We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Part of my shop roof has direct exposure to lakeside wind, and needs replacement. It is probably about 22' x 10', so not large. We have been here for 15 years, and the roof was in place when we arrived. Given the weather it has lasted rather well. The most straightforward thing would be to re-roof with asphalt shingles. The only thing against it is if there is a lighter, cheaper, and more windproof alternative, I would be for it. Local big box stores only have asphalt and most metal suppliers seem to want to measure the roof and do the instal themselves. Any suggestions for an alternative? Would rolled roofing work? Pitch is something short of 6/12, maybe 4/12. I will strip off the old shingles.
Hard to beat the "value" of asphalt shingles. I would stay away from roll roofing. Generally considered the cheapest of the cheap and probably won't last as long as even cheap shingles. Most three tab asphalt shingles sold today are rated for 25 years and I think roll roofing is rated for ten years.
There are multi dimensional shingles that have two layers of material and they are rated for thirty years or more, but they weigh substantially more than three tab shingles and are more expensive. I generally use them on my rental property to get the longer life expectancy, but I may have to rethink that now that the three tab ones are rated for 25 years rather than the 20 years that used to be the case.
Did you mean lighter in weight or light in color? Back in the day when the shingles were felt based the white shingles would last almost fifty percent longer than the black ones. In those days they were rated for 15 years but you would get barely fifteen from the black ones and 20 to 22 for the white ones. The shingles are fiberglass based today and there does not seem to be that much variation in the life expectancy.
Incidentally, the so called warranty on shingles starts at 4 in 12 slope. Steeper than that, you get longer life. Less steep may not last as long and if they get significantly flatter you need to go to a low slope application or not use them.
It is a good idea to remove the original layer. A nail over may cost you 10 to 30% on the life expectancy.
I would love to have a metal roof, but they are significantly more expensive.
A couple of years ago we replaced our roof with steel shingles, with a so called lifetime warrenty. The only reason I went that way so my wife would not have to worry about a new roof down the line if she outlives me. The way my health is going that`s the way it`ll be. So far they look very good, people that come by cann`t tell that they are steel and not asphalt. Larry
I just finished reroofing my old barn and workshop. The shop was leaking and the old shingles would not make it through another winter. I'm 63 year old and I didn't want to go through the hassle of stripping and disposing of the old shingles. I ordered Fabral 4 rib metal roofing from my local building supplier. The sheets were custom cut to the exact length needed to cover my roof so that there were no seams. The metal roofing was painted "light gray" and has a 40 year paint warranty and are 36" wide. They were relatively light and installed very easily. With help, you can cover a roof very quickly.
I did the cost analysis and by the time you add the ridge cap, end caps, ect. The metal was only about 25% more than the asphalt shingles. My supplier's price was $2.70 per linear ft. with no additional charge for custom cuts. But, being able to go over the old shingles and the labor savings with the quick install easily made the metal more attractive to me.
Fabral has a whole series of how to videos on Utube. It might help you see what the metal roofing is like to install. A cordless "impact" drill makes the installation much easier. Also, Fabral has special screw placement spec's for high wind prone regions.
My barn and shop now have a new lease on life! They look great and crisp! And I never have to climb up there ever again! Yahooooo!
When we moved in the shop had asphalt roll. It HAS lasted 13 years but I looked at the prices and when I replace I'll go with asphalt shingles. Cost a bit more but I think they'll last longer.
as an alternative to shingles. I put this on my first "shop" - a simple pole building with a straight roofline and currently have it on a shed behind my shop. Its an easy DIY product - big sheets, no sharp edges. Bought mine at the big blue box.
Your dreaming if you think Hail won't damage steel roofing.
In Abilene on June first we had a Hail storm come through twice, once at 8:30PM and it did a u turn and back at 11:00PM. Hail ranged up to softball size and a lot of it.
It destroyed over six hundred roofs in town and the only roofing material to survive was some commercial buildings with Foam roofing .
It made little or no difference if the roof was steel , it beat it all to hell anyway.
The county and city redid the Government buildings in foam, which is a flat roof application, the ones in town that had it escaped any damage.
I recommend the same shingle we had on the rentals , they survived without any leaks , which many steel ones did not, but still needed to be replaced , which State Farm paid for.
That particular Shingle is Heritage Brand , multi layered Asphalt , thirty year composition.
You get what you pay for in roofing, don't cover old shingles and get a good local guy to guide you.
Barry, by heavy I meant weight. I'm 52, but I have a lot of "problems" and carrying shingles up ladders is not a good deal for me. But I can get it done, and hiring it out doesn't make any sense in my situation. I was daydreaming, and thought of a way that might work to lift them up to my deck then scoot them across to the roof.
