Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

Posts

OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#1

JL

OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

JL

I have an Echo gas powered. It is old and it is really getting cranky on starting and continuing to run.

I have a lot of slope to cut by the house - while I could use an electric there - I'd hate to drag a cord that far (slope dimensions are ~15' x 75' at about 45 degrees). I also have slope to cut by the road - which is a couple hundred feet away. That slope is well over 100' long but maybe only 8-10' "wide".

I'm looking for recommendations or to be pointed at a site that has reasonable evaluations of the various weed "whackers".

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#2

One compelling advantage of Stihl

Bill Tindall

I have been unable to wrap tall grass around the head. My previous trimmer, can't recall brand but it is the main competitor to Stihl around here, was exceptionally prone to long grass wrap. All the trimming I do on the farm is tall stemmy fescue grass and weeds and the joy of never needing to stop to unwrap stems from the head a compelling reason to buy the Stihl.

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#3

Re: One compelling advantage of Stihl

Wade

When it comes to outdoor power equipment, it is very hard to beat the Stihl products. Sure you will pay a bit more for it, but when you need to use it, it will start right up, it will make childs play out of almost any yard task, and you will be able to get back to the work shop or out on the mountain bike trails that much sooner.

No affiliation with Stihl, just a satisfied customer of two of their chainsaws, one backpack blower, one line trimmer and a hedge trimmer. Never second guessed a single purchase.

I decent Stihl dealer might even be able to set you up with a loaner/demo unit to see for yourself.

I have also had the opportunity to try a 4 stroke Honda line trimmer a while back. Nice unit, if you need a 4 stroke trimmer (some states and towns are beginning restrictions on 2 stroke power tools).

Wade

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#4

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

Pat Evans

My 31 year old electric Crapsman still works fine. Zero ($0) maintenance. I don't enjoy dragging the cord around either, but it is by far the lowest cost method.

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#5

Stihl FS-56RC-E

Dave's Not Here

This past spring I purchased the Stihl FS-56RC-E and is it ever a sweet machine. I had a Ryobi that gave me good service for many years but it was at the end of its life. Yes I paid more for the Stihl but it's also more of a machine than the Ryobi ever though of being AND it starts on the first or second pull everytime.

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#6

Clint Searl

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

Clint Searl

I currently have a 4stroke Cub Cadet that's reliable and can handle heavy weeds. The thing I like most about it is it takes thick string and the fact that there's no reel to wind. Pieces of string are cut to length and simply passed through the head. Quick and easy.

Clint

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#7

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

Barry Irby

My son is in the process of buying a whacker as we speak. He has far more experience with them than I do and has friends in the "Mow, Blow, and Go" business. He has about talked me to death about this over the last few days. His advice is to buy an ECHO with a straight shaft. Get the commercial model that is in the $400 to 500 range. They offer a 5 year warranty to home owners. He claims all the pros use them locally.

He also says Stihl is a good unit but they don't offer the long warranty.

The straight shaft allows you to turn it up on its side and use it as an edger without killing yourself.

I can get you exact model numbers if you want, but frankly, I have heard enough about whackers for a while.

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#8

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

FredD

My Wife would leave me if I didn''t maintain her Echo Weed whacker.

We had gone through several brands and none lasted longer then two years.

This Echo is about ten years old and starts on first pull.

I have a Stihl chainsaw which is the best, I have owned, but I don't have any experience with any of their other products.

FredD

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#9

JL

Stihl is available here - in a larger version.

JL

as well as the smaller version. As I have several hundred feet of weeds to trim, I'll probably go with a more "robust" version.

Could the ethanol gas be causing me problems? I put Stabil in the mixture.

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#10

My Brand Is

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Called "JIM" who is the guy who works for Ramon who's the guy who drives the mower for his brother Jose who owns the lawn service that does my yard. I quit doing all that 20 years ago when I did the cost/benefit analysis that included cost of the equipment, my operation time, machine maintenance time and cost, and general scheduling having to "do the grass" when there were so many other things I'd rather be doing.

BTW Jim uses a straight shaft ECHO. :D

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#11

Moses Yoder

Re: My Brand Is

Moses Yoder

Obviously you did not calculate the joy of chopping the heads off of your grass.

Lets see, if I have a limited amount of hours to work (limited amount of work available) and the rest of my time is spent lounging in an easy chair, I would calculate the worth of time spent lounging at $0.00. And my wife would definitely agree. Now if I figure $150 for a push mower that lasts 10 years and $80 for a Weed Eater string trimmer that has lasted 10 years, and it takes me 1.25 hours per week to mow the yard 6 months out of a year, my equipment cost is 71 cents per hour or 89 cents per week. Kind of hard to justify paying someone $40 to mow the yard once a week. A penny saved is a penny earned.

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#12

Re: My Yard

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

is a bit more than yours with 1+ acre of weeds to keep short. I actually started off with a Snapper walk-behind. That was 3+ hours, plus trimming + cleaning the clippings, per week. Mower lasted 4 years. With all the rocks that seemed to grow out of the ground about as fast as the grass, the mower had to be sharpened each week.

