Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Advice requested

Posts

Advice requested

#1

Advice requested

Nathan

I've undertaken to build a goldsmith workbench (in Oak) for my wife, something along the lines of this:


As you can see in the picture, the bench will consist of a top and two drawer units. The top is well underway, so the immediate task is to make the two "drawer units".

Each of the two drawer units will be approximately 27" deep and 35" tall and will consist of two side frames, a face frame, a back panel, and three horizontal reinforcement members (top, bottom, and center), which will be attached to the side frames using sliding dovetails.

Hopefully this makes sense - at least to someone. If it doesn't, let me know and I will post more drawings.

I'm not completely sure how to proceed with the side frames and horizontal reinforcement members. It seems like there are two possible game plans: (A) execute the dovetails only in the rails (prior to assembly), then put the horizontal reinforcement members into the dovetails, and then assemble the side frames, then put on the back panel and face frame. Or, (B) first assemble the side frames, then route the sliding dovetails all the way through the stiles and the rails, then put the horizontal members into the dovetails, then attach back panel and face frame.

What would be the comparative advantages and disadvantages of these two strategies?

Maybe there's a better/easier way that I haven't considered yet?

Re: Advice requested

#2

you lost me....

Bill Tindall

What you are building is a straightforward cabinet for which there are several typical means of construction. One traditional approach is illustrated in my recent post concerning the wood pile. At the other extreme is typical kitchen cabinet construction. From the wording it would seem that you are combining the the two.?.

Let us get some terms defined.....

"I'm not completely sure how to proceed with the side frames".......What is a side frame? Is the side of this piece frame and panel and not a solid panel as shown?

"and horizontal reinforcement members"....... Is this piece a drawer divider/blade, and if not how is it different?

(A) "execute the dovetails only in the rails" .... What part of this piece are the rails? How are reinforcement members and rails different? My confusion is that there are more parts described in the text than shown on the drawing.

The sides of a case like what is shown are typically held together by the drawer dividers(dovetailed into the sides for example), or a face frame is assembled with mortise and tenon(or equivalent) and the sides are attached to the face frame by some means (kitchen cabinet construction).

Re: Advice requested

#3

Bear with me

Nathan

Bill: thanks for filling in the terms (cabinet, drawer divider...) I was missing. Here's a more detailed picture of what I was trying to explain in words:


Yes, originally I assumed I would do full panels for the sides of the cabinets. But then I got to thinking maybe a frame and panel approach would be easier and use up less wood. (Not that I don't have enough...)

Here's a picture of what I was trying to describe. I only drew the dovetails on the top drawer divider/blade only. Please imagine them being there in the center and bottom dividers as well.

To rephrase the question: should I build as shown in the picture, routing out the dovetails after the side frames are assembled, or should I route the dovetails in the rails only, assemble the rails with the drawer dividers first and then add the stiles?

Hopefully this is clearer than the previous attempt.

Re: Advice requested

#4

The challenge of this kind of construction

Bill Tindall

If you are hanging the drawers off hardware it may not matter what assembly is used. But if you are making a case where the drawers run on the dividers then the challenge is to get everything supporting the drawer in one plane; otherwise the drawer won't sit level. In this case I would assemble the side panels and then locate and make the dovetails in the stiles of the case sides.

The horizontal pieces holding the case sides together do not need to be over

2-1/2 to 3" deep. There is no need to taper this joint. It has boggling holding power so make it loose enough that it slides together easily with light taps.

Normally a solid case top would be dovetailed into the case side. In your case you could just dovetail a piece across the top of each stile with a half blind dovetail. But what you have shown is fine if you don't mind loosing the space above the top divider.

Re: Advice requested

#5

clarification

Bill Tindall

there is no need to make dovetailed piece the full depth of the cabinet. In fact to avoid a cross grain situation between the divider and the rail, you shouldn't. So, just make the dovetail in the stile and mate it with a divider of equal width/depth.

This picture shows typical framing for a cabinet with drawers.

