Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

shop dust collection

Posts

shop dust collection

#1

shop dust collection

Paul Blackwell

I am currently downsizing my shop to a basement in a new house. We reached the decision to build a new house and sell our current house with 3 acres of lawn, lots of plantings, and a 24 x 40 pole barn which is my heated and insulated woodworking shop. I had a Jet 3 hp twin canister dust collector in the shop permanently piped to all machines. It's too large for the basement (and too noisy), and I'm wondering if a Fein shop vac which I'd wheel around and connect to each machine would be sufficient to handle dust collection. I'd have a Unisaw, jointer, Performax drum sander, band saw and spindle sander. The miter saws would pose a problem, I suppose. The alternative would be a smaller conventional dust collector. Any thoughts?

Re: shop dust collection

#2

JL

Re: shop dust collection

JL

I'm not knocking Fein tools or "dust extraction" devices. Heavens, I've admired them for years.

IMO, a Fein isn't up to the task. You need about 800 CFM for a Unisaw and close to that for your drum sander. Call it 600 CFM for the jointer. I don't believe you'll get but a fraction of that with a Fein (maybe 125 CFM?).

Yes the Fein is quieter. But it doesn't have the CFM. How about a nice roll around canister unit that is smaller?? I don't know the about the noise levels though. How about a sound baffle enclosure around your Jet??

Re: shop dust collection

#3

Re: shop dust collection

Hoa in Alameda

I have my shop in a 2-car garage (people in CA have stopped using the term "acre" when it comes to houses). I tried to make do with a shop vac at first, but quickly realized that I was fighting a losing battle. So I bought the bullet and got a 2HP Grizzly with a canister.

It sits in a corner of the shop, with 4" hoses running along a wall, then branching out to the Unisaw and the router table (actually a wing of the Unisaw) and the drill press. In addition, I have two non-dedicated dust ports shared by big dust makers (jointer, thickness planer, drum sander).

I use a shopvac for portable power tools: RO sander, handheld router, ...

I gave up on the mitersaw. Due to lack of space, I don't have a mitersaw station. If I need to use the mitersaw, it's in the driveway and the wind takes care of the dust.

It's a bit inconvenient to attach/detach/move the hoses around when I need to use the jointer, the thickness planer, or the drum sander, but the dust collection thingies hardly take any room at all.

Only one blast gate is opened at a time.

Of course I have an air cleaner running almost all the time I'm working in the shop.

Re: shop dust collection

#4

Re: shop dust collection

Hank Knight

Paul,

I made do with a Fein Turbo III as a "dust collector" in my small basement shop for many years. I used it with a Unisaw, a Laguna LT 18 bandsaw and an Inca 570 Jointer Planer. It is a great vac, but it was never even close to adequate as a dust collector. It didn't generate enough CFMs to handle the bandsaw or the Unisaw. I continued to hook it up to the bandsaw (don't know how much good it did), but I gave up entirely on the Unisaw and would just let the chips collect on the floor and vacuum/sweep them up. It got most of the big chips from my Inca jointer/planer, but it required emptying frequently which interrupted the work flow. Most importantly, it did not capture any of the fine dust created by these machines.

The fines finally got to me; I started having severe sinus headaches when I worked with the machines for any length of time. Last year I bit the bullet and upgraded to a ClearVue Cyclone and piped it to all of my machines. I'm a happy man. No more struggling with the vac, no more headaches and a clean shop to boot. I don't want to pour water on your idea, but I think you will be disappointed trying to use a vac as a dust collector, especially coming from a shop with a real dust collector.

My $.02

Hank

Re: shop dust collection

#5

Re: shop dust collection

Barry Irby

I have to agree with all those above that say a shop vac won't be up to the task. I have a 1 1/2hp Delta unit that I put in a closet I built outside the shop.

Look into that idea if you can. It offers many advantages. The noise is out side and so is the dust. Anything it collects fine or coarse is gone. So is most of the noise. Much easier to empty the dust also. I also put my compressor out there. A major improvement to get that noise out there too.

Moving them outside was one of the best things I did to my shop.

Re: shop dust collection

#6

Re: shop dust collection

Jesse Cloud

Does the basement have a window? If so, maybe you could put up a little outdoor shed for the dust collector and run pipe in through the window. You will loose heat/cooling in the basement, but it would get the dust.

Re: shop dust collection

#7

Re: shop dust collection ( Delta 50-760 )

Charlie Lenz

I was looking for a portable and compact DC unit not too long ago and this is what I came up with, the Delta 50-760 that I built and added a side inlet Separator that has a Thien baffle installed inside.


img

Re: shop dust collection

#8

Re: shop dust collection

Dale Penkala

Hello Paul

Have to say I've used my larger shop vac for many different machines for dust control and yes it helps but leaves alot to be desiered. My shop is approxamatly 12x30.