Had a Ryobi whacker, gave it to my BIL when the mower died. Last I checked, Ryobi's still working [for him].

Don't have one of them chairs. ;)

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#13

Nuth'n I love better . . .

steve mackay

I know tailed gear isn't for every one. But my yard is the right size and I've gotten good with the "cord-flip". And there is nuth'n I love better than watching all my neighbors spend an hour fiddling with gas mowers and trimers to do fifteen minutes worth of cutting. Makes me a jerk doesn't it ? :b

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#14

Re: Stihl is available here - in a larger version.

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

My older stihl chain saws are not as sensitive to stale gas or problems with ethanol as my dad's new stihl weed trimmer. One of my chainsaws is late 80's and the other is early 70's vintage.

I have had mild stale gas issues with my honda weed trimmer and now I drain it in the fall.

My dad loves his new Stihl weed trimmer which replaced a Johnesred, in all fairnes to the j-red the Stih is a bit bigger. I have not used his new trimmer but my Honda is way more powerful than the J-red. With 2 strokes you only have power at the top end of the rpm range and with the four strokes there is a fair amount of bottom end torque that enables them to cut well even when they bog down. If all you are cutting is grass then the 2 strokes work just fine but if you encounter woody stem weeds the four strokes are the way to go. I should add that I love 2 stroke engines.

I was very skeptical about the durability of a four stroke with vallves the size of dimes, but my Honda weed trimmer has held up like a Honda. I have owned it for almost 10 years and the only service it has had is a carb rebuild without a kit and a new fuel filter.

Robin

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#15

Re: OT - Stihl FS85 Here

John McGaw

I've owned several different makes of gas-powered trimmers and Stihl beats them all hands-down. The straight-shaft Stihl units have the advantage of taking other heads for other tasks. I've even taken the reciprocating saw head from a defunct Ryobi 4-stroke trimmer (a piece of junk if there ever was one) that preceded this one and modified it to work with the Stihl. The regular string head for the Stihl is great but it will also accept the steel disc head which will whack down 1" brush with ease. In theory you aren't supposed to use this type of head unless the trimmer has the bicycle-style handles but I'm a wild and crazy guy and take the chance.

Oh, I have a Stihl chainsaw and leaf blower too -- both are top-notch machines.

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#16

JL

I don't have power cords that long...

JL

I have an electric - for around the house. I can't go from my house to the farthest portion of my property with the power cords that I have (nor do I have the strength to lug them that far). I also have too many trees in the way. It's probably about 400' or so from the house down to the corner of the lot by the culvert.

Now if they made a decent rechargeable, we might talk.

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#17

Does it have to be powered?

R. Payne

Once you get the hang of a scythe, you should find it's faster, quieter and easier on your body that a powered trimmer.

Of course I'm old school.

ron

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#18

Re: I don't have power cords that long...

steve mackay

I'm sorry, I was yank'n your chain. But watching "no habla" figuring out the english instructions is STILL funny.

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#19

JL

Re: Does it have to be powered?

JL

Somehow the thought of handling and swinging a sharp blade on a 45 degree slope doesn't do much for me. I've fallen with the weed whacker before. I'd rather not fall with a sharp blade >( .

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#20

Read about the inventor of the weed eater  *LINK*

Tom Dunlap


Inventor of Weed Eater

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#21

Re: Does it have to be powered?

R. Payne

Understandable.

Perfect job for a herd of goats.

ron

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#22

No Ethanol For Me

Dave's Not Here

I use pure gas in all of my small engine tools including my lawn tractor and snow blower. Almost everyone I've ever asked about that practice agrees with me. 100% gasoline can be a little hard to find so if you must use an ethanol mixture I'd recommend you use the Marine Stabil instead of the regular red stuff. It's formulated to work with ethanol mixture gas.

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#23

Really ? . . .

steve mackay

I've often wondered what I'm going to do IF I ever get my old ('74) Sporty back together.

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#24

Re: Stihl is available here - in a larger version.

matt overton

I have two Stihl Combi units. One for the house, one for home. Expensive, but well worth it. They can convert to edger, tiller, hedge trimmer, chain saw trimmer, power broom and other tools. I have the 110cc and the 130cc units. It is the last piece of yard equipment I will buy.

Re: OT - Weed "whacker" recommendations?

#25

I was down on the Peninsula....

Barry Irby

Next to the Rivah, which is full of wahtah, where people put in the boats with the big a$$ed engines. The local service station had gasoline without ethanol. I was amazed. No such luck around here (heah). I think its amazing that engine technology has not caught up with ethanol gasoline. They need to live in the real world and unfortunately, that includes ethanol.

Just replaced the fuel lines and priming bulb on my little rototiller and my son's borrowed weed eater. Come on, Makers of Small Engines, Ethanol has been around, what, twenty years and sunlight even longer. Grow up.