Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Large Radius Arc / router / 100' steel tape

Posts

Large Radius Arc / router / 100' steel tape

#1

Large Radius Arc / router / 100' steel tape

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I have a project coming up where I will need to make some stair nosing for a church choir loft, which has four 32' long arcs with radii from 39' to 46'. I was thinking about trying to find someone with a cnc router, but wanted to try something here first.

Last time I made large arcs, the R was ~ 20', and I managed by making a large trammel using a pipe driven into the asphalt out on my parking lot, with several lengths of 1/2" x 5" plywood strips joined end to end to swing my router around, using holes for the guide bushing to drop into.

I had to add a cross bar half way out, then some thin battens to keep the drag in the middle from flexing, so I knew doubling the length of the R was too much for this project, so I was thinking of using wire.

I picked up some vinyl coated wire from the hardware store, then laid out my MDF sheet, measured out my first length, and marked it with pencil. When I hooked my router to the wire, I found I had about 2" of stretch in the wire, so I scrapped that idea.

But, what I need to replace it with was laying right in front of me. The 100' steel tape that we had used to measure the arc, was right there, with a neat little bail and hook on the end.

I was already using the fence rods with the fence removed on my 3 hp Makita. The rods gave me ~8" of fine adjustment and the thumb screw that holds the fence on captured the tape bail perfectly without the aid of any tools, and the tape has very little stretch. We were using wooden hand-screws to clamp the pivot end to the side of a 4 x 4 shed post.

The next obstacle was the sag in the tape at that length allowed the tape to drag and snag everything sharp on the asphalt, so I laid 3 pieces of PVC pipe across the swing path to support the sag distance into 4 equal parts, which worked very nicely.

I swung the router around clockwise, so the cutting action was pulling against the tape. This gave me a very smooth arc, with no more than 1/32" variation, which is plenty good for this project. And it likely was faster and easier than driving to pick the parts up, if I could find a willing shop with a CNC.

Re: Large Radius Arc / router / 100' steel tape

#2

Re: Large Radius Arc / router / 100' steel tape

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I used to make a lot of patterns for curved stair treads, pool copeing, baulestrade railings and the like. I had a 20' length of 2" square tubing with a short length of angle welded on one end so I could clamp a short 2x2 to run the guide rods of the router through. It worked similar to your pipe but the square tubing had less flex. That shop had 25' ceielings so I could stand my radius jig in the corner and the shop was larg enough that I didn't need to take it out to the parking lot to use it. I tried making a coupler to double the length and it had too much flex. For stuf requiring a larger radii I would use a tape to draw it out and then rough cut on a band saw and than sand to the mark on a large disc sander.

On jobs I do now I need better acuracy than that so I use a trig formula to give me the rise at the mid point of an arc and keep breaking it down to smaller arcs and then use a batten to scribe a knife line. If I have a knife line I can sand to it on a disc sander and be more acurate than using a router.

I once did a job for a designer that had a large plotter and thought he could print me some templates that were more acurate then what I could make, that was a huge disaster.

I have used CNC templates a couple of times and found them to be every bit as acurate as what I can make and for a job with a lot of large radii it can save enough time to make it worth the cost. There is a solid body guitar maker near me that rents time on his CNC router for $60/hour and the cost is the same for programing or runing the tool.

For architectrual work I alway wanted to try the way you did it, but never had the nerve.

Robin

Re: Large Radius Arc / router / 100' steel tape

#3

Re: Large Radius Arc / router / 100' steel tape

Woody

There is another alternative where you don't need to have or find the center point and use a radius:

Method A or Method B here: http://www.carrscorner.com/yabbse/Newsletter/newsletter12-06.pdf

Re: Large Radius Arc / router / 100' steel tape

#4

Thanks Robin and Woody

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I am well aware of the other methods, and have used them before, but I already knew the R from the blueprints, so I was not needing to find the chord depth.

The beauty of my post was it's simplicity. The end of a steel tape is made to connect with almost anything. Since I needed it to mark this long radius, doesn't stretch, and connected so easily to the router, it seems to be a no-brainer.

Since this is an active church, I need to have all my parts ready to go, when the carpet comes up, so I can put this in without disrupting service. The thick carpet which is on there now obscures any hard edges for accurate measurement.