Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Shaper hold-downs vs. fingerboards

Posts

Shaper hold-downs vs. fingerboards

#1

Shaper hold-downs vs. fingerboards

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My router table is an older Porter-Cable 698. The table itself is fine and, since I have to put it away when it's not in use, the light weight is a benefit; but the factory fence is dreadful. I used an aftermarket fence, but find that it's not tall enough to install fingerboards for some of the work I want to do, so am weighing making up a new fence. In the process, I'm looking at some shaper-type hold-downs I have in my junk pile, similar to those pictured below.

I'd appreciate any comments on these vs. fingerboards.


img

Re: Shaper hold-downs vs. fingerboards

#2

Re: Shaper hold-downs vs. fingerboards

roger lance

I have an even older PC router table that is shorter in height to your 698 and your stock fence was a big improvement over what PC had on its original table....so I made a new fence with dust collection and other improvements....used 3/4" bb (would use 1/2" bb if I did it again) and faced it with laminate and made the fence tall enough to use finger boards that slide...adjust...in a t-slot (made with a Rockler router bit)....I bought that table as I bought into PC's advertising campaign for buying a router system where everything fit each other...690's, plunge/d-handle bases, router table, guide bushings, omnijig, etc....the table does the job and is convenient to store away when done....but that fence had to go.

Re: Shaper hold-downs vs. fingerboards

#3

Re: Shaper hold-downs vs. fingerboards

FredD

I have a small 1 HP Delta shaper I bought new and since the router tables came out , have not used it in years.

It came with the exact same set of hold downs you show in pic and they are absolutely worthless.

Anybody want a excellent condition small shaper with reversible motor , make a offer.

FredD

Re: Shaper hold-downs vs. fingerboards

#4

Ellis Walentine

Make a new fence

Ellis Walentine

... or buy one. You can get as sophisticated or as custom as you like and spend as much as you want.

I prefer featherboards any day over those spring-steel contraptions that come standard with some shapers. Featherboards can be made any length or width for any job. You can even drill out the endgrain so the feathers can extend down around the router bit. Just make your fence high enough that you have room to clamp the featherboard on. While you're at it, build a box around the router bit area with a hole in it for your shop vac hose.

If you want, there are lots of aftermarket fences out there, in all price ranges, that offer T-slots, movable fences, zero-clearance inserts, bit protectors, dust collection, micrometer adjustment and shims for setting the outfeed fence for jointing operations. Find one with the features you're likely to want and go for it.

Ellis

Re: Shaper hold-downs vs. fingerboards

#5

I'm with Ellis on this one

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Make your own; it has exactly the features you want.

Mine is homemade, just like a lot of my stuff, including the router table, which is made from a sink cutout. I'll send you a pic when I get home.

Re: Shaper hold-downs vs. fingerboards

#6

Moses Yoder

Thomas Tusser

Moses Yoder

I guess it was Thomas Tusser who originated the phrase that turned into "a fool and his money are soon parted". There are people setting around in offices all day thinking of ways to part money from fools. One of them came up with the metal shaper hold down.

Re: Shaper hold-downs vs. fingerboards

#7

More or less my intention

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm leaning toward my own fence - although I then have to be careful not to over-engineer it (a family virtue that can easily tip into a failing). Fingerboards were are more attractive idea, and the conversation here has pretty well convinced me that I was right.

If I build my own, I should be able to use the existing tapped holes for the factory fence, which would likely be an improvement over my current fence clamping (T-slot extrusions, which fill with chips). I note that Porter-Cable at some point recognized the weakness of the original fence design for this accessory, and offers what appears to be a superior, if complex, fence on the current model.

Freud offers an attractive fence, except it's too low.

At any rate, thanks, all, for the comments.

Re: Shaper hold-downs vs. fingerboards

#9

What "thing" was that?

paul in AZ

Re: Shaper hold-downs vs. fingerboards

#10

Re: Shaper hold-downs vs. fingerboards

Hikmet C. Sakman Victoria, BC CDN

What you see in the picture of the origial post. Mine was made by Sears, and it had an excellent mounting bracket, which was rock-solid and springs were very good quality spring steel. Probably it has many knock offs which are not possible to be secured firmly.

One important point, I used them on a custom made wood/ply router fence and it worked very well for me when I built solid oak kitchen cabinets. As I can tell by their design, thumbscrews on a metal fence will not be secure and doomed to fail (come loose) during use. My 2 cents.

Chico...