Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Power hand planer

Posts

Power hand planer

#1

Power hand planer

Larry in NW OHIO

As the title indicates this post is about a power hand planer, so this is a WW topic for once. What I would like to know is, what kind of power hand planer you have and if you have used others and what you liked about them. If you only used one what did you like about it? I`d like to get one, so opinions please. What size do you have and would you get something different? Thank You. Larry

Re: Power hand planer

#2

Re: Power hand planer

Dave Paine

I have a Black and Decker "Professional" model. Decades old. Rarely used.

The last time I used it was to plane off some bumps in 2/4 framing so my drywall would lie flat against the framing.

Back then I did not own a hand plane. These days I would use a hand plane for that task.

I found the power planer was difficult for me to get a smooth surface. The slightest variation in feed rate results in undulations. Going back over never worked for me.

You can take a lot of surface off the wood with little effort. Sometimes too much. :)

Re: Power hand planer

#3

Re: Power hand planer

Yonak

I concur with Dave. I find few uses for mine. I got a Porter Cable a while back, which works fine within its limitations, but I have rarely used it .. only for a few doors. I thought I would use it on panels that were difficult to handle on the jointer but I still had to finish them off on the jointer to get the entire edge straight.

Re: Power hand planer

#4

Re: Power hand planer

Gary Smyth

Rockwell 167. Hand power planer maybe 10" long. Purchased in the early 1970's. I bought it to trim doors in a 19th century Victorian.

Didn't know what I was doing. Ruined two doors that I still grieve about by tearing out an edge on a 2 1/4" thick door edge. Cost me a lot more to redress the edge and add a glued strip then match the woodwork. What was I thinking? After a lot of years use and adjusted for the finest cut and a long fence you have to be careful or it will own you.

Your application matters. But hand planes will be the better solution. The picture shows one now up on ebay in 45 minutes now at $70. Not mine, just found it trying for a pic.

Re: Power hand planer

#5

Re: Power hand planer

JMOHNIKE

I have 2, a Craftsman and a Harbor Freight special. I do not use them as a "plane". I use a lot of "recycled" wood, and use the planes to clean up the wood and remove dirt, paint etc. I do check the wood for metal but sometimes I miss one. I sacrafice the blades on the 4" planes to protect my 12" planer. I never use the power planes as a finish tool, will use a standard hand plane instead.

Re: Power hand planer

#6

Re: Terrific In Some Applications

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Morning Larry,

I personally have an old P+C which I infrequently use, and also consider potentially dangerous. My #3 son uses a Bosch in his contracting work--Ken doesn't own a hand plane!

He used the Bosch on a cedar chest which I had made for SWMBO. The chest's lid, made of curly maple, twisted slightly and therefore wouldn't lay flat. Ken shimmed opposite corners until there was a slight and equal gap, scribed it, and then power planed the chest sides until the top was level and fit with no gaps anywhere. (See Shop Shot 746). It could have been done with a hand plane, but would have taken much longer.

George

Re: Power hand planer

#8

For Construction

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Useless for woodworking.

Have used both a Dewalt and several Bosch units. Bosches were better and would, with care, do a reasonable dado on a rim joist or chamfered edges.

Again, only use was on framing and decking lumber. Look at them as a fast belt sander for hogging off excess where the cut surface will covered.

Re: Power hand planer

#9

Re: Power hand planer

FredD

I have a Makita that is great for trimming flush doors and a Porter-Cable power block plane which is no longer made and is good for trimming a face frame to a line for instance.

I run carbide blades on both and the one on the Power Block plane is a spiral cutter.

FredD

Re: Power hand planer

#10

Re: Power hand planer

FredD

that is a great little tool , maybe you need to practice some Gary.

FredD

Re: Power hand planer

#11

Re: Power hand planer

Dale warder

I have a Skill power planer purchased in the 1970s. It has probably been used three or four times. It is very difficult to achieve a smooth surface, due to the depth adjustment. The front shoe is adjusted by turning the front knob. This compresses a foam between the shoe and the body of the planer, thus adjusting the depth of cut. As the front knob also serves as a handle when using the planer, the adjustment is easily changed. Also the pressure on the knob will affect the adjustment. These problems serve to make smoothing difficult if not impossible. My solution: use a hand plane.

Re: Power hand planer

#12

Steve Strickland

Re: Lead Paint Removal

Steve Strickland

I've seen them used very effectively to remove lead paint from home exteriors.

Re: Power hand planer

#13

No question about it.

Gary Smyth

Re: Power hand planer

#14

Re: Power hand planer

woodenleg

While I have never owned one, I have used them for scarfing wood together (mainly plywood) for when building boats. My father used to use them for moulding ( finish carpenter ) in big runs. I was never that good. He quit when he could no longer see a 1/64 of a inch, went to building airplanes instead. Dave

Re: Power hand planer

#15

Re: Power hand planer

Barry Irby

I have a Makita. The longer bed version Probably about 12 or 14" long as opposed to the block plane version that appears to be about 9 or 10" long. I really like mine and have gotten a lot of use out of, but that was for home building, not shop work or furniture. Can't beat it for dressing out doors if you are hanging them rather than buying pre hung doors. For hogging material and straightening joists it can't be beat.

I have never tried to flatten a panel with it and I guess I have assumed it would not work well for that.

I did use it to clean the tar/glue off an oak floor that had had vinyl block tile glued to it. It worked well for that except that the black tar like glue clogged it up. Took hours to clean the pale up, but it did a great ob of hogging the glue off the floor. Left lines and ridges, but the sander took those right out.

I need to take it with me to the house I am remodeling tomorrow. There are a couple of doors that are sticking the frames. These are hollow core doors and hell to hand plane on the top.

Re: Power hand planer

#16

Larry, You can't do better than this. *LINK*

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I have used lots of brands, mostly smaller, but I have had one for close to 30 years, and use it a lot.

It has a long enough infeed bed that allows you to get started off right, whether hand held, or upside-down in a vice for small parts.

Like most, the front handle is the depth adjustment, so you can change the depth of cut on the fly, which helps removing bumps when flattening work too large to go through the other equipment.

When I bought mine, it was ~$400, which pro-rated, works out to ~ $13 per year, so I'm sure I've gotten my money's worth out of it.


http://www.google.com/products/catalog?client=safari&rls=en&oe=UTF-8&q=makita+power+plane&um=1&ie=UTF-8&tbm=shop&cid=17250157144192604818&sa=X&ei=IukeTvivHaHgsQK2zqjaAw&ved=0CD4Q8gIwBQ

Re: Power hand planer

#17

I hope the workers were using chip collection

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Under current rules, I doubt a power planer would be acceptable for lead-containing paint removal.

Re: Power hand planer

#18

Steve Strickland

Re: I hope the workers were using chip collection

Steve Strickland

They were a licensed outfit on This Old House. They wore all the gear and had to lay plastic sheeting for about 12 feet (maybe more) around the house to catch all the chips. I don't recall if the power planer had a dust collector hooked up or not. That old paint sure came off fast with that tool.

Re: Power hand planer

#19

Re: Larry, You can't do better than this.

Larry in NW OHIO

I`ve seen them, they also have a 12" hand planer. That would be a real beast. Larry