Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

Posts

OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#1

JL

OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

JL

We are replacing the countertop in our kitchen. We want Corian or an equivalent.

Home Depot has the Corian in the color that we would like on "sale" for $2588. Lowes has their brand (not Corian, but Allen and Roth) for about $5 less. So virtually the same price. The colors and everything else are equivalent.

There are NO local dealers for solid surface countertops, just stone. We do not want stone. So we pretty much have to go with HD or Lowes. They contract out of course and the installer/fabricators are nowhere near.

So - Home Depot or Lowes. Which would you deal with??

TIA.

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#2

Clint Searl

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice ne

Clint Searl

They both will stand behind their products, so what's your favorite color,,,,orange or blue?

Clint

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#3

Clint Searl

Corian can't beat


Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#4

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice ne

FredD

Corian is Duponts patented product and has always been high in my opinion for something that is as easily damaged as it is.

But i would go with it and not with anything from a Home Depot or Lowes contractor/installer.

Find a countertop shop , they are everywhere.

About the price you were quoted , make sure that included the sink and edge treatment which invariably are extra, for instance a trim added to the edge to make it appear thicker then it is.

I did kitchens for a living for years and never had a customer go with Corian after they had been shown a professional Ceramic Tile job with tile all the way to the bottom of the upper cabinets.

Granite is popular now , but a hell of a mess in your house during installation.

FredD

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#5

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice ne

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Disagree.

We've had two ceramic tile countertops, and will NEVER consider another one. Between grout problems, and needing bleach and a toothbrush to keep the grout clean, they're a hassle. Also, hard (nearly impossible) to have an under-mount sink with tile.

As for granite - which we have now - it pretty much seems impervious so long as reasonable care is taken. Acidic juices are said to possibly etch it, but we've taken care not to let that happen. Seal it once a year, and you're done 'caring for it.'

As for messy installation, I don't know what you mean. The techs came and measured everything for templating, took the template for the sink we'd already bought, and came back two weeks later to install. Installation of about 60 ft², and 6" backsplash took about three hours, including two epoxied seams. No mess. Only odor was the acetone used to clean the seams. No hassle.

Never had Corian®, but have heard that it scratches easily, but and be sanded and polished to repair. Have also heard it'll melt under a hot pan, but you're not supposed to put hot pans on the counter anyway..

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#6

no relevant info to base a decision

Bill Tindall

The installer/fabricator is everything. There is considerable skill and experience involved which can result in considerable differences in the final result. So, you pick the best installer, as judged by a site visit and inspection of previous work.

Curious...why was rock rejected? We too initially rejected rock because I thought it all looked like tombstones or bank lobies. But in recent years a multitude of new sources have developed in lighter colors, and different minerals.

Daughter choose Corian and found it scratched easily and in general showed wear. Out rock (a gneiss from India) has been durable and hides dirt so well it is hard to know when it needs cleaning. Immune to hot stuff too. As a mineral collector I love the pink garnets scattered through the white feldspar matrix crystals.

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#7

Re: no relevant info to base a decision

Dale Penkala

Hello JL

My brother has had 2 dealings with Home Depot. 1st one was on his kitchen cabinets. (Which he had granite installed) When he took the cabinets out of the boxes they were shipped in he found 2-3 of the cabinets that had enough damage to them that he didn't install them. They had to be replaced. Don't remember how long it took to get them but when your installing cabinets its to long! In the end they did get him the cabinets and he was a happy camper!

Now the 2nd didn't go so good! This one was all new windows. He placed the order and they told him they would be in on such a such date and when that time came they were not in. This went on for over 4 months! Long story short he cancelled the order and got his down payment back.

Personally something like cabinets/counter tops I'm going to go to a place that specilizes in countertops. I really want granite so that is what I'll be getting for my kitchen.

Anyway good luck with your project!

Dale

Mid-Michigan

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#8

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice ne

Joseph Mulherin

I am a retired pipefitter/plumber and when we redid our entire kitchen a few yrs ago we chose to go with the Corian. Bought it installed from a local dealer and the cost was only $900.

If you get any scratches on it thru cutting with knives just use your orbital sander and they will disappear.i

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#9

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice ne

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon JL,

We used Home Depot. My wife helped them design a floor plan and she chose the cabinets. Then my #3 son got involved, and altered the floor plan for the better. He does kitchens as a contractor. He also suggested granite, which he ordered thru a supplier/installer. We were obligated to buy a large slab, which they cut and installed/epoxied into an "L", and its seamless. With the offcut from the granite, I had them cut me a kitchen table top, a window sill for over the sink, a cutting board and lazy susan. Everything matches. Ken was present during the installation, so there were no hassles and no mess. They cleaned up.

