We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Taking my chest of drawers as an example, what about this construction would not be stout enough for a stack of drawers for a work bench, for example. Or, alternatively, what joinery would be used instead? What is puzzling me...... a case dovetailed together is the strongest construction I can think of. While I would make some utility work piece from something other than cherry(oak or maple for example), I would not use any different construction if I was after maximum robustness.
Consider hanging the drawers on full extension high quality (Accuride for example) drawer glides. These ball bearing glides work smoothly and enable the drawer to be pulled all the way out, should that be useful. In this case dovetail a top and bottom into the case sides with half blind dovetails(build a dovetailed box) and just fill in the drawers , which will just be boxes with a nice front. It can sit up off the floor on short legs or some skirt affair.
If you go this route shop for the glides. The wholesale cabinet supply places sell them cheaper than the woodworking stores. Moses will know the best place to get them.
If I were to build another goldsmith's bench, I'd include a deep and wide cutout (which, to fit my girth, would need to be very wide, indeed). I do like the traditional European workbenches, but I also like some of the more modern ones, as well. Decisions, decisions. Lots of top surface on this one:
You're right. Knowing when to stop planning and when to just build the thing is a good trait that I worked hard to cultivate, and for me, it's an ongoing battle. It doesn't have to be perfect.
Whatever you make, it will be something long used and treasured. It's a proven design, without a doubt. If she's trained on one, liked it and wants one, you can't go wrong.
Since we're at least 6 hours ahead of you here in the sunny Czech Republic, I didn't read your reply until morning. Also, I drank a cup of green tea pretty late in the evening. Due to those two factors, I couldn't go to sleep and my mind was running in circles over those drawer runners. Finally, I couldn't stand it and ran a search for "drawer runner cross grain" or some such and Google came up with a passage from "The Small Wood Shop by Fine Woodworking" where the authors describe how they did drawer runners (mortised and tenoned into the blade in front and slotted screw in back). That's when I realized that, although the drawer dividers in your piece appear to be frames, they obviously cannot be glued and the tenons on the drawer runners must float in the mortises front and back.
Thanks, now I understand this much better. I like your system of having dovetailed blades front and back - must be really strong. Now, what about the center? With a 27" depth, wouldn't it be good for there be one dovetailed blade at the very center of the cabinet (half-way up, half-way back), just for sure?
I can get good (and cheap) ball-bearing drawer glides here.
This would entail "selling out" to the "kitchen cabinet" method, which is fine.
I'm a little concerned, though, about the point John in NM brought up - i.e., the narrowness of these cabinets (7" clearance) coupled with the depth (27"), should the drawer glides be installed after assembly. But I suppose I could install them prior to assembly - but better be sure everything is dead on, huh?
- put a tall lip around the sides and back (that way things can only roll or fall off the FRONT)
- a replacable layer of melamine, or better yet, formica, Easier to keep clean and if it gets damaged
easy to replace
- skip the curved cut out in the top. You'll need to use a "bench pin" for sawing and pierecing and it'll need a not to fit in under the center of the bench front. It's also handy to have a small hole to the right and left of the bench pin slot - to push the end of a ring mandrel in at times.
Put a shelf in under the top and above the drawers. Great place to store ring mandrels, chasing and ball pean hammers, full size files, ring clamps, flex shaft handpieces, bench pins etc.
Drawers:
- deep drawers tend to lose things it the back. So a 16" drawer is preferable to a 26" drawer
-things get buried in deep drawers and you don't want to be digging around
in a drawer of sharp engraving tools, sharp wire cutters, scalpels, etc
- top four drawer fronts 2 1/4 to 2 1/2" tall
- fifth drawer down fronts 4 1/2" (deep enough for bur sets, dapping blocks
- 12" wide drawers
Cabinet under drawers - you need a place to keep an engraving block and its leather donut
10" minimum height, 12" better.
She's going to have a flex shaft, preferably a Foredom with a full wave rectifier foot pedal so she'll have good torque even at low rpms. That means you need an upright at the front right corner (if she's right handed) to hang it from AND she'll need to get the power cord to foot pedal THROUGH the back of the bench. And the plugs to these things ain't small. Put a hook on the flex shaft upright - to hand a jeweler's torch on when not being used.
Also figure on mounting a light, preferably a three fluorescent with special bulbs - that reproduce the light at the Antwerp diamond sorting room - north facing. Having another lamp with a round flourescent and magnifying glass is nice to have.
