Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Image of worn titanium nitride coated plane iron

Posts

Image of worn titanium nitride coated plane iron

#1

Image of worn titanium nitride coated plane iron

Bill Tindall


First the "decoder ring" for the image label. A2 is the metal, this plane iron was coated with Titanium Nitride, this region of the plane iron experienced 50 meters of wear planing hard maple, the objective lens is 50X and illumination is bright field "BF" which means the image is of the light reflected perpendicular to the metal surface. This image is from the flat side of the plane iron. I can not image the beveled side with BF illumination because the stage will not hold the plane iron so the bevel reflects light back to the objective lens.

Two features stand out. First, and most obvious is that the TiN has worn off the first 36 microns of the edge. This loss was obvious with a hand lens at about30-40 meters of planing.

The second feature is more subtle, but note the texture of the worn surface. From this image I can not tell if the features are bumps or holes. If they are bumps it could mean we are seeing the projection of abrasion resistant carbide grains in this alloy. If they are pits, it could be an indication of metal loss by corrosion. Corrosion is a known dulling mechanism in higher speed wood milling.

One additional point. This blade was softened from a hardness of Rc60 to Rc54 by the coating process. I expected the hard maple to severely deform the edge and if anything this edge looks better than the A2 control at Rc 60.

Need help. I have 4 images from this experiment that could be best compared in side by side images, for example coated vs uncoated after wear. I have no means of assembling these images in side by side pairs for posting. If anyone can do this assembly I could like to send the originals for such processing and then we could post the results.

Also, what next? Any suggestions on what to do next with this TiN blade?

Re: Image of worn titanium nitride coated plane iron

#2

Re: Image of worn titanium nitride coated plane ir

john lucas

Bill I've been trying to follow this but over the weeks have forgotten all the details. Have you reached a conclusion? Is the titanium coating any good or was it worn away at the first sharpening. I'm curious because I need a new set of forestner and brad point bits and of course you can get them coated or uncoated. I'm still out on whether the coating does any good or not.

Re: Image of worn titanium nitride coated plane iron

#3

Re: Image of worn titanium nitride coated plane ir

Bill Tindall

I have not reached a conclusion on wear but TiN stuff doesn't rust and for that reason alone I would buy coated tools if they were available.

Re: Image of worn titanium nitride coated plane iron

#4

Re: Image of worn titanium nitride coated plane ir

Larry in NW OHIO

Bill I really enjoy these postings, although I don`t understand a Da-- thing you say. The thing I would get more out of it is if you would campare different brands. Like would HF coated tools wear basically the same as Craftsman and maybe a better brand. I know this is asking alot and I appreciate what you already did. I think I do understand the coating in the picture. The 1/2" of silver on the end is what Tin came off the end from usage. Thank you Larry

Re: Image of worn titanium nitride coated plane iron

#5

Re: Image of worn titanium nitride coated plane ir

Dave Paine

Bill, if you just need someone to put the images in Photoshop side by side, I can have my wife do this. She is a Photoshop expert.

Re: Image of worn titanium nitride coated plane iron

#6

Thanks, didn't know that about rust

john lucas