(It was noted in a previous post of this picture that I had put the feet on the top of the cabinet. However I replied that these were finials!)

Re: Advice requested

#6

Panel or rail/stile for cabinet sides

Nathan

Here's a more detailed drawing of the rail-and-stile design I'm currently looking at. The full-panel approach would obviously give more support to the drawer runners. With the rail-and-stile frame for the side, the drawer runners for four of the drawers would only be attached to the stiles.


What are the pros and cons of a full oak panel vs. rail-and-stile frame construction for the cabinet sides?

For me, going the full oak panel route would mean using more boards (more time on stock prep and assembly) and would necessitate assembling two separate half-width panels, planing them separately, and then attaching them together with the inevitable inaccuracy this involves. (But might be an excuse to finally buy a biscuit joiner?)

Re: Advice requested

#7

Re: Advice requested

steve mackay

My first impresion was hair dresser's station. We might consider going along on her next hair appointment and sneaking a look at how those are put together. They seem pretty stout.

Re: Advice requested

#8

A different strategy...

John in NM

I had planned to make one of these for a friend years ago, but it never happened due to his change of careers.

I would build it more like a traditional carcase with each drawer supported on a frame and hardwood runners, or even just plywood shelves that the drawer boxes slide into. The main reason is that using drawer guides in such a narrow box is something that I always found a major pain, unless you have one of those nifty festool angle drivers, long arms, and x-ray vision.

Maybe you aren't planning to use guides anyway, could just do square runners let into the sides of the box and dadoes in the drawer sides. If she has a lot of dapping blocks and similar forming tools, some of the drawers might get a bit too heavy for this though.

Re: Advice requested

#9

Re: Advice requested

Bob Hackett

I would suggest that you first decide if this is going to be a toolbox/bench combination or furniture.

I believe if this is to be used as a bench/toolbox it needs to designed as such and use the methods of construction that are appropriate for that type of work as a basis for it`s construction. Build it for strength,rigidity and load bearing ability first and foremost.

Building it like a chest of drawers or a dresser meant to hold cloth items would be a huge mistake IMO.

Re: Advice requested

#10

Do I understand this correctly?

Nathan

So you have dovetails at the front and back on each side of the drawer divider? And in this picture (from the front) the front dovetails are not visible because you have glued strips of veneer onto the front edges?

In between the front and back dovetails the divider is dadoed into the sides, but since it is a "cross-grain situation", you have no glue in the dado?

Re: Advice requested

#11

correct

Bill Tindall

It is not traditional to dovetail the back drawer divider; these are typically mortised into the case. But, making the dovetail is so easy I just do it.

it is not essential to dado the runner into the case side. There is little load on this piece. However, the dado as I described makes locating all the parts in one plane more reliable.

Re: Advice requested

#12

Please clarify

Bill Tindall

What would be different about the construction of a "bench or tool box" from a chest of drawers?

For the scale these look like tiny drawers. What would be in them that would equal the weight of a 9" tall chest of drawers drawer full of quilts, for example?

Re: Advice requested

#13

stepping back for a moment....

Bill Tindall

The primary objective here is to build a work bench with storage in a style that looks much like a typical desk and hence could be made by any means suitable for a desk. However, it is possible that there is a second objective and that would be to practice and refine some case goods construction technique to be used in the future. For example, when learning to dovetail I dovetailed all manner of stuff that could have been nailed together just to get the practice.

If I was just making a bench that looked like a desk I would be making it simple like a base unit for a kitchen cabinet and hanging the drawers off mechanical slides of more or less quality depending on my expectations for the piece.

In this utility lathe tool case the top and bottom are dovetailed into the case sides with half blind dovetails. For a finished cabinet I would have added an overlayed finished drawer front.

But, if I expected to make a chest of drawers for the bedroom next, then I would be practicing a more refined technique such as used in my previous post. Personally, I like to use each project to stretch my skills and practice and refine techniques. But this is a luxury I acquired after I retired. Before that it was "get it done" as quick and reliable as possible.