You want a pull out bench tray between the drawer units - a place to put the tools you're using for a job. The bottom of the tray should be at least 25" up from the floor.
You also want a pull out leather "apron" above the bench tray. The apron will catch an gold or silver "sawdust" produced by a jeweler's saw or files. At $1700+ an ounce you want to save that dust.
Find a jeweler who fabricates pieces from sheet stock and wires - and watch him/her work at the bench for a couple of hours. You'll quickly see that a jeweler's bench, life a woodworker's bench is a multi-purpose tool, not just a desk.
" Now, what about the center? With a 27" depth, wouldn't it be good for there be one dovetailed blade at the very center of the cabinet (half-way up, half-way back), just for sure?"
You raise a valid point. Often in a case like what you are building a full top will be dovetailed to the sides with half blind dovetails and a full bottom will be slipped in with a sliding dovetail. This arrangement is sufficient to keep the sides from cupping. No" half way" up blade is needed in the center of the side.
As an alternative to a solid top, a front back and middle "blade" can be installed, again with half blinds dovetails. This arrangement can be repeated on the bottom if the case sets on feet. The advantage is less weight to the case.
To clear things up Bill,I am in no way saying any of the techniques you have suggested weren`t up to the task. What I was suggesting to the person who started this thread was to think of this as a workbench and not a dresser, desk,or chest of drawers.
Your own follow on posts and some from others suggest things like heavy duty, ball bearing, full extension guides. IME these are more appropriate than wood guides for this application. I would also beef up the size of the uprights so they act as legs on a workbench and absorb/transmit the weight of the tools on the top and pounding forces directly to the floor and maybe use thick veneer faced plywood to connect those legs.
As mentioned in the posts from David and others there are needs such as lights,magnification and tooling such as a flex shaft motor and foot pedal that need to be met for this bench to reach it`s full potential.
History,tradition and decor are nice but around my shop they don`t trump durability and/or function. That is all I`m trying to get across to the fellow who originally asked for advice.
The ball bearing glides take up 1/2" each. And they require at least 1/2" drawer sides for the screws. If the opening is only 7" that leaves just 5" drawer opening, which seems uselessly small.
Their only advantage is they can be full extension which can make the back of the drawer more accessible. I don't know how you could install them in a 7" wide opening.
Thanks, Charlie, for your suggestions. Some of them have already been addressed, just not shown in the drawing. Others we are following and others we are not, at our own risk :-)
Lip around three sides of top - just didn't include it in the drawing
Melamine layer on the top - very good idea
Dispense with cut-out to increase top real estate - this is a European-style bench so the cut-out is essential. We are discussing possibly making it shallower.,
Bench pin slot - just not included in drawing. There will be a bench pin and a steel plate screwed to the top behind the bench pin - for use with the torch.
Extra shelf between oak top and oak cabinets - this is an interesting idea that we had toyed with before, and I even acquired a piece of plywood for that purpose. Now I see that it would make the cabinets shorter, and hence easier to make, so we're going back to it at your suggestion.
No deep drawers - good point, taken.
Four short upper drawers and two tall lower drawers - good point, taken.
12" wide drawers - agree with you, but unfortunately the overall width of the bench is limited so the cabinets have to be narrow.
Cabinet under drawers, flex-shaft upright - excellent ideas. She's a beginner, so engraving and flex-shafts are not in her present, but possibly in her future.
Lighting - right now she gets by with an ordinary balanced-arm lamp which can be fixed to the lip around the top.
Pull-out tray between the cabinets - didn't include it in the drawing, but it will be there.
Leather apron - her leather apron is made out of powder-coated sheet metal and is shown in the picture. This will be on runners and placed at the correct height for her.
Thanks again for your practical and useful suggestions.
I updated the cabinet design in light of your suggestions - thanks to everyone who replied, and especially to Bill, David and Charlie. I knew I would get help here, but I'm awestruck by the depth and usefulness - invaluable!
Based on the suggestions, I'm going for solid panel sides with three dovetailed horizontal "crossbars" top and bottom, and drawer blades front and back for each drawer (three of them in sliding dovetails, two upper drawer blades in shallow dados), and I'm making the whole cabinet somewhat shorter and putting it up on legs.
It will be sufficiently robust for any anticipated task. If you lived in Oklahoma you could use it for a tornado shelter. I think you will be glad the drawers got widened by an inch. By the time you are done making all those drawers you will be an expert at what ever technique you intend to use.
On the dovetails.....don't make them too tight. They should go together with light taps. Fitted this way there is no risk that they will set prematurely up during assembly.