Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Not OT - All-in-one printers?

Posts

Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#1

JL

Not OT - All-in-one printers?

JL

My old one just died. Can't print bills without one. Can't scan or fax without one. Can't copy without one.

So the old one was on the order of 8-10 years old. It was getting cranky and now won't even power on.

I don't do any "high capacity" printing, copying or scanning - so I can't really justify a lot of expense.

I see all-in-ones going for under $100.

I can dust off the printer that I inherited from my brother as a temporary fix. Put in a couple of cartridges and it should be ready to go. Good for printing at least.

Following questions:

Should I wait until I replace my desktop computer and get a "package" deal?

Should I get a wireless all-in-one?

I don't mind spending money if I have to - should I consider a more expensive printer?

Any brands to avoid?

Any recommended brands?

TIA

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#2

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

Ralph Lipeles

No reason to wait. Many of them are extremely inexpensive. If you scan eBay you will see a few, brand new, that will auto feed 20 pages, for about $85. I just bought a HP Officejet 4500. I have used it to print and copy and it works fine. I Have not tested the scanner or FAX yet. Ink cartridges, on line, are very reasonably priced.

Ralph Lipeles

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#3

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I recently purchased a Kodak ESP9250 wireless all in one Photo printer/scanner/fax and am extremely satisfied. I had always favored Epson due to being able to purchase generic cartridges cheap. My Epson gave up (clogged head) after a few years so I looked into the market again, my son has a Kodak and it does very good photos, so after finding the Kodak cartridges are about the cheapest on the market and the most easily available (almost all Kodak printers use the same cartridges). I purchased mine. I have a wireless Brother laser for monotone printing as it is quite fast and much cheaper to operate than the Ink jets. I searched the web for prices and ended up purchasing at Best Buy - ordering it for store pickup as they had a sale on the unit at the time. I can't remember the price - think it was around $150.

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#4

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

PaulSV

I absolutely detest the Lexmark all in one I bought last year. It prints about half the time I try to print on it, it has idiotic error messages and poor manual and on-line support. I had previously used HP's and they always worked well for me.

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#5

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

Tony - Memphis

We have an HP 6300 series (I think that is the right number) that we bought around '05. Never had any trouble with it at all. Great printer. Now, let me qualify...we aren't power users. We print a few pages a week. We have scanned, faxed (not much), and printed on all sorts of media without any issues. I just upgraded our PC, but I kept the printer because it was still chugging. I'm not familiar with the newer models, but that's what I would try.

I work with wireless at work a lot. For me, wouldn't go with a wireless (ours is USB). Not worth the trouble or the extra money for us anyway.

Tony

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#6

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

Barry

I have an all-in-one. HP Photosmart B209-a-m. It was about $100. Great printer, scanner and copier. Works really well.

Eats cartridges like they were popcorn. That's the reason the printers/scanners/ copiers are so cheap. They could give them away and still make a ton of money off the cartridges. That's the only downside that I see. If you don't print a lot, ink carrtridges may not be a big deal.

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#7

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

JMOHNIKE

I have both a Brother (2) and 2 HP's. The Brother is a laser and the HP's are both inkjets. In my opinion the the Brother is the best one. Printing is faster, less expensive. The HP's are both color printers which I do have to use on occasion, but most of my printing is done on the Brother. I print 250-300 pages a day. The prices are within a few dollars of each other, the toner cart. for the lasiers runs about $85.00 and I get aroun 7000 pages, the cost of the ink jets is more than double for the same # of pages. All of them good fax units and scanners.

Just my $.02's worth.

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#8

Laser - the only way to go

Joe Pack

Black and white or color, laser is the ONLY way to go for a printer, particularly when your refill your own laser cartridges. Ink jet printers are cheap because the companies make a fortune on selling $2 worth of ink for $20. There is absolutely nothing to refilling a laser cartridge...the cost is about $15 (less if you buy toner in quantity). I am on my 4th refill in my Brother MFC-7420 (printer, scanner, fax) that cost all of $160 several years ago. Toner from TonerRefill.com is cheap; the first refill will take you 20 minutes (18 to figure out how, 2 to actually do it)

Sorry, rambling...shoulder surgery makes for difficult typing/thinking.

Anyhow, if you go laser, you will NEVER consider ink jet again.

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#9

I'll never buy another HP

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I have an HP 6210 all-in-one and for printing documents it works fine in b&w or color. For printing pictures it only works with HP paper otherwise it jams. Fax works but will ocasionaly double feed sheets an require resending. scanning is fine but the softwaere is not the best but is not really a problem. copying from the bed leacves a line down the middle that is not there when scanning. copying from the document tray is fine.

That all said I will never buy ANY HP product as long as I live, even if it is the top rated in its class, based on the customer support I recieved with this printer. It took three printers before I got one that worked. I was not as upset that it took three printers before I got a good one but more by how I was treated during the process. The funny part is that My previous printer was an HP and that is why I bought the all in one. My experiance with customer service with the all-in-one was so horrific as to negate my prevoius good experiance with HP.