Re: Advice requested

#14

Frame and panel side vs solid; panel gluing

Bill Tindall

A frame and panel can be lighter weight if the panel is made thin. But, there is more labor in the frame and panel. Otherwise, it is just a matter of looks.

If the lumber is flat it is easy to glue up a panel that turns out flat with perfectly aligned joints...... and biscuits will not help at all.

Glue one piece at a time. Have the lumber lying on the clamps. Apply a thin layer of glue to each surface. Start in the middle easing (gently!) up the clamp while keeping the boards perfectly aligned at this point. Then work to each end one clamp at a time, raising or lowering a board by raising or lowering the end until the joint is perfectly level, then lightly snug the next clamp in line. Repeat until you get to the last clamp at the end. When all the clamps are snug and the joint perfect then crank down on all the clamps to complete the joint. (practice first before moving on to the real side) With practice you can manage 3 or 4 boards at once, but start training with just two.

Re: Advice requested

#15

Panel glue-ups

Nathan

Panel glue-ups - I can get them close but not perfect. Getting a perfectly flat frame is non-trivial, too.

I guess I need more practice.

Re: Advice requested

#16

Re: Frame and panel side vs solid; panel gluing

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Bill, since I am fortunate to have a 20" stationary planer and I seldom make any panels over that width, I usually make my panels by planing the lumber over thickness and gluing them up all at once. After glue up, I let them sit for two or three days to stabilize and shrink, then plane them down to 3/4 (or whatever thickness I want), then trim to length & width prior to shaping the edge. - may not be kosher but works for me.

Re: Advice requested

#17

that is exactly what the furniture factories do

Bill Tindall

It is a preferred approach if the planer is wide enough.

Re: Advice requested

#18

Sounds fine to me too...

John in NM

Last shop I worked for (over 15 years ago now, yikes!), we used a widebelt instead of the planer, but the concept is the same.

Re: Advice requested

#19

David Barnett

A few ideas

David Barnett

Bill's offered excellent construction advise, Nathan, so I'll just add a few considerations, as I have some experience in these.

If you're intending a traditional goldsmith's bench, I'd first suggest looking at the double bank benches offered by Otto Frei* or Rio Grande**, using their dimensions as a starting point and modifying to fit your wife's sitting and working height. It is very important that it be neither too tall nor too short. Shoot for a Goldilocks fit. A too-tall top surface can be frustrating when reaching for tools, a process that should become so natural as to be nearly unconscious. Too short, though, causes more serious issues.

Generally, you'll want a top that places the bench pin at sternum level (a good rule of thumb, although you might start a tad higher - especially if you opt for retractable padded armrests), allowing the maximum of strength and precision at a height that affords best vision, with or without optivisors. Just one inch too short and a goldsmith can and probably will develop uncomfortable and even debilitating neck strain, strain that can effect the upper vertebrae (C2-C8) leading to more pain and weakness in the limbs with diminished sensitivity in the pads of the fingers. Numbness in the pinkies is apt to be a C8 thing, for example.

Goldsmiths and gem setters often benefit significantly from even subtle changes in the seating and working heights over time. Because a bench is a working tool, I prefer it be built in a way to promote height modifications should the need arise, favoring traditional leg frames with panels rather than enclosed pedestal bases with face frames. Above all, the bench should be able to take a fair amount of pounding.

Drawers should not be so deep as 27", in my opinion, putting me in the Rio Grande camp, with their 22" depth, comfortably accessible. I do favor a deeper cutout for most persons, so 24" can be a good compromise. Sweeps tray should be a convenient height, and prefer to fit this to the individual. A good add-on option is a lower auxiliary work surface (well-supported and sturdy) for light hammer work and so on. It's also a good position for vises, an engraver's ball, pitch bowl (for chasing/repousse), soldering and annealing larger work, sharpening and more-aggressive tasks than usually performed at the bench pin. This is also a useful retrofit when and if a microscope is added for engraving or stone setting.

