Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Help with a frustrating project

Posts

Help with a frustrating project

#1

Help with a frustrating project

doug f, san clemente, ca

Since we had a long weekend, I decided to take up the task of once again sharpening all the kitchen knives. Aargh!!!! Try as I might, I can't ever get the super sharp edge that the knives had right out of the box.

Chisels and plane irons have never been a problem; super sharp with 0.001" shavings consistently. But knives have got the best of me.

I use a Spyderco jig with both grey and white stones and the edge is OK, but still won't whisper through tomatoes like the factory edge does.

Any suggestions would be appreciated.

Have a great Labor Day.

Doug

PS. I have a mixture of Henckels and Wosthof knives from a 3" paring knife to a 10" Chefs knife.

Re: Help with a frustrating project

#2

Re: Help with frustrating project

paul in AZ

I picked up an Accusharp in a restaurant supply house. It quickly does a wonderful job on straight edges but I'm not impressed with it on serrated edges. A few passes and knives will cut like a straight razor.

It is only about $10.

A while back I saw what looked like the identical tool in Woodcraft's store. Check their website.

Re: Help with a frustrating project

#3

Clint Searl

Re: Help with a frustrating project

Clint Searl

I hold the oil stone in my dominant hand and the knife in the other, bracing the knife to stabilize it, then moving the stone in circles from one end of the blade to the other at the angle where I feel the stone bite. When one side is evenly ground, flip the knife over and do the other side. Progress through the necessary grits to get a fine edge. I finish on a linen and leather strop.

Clint

Re: Help with a frustrating project

#4

Re: Help with a frustrating project *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

try one of these. My brother gave us one some years ago and they are fabulous.


Trident diamond steel

Re: Help with a frustrating project

#5

Re: Help with a frustrating project

Hal

I have used stones and jigs from Razor Edge Systems for years, and although it takes a little time, I can consistently get a true razor edge. You use the stones dry (in fact they caution you not to use water or oil). Address is 303 North 17th Ave. E.

Ely, Mn 55731

800-541-1548

They're not cheap, but you use only two stones, coarse and fine. Get the jig for sharpening knives.

Hal

Re: Help with a frustrating project

#6

Re: Help with frustrating project

Larry in NW Ohio

How does a person sharpen a serrated blade? Thank You. Larry

Re: Help with a frustrating project

#7

Clint Searl

Re: Help with a frustrating project

Clint Searl

They don't seem very forthcoming in describing the composition of their stones nor why they're superior to oil, water, diamond, or ceramic stones.

Clint

Re: Help with a frustrating project

#8

I have no idea.  Wish I did.


Re: Help with a frustrating project

#9

Re: Help with a frustrating project

Gary Smyth

We’re talking a utilitarian tool for food here. I buy good knives and I try to keep them as sharp as stainless gets. I have tried numerous steels, Spyderco (good, in my opinion), various sharpening blocks and stone combinations. Someone gave me a Smith’s yellow hand sharpener. Carbide steel and ceramic set and locked in a cross pattern. Fits in the palm of your hand and comes with a key chain of all things. I’ve seen them (correction, I’ve bought them (now four of them) for $3.50 each) over ebay. Don't scoff. These work like the Spyderco in that you draw the knife through the steel or ceramic, but this sharpens both sides at once and not nearly as expensive as the $45 - $70 you’ll pay for the Spyderco…that, and you can’t do scissors. You simply hold on to the yellow part and draw the knife through. It’s not for those not paying attention though. You have to watch what you’re doing. After a while you get used to the feel and the sound, and you tilt it slightly to feel the knife bite. It cuts at a slightly different angle than some of the other set angle sharpeners, but it works, and I’ll not go back when it comes to kitchen knives. Now the only warning I have is that it takes off steel to get the initial setting. If you have less expensive knives it will take more steel than some better brands. Still, it takes off steel. Blades not set to the Smith’s angle will also deform the ceramic over time. Once set, one or two draws and a wipe before cutting is all you'll need for the next ten years. If you are concerned about having a pretty knife forever then don’t use this. On the other hand, if you want a knife that doesn’t need to saw, can slide down the skin of a fish, cut fat off of wet chicken, make an incision in porkchops, and has been known to slice through a dish towel if you dry it off at the wrong angle, then check out the Smith’s. Oh, serrated blades don't do any better here than anywhere else.

Re: Help with a frustrating project

#10

Re: Help with a frustrating project

FredD

I buy Carbon steel knives , Chicago brand and use their Steel to keep the edge.

The steel is used before each use and it does not remove metal, it realigns it.

The cheap knives my Wife uses for tools are maintained with a inexpensive Carbide die available in Hardware stores and Co ops around here.

FredD

Re: Help with a frustrating project

#11

Serrated knives

Chad Pearson

For regular knives I purchased a Chef's Select knife sharpener. It seems to do a pretty good job on straight knives. I feel I can do better if I really spend the time on my waterstones but given difficult duty it just doesn't seem worth the effort compared to the electric sharpener.

I like you have always had trouble with serrated knives. Even the ceramic hones I see elsewhere in this thread that are supposed to work on serrated knives could never get my favorite bread knife back to its factory edge. Part of the reason I purchased the Chef's Select sharpener was because it said it worked on serrated knives (by using the final honing wheel only). Unfortunately it gave only mediocre results. The wonderful thing it did do however is spark an idea to use my felt honing wheel for the serrated edge. I used green honing compound on a stiff felt wheel to hone the side of the knife with the serrated edge. I then ran the flat side of the blade over a 6000 grit waterstone to remove any burr. This technique gave a far superior edge to my bread knife than all the methods I have tried in the past. It isn't quite like the factory edge but it is very close.