Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

Posts

OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#1

OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

Tom Dunlap

I have an external drive that has locked itself down. The tech guy at the university where I work looked at it and said that it needs to go into a shop that does the 'clean room tear-down'. He warned me that it will likely be spendy...$900 plus.

Years of pictures and other important info is on the drive so I'm going to get this done.

Can anyone share some insights about how to choose a shop to do the data recovery?

Thanks

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#2

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

Chuck in Mtl.

When you say it locked itself down does it mean that it clicks and clunks when you apply power to the drive? You friend may be right....companies that do that kind of work charge a lot but you will get your data back. Some things you can try...put it in the freezer for a while...head this can rejuvenate them.

If the servo for the read head is dead then it can be complicated. One person went so far as to buy an identical drive to his failed drive, including firmware revision, and carefully replaced the servo board and servo mechanism and was able to recover most of the data.

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#3

Steve Strickland

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

Steve Strickland

Many drive failures are due to power supply. Try putting the drive in another enclosure and see if it spins up.

If the drive spins up but cannot be read there are several repair utilities that can fix most problems due to bad blocks and directories. If a block has gone bad you lose it but can save everything else. Norton's is pretty good and there are others that repair things Norton's doesn't do.

So most fails are due to either a power failures or corrupt files that can be repaired yourself without a clean room.

The worst and least common problems are a failure of the drive controller chip or a head crash. In these cases where the drive won't spin up with a good enclosure you'll need the clean room treatment and a pro.

Drives fail so backup, backup backup. In digital media there is no such thing as a permanent archive. Drives, tapes, CDs, DVDs and ROMs all degrade with time and fail for many reasons. What the pros do is use a RAID that backs up on multiple drives eliminating single point failures and then backup the RAID with tapes stored off site (tsunamis, fires, earthquakes, bombs, etc). There's some cloud archiving services that should do fine but there's already been some spectacular failures in cloud archiving leading me to think maybe it's a premature technology.

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#4

Re: OT-Data recovery..details

Tom Dunlap

My brother who is a wiz tried and was stumped.

The tech guy at school is good too...stumped.

Power supply is not an issue...bro checked. No noises when it stopped working.

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#5

Re: OT-Data recovery..details

Chuck in Mtl.

Does it make any noise at all when power is applied? what brand and model is the drive?

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#6

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

If it makes any sound at all and just won't spin up, try putting it in the freezer for 30 minutes to an hour. No kidding! I've done this with internal drives and it has worked. I think I put them in a ziplock bag to protect them from the moisture. Do be sure to disconnect it from the external power supply first, though, eh? :-)

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#7

Re: OT-Data recovery..details

Tom Dunlap

No noise at all

Lacie

I trust my brother and the tech, now I need to go to unknown territory, picking a data recovery company. How do I do that? Spin the wheel? :)

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#8

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

Dave Paine

Good advise from the other replies. I am not happy to say I have been a victim of too many hard drive failures.

As one reply stated, try removing the hard drive and directly connecting to a PC.

If the drive spins, you have the potential for getting "something" to read this.

If the drive does not spin, you are into what is called "Forensic recovery".

My supervisor needed this a few months ago. Although his external drive was only a few weeks old, it died and with his backup and then he had wiped out the original. He needed the tax files.

A local service was able to determine the controller board was the culprit and was able to kludge together a "frankenstein" controller board from other components. This ended up costing a few hundred dollars.

The alternate was "clean room recovery" which would have added many hundreds to the bill.

I hope you are able to avoid the "clean room recovery" step. This is where they have to remove the platters in a clean room and connect to a drive mechanism to remove the files. Very expensive.

I have experienced drive failures after only a few weeks, and others after a few years. I am not able to predict which drive manufacturers last longer than others.

These days too many hard drive manufacturers have been bought by others, and then the factories move to other countries. Too many variables.

Good luck. You have my sympathy. I have had my own share of such issues.

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#9

Re: OT-Data recovery..details

Chuck in Mtl.

does your tech friend know a company doing this type of work...otherwise do a search on the internet.

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#10

Re: OT-Data recovery..details

Tom Dunlap

Yes...he gave me the name of a company that the university uses.

When I go into the unknown I try and find out info from people who have gone there before me. Google is an amazing help of course. But going there first is not always best.

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#11

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

Grant Wilkinson

Been there, done that - unfortunately.