I don't like that lower shelf in your first drawing, especially when something tiny is inevitably dropped and needs retreiving (a light under the bench is very helpful). Drawers should be sized and planned to place smaller and more commonly used items in upper drawers (burrs, drills, collets for flexshaft, and so on, bigger and less-used tools in the lowest. Notice that the Rio Grande bench lacks a back panel, which is not really an issue if the frame is well-made. If the bench is not placed against a wall, that might be a consideration, however. Although you didn't draw it, an edge rail around three sides of the top is a must.

Finally, my personal bench (oak - truss rod construction) started out a fairly tall 43", but was lowered somewhat when I began to use microscopes more and more. I also prefer external drawer banks (also oak) on casters as I use different tool suites. The tops allow related tools to be routinely grasped from prefered positions, so the real estate on my main bench, which is narrower, stays uncluttered. I also keep a Kennedy machinist's chest for certain precision tools (love those shallow drawers).

I have several flat mounting plates for my GRS BenchMate (bench pin vise) and other accessories at two main working heights, so chose not to use the more-traditional cutout. No sweeps tray for me (my joiner's bench has no tool tray, either), so I occasionally attach an old-fashioned skin to catch things.

Here's my setting bench when I first built it. It's evolved over the years; the legs are slightly shorter, the cold-halogen box is now in the till below, and so on.


I'd advise reading Charles Lewton-Brain's "The Jeweler's Bench Book":

http://www.amazon.com/Jewelers-Bench-Book-Charles-Lewton-Brain/dp/0979996201

It's pricey and somewhat slim, so try your library.

At the very least, peruse the 59 pages of goldsmith benches and workstations of the Jeweler's Bench Exchange, a good source for ideas and inspiration.

http://www.ganoksin.com/exhibition/v/BenchExchange/

To delve even deeper, try:

http://www.amazon.com/Human-Hand-Function-Lynette-Jones/dp/0195173155

This book informs much of my current tool use and design; for goldsmithing, silversmithing, and woodworking. There's still plenty of handtools that could stand improvement.

*61-1/2"W x 26"D x 38"H, www.ottofrei.com

**64-1/4"W x 22"D x 38-3/4"H www.riogrande.com

Re: Advice requested

#20

Re: Please clarify

Bob Hackett

Well Bill,much as I`d like to my wife will not allow me to stack multiple heavy racks of tools on my bedroom dresser or store things like bench blocks,hammers and other rather heavy items in my dresser drawers. Nor will she allow me to even do things like saw or hammer on relatively soft metals like silver and gold on top of the dresser. she seems to think that to do so would damage the dresser and sooner or later that would render it unfit for future use as storage for clothes. Silly girl.

What I was concerned about was the ability of this particular project to stand up to the stresses of being used as a work station rather than a piece of furniture. If I were the one undertaking it I would design for strength,rigidity and load bearing first (as I said in my previous post) and then think in terms of making it pretty as a secondary factor.

Durability as a work station would be my focus. For me it comes down to;hell for stout and functional first,blending with the decor of the house second. Just my approach and opinion,nothing more than that and worth exactly what everyone here paid for it. :)

Re: Advice requested

#21

Re: Thanks for the information

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I didn't know it was an accepted practice, I am just a hobbyist woodworker - spent about 40 years in manufacturing as an Engineer before retiring. My son's helped me build my shop about 2 years before I retired about 5 years ago. The youngest purchased the 20" planer with a Byrd head as a retirement present. The first major jobs we did were to make all the oak trim for his house - window, door, baseboard and cove. Then we made his Cherry kitchen cabinets and a bathroom vanity (from Locust). I really enjoy working with him. I'm sure some of the methods I use are not orthodox, but if the results are ok, I'm happy! Ignorance is bliss as they say!

Re: Advice requested

#22

Rio Grande bench

Nathan

Thanks, David, for the advice and links. We had already gone through the pictures at the Jewellers Bench Exchange, but the Rio Grande and Otto/John Frei benches are new to me.

