We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Good morning Lee, my former spouse has a set of 18 craving gouges. They are stamped S. J. Adiss cast steel England with a Compass and Square logo. They seem to be I good to very good shape. I see a bit on the internet that makes them sound like good tools, but nothing that mentions the England mark. I only know they belonged to an uncle, who would be 100 plus years old. Any opinions on quality and or value?
I have quite a few Addis carving tools and about half are stamped the same as yours. I am particularly partial to Addis tools and I think they are among the best carving tools ever made. They are definitely better than anything currently being made. Before I start a riot of protests with that last statement I should clarify that I prefer high carbon steel for carving tools, and the quality of the steel used in Addis tools is top quality Sheffield tools steel.
As for value, it depends somewhat on the size and profile of the individual tools as well as the condition. I have not seen an Addis tool for less than $10 in a long time. I still find some in that price range and they usually need a bit of work and likely a new handle. For an Addis tool with no pitting and a solid handle the price is $15-20. Some of the larger tools with cutting edges 1 1/4" wide or even larger command prices $75 or even higher. Unusual profiles like spoon bent "v" or front bent gouges also command a bit more $20-35 depending on the desirability and condition. I have only seen one Addis macaroni and it sold for $80, which is a bit more than a new tool with a macaroni profile. These values are what I see around me and on eBay.
When I mentioned condition for Addis tools I refer to if there is any pitting on the front as well as the shape of the bevel. Most carvers are willing and able to repair the grind but it takes time and time is money. I eventually replace all my chisel handles with ones I make so I don't care about or pay a premium for good original handles others may differ on this.
I'd go with what Robin said. I'm not familiar with that particular brand first hand but England, especially the Sheffield area, made some really good tools. I'd look closely at the patterns, the shape of the tools. It's tough to find some of the old patterns and it's possible you may have a true gem or two in there. Besides, isn't it about time you started carving?