Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

another Shop Vac Question

Posts

another Shop Vac Question

#1

another Shop Vac Question

Barry Irby

Several of you mentioned you have 5 gallon shop Vacs. I have always bought larger ones, like the 16 to 20 gallon size. They are bulky but don't require emptying as often. Do you like the smaller size enough to justify emptying it more often? (I am planning to use this mostly on houses I am remodeling.)

Re: another Shop Vac Question

#2

Re: another Shop Vac Question

Larry in NW OHIO

Barry If you going to use a vac for cleaning up in houses you are remodeling, I don1t think you`d be satisfied with the performance of it. I don`t believe it would clean up like a bigger one would. Good luck with whatever you do. Larry

Re: another Shop Vac Question

#3

Re: another Shop Vac Question

steve mackay

I based it on the filter. THAT fills up WAY before the canister (in my jungle). So canister size is moot. I stacked that up against the bulk of the whole rig. I can drag the 5 gal from room to room or down the hallway when "projecting". And it tucks away in its corner when hooked up to my shop dust collection.

Re: another Shop Vac Question

#4

JL

Re: another Shop Vac Question

JL

Some thoughts.

I don't like LARGE shop vacs - too big to comfortably get through a door. A 10-15 gallon works for me.

If you put a cyclone in line, the cyclone will be collecting most of the debris and a lot of the dust. Therefore you will have to clean the filter less often.

If you get (or make) a small cyclone that fits on a 5 gallon bucket, the bucket should be easy to dump. If you get a "translucent" or relatively clear bucket, you can visually see when it is full.

My $0.02.

Re: another Shop Vac Question

#5

Re: another Shop Vac Question

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Morning Barry,

I have 2 of the 5 ga models, each one is in a small shop room. Its easier for me to dump, and not have to drag it from one room to aother. Plus, I can vacuum the filter of one with the other when emptying. The capacity is fine, even when I am using my lathe. I do need to empty them about once per week, but they are light to man handle.

For your clean up work, I'd tend to bring a smaller 5 ga model, as it is easier to manage and transport.

George

Re: another Shop Vac Question

#6

Re: another Shop Vac Question

Larry in NW OHIO

Yes Barry as JL said, If he is talking about the Oneida cyclone on the bucket, that works very well at least for me, and I mounted mine on top of the vacuum so it doesn`t take any space around the floor area. Larry

Re: another Shop Vac Question

#7

Re: another Shop Vac Question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I was given the 5-gal version (about 25 years ago). I would get a bigger one for a couple reasons.

The small one has a hose the size of a typical indoor vacuum. It's too small and gets clogged with shavings and other stuff fairly easily. We use ours to clean leaves and debris from our cactus patch and the leaves clog it all the time. I don't think that would happen with a bigger hose.

The useful level of gunk the canister will hold isn't really all that much, and it certainly doesn't reach to the bottom of the filter, maybe only 6" or so.

However, this little sucker has been a real workhorse and trouper, going waaayyy above and beyond normal duty.

One of the advantages of the small size is that I often take the top off, clean off the filter and just use it to blow out the shop. That's more fun than should be legal.

Re: another Shop Vac Question

#8

Re: Shop Vac Separator 

Charlie Lenz

In my opinion the Dust Deputy is too tall and prone to tipping. Heres the Separator that I came up with, it has a Thien baffle installed inside.


img

Re: another Shop Vac Question

#9

Clint Searl

Nice looking unit


Re: another Shop Vac Question

#10

If you feel your time is money,

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

Then it should be a no-brainer.

If they both pull the same inches of water, but the small one has a 1" ID hose, and the large has a 2" hose, The large will move 4 times as much air, or clean up 4 times the area in X amount of time.

My time is worth a lot more than the difference in price between the two units. Hefting large heavy objects will keep you strong longer.

Re: another Shop Vac Question

#11

Re: Shop Vac Separator

Larry in NW OHIO

Actually having the deputy on top of the vac is nice and for me it is not top heavy. It follows me around like a little puppy. It also doesn`t take up any more room in the shop. Larry