Since my wife has so far always trained on traditional European benches with the cut-out top, she thinks that is the way to go.

Like you, she'd rather have drawer units on casters instead of built-in drawers, just because she likes to have legroom and the flexibility of mobile storage units. But I eventually sold her on this double-cabinet design which, as Bill rightly pointed out, is just like a desk.

I had already considered having deeper lower drawers and shallow upper drawers, and rejected the idea on the grounds that having all the drawers be identical would be expedient. But now I see that it won't be too difficult to make drawers of two different heights.

SketchUp is extremely useful, but time-consuming, so I didn't include it in the drawing, but between the top and the sheet-metal "waste capture" tray there will be a rectangular-shaped work surface (like a shallow drawer without a front) that she can pull out or push back depending on what she's doing. I see on the John Frei bench they went all-out and made it a double-decker.

The edge rail around the top will be there - just didn't draw it.

The drawers will not be 27" deep, but the drawer sides will be about that long. This is so she can pull out the entire drawer and get at whatever is all the way in the back. I will go with the 22" drawer depth you recommend.

My planer is only 16" so if I go with panels for the cabinet sides, I will of a necessity have to make two narrower panels, plane them down and then glue them together. I'm leaning toward the panels.

Good point about tiny things that get dropped! I will dispense with the lower crosspieces/shelf and put a back panel on instead.

Putting the entire thing up on legs is another interesting idea I hadn't thought of.

Just as a general note, we are specifically not attempting to make the perfect bench here. My wife is a beginner, so this basic version will meet her needs for some time, if not for all time. I'm not under any illusions that this bench will have its stronger and weaker points, and I am hoping to maximize the former and minimize the latter (within reason), but my wife is getting impatient already (even threatening to buy a ready-made bench) so the project has to move forward. Not much time left to tweak the design.

In case anyone is interested, here's the Rio Grande bench that David mentioned (the image of the John Frei bench is available only as a Flash presentation, so I can't include it here):


Re: Advice requested

#23

Re: Thanks for the information

Nathan

Making panels over-thick and then planing them down is the way they do it at the cabinet shop where I apprenticed. This is faster than planing first and then gluing up very carefully. They have a 24" planer, though. Mr. Bazant told me that when they need to make a panel wider than that (a rare occurrence), they make two narrower panels and then glue them together using biscuits. Whatever minor inaccuracy would then be sanded out on the narrow-belt (they don't have a wide-belt). Needless to say, they work at a much faster pace there than I do in my home shop.

My planer does 15" comfortably. So I will make two narrow panels and then glue them together carefully (as Bill recommended) and hope for the best. The same goes with the top.

Re: Advice requested

#24

Cross-grain situation

Nathan

Bill - really nice piece and I like the what-looks-like cello rosin you placed on one of the drawer dividers.

I have a question regarding this case construction. The drawer dividers are frames and the sides are panels with the grain running top to bottom. As I understand it, you've got ends of the frame stiles glued into sliding dadoes (front and back) and the rail between them just floats (no glue) in a shallow dado.

I can't help but wonder what happens when the panel contracts, say, a quarter inch across its width, while the divider's dimensions remain the same (because it's a frame). That's 1/8" of movement for each sliding dado. Won't that break the glue joint in the sliding dado (or cause the side panel to crack)?

Re: Advice requested

#25

There is something I haven't made clear

Bill Tindall

Not sure what.......


The top is glued into the sides with half blind dovetails. Grain for top and sides runs the same so no problem here.

Drawer dividers (these are the parts that run perpendicular to the sides) are dovetailed into the sides and glued. Again, grain orientation is same for divider and side.

Drawer runners (the parts parallel to the sides) are not glued anywhere. They stick into the dividers with tongue and groove. Optional, they can also be inlet to the sides with a dado, that is not glued.

The sides are not constrained to come and go in any way. Note the gap at the end of the runner to enable contraction.

You mention "frame". There is no frame involved.