We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I've decided that it's time to build an actual workbench. The sheet of plywood and 25 year old sawhorses that I've been using for the past 10 years have finally been retired to the kindling bin. My question involves the top. All my local HD and Lowes sell in SYP is 2x12s. So do I have anything to lose from just ripping the 2x12s in half and building a significantly thicker top. I obviously gain mass, but I worry that there is some draw back that will not be evident until it's a bit too late. Thoughts?
Depending on the quality of the 2x12s and the tools you have available, it may be easy or hard - if you're going to laminate like that, you need good mating faces on the boards. If you do that, you might stagger the joints so that, seen from the end, your boards are kind of like two courses in brickwork - no glue joints in one layer being directly above another layer.
I think that moisture level of the wood will be your biggest problem. Most construction lumber is at least 19%, and that's not consistant through the board. Rip it open and let it sit over the weekend, and you may get snow skis. Buy it 6 months before you want to build and it may be okay, but it will sure take some work to make it flat then.
Buy the driest wood that you can. You may even want to invest in an inexpensive moisture meter. I would rip your 2 x 12s in thirds and let them sit for at least a few months in a dry area.
Well just to be totally different, see if you can find a place that sells salvage or reject doors. I bought an oak door that was 3 feet wide and the usual height. It had a large hole near the bottom to hold a return duct. I cut it down to 28" wide and cut off the end that had the hole. That has been my workbench now for 20 years. It is very heavy and solid.
You might look at the bench that HF sells. I don't think it costs much more than that and if I remember it is a pretty decent Oak bench. It has drawers and is $160.00/ I have seen it and it looks pretty good. Just a thought.
My work bench (built in 1986) is a grid of 1x6s with a plywood top, and 4x4 legs. Also has a shelf down low, using an apron of 1x4s & plywood, to stabilize the legs (and provide a shelf). I designed it for easy disassembly, as I was in the USAF and anticipated moving around a bit (which I did over the long run). The drawback is that using 1x6s means you need a longer clamp to clamp anything down.
Then I recently got a holdfast and some bench dogs. The dogs work fine, but the holdfast seems to want a thicker top (a deeper hole) to hold workpieces securely.
I would build a good workbench once, put some thought into the design, and then use it for the rest of your life. A workbench must be caple of holding boards in various positions, which Christopher Schwarz goes into in "Workbenchs." See link below.
I would suggest you read Scott Landis book on workbenches....there are several examples of very innovative benches in that book that are an alternative to the traditional hard maple bench including benches made by laminating plywood strips etc....this will give you the possibility of making a bench on a budget....you need to educate yourself on the subject....and realize no one style of bench will answer all needs....you have also to figure out your needs and ww style....there is no better book on the subject than Landis and it should be available in your library.
I've been to Festus numerous times, and have always liked the Festus/Eureka/Pacific Mo area. I agree with all of the above posts. While I am unsure of your specifications/utility needs, all that info is worth reading. I've had my hand built carpenters' bench for years, and it is itself an antique. It was a gift, given by a customer who wanted her basement cleaned out. Craig's List has benchs listed for sale frequently. Some are very reasonable, and incorporate many sought after features like tail and leg vises, and tool trays. Look for them in your area. It will be very good value for perhaps less than you are now willing to pay.
I am completely unqualified to answer your question. I bought my workbench/assembly table 40 years ago. It has a cast iron top and I have extended those with some additions I covered in Formica. As an added benefit, there is a blade that rises out of it near the middle and that spins when I flip the switch. I can rip boards with it if I can get the latest project off the top of it long enough.
I have built a bunch of stuff out of SYP framing lumber over the years. I agree with buying 2 x 12's and ripping them, but I would rip them into thirds. That will be thick enough. Also, those who said the lumber if too wet are correct. I used to buy a few boards and store them for several months to let them dry. The reason I like larger boards and ripping them is that they almost by definition come out of larger trees, something more akin to "old Growth" than 2x4's. I once saw a stack of 2x4's at Lowes that appeared to be from trees just barely big enough to get a 4x4 out of them and those had been resawn into two 2x4's. 100% juvenile wood. You do not want juvenile wood, so pick boards that do not have the pith of the tree in them and those will have to larger than 2x4's. I am very skeptical of laminating a top like this without letting it dry further for several months before you do the glue up.
I find the idea of salvaging a solid core door very appealing. Get two and laminate them. Much easier than using solid stock and stable.
Are you sure it's Oak? I believe it's made of paulownia, which is pretty light. I have a similar cheap bench (of exactly the same dimensions), which is not quite rigid enough for planing and chopping.
I built the Chris Schwarz version of the Rubo bench a couple of years ago. I am in SW MO and I used 2X hemfer material. I bought it a couple of weeks before I started building, stacked it in my shed, and did not have any problems. My top is 4" thick and I think that I started with 2x12s. As stated before buy the widest that you can and the lightest, the lighter the board the dryer it should be.
Alex, Im NOT sure it is Oak since it has been a while since I looked at it, but I think it is. I'll check and see. I just thought if I hadn't already had a good bench I would have been interested and checked it out further.