I got a Harbor Freight DC (little embaraced about this) for an incredible price and jumped at it. $169!!! Best thing I ever did for DC! My unit is 2hp 120v with 4" ports and covers my 3hp table saw, miter saw, band saw, router table and my small belt/disk combo. I did upgrade to a 1 micron top bag. See pix below!

Originaly I wanted to put my DC in the other room as well but I have my furnace, & hot water heater in there so I decided not to do that.


Re: shop dust collection

#9

Re: shop dust collection *LINK*

mdclor

I don't have one, but the db rating on this 2hp cyclone looks pretty good to me. The price is a little steep however.


Oneida portable 2 hp dust collector

Re: shop dust collection

#10

Re: shop dust collection

Charlie Lenz

The JDS is in about the same price range ( $1400 ) as the Oneida.

Re: shop dust collection

#11

Re: shop dust collection ( Delta 50-760 )

Charlie Lenz

If anyone doubts how well it works, this is how full the Separator gets before dust bypasses it and goes to the bag.


img

Re: shop dust collection

#12

Re: shop dust collection

Larry in NW OHIO

Nice outfit mdclor. I bought one of their 3hp industrial models around 10 years ago, best thing I ever did for my shop. I would sure do it again. The best thing is that they are made in the USA, that is the biggest reason I bought it, and that it has a US made Baldor motor. I dought if I ever have trouble with it. :D :D :D Larry

Re: shop dust collection

#13

Had a Delta

Phil Joines

When the motor went south they wanted $500 for a new one. Also, they put the start contacts behind the cooling fans where the dust gets blown over them. I repaired 5 of them when I did plant maintenance. They all had burnt contacts from the dust. $75 for a new set.

Re: shop dust collection

#14

Re: Had a Delta

Charlie Lenz

Thats the first time that I've heard of a complaint about the 50-760, it has been rated pretty highly for a number of years. Makes me wonder how the DC's were being used, or the enviroment that they were in. A Separator certainly would of lessened the amount of dust going through the DC itself. But what ever, can't make everyone happy, and not everyone can afford a $1400 DC in a one man shop. Once again, why do I bother ?

Re: shop dust collection

#15

Re: Had a Delta

Phil Joines

I don't remember the model numbers, they weren't all the same. These were single stage Deltas used with table saws in an aircraft cabinet shop. The bags were emptied on average every 4 days. The start switches lasted about a year on average. I considered the design to be at fault since they were mounted behind the fan in the stream of dirty air rather than inside the enclosed motor case.

Re: shop dust collection

#16

Re: Had a Delta

Charlie Lenz

Well if your not refering to this specific model how can that be a fair statement ? I can't imagine that all Delta dust collector's have problems. And if there are problems, how many are the users fault ? I would suspect a good percentage.

Re: shop dust collection

#17

Re: Had a Delta

Phil Joines

I am referring to the motor design of all the Delta dust collectors I have worked on. As I remember there have been 4 or 5 different models. If you got a good one then good for you but I wouldn't buy any of them.

Re: shop dust collection

#18

Re: Had a Delta

Charlie Lenz

According to the Amazon customer reviews there happen to be alot of people that are happy with this particular model. Many magazine reviews have also rated it very highly. For instance here is the FWW review. http://www.finewoodworking.com/ToolGuide/ToolGuideProduct.aspx?id=26113 I've noticed a push for Oneidas here lately, new sponsor ?

Re: shop dust collection

#19

Re: Had a Delta

Charlie Lenz

Ok Phil, just to clarify and defend my position on this. I'm sure that the Oneida's are nice machines being that they are Made here in the USA with Baldor motors. The thing is, I've been out of work for quite sometime and I can't afford alot. I'm still useing an American made Delta Contractor's table saw, with a Unifence that I bought new in 1995, and have done some upgrades to it to make it all the machine it can be. I can't afford or justify a Cabinet table saw or any other Commercial or Industrial piece of machinery right now. If I could make a liveing from woodworking then the story would be different. I chose the Delta DC mostly because of it's design, I've always liked the setup of the JDS 2HP Cyclone 2100-CKV 1700 CFM Dust Collector and thought that it would be a good fit for my shop, but the price is more then I can afford. So the Delta just happens to be the next best thing to it at a price that I can afford, thanks to Phil Thien and his great Separator baffle design. I did all the work to it, and already had 99 % of the materials that I needed to build the accessories, so it cost me very little to make what I wanted. In a nutshell, I don't have alot of money, I like to tinker, and sheet metal work has become another interest of mine lately.

Re: shop dust collection

#20

Re: shop dust collection

Charlie Lenz

I could careless about Oneida or JDS, they don't support my ideas, so I don't support them. They just want to sell dust collectors and ducting, they could careless about how you hookup a machine to their DC's. But ofcourse they still want to be number one in dust collection, whatever, they don't impress me.