Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Electrical question 3 phase power

Posts

Electrical question 3 phase power

#1

JL

Electrical question 3 phase power

JL

We have 3 phase power coming into the playhouse. We have a 400 amp 3 phase service with 3 phase breakers.

This got me to thinking.

If we have a 200 amp 3 phase breaker - does this mean each of the legs would have 200 amps single phase?

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

#2

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Yes, you would have 200 amps of single phase on each leg. With one hot and a neutral you have 120 volt, single phase. With two hots and no neutral, you have 208v or 240v single phase (actually two phase, which is still refered to as single phase). The 208/240 difference depends on configuration of transformer on the power company side. If using single phase loads from a three phase panel BE SURE That all three phases are fairly evernly loaded. Please consult an electrician.

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

#3

JL

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

JL

I wasn't planning on doing it without an electrician. I was just wondering how much power I had available if and when we expand the shop area.

It does make me think about upgrading the electrical service to a higher amperage (500 or 600 amps). Between the theatrical lighting, HVAC and other building requirements, there isn't much left for the shop part.

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

#4

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

John in NM

Surely you're not using the shop while using the stage lighting :D

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

#5

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

Larry in nw ohio

JL With all due respect to Bill, that just doesn`t sound right. It`s been over 10 years since I messed with 3 phase but I still remember that with 3 phase if you have 400 amp 3 phase coming in then I think you should have 400 amp 3phase going out. Also I believe it should be 400 volts, the amps is what you use to protect the wires so you don`t overload them. If you want 110volt single phase you need to put in a transformer. But you have to have single phase around the stage somewhere anyhow just to run the lights and various other things. As I said before it`s been awhile but I`m pretty sure of that but I`ve been known to be wrong. As You and Bill said do not mess with any of that unless you know what you are doing. Larry

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

#6

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

To use the over-simplified metaphorish terms, volts are pressure, amps are flow. That he's got 400 amps coming in says nothing about the voltage, which could be 408 or could be "220."

JL, if you're equipping the shop area - buying equipment - and if you're buying table saws, bandsaws, etc., used, you might consider seeking out three-phase machines. They often go cheaper because home shop folks don't usually have three-phase available.

Of course, you'll still need 220 and 110 circuits - three-phase handheld drill motors are darned hard to find :)

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

#7

JL

Don't think so

JL

Yes, a 3 phase table saw can be less expensive as can some of the other used industrial equipment.

If I were the only one using it, I wouldn't have a problem buying it :D . But I'm not. There are some of the people that I don't trust using a 1 1/2 hp contractor's saw - I'd be frightened at the thought of them using a 3 (or 5) hp cabinet saw. Band saw might be okay.

What I would like is a Sawstop contractor's saw - but I don't know how the sensing system would react to things like staples, paint, etc.

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

#8

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

There is 208/240v-3 phase as I described. Then there is 480v-3 phase. 480v-3 phase yields 277v-1 phase with a neutral. 277v-1 phase is used, normally for flourescent lighting in large buildings.

JL, how many machines will operate at one time in your shop? A one man shop will almost never use more than about 30 amps/230v-single phase. That is one saw and a dust collector or air compressor...consult an industrial electrician, NOT a residential one. They are different birds of a feather.

Somewhere, if you have 480 volts, there is a 480v to 208/240 transformer and a 240v panel. Upgrading a 100/200 amps of 3 phase system could be a huge unneeded expnse. Panels and disrribution can be loaded at 80%. All this is based on average and alternating loads. Most modern houses have 200 amp services...they usually have ~400 amps of breakers installed. Half the lights are usually off, heat does not run when AC does, not all outlets are constantly used, you usually don't cook, dry clothes,heat water, iron, dry hair, wash clothes,etc. all at the same time. Pay an electrician's consultation fee of $150, might save you several THOUSAND is construction costs.

There is a special code section for theatres because of the constant large loads of AC, lighting, and the need for fire protection of the public. I would guess that the shop electrical needs (of ten people) would easily be covered by the unused large loads that are not being used while shop work is performed.