Ken was especially anxious they installed the counter with the correct overhang. We used tile to run between the bottoms of the upper cabinets and the counter.

We ordered the best cabinets HD had. There was a problem with two of the doors, and the company replaced them by direct shipment immediately. The problem was cosmetic, and very minor in my judgment, but SWMBO insisted.

Our former kitchen was gutted, and even the old floor removed and leveled. The ceiling was also leveled, and also some wall work. We are very satisfied with the HD portion of the undertaking. However, I'm sure we shop at different stores!

George

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#10

JL

No local installers for Corian.

JL

There are two granite/stone installers/fabricators.

We don't want stone for several reasons. We like Corian. We had it in our old kitchen and it worked well for us for many years (until we moved). Never had a problem. The granites available in our area are too dark. We currently have a granite tile top. We REALLY don't like it. Cost is another factor. Stone would probably run us another $1000.

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#11

broaken search.. and more on rock choice

Bill Tindall

While there may not be a local installer there clearly is an installer somewhere willing to travel to your area to install. Suggest broadening your search. The best local installer in my area installs at least 60 miles from home base. It is likely that contacting Corian HQ will get you a list of installers as they all have to be approved by DuPont to receive material from DuPont.

Not trying to convince you on rock but to get the story straight on choice for other interested parties...Somewhere there will be a rock distributor in your area. We have two to choose from, each about 100 miles distant. Every medium sized city will have one.

These distributors will stock thousands of slabs of rock in a hundred or more varieties. They are set up to offer retail customers and decorators the opportunity to select rock for a job. They are even amenable to knocking off a corner to be taken away for evaluation. While visiting with a client at one of these distributors in Travels Rest, SC we found there was light colored rock available (for example Indian gneiss). One can pick out the rock of choice and have it sent to the fabricators the distributor deals with. In our case they even recommended a reliable choice.

The bottom line is that you don't have to deal with the tiny amount of rock in inventory at a local fabricator. In or case we found that there is a gneiss from India that is mostly light colored feldspar and quartz with a bit of black mica and pink garnets.

And all rock is not created equal. The small fly by night fabricators ($39/ sqft installed!) may not be getting the best quality rock. Rock even from the same quarry can be more or less porous and or have weak places. This lesser quality rock often can wind up at the El Cheapo fabricators.

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#12

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice ne

Craig Daymon

Granite. It won't melt when you put a hot pan on it and it has been "in fashion" for hundreds, if not thousands of years. If you shop around a bit, especially in the current market, I suspect you would be able to find a nice color for the same price...maybe even less.

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#13

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice ne

John McGaw

Up front I will say that I've never had a Corian countertop. What I have had is friends and acquaintances who have had it and to a one they all have bad things to say about it and none seem to be willing to go that way again. Complaints are that it is easily damaged and stained and that, while surface problems can be sanded out sometimes, the finish never looks right afterward and deeper damage leaves highly visible evidence in the form of dips and waves.

When I redo my kitchen, which has ceramic tile countertops as an interim measure, I will be looking for one of the recycled (glass in cement looks fantastic) materials. Failing that I will be going for what is generically called 'quartz' material which is an advance over Corian in that it has a higher mineral content, more resistant minerals, and less plastic binder. The high percentage of plastic binder in Corian seems to be the root of most of its problems. I would take granite countertops if I could find what I wanted cheaply enough and prices are coming down pretty sharply for some colors and from some sources so there might still be natural stone in my future but if I get it I won't be getting the highly-polished variety since, to me, the antique finish or the honed finish look better.

There are other recycled material used in countertops including paper and something like that seems attractive but since they are so new I don't have a feel for the long-term reliability. Anything I do in my kitchen no will be expected to last as long as I do.

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#14

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice ne

FredD

Well Jim, having one or two Tile counters certainly doesn't qualify you as a expert on them as your message reveals.

What you would call a undermount sink is actually a sink set on the substrate and the tile and trim pieces overlay it.

Piece of cake and done all of the time by Professional tile setters and here is one craft that definitely requires a expert in what is known as a "Trowel Trade".

Of course I am talking about Tile set in Mortar, commonly called a Mud job in the trade, anything else is a "glue job" and not considered a Tile job by many Jurisdiction's "Grades and Standards" for Kitchen and Bath tile.

As for the mess I mentioned, including my Brother's last Kitchen upgrade, the installers cut the sink hole on the job and naturally didn't mask off the Kitchen, so you might well imagine the grit from the Granite through out the house, not a pretty sight or a happy Wife.

For Corian or it's clones , I have never recommended it for some of the reasons you state.

I am glad your happy with your Granite , it should outlast you , just like a Professional Tile job.

