Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Broken router bit

Posts

Broken router bit

#1

JL

Broken router bit

JL

I was using a 1/2" shank 1/2" upcut spiral bit yesterday. Plunge cut then gently ease across. Brand new bit.

I've done this repeatedly with my 1/2" shank 3/8" upcut spiral bit. Needless to say, I'm not pleased.

Was the bit defective? I can hog out the area of the cut with my drill press or I can take more shallow passes if it is a process problem.

I am contemplating taking the bit back for a replacement and trying to negotiate either a free or reduced price on the replacement.

Re: Broken router bit

#2

Re: Broken router bit

Larry in nw ohio

I would take it back, but how deep was your cut, you should take several passes if it is more than say 3/8-1/2" deep. Especially if it`s hardwood. Larry

Re: Broken router bit

#3

Re: Broken router bit

del schisler

Take it back must have been defective. If from a box store ?? I don't buy from them. I do that type of cut all the time with 1/2" bit and 3/8" and never a problum i would say i take a 3/8" cut or maybe more just what ever i plunge to but keep it around 3/8" is the best or less.

Re: Broken router bit

#4

Sounds Defective

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Upcut spirals are solid carbide and could easily have had an undiscovered defect in the material or could have been dropped and partially fractured anywhere along the supply chain. You're lucky you didn't get hurt by flying carbide.

I would take the bit and the workpiece you were routing to the store for a replacement (free) bit.

BTW, as a matter of personal practice, I never take more than a 1/4" bite with any router bit. I get cleaner cuts with less vibration using multiple passes. IMV, that's what the stop gauge and a plunge router are all about.

Re: Broken router bit

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: Broken router bit

Moses Yoder

There's a good chance the bit was not defective. If you go more than 1/2" deep in one pass, the bit will set up vibrations that will snap a solid carbide bit. Straight steel bits with carbide edges are different.

Re: Broken router bit

#6

Re: Broken router bit

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Morning JL,

I'm assuming you made multiple passes. I believe the bit may have been defective, and if I were a manufacturer/importer, I'd give you the benefit of any doubt. I always buy my router bitsd thru mail order, from vendors who offer lifetime guarantees. Both my #3 son and I have exercised that guarantee a couple times from Woodline USA. Never a problem obtaining a free replacement.

George

Re: Broken router bit

#7

Re: Broken router bit

Jim Dillon

JL,

I had the same thing happen to my CMT 1/2-inch upcut spiral bit (one of my most expensive bits) when I plunge cut the bit into jatoba (a very hard wood). The end chipped off and I was sure glad I was wearing my safety goggles. Was the bit defective? Who knows. In my case, I believe I plunged way too rapidly and did not have a stop set for limiting the depth of cut. I also think the router may have twisted just a hair because I did not have good control. Lessons learned, I guess. I did not consider asking for a replacement as it appeared that the fault was very likely mine. In your case, if it is convenient, I would try asking for a replacement. Can't hurt.

Jim