Do a little research. On a performance day, read your meter at the start. Read it at the end. The measured KWHours divided by the time between readings= Kwatt/hour. KWatt divided by voltage = average amp draw per hour. This will give you a general estimate of how loaded your service is. Most power companys will offer free engineering service, if you don't understand this suggestion. Some meters have Multipliers on them. Ask your power company for help and info.

Bill, who was set chief of Absolute Theatre, Hendersonville, NC for 4 yrs in the 1990s

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

#9

Re: Don't think so

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

I would not be any more afraid of a tablesaw based on HP. A 1/2 HP saw blabe will take off your finger, just as fast as a 5 HP. A horse can weigh almost 1000 pounds. A thousand pounds pushing those teeth thru your hand vs 500# pushing does not make much difference.

We never let people younger than about 25 use the "bad boy" tools. This was with a volunteer crew of over 100 people over the years. We always had some 25 kids around.

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

#10

Question

Bill Tindall

A good friend who ran a local saw mill had an only son killed messing with 3 phase 440 panel at the mill.

How does a 3 phase breaker work? I presume they trip as a result of heat resulting from current flow at operating voltage? In other words some amount of watts trips them? If the breaker is rated at XX amps will the breaker trip if XX amps is exceeded in ANY wire connected to the breaker?

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

#11

Re: Question

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Any breaker, one, two, or three phase is designed to trip if an overload is sensed on any leg. It must then trip ALL of the legs. As the load increases, the trip time decreases. A dead short is an infinite load (10,000 amps in a milli-second), therefore trip should be instantaneous. A mild overload may not trip for several seconds.(a 22 amp load on a 20 amp breaker). A few milliamps on 120 volts can kill in the correct situation. Unfortunately, at higher voltages, it takes less exposure to damage the body. 480v sometimes blows you clear and shortens the contact time. The shock can stop your heart like a reverse defribulator or create steam in your organs. A heart blown into pieces will not be restarted. ALWAYS ASSUME THAT ANY BARE CONDUCTOR IS ENERGISED!

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

#12

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Volts, amps and you.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

It's often said that it only takes about a tenth of an amp (0.1A, or 100 mA) to kill you. This is true, but doesn't tell the whole story. That 0.1A has to go through the heart. But, the body has some resistance, so the more of the body that is involved, the higher the voltage has to be to get to that deadly current.

Ohm's Law is V=IR, where V is voltage, I is current and R is resistance. Solve for I and you get I=V/R, which shows that to get a high current, either V must be large, or R must be small.

Higher voltage can be dangerous because it causes the muscles of the body to involuntarily flex, possibly not allowing the release of dangerous contact with a live wire. For example, Tasers use two electrodes at about 50,000V, which will take away all muscle control of most people. However, the amperage is very, very small, in the neighborhood of 3-4 mA (about 1/25 of what could be fatal).

Higher voltage is also dangerous because of a greater ability to arc over a greater distance. 120V won't arc very far in air, but the 7000V on the other side of the transformer that feeds your house will jump a little ways, which is why downed power lines are so dangerous.

Then there is the concept of power available. P=IV (power, current, voltage) So, when there is higher current and/or higher voltage available, the potential for damage beyond electrocution is there--welding, arc flash, explosions, molten conductors splashing, burns, etc.

Be safe, folks.

Jason

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

#13

Re: Don't think so

Rob C

There is one way a 5HP saw can be much more dangerous than a 1.5HP contractors saw. Kickback. The small saw can jam or stop or throw a board back if used improperly, but you can almost count on the big saw sending a board back like a bullet and it can do some real damage. I've seen boards go through sheetrock walls in a pro shop. Use a riving knife, don't cut with the blade angled into the fence! The big saws aren't for the uninitiated ands a Sawstop will not protect you from this type of incident

Rob

Re: Electrical question 3 phase power

#14

The solution

Bill Tindall

Which is why I run a 7 1/2" very thin kerf 40T combo blade on my 10" Unisaw. There is no propensity for kickback. There is almost no cutting resistance. It feels very safe, especially so for smaller stock pieces.

This idea is so radical that few have been willing to try it. For routine operations it does everything well and safely. Try it and see. I like the CMT very thin kerf blades for this task.