FredD

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#15

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice ne

Larry in NW Ohio

JL We redid our kithen about 7 years ago and we put Silestone in from Home Depot and a local, installer put it in for us. Then about 2 years or so we noticed a crack developing just off the right side of the sink. We watched it for a few weeks, since the warrenty was for 10 years or more, so no real big hurry. Well it keeped getting bigger so we contacted HD and got someone who seemed concerened, so we went through all the calls and waiting and fianally somone came out to look at it and take pictures. After a few more weeks we got a call and they tried to tell us we did sonething to cause it. Like put a hot pan on it. No way. So called HD again and the lady we talked to earlier was put into another department so we got someone else, sounded like a very young person, but sounded very concerened and very excited to get this taken care of. Try to shorten this, she really got things going, she would call us about every two weeks to see how it was going, if nothing then she would do some calling. Anyway after a couple of months they came out and replaced it, all brand spanking new. So we are pleased with that. Larry

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#16

Sounds like a sloppy job...

John in NM

I've never seen granite guys do their cuts inside like that... but perhaps that's because I was working in Tucson, where it's easy enough to take the slab back outside for the cuts. Fairly appalling that the installers wouldn't mask off the room inside though, makes me think that they were fairly new at it or not very well trained.

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#17

Am I the only Formica lover left?

Ronster

I personally like Formica-like products and their price is right too. Easy to clean. Lots of colors/patterns. Can set a glass on it without being gentle. Not fussy except hot pots are a no-no.

Why am I in such a minority these days? Am I missing something?

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#18

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

My opinion...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Formica isn't a natural material. That's why I'm also not a big fan of Corian and its equivalents, laminate flooring, MDF cabinets, vinyl siding, etc.

Jason

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#19

Moses Yoder

Re: Formica is cheap

Moses Yoder

Pretty much everyone knows the three main countertop materials, Formica, Corian, and Granite, and they know Formica is the cheapest of the three. Therefore if you have Formica Laminate countertops, people will think less of you.

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#20

Re: Formica is cheap

Ronster

So, ... even if I like it more than the other options, I do so at my own peril cause people will think badly of me. Dang, I hate when that happens;)

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#21

I have formica and am a loser and eat dirt

Thomas S Stockton

oh well it's cheap and getting anything to work easily in a round house is a pain

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#22

Re: Sounds like a sloppy job...

FredD

The excuse given for cutting the sink hole in situ was that cutting it anywhere else ran the risk of breaking the slab at the hole.

And your right it was a sloppy job .

FredD

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#23

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice ne

Jim Dillon

JL,

If you like Corian, maybe a search of DuPont's web site will lead you to ALL certified installers in your area (not just the ones HD/Lowes uses); there must be someone somewhere.

We have two kitchens in two houses with Corian countertops. One is probably 16 years old, and the other is roughly 8 years old and also includes a Corian sink. We love them both and have had absolutely no problems. We chose the matte finish in both and this likely helps a lot in minimizing the appearance of scratches etc. I have also heard of problems with reflection of under cabinet lights onto the glossy-surfaced Corian. Obviously, we do not set hot pans on the Corian, and run hot water into the Corian sink prior to dumping large quantities of boiling water into the sink. The cream colored sink cleans up great with Softscrub with bleach, and the countertops need just a routine swipe with a damp rag, and maybe Softscrub for a possible stain. Other than that, we have had zero issues. And I love the soft feel of the Corian.

I would find out who HD or Lowes uses to install their Corian counter tops, call them, and get references about their installs. For our second kitchen, we first shopped the local HD. Frankly, they didn't seem to be interested in ordering a different color from what they had in stock, so we went to a custom installer. But that may have been our own bad luck with the local HD. And "routine" embellishments like moldings, decorative edging, drip edging on the back wall can add a LOT to the cost.

Keep looking, I'm sure you will find someone who you have confidence in and it may turn out to be HD or Lowes.

Jim

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#24

JL

Thanks for all the responses

JL

We put in an order at Home Depot for a Corain counter top.

Turns out there was a "sale" going on. Therefore the price was a bit lower than Lowes. Tried for a couple of days to find local suppliers/fabricators. The one company that supposedly does solid surface (not stone) counter tops did give me a call, I gave them the dimensions - and they never called me back.

My wife and I discussed Silestone and quartz equivalents. She really want's a coved backsplash. We like the "warmer" feel of Corain. We were happy with our Corian counter top before and will probably be just as happy with this one.

Re: OT - Corian or equivalent countertop advice needed

#25

Re: Thanks for all the responses

Barry Irby

JL, I was going to mention that there MUST be somebody willing to install this stuff in your area because there is nearly a 100% certainty that these are not Lowe's or HD employees, but are subcontracting the work. But, you have made your decision, so Good Luck. I am not a fan of this product, but you have experience with it and do like it so that's great. Post some pictures for us.