I did a roll roof once that was really low angle, and covered the whole thing under there with rain and ice shield. The hope was my parents would never have to redo it. My mom who was @ 79 at the time was helper for that job! I just thought it might be less damaged by wind but the low life expectancy vs. the fact I could do shingles at the moment whereas I might not even be around to do re-roll in 10 years...
Thanks, I will look into those products, and value the suggestions. I thought of one other thing that will affect this project. I could sell the house at some future date. I always forget that one when I am looking ahead to a new product and options. But really, the house and shop will look better with matching shingles. I hate when I go to make a change and I have to just keep on keeping on, most likely.
I seriously considered Ondura when it became obvious that a new roof on the shop was going to be required NOW.
However, after reading numerous threads on the internet from very unhappy customers I went with steel instead. Any product has supporters and detractors. In this case, all the detractors (and there were lots of them) said the same things, the most important being that the “warranty” if a problem occurred was pretty much worthless.
I might consider Ondura for a small job like a storage shed or a small porch but the shop has steel panels that should allow me to never have to put a foot on the roof again.
Tom, I pretty much agree with everything that has been said below. I think roll roofing is much less resistant to blow off than shingles. There is another product, modified bitumen sheet that is significantly better and can be stuck down to the deck, but is is significantly more expensive and a pro job to install it. It looks a lot like roll roofing.
The last two roofs I have done I bought the shingles based on the fact they would deliver them onto the roof. In one case they brought a scissor body truck and parked near the house and put them along the ridge. They "charged my wife $25 extra for putting them on the roof. It was supposed to be apart of the job, but I thing the guys on the truck wanted beer money. Thinking back, that might have been the best $25 I ever spent. The other company used a boom truck and lifted the pallet to the roof and we set the shingle along the ridge. (Put the shingles at the top, so you use them up before they get in your way)
You might be able to rent a ladder jack. the gadget lots of roofers use to run the bundles up a ladder. Since you are working at your own house you might even find an electric one.
I sympathise. The shingles were worth nothing to me on the ground. I'm 62 and don't have any significant issues, but my knees said NO! to carrying fifty bundles up a ladder.
New three tab shingle weight about 75 to 80lbs per bundle and there are three to the square (100 sf). The multidimensional ones are heavier, but they will have four or five bundles to the square and the bundles weigh about the same.
One thing to look out for is that some of the shingles are now what appears to be Metric. OH! Horror, Not METRIC. They don't mention the metric system because we here in the good old US of A are metric phobic, but the older shingles were 12" by 36" and you exposed 5". The newer ones in some brands are 39+" by 13+" and you expose something like 5 5/8". I found this to be something of a PITA. Its so easy to mark off 5" courses, but a pain to do 5 5/8".
Also, if you opt for the multidimensional ones check the nailing pattern carefully. They have a nailing line on them and you should nail ON THE LINE, not above or below.
And one more thing, this is a great time to buy or rent a nail gun. You can buy one and then sell it on Craig's list. Best thing ever.
I have an old (1880's) house with an add on "garage". I converted the "garage" which is about 10 X 24 to a storage area, but the issue I had was that when they added this structure the roof pitch was around 3-12. When I purchased the house about 40 years ago the roof was leaking. I replaced all the shingles on the house (including the add on) with a top quality 3 tab. The add on, due to the low pitch started leaking in about 5 years. About 10 years ago I replaced the roof on the add on with Ondura. This looks good, and I have had NO issues with leaks, nor do I expect any for the next 20 years - By then it will be my son's problem as I am sure I will be gone. As far as warranty, if you read the fine print on any roof coating (Ondura, 3 tab, roll, rubber etc.) you will probably find it would cost more to file a warranty after 5 years than the money you will get back.
I agree on buying a nailer. Even a HF nailer as you will complete the job within the warranty period. However, you are covering not very much shop, so not sure there. Even the Porter Cable and Senco's are a lot cheaper (they are probably made in China too) now.
Maybe hire a helper?
Delivery on the roof would be the way to go, but for a small order, it might be a lot more fee, I don't know.
I'd put shingles back. I can tell you it sounds wierd, but they hold up well, even in a hurricane. In a hurricane if a few tabs lift and blow off, usually the roof survives. With metal, if a corner lifts, the whole sheet is going! I'd put whatever the house has or is going to have. I usually pic a light grey or so.
If you live in FL near the coast, you probably can't use Ondura and comply with the hurricane code. And insurers are now sending out inspectors to check roofs for age and compliance.
So where-ever you live, please check your codes to make sure it meets your local requirements before purchasing a particular product.
I certainly would consider Ondura for some situations (barns, etc-seems to be perfect) but only if it met code in my area.