.

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Epoxy set time question.

Moses Yoder

Yep, any wood that your ex-wife gave you should be treated as special. :b

Re: Epoxy set time question.

#3

Re: Epoxy set time question.

John McGaw

In my experience, once you start mixing things with epoxy (even things that are meant for the purpose) all bets are off. I built a cherry table a long while back and there was a single 3/8" knot hole in the top. Being clever I mixed up some epoxy (West System IIRC) along with black colorant sold for the purpose, put a piece of blue tape on the bottom of the wood, and filled the hole flush to the surface. A week later I peeled off the tape. The next day I found black drips on the hardwood floor -- epoxy drips. To make an already overly long story short, the epoxy never got much beyond bubblegum hardness over the next year and is still not as hard as I would have expected.

Re: Epoxy set time question.

#4

Depends

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

The 5-min stuff you squeeze from the double tube will "set" in 5-10 minutes, but will continue to cure for the next day or so depending on temperature. [warmer+ faster reaction] I have been told that the slower the cure, the better the bond as the resin gets a better grip on the wood fibers. I would not use the 5-min stuff on boards or with epoxy paste pigment, mostly because the pigment will skew the mix proportions and weaken the final produce. Either way, I would not put pressure on that joint for 3 days at least to allow the best cure possible.

Other epoxies can be mixed wrong (often too much hardener) and never set beyond a soft stage. West wants their resin mixed by volume, whereas System 3 wants their stuff mixed by precise weight. I use epoxy for fills, some joints, and turnings so I had to buy a micro gram scale to mix my stuff (Sys-3) in the correct proportion of 1:44/100. Since then it has worked just fine. I do color my resin with either epoxy paste in black or white (or with a spot of Transtint liquid dye), but I do so and add to the resin before calculating how much hardener to add. I also use a "medium" speed hardener that takes 30-45 minutes to gel.

Re: Epoxy set time question.

#5

Re: Epoxy set time question.

Jesse Cloud

Lots of things can affect the cure time of epoxy, most importantly the precision of measurement of the two parts. I have had epoxy that basically never cured. I tried again using the same bottles and the same procedure and it did fine.... I'm sure it was my error, but never did find it for sure what the error was. Best thing to do is to put a dab on a scrap board and maybe even epoxy a couple of pieces of scrap together along with your regular project. Check how the scrap is doing before you take the clamps off.

By the way, spalted maple is not a real strong wood. The spalting process can definitely make it funky in some places. I have used it for decorative panels, but would never use it for a floor or anything structural.

Re: Epoxy set time question.

#6

Re: Epoxy set time question.

TomD

You should be able to handle it within 24 hours. The five minutes is the workability time, for the most part. Manufacturers vary.

Each 18 degree F increase in temp halves the cure time. Significantly elevating temp may add significant strength, or not. Not only is green cure epoxy not at full strength, but it is more likely to be a sensitizer, so it can be unsafe to sand early. Chiselling, planing etc... should be easier.

The best blackener for epoxy is generally graphite powder. You can get it at epoxy suppliers, and sometimes pure versions are sold in hardwares as grease, but they might have other stuff in there. Graphite has some beneficial characteristics for epoxy depending on objective. It will somewhat delay cure and soften the end result. For colour one should use the bare minimum. For making your epoxy more graphitie (not to be confused with graphite fiber), you can go 20% by volume. Many dyes and paints will adversely change epoxy. If it eventually hardens, hard, you are probably OK. Despite a lot of nonsense about flexibility in glue being beneficial, usually hardness is harder to achieve and more useful.

Normally 5 minute is a poor choice structurally and for UV survival. There are many formulations on the market. Formulation takes place on the design spiral where the emphasis of any characteristic is normally at the cost of some other. 5 things with 5 minute"

- Normally low quality, though there are good brands, I buy squeeze bottles of WEST, and also devcon. (I liked the WEST even before I learned it could be blended with their "for real" products to modify cure times and other properties.) Normally 5 minute is best in structural aps where it is not overly under tensile loading. I would use it to blue handle ona fly rod, but not to build the blank, kind of thing.

- Viscosity often precludes amalgamation of useful additives. Using liquid thinners wets it but does not thin it. People feel it is flowing and penetrating, but it is actually just sitting on the surface.

- Viscosity often stops it from properly wetting on wood, surface micro dusts etc.. can be enough to inhibit contact

- Not good structural properties.

- Safety is always a bit of a guessing game, but I have a variety of worries about brands that are out there that range from whether there are exceptions for the non-industrial use, to source of some products. For instance, I doubt OSHA drops into too many workplaces where 5 minute from the hardware store is in heavy use, but there are guys with their nose in it in some home shops, all day long.

Re: Epoxy set time question.

#7

next time try a powdered pigment

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I woud only use a brad of liquid dye for epoxy that is sold to be used with that brand or you risk having problems. I have never had problems if incompatability when using dry pigments and my prefered dry pigments are pure synthetic iron oxides sold by Davis Color. In a pinch the mason stains sold at most of the big box stores for coloring concrete will work just fine. These are inert and wil not affect the strength or cure of epoxies in any way. dry pigments will thicken the epoxy and care should be taken not to use too much. I always measuere the epoxy components then mix the powdered pigment with one part then add the hardener and mix so I have the full pot life to work with once it is mixed, this can be a big deal with 5 minute epoxy.

Robin

Re: Epoxy set time question.

#8

Thanks for the help....And

Barry Irby

I used the Epoxy I had, I bought it at Lowe's some time ago and was actually trying to buy the one hour kind. Today or soon, I will go to WoodCraft and stock up on better stuff. I don't see much advantage to the 5 minute stuff Since both of them seem to acquire their ultimate strength slowly and I have to leave the clamps on for more than five minutes anyway. I only used the epoxy to be able to blacken it and mimic the spalt lines. I used the powdered dyes that came with a Mohawk Furniture repair kit I bought about forty years ago. Might have been better to use PVA.

Anybody tried coloring PVA?

I am about to go clean up the board and see what I got. Making something out of nothing.