Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Wood Identification

Posts

Wood Identification

#1

Wood Identification

Bill Tindall

I went hunting in the lumber racks for some stuff for framing and drawers. I have one rack that became a catch -all and today I unloaded it and 3 others and rearranged the maple, ash and catch-all bays. During this archaeology I came upon some forgotten lumber. It came some years ago from the kiln mixed among a pack of ash. Now it is not unknown to mix sassafras in with ash but this stuff isn't sassafras.

Specimen 1

This lumber is even redder than it shows in the picture. Extremely dense pretty wood. Could it be persimmon?

Specimen 2

Again this lumber is extremely dense. Its true color is likely nearly white. This lumber was very weathered from air drying and it has a gray cast from stain, I think. I has a grain like hickory but there is no evidence of reddish heartwood, or any sort of darker heartwood. I might think hackberry but I don't recall hackberry being this dense. Note the black knots. They are as black as India ink. The tree this lumber came from was small as the boards are only 6" wide but 16' long. I can't imagine cutting a hickory this small and sawing it, profitably.

Specimen 3

I was told this is catalpa. It is moderate weight. Coarse grain, more coarse than oak and nearly white, maybe a bit of yellowish cast.

Re: Wood Identification

#2

Re: Wood Identification

Tom Dunlap

I would guess catalpa...but it is quite light weight.

Have you looked on the Wood Products Laboratory website?

Re: Wood Identification

#3

Re: Wood Identification

Robert R. Clough

Bill, could it be Red Elm? I have just finished a piece using that. Your picture shows graining similar to what I had but the color is not quite the same.

Re: Wood Identification

#4

Re: Wood Identification

Dick Coers

I'm voting honey locust for #1, I'm certain #2 is persimmon, 3 is a mystery. I've never seen a yellow cast to catalpa, and it is feather light. It has a very distinctive smell. Notice any smell with number 3?

Re: Wood Identification

#5

Re: Wood Identification

Bill Tindall

I agree from the color but not the weight. It is heavier, or at least as heavy, as oak

Re: Wood Identification

#6

My limited experience/observations

DizD

If you route or saw catalpa, it will "fuzz up" - difficult to get a smooth surface from machining.

Hackberry starts out light creamy color and develops a yellowish cast after exposure to uv.

Re: Wood Identification

#7

report back

Bill Tindall

I found a picture of persimmon sap wood with black knots and it looked like it was cut from a #2 board. And I always thought persimmon was reddish. Is it good for anything I might ever expect to make?

#3 doesn't stink and it is moderately heavy so it isn't catalpa.

#1 When I complained about the renegade lumber in the "ash" bundle, the mill told me "it" might be locust, but "it" turned out to be 3 renegade species. But I have seen locust (black) and it has a definite yellowish cast. This stuff indeed has that locust grain and luster, just that it is red like hickory heart wood, actually a pretty wood, unlike the persimmon sap wood and the other stuff which is too ugly to use as drawer sides. So if honey locust is reddish with little sap wood then you nailed #1 too.

In any case I know more now than I did before asking.

Re: Wood Identification

#8

Re: report back

John Veerkamp

I have honey locust around here. It often has red and pink tones in the wood. End grain in honey locust with the red is extraordinary. I think you're on to it.

Re: Wood Identification

#9

Re: Wood Identification

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I have some red elm that is every bit as heavy as oak and I have some chinese elm(ulmas parvifolia) that is heavier than oak. Besides the tell tale barnyard scent for red elm, all elms will have littel "W"s in the early wood of flat sawn boards when viewed up close. Chinese elm has a very spicy almost pepery scent.

Sample #1 ooks like red elm to me too.

Re: Wood Identification

#10

Ellis Walentine

Re: Wood Identification

Ellis Walentine

#1 could definitely be honey locust. #2 is probably persimmon if the heart is black, as it is a member of the ebony genus. #3 looks like one of the black ash species, maybe swamp ash like they used to make Telecaster guitars out of.

Just guessing.

Ellis

Re: Wood Identification

#11

Re: report back

Dick Coers

Persimmon is supposed to be in the ebony family, the only North American cousin to ebony. It turns like a dream. For flat work, it will take an incredibly fine detail, but I can't think of much it will do that white oak or hard maple won't. Mabye a little less chippy than white oak or hard maple. It was the primary wood of golf club heads in the day.

Re: Wood Identification

#12

Persimmon observation

Tom Dunlap

There is a six stem persimmon that I take care of on my campus. The stems average 6" diameter. ALL of the old branch cuts have discolored over the years and are very black.

If I didn't know better I would guess that they were painted every year. Don't try and guess that the age old myth of pruning paint is valid. In the arborcultural profession we stopped painting wounds over 30 years ago because it doesn't do any good.

The knots on one of the samples do look very similar to what I would expect to see if any of these stems were slabbed. Since I've never seen inside a persimmon stem I have no clue what the grain might look like.