Robin

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#10

Another reason Joe Pack is right

Nathan

I second everything Joe said, and add the following: ink likes to dry up and this causes no end of difficulties with ink jet printers that only see occasional use. Laser printers do not suffer from this problem. Toner doesn't dry up. I didn't know you can refill toner cartridges, though. Sounds like something to look into - thanks.

If you like the image/color quality you get when printing photos on an ink jet, then ink may be your only option. Just make sure you print photos regularly - like twice a month at the least. This will keep the jets from clogging with dried ink.

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#11

Laser Toner Source *LINK*

Joe Pack

I have used the services of Toner Refill Kits several times, and have been completely satisfied. No affiliation of any kind, just a satisfied customer.

Refilling a toner cartridge is a no-brainer, even for me. You may, or may not, need a small specialized tool, but they sell it very cheap (just a soldering pencil with a specialized tip to burn the right size hole, plus a couple of plugs). Read the FAQ section on their web page.

Hope this helps somebody save a boat load of money!


Toner Refill Kits

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#12

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

FredD

JL , I have a Dell all in one and I have to say the ink has to be their product or it won't work and it cost's more then a rare blood transfusion.

Never will buy another of that brand.

FredD

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#13

Re: I'll never buy another HP

Barry

I had a HP 960-Cse. It was just an inkjet printer. No fax. No copier. No scanner. It gave good service for about eight (8) years and run about ten (10) months on a cartridge. I'm lucky to get three (3) months out of a cartridge for my HP Photosmart All-In-One printer.

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#14

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

Paul Blackwell

I recently purchased a Kodak ESP7250 all in one, and so far I love it. Copies and photos are excellent quality, and ink cartridges are about half what I used to pay for the HP. It's wireless, by the way.

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#15

Re: Laser - the only way to go

John McGaw

Nothing wrong with lasers -- I have a big office-sized Dell color laser and my old LaserJet 4P B&W on the network. Either one of these can to sufficiently good graphics for an occasional chart in a document but I've never seen a laser yet that can do an acceptably high-quality photograph. For that I have an Epson six-cartridge printer which does spectacularly good glossy photos up t 8.5X11. Had I been able to find a refurbished printer capable of larger prints I probably would have jumped at that one instead. The Epson is an all-in-one although I seldom do more than a quick B&W copy on it. It's scanning is fine but for some reason or other I usually use a separate Visioneer scanner when I'm doing a lot of work. I've had no trouble with the Epson for the 3+ years I've had it -- no dried ink, no skipping, etc. The ink is, as others have noted, is pretty expensive but for copying I use up mostly the black cartridge and the 5 large color cartridges seem to have good life in real-world usage.

One thing to keep in mind is that a color laser all-in-one is likely to be a pretty sizable chunk of hardware that would look more at home in an office than in a home. I'd expect that you would need to spend $500+ to get one also.

Wireless might save some work (at a possible cost in security, IMHO) if you don't have a wired network. I already have everything here wired with Gigabit copper so I really only use wireless to connect with my Android phone.

As always, any opinions expressed are guaranteed up the price paid for them.

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#16

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

Joseph Mulherin

Barry, I have had HP printers for many years and I do refill my own cartridges with ink from Staples store. They have both black and color refills. Each bottle will give me about 4 times as many uses on the cartridge before having to refill again. Three bottles in a package...12 refills, and cleaner to use to clean out the syringe. Just be easy with squirting the ink into the cartridge hole so yoo do not spill too much.

Wipe off top and cover with packing tape and go back to printing.

Every so often you might have to take your printer off-line and clean up the bottom of the ink carriage with alchohol and swabs to clean up ink which does get accumulated over time. Hope this helps...o

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#17

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

Joseph Mulherin

Tony, I have the same printer and use it everyday and like I just told Barry, you can clean up the ink carriage every so often to keep the accumulation out. Mine works just fine.

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#18

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

Barry

Thanks, I've never refilled my own cartridges, but I may start, now that I have this printer with a seemingly unquenchable thirst for ink.

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#19

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

Jesper, Denmark

I have been very happy with my HP OfficeJet Pro 8500A.

fast and reliable and the ink cartridges are not too expensive.

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#20

JL

Thanks for the reponses.

JL

I'll probably go with an HP printer/all-in-one. The prices of the printers are reasonable even if the prices of the ink cartridges are not.

If I can talk the LOML into not wanting color, I've seen some reasonably priced B&W laser printers/all-in-ones.

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

#21

Re: Not OT - All-in-one printers?

Kurt

If you go inkjet, spend a little time on Ebay. Some printers have available refillable cartridges. I bought a set of 6 cartridges for an HP Photosmart printer. This has chipped kill-me cartridges that you can't refill. The refillables have a chip that when the cartridge is removed, it resets to send a "I'm new and full" signal to the printer. I've refilled 'em once and they work like new. I bought a set of refillables for a Brother inkjet. Those were a little more of a pain-I had to insert insulin syringe needles into the vent mechanism because otherwise the cartridge would build a vacuum and wouldn't feed.