Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Whirlwind *LINK*

Posts

Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#2

As a SawStop owner

Neal in San Jose

And someone who will admit to having a digit saved by the SawStop, I'm delighted to see this. If this device ever makes it to production, then free market competition should drive the price of the SawStop down and maybe make it more affordable, thereby saving more digits.

However, it appears that this new device has a shortcoming that, in my shop anyway, would mean I wouldn't use it all of the time. I use a sled for many operations on the table saw, and my Excaliber guard isn't usable with a sled. It looks like this one wouldn't be usable in conjuction with a sled, either. I'm not clear how much trouble it would be to take it off and replace it after using the sled, but the Excaliber is a simple one-handed-slide-it-back-into-place operation. Maybe version II?

He also states it takes 1/8 of a second for the blade to stop. That's a long time in the middle of an accident. In my accident, I got touched by exactly one tooth of an 80 tooth blade. In 1/8 of a second, several hunderd teeth would have gone by.

Clever idea, tho, and probably a lot better than nothing.

Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#3

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Yabbut...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

This one does not require contact with the blade like the SawStop, and it also does not damage the blade.

I'll agree, though, that the downside is that it's an over-blade guard. I wouldn't use it (I wouldn't buy the SawStop, either).

The bottom line is that our brains still do a better job of distinguishing our own flesh from the wood we're trying to cut. We just have to use said brain EVERY TIME we make a cut.

Jason

Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#4

Did you make this sign?

Henry Higginbotham

Probably should be standard equipment. :)


Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#5

Steve Strickland

Re: A couple of plusses

Steve Strickland

It looks like the mounting bracket lies entirely in the kerf. If this is true we should be able to use sleds with it. However, my jigs don't need protection like this because my pieces are always clamped, never hand held.

This device is a retrofit so you don't need to buy an entire saw to get the protection.

When the device is triggered, you don't have to buy a replacement cartridge. Just start up the saw and keep working.

The stop is activated by touching the cover, not the blade. I don't see the 1/8th second stopping time as a downside because you're too far from the blade.

I hope this breaks the patent monopoly held by Saw Stop, which was my only objection to making the safeties required on new saws.

Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#6

What I'd like to see is....

Brian in SLO

For SawStop to make a conversion for some of the more popular saws. I understand some of the complexities that may be involved in undertaking such a product. I've always hoped and thought something like the Whirlwind would come along but I just don't like the idea of an over blade guard, I like to see what I'm cutting. To accomplish that, 1/8 second is just too much time.

I don't mind the thought of replacing a blade and cartridge if it means I don't have to lose a digit in the process (I've been repaired way too many times without the help of my woodworking equipment).

If sawstop (or anyone else for that matter) could come up with a quick firing safety mechanism retrofit that allows us to operate in, what some may call, our unsafe ways, it surely would be less costly than a whole new saw.

I'm sure there are a few Unisaws out there, maybe a couple anyway.

Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#7

Re: What don`t understand is

Larry in NW Ohio

What I don`t understand about the saw stop is, when it fires it drops the blade and also jams the blade into a piece of metal to stop it. Now, why is it necessary to jam the blade into a piece of metal to stop it. The way I look at it when the hand is moving toward the blade and is going to touch the blade and does, as soon as it does it drops and it does this very quickly. In my way of thinking, and I`m probably wrong here, but since the blade drops so fast, would it not be down and out of the way of the finger by the time the finger has time to get farther into blade, thus no need to stop the blade. The blade would be under the table and out of the way and it could just coast to a stop or have a brake type system to stop it. I thought ever since the saw stop came out and I seen how quick the blade drops. At least that is my way of thinking. Larry

Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#8

Re: Did you make this sign?

steve mackay

If we mandated that sign on all consumer goods we wouldn't need all the gadgets !

Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#9

Someone check my numbers

Gary Smyth

If a 3450RPM saw with an 80 tooth blade is running accurately there are 276000 teeth per minute passing a point. Dividing that by 60 seconds I get 4600 teeth per second. 1/8 of that is 575 teeth in 1/8th of a second past a point and that is 7.2 revolutions of the 80 tooth blade. That is a several fingers worth of of damage. If my math is correct there is no hope for that saw.

Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#10

Re:Numbers are probably correct BUT

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

You are analyzing the operation improperly. You are basing your data on the premise that the operator's finger / flesh is touching the blade at the time of actuation. This is not correct - the capacitance safety system works before that occurs. For several years before I retired as an Engineer, I used "Proxagard" capacitance safety systems on many automated machines. They generate a "field" around "antenna". This "field" is shaped by the antenna. On the machines I designed, the antenna was made using ridged copper tubing. By adjusting the system you could cause machine halt when you were several inches from the danger zone. These were OSHA approved safe systems used on Punch presses, automated inline machines, rotary tables etc. By setting the antenna position and field strength, it could be made impossible for anyone to actually enter the danger area before everything had stopped moving.

Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#11

craigd

Re: What don`t understand is

craigd

>Now, why is it necessary to jam the blade into a piece of metal to stop it

I wonder if the energy generated by the jam is what causes the blade to drop so fast? Think of a climb cut with the router, the saw blade really wants to run down that piece of metal quickly.

Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#12

Re: Whirlwind

FredD

The Power Tool Institute finally got around to addressing the SawStop attempt to have the Government force Gass's invention down everybody's throat.

The article in this issue of WoodShopNews states it very well and should be a must read for those who have heard nothing but rumors over the last three years.

FredD

Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#13

I believe you are correct...

John in NM

The blade dropping is part of dealing with the momentum of the blade and the physics of stopping so suddenly. I would guess that it is this mechanism that makes it so hard to retro-fit to existing saws - you'd need a whole new motor-arbor trunion.

Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#14

Pretty neat Larry....

John in NM

I bet you could design a Theremin too :D

Here's a question though, if the overblade guard is a negative for many users, couldn't the guard be raised a bit for better visibility and the field strength increased?

Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#15

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I'm sure you could, but...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...if the guard and field generator are too far away, then you have to keep your hands too far from the blade.

Too far from the blade?!? Yes, that's also dangerous, as then it is harder to push a work piece through the blade parallel to the cut without introducing torque/rotation, thus increasing the chances of binding and kickback.

Jason

Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#16

Please summarize the response from...

Tom Dunlap

...The Power Tool Institute.

I'll try to thumb a copy of the article at the borg but my timing might be off.

Thanks,

Tom

Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#17

PTI Response *LINK*

Bob Lang

The statement from the Power Tool Institute is available in PDF format from the link at the bottom of the blog post linked below.

Bob Lang


PTI Statement

Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#18

That's funny...

John in NM

Whenever I'm cutting something large enough to induce significant torque or rotation, my hands tend to be further from the blade in any case - usually more or less centered on whatever it is I'm pushing. Small work where my hands might be closer to the blade (were it not for push sticks) don't seem to be excessively torquey.

However, one could certainly engineer a field antenna that would give you the desired field area at a given height. Might not work to simply raise an existing one, but that's not quite what I had been talking about anyway.

Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#19

Re: PTI Response

FredD

Thanks Bob,

FredD

Re: Whirlwind *LINK*

#20

Re: Pretty neat Larry....

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I'm not sure you could design an antenna which would allow you to effectively safeguard the operator from the blade while allowing clearance for vision and push sticks etc.. The Proxagard units also required calibration prior to operation every shift. Leaving this to "untrained" saw operators might be as dangerous as no guarding. I personally use the Grr-Ripper system with the MJ splitter. I have accidentally put a few saw cuts in the Ripper but have never came close to injuring myself - and the Grr-Ripper system with the splitter works very well in preventing kickback. I have been woodworking for over 50 years - as well as using chain saws for firewood when I heated my home with wood for about 8 years. In all that time I have never made any trips to the hospital nor had any injuries from the saw-blades (other than cutting my finger on a stopped chain when sharpening). I have had bruises from kickback - all prior to using the Grr-Ripper and MJ splitter for the last 4-5 years. I would not purchase any add on guard system or other safety for my Unisaw - I don't use the one that came with it. I feel the devices I use (along with paying attention and common sense) is really all that is needed.