The places local to me that do this sort of recovery do not charge if they cannot recover the data. I don't know if your area's will be the same, but it's something to look for.

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#12

Moses Yoder

Re: OT-Data recovery..details

Moses Yoder

I think it's possible that you are the only person who reads this forum that would actually spend $900 to recover some pictures. The other people seem to be able to read but they either have never had a drive dissected or they don't understand what you are asking. I think if I had $900 I would add a little bit to it and buy a Holtey plane and throw the drive in the trash. I can take more pictures.

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#13

Kneale Brownson

You can't take pictures of a dead parent

Kneale Brownson

or an event that's already happened and is over.

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#14

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

Alex Grigoriev

A few words of advice for everybody:

1. Don't trust hard drives for long term backup. They are prone to catastrophic failures.

Use recordable media. They will only fail completely if broken or burned in a fire.

2. Use quality CD/DVD/BD-R blanks. Reliable brands are Verbatim, Philips, Tayo Yuden. Rewritable media may have better long-term reliability, because it's not subject to fade-out. I have 13 year old CD-R that still read perfectly. I have 8 year old cheap brand CD-R that still can be read, but the drive slows down on them.

Use a quality CD/DVD/BDR recorder drive. Cheapest drives don't produce long-lasting recordings, and they also don't read reliably a recording with marginal readability. I've had good experience with Pioneer and Plextor drives. LiteOn drives (used in most brand-name computers and many set-top DVD players) are horrible.

Make 2 copies and keep one off-site.

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#15

Moses Yoder

Re: Better yet

Moses Yoder

Better yet is this advice, about 1940 years old if I remember correctly, from the Holy Bible, Matthew 6:19-20

�Do not lay up for yourselves treasures on earth, where moth and rust destroy and where thieves break in and steal; but lay up for yourselves treasures in heaven, where neither moth nor rust destroys and where thieves do not break in and steal."

I always kind of understood this to mean that no matter what I own on earth, or how it is stored, eventually it will be decayed and no good. In other words, nothing on earth lasts forever.

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#16

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

Robert Hix

If you choose to use optical media for backups, you had better have a way to periodically check to be sure the backup is still valid. I am not sure what programs are out there to do this as I have developed my own software for this type of thing. Simply put, I DO NOT trust writable optical media for backups that I expect to last any longer than 3 to 5 years. Even then, I suggest at least two copies.

So far my most reliable backup media has been hard drives. I rotate two hard drives through offsite storage. Worst case, if the drive I took to storage this week decided to die, the drive I have at home this week has data from two weeks ago on it. Not too bad considering I do not generate a lot of content.

My pictures and video are a different story. I have at least seven different copies of my pictures at any one time. I am pretty sure I am not going to suffer any data loss on my pictures.

All said, what you back up on, how many copies you have, and where you keep those copies are all a function of how much you need, or desire, to keep the data. Just remember the basic 3-2-1 rule of keeping your data safe. You need three copies of the data, preferably on two different types of media, and at least one of those backups should be off-site.

Good luck with the data recovery. When you get the drive back, spend a little more money and get you some backup drives so you will not have to do this again.

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#17

'Some pictures' ...hardly~~~~

Tom Dunlap

There is much more than 'some pictures' on the drive. Besides the quantity there is the quality of the pictures. Dad died five years ago...his pics and memories are there. Nieces growing up. Family memories...what is the line??? 'Priceless!'

Besides that I teach classes in my profession as an arborist. When I find a 'teachable moment' I take a picture. Those pics have all paid me back in money that I have used for tools, vacation, food, rent, etc.

'Some pictures' is like looking at my stash of lumber that came from trees that I removed, milled and dried...then moved around the country with me...and say, just buy more boards. Not gonna happen.

There are files that I need too. The value to me is different than to others.

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#18

Well said Tom!!

Jim Dillon

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

#19

Re: OT-Data recovery from ext. drive

Bill Howatt

I agree. Any problems I've had with archived files have been on optical media not hard-drives and I use good media and often burn at slower than maximum speeds with a verify after writing.

It appears the unfortunate original poster made the mistake of putting all his eggs in one basket and the basket broke. He should have had a minimum of a couple of external drives and alternated them when doing backups. This way the failed drive would have shown up while the other was still operational.

For some reason people think that they are safe when the remove the files and put them on some external media, optical or otherwise. The reality is that you still only have one copy without